Schmitt v. McCorkle Document 1: Complaint

Filed July 25, 2008

BackBack to Schmitt v. McCorkle, Illinois Northern District Court Case No. 3:08-cv-50155

COMPLAINT filed by Timothy Schmitt, Sr; Jury Demand. Filing fee $ 350. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A)(pg, )

Tags No tags have been applied so far. Sign in to add some.

SpacePlain English Get Plain EnglishSpaceComplaint Analysis Get Complaint AnalysisSpaceAdd a Flag Add a FlagSpaceAdd a Citation Add a CitationSpaceLink To Thread Link To Thread

  Source Document Tab Overlap Formatted Derived Text Tab Overlap Raw Derived Text Right End
PDF Page
1
PlainSite Cover Page
PDF Page
2
FILEDCase 3:08-cv-50155 Document 1 Filed 07/25/2008 PG Page 1 of 5 JULY 25, 2008 MICHAEL W. DOBBINS CLERK, U.S. DISTRICT COURT IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS WESTERN DIVISION TIMOTHY W. SCHMITT, SR., ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) Plaintiff, v. PAMELA MCCORKLE, as trustee of the Timothy W. Schmitt Trust, and executor of the Estate of John W. Schmitt, and WARD, MURRAY, PACE & JOHNSON, P.C., Defendants. 08 C 50155 JUDGE REINHARD MAGISTRATE JUDGE MAHONEY Jury Trial Demanded COMPLAINT Plaintiff, Timothy W. Schmitt, SR., by his attorney, and for his Complaint against defendants, states as follows: Parties, Jurisdiction and Venue 1. Plaintiff Timothy W. Schmitt, SR., (“Schmitt”) is a citizen of and resides in the State of Arizona. Schmitt is an heir of the Estate of John W. Schmitt, the beneficiary of the Timothy W. Schmitt Trust, and a limited partner of John W. Schmitt Partners, L.P. 2. Defendant Pamela McCorkle (“McCorkle”) is a citizen of and resides in the State of Wisconsin. At all relevant times, McCorkle was an executor of the Estate of John W. Schmitt, the trustee of the Timothy W. Schmitt Trust, an Illinois trust, and controlled the general partner of John W. Schmitt Partners, L.P., an Illinois limited partnership. 3. Defendant Ward, Murray, Pace & Johnson, P.C. (“Ward”) is an Illinois professional corporation with its principal places of business in Illinois. At all relevant times, Ward represented the Estate of John W. Schmitt, the trustee of the Timothy W. Schmitt Trust, and John W. Schmitt Partners, L.P. 1
PDF Page
3
Case 3:08-cv-50155 4. Document 1 Filed 07/25/2008 Page 2 of 5 Subject matter jurisdiction exists based on diversity of citizenship pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Section 1332(a). Plaintiff and defendants are citizens of different States and the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000.00. Personal jurisdiction exists because defendants reside in this district and do business in Illinois. 5. Venue is proper in this Court because the transactions complained of occurred in this judicial district and defendants do continuous and systematic business in this judicial district. Facts Common to All Counts 8. McCorkle, a sister of Schmitt, is the executor of the Estate of John W. Schmitt (“Estate”), an Illinios estate. McCorkle also serves as trustee of the Timothy W. Schmitt Trust (the “Trust”). Schmitt is the beneficiary of the Trust. 9. The principal asset of the Estate is John W. Schmitt Partners, L.P. (the “Limited Partnership”). McCorkle controls the general partner of the Limited Partnership. Schmitt is an heir of the Estate. 10. At all relevant times, Ward represented the Estate, the Limited Partnership and McCorkle in her roles as trustee. 11. Schmitt owned a 6.69% limited partner interest in the Limited Partnership. 12. Schmitt entered into a Redemption Agreement dated July 31, 2006, pursuant to which the Limited Partnership redeemed 6.5% of his limited partnership interest. A true and correct copy of the Redemption Agreement is attached hereto as Exhibit A. 13. The Limited Partnership redeemed Schmitt’s limited partnership interest for $230,989.20, which was 53% less than what the Estate had determined was the fair value of the Limited Partnership. 14. Neither McCorkle nor Ward disclosed to Schmitt how the fair value of the 2
PDF Page
4
Case 3:08-cv-50155 Document 1 Filed 07/25/2008 Page 3 of 5 Limited Partnership was calculated or how the substantial discounts were calculated prior to the Redemption Agreement. 13. Several months after entering into the Redemption Agreement, defendants disclosed to Schmitt the Estate tax return, which reflected the fair value and explained how defendants had discounted the value of Schmitt’s 6.5% limited partnership interest by over 50%. 14. Defendants have not disclosed to Schmitt information concerning the financial condition of the Limited Partnership or the Timothy Trust. Count I – Breach of Fiduciary Duty (Pamela McCorkle and Ward, Murray, Pace & Johnson, P.C.) 15. Plaintiff adopts and incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 – 14 as if fully re-stated herein. 16. McCorkle, as trustee and executor, owed fiduciary duties to Schmitt, the beneficiary of the Trust and heir of the Estate. 17. Ward, as lawyer of the Estate and for the trustee, owed fiduciary duties to Schmitt, heir of the Estate and beneficiary of the Trust. 18. By virtue of their fiduciary relationships, defendants owed the fiduciary obligations of good faith, trust, loyalty, and due care and were required to deal with Schmitt with full candor and fairness. 19. Ward was required to exercise reasonable competence and skill when providing legal services benefiting Schmitt. 20. As heir of the Estate and beneficiary of the Trust, Schmitt was an intended beneficiary of Ward’s services. 21. Defendants breached their fiduciary duties to Schmitt by one or more of the 3
PDF Page
5
Case 3:08-cv-50155 Document 1 Filed 07/25/2008 Page 4 of 5 following acts or omissions: 23. a. failing to fully disclose all relevant facts and financial information concerning the Limited Partnership prior to the redemption of Schmitt’s limited partnership interest; b. failing to deal fairly with Schmitt in entering into the Redemption Agreement; c. redeeming Schmitt’s 6.5% limited partnership interest for approximately 47% of the fair value of that interest; and d. failing to disclose to Schmitt the basis for the 53% reduction in value of his limited partnership interest. Schmitt was underpaid by 53% of the value of his limited partnership interest as a result of defendants’ conduct and representations. The purported Buyer’s Discount and discounts for lack of marketability and minority interest were improperly calculated and lacked any factual or legal foundation. 24. Defendants’ breach of their fiduciary duties was a proximate cause of Schmitt’s damages. Schmitt was underpaid for his limited partnership interest by $259,234.60. WHEREFORE, plaintiff Timothy Schmitt prays that judgment be entered on his behalf and against defendants in an amount to be proven at trial, plus prejudgment interest and costs, and that the Court award them any further relief that it deems just. Count II – Professional Negligence (Ward, Murray, Pace & Johnson, P.C.) 25. Plaintiff adopts and incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 - 24 as if fully re-stated herein. 26. Defendant Ward had a duty to communicate accurate information to Schmitt and a duty to exercise competence, reasonable care, and skill when rendering its services to the 4
PDF Page
6
Case 3:08-cv-50155 Document 1 Filed 07/25/2008 Page 5 of 5 Estate and Trust for the benefit of Schmitt as heir and beneficiary. 27. Ward failed to disclose full financial information concerning the Trust, Limited Partnership and Estate to Schmitt prior to the Redemption Agreement. Specifically, Ward failed to disclose the basis for the fair value calculation of the Limited Partnership and that the Limited Partnership had purported to discount Schmitt’s 6.5% interest for an alleged “Buyer’s Discount” in addition to an alleged minority discount and lack of marketability discount. 28. Under Illinois law, in a redemption transaction no discount for lack of marketability or minority interest is allowed. Ward failed to advise Schmitt of such Illinois law. 29. In addition, the purported Buyer’s Discount duplicated the purported lack of marketability discount and was unwarranted under Illinois law. 30. By failing properly to advise Schmitt and by failing fully disclose all relevant financial information regarding the Limited Partnership, Ward breached a duty of care. Ward owed such a duty to Schmitt, as intended beneficiary of Ward’s services. 31. As a proximate result of Ward’s breach of the duty of care, Schmitt was underpaid for his limited partnership interest by over $250,000. WHEREFORE, plaintiff Timothy Schmitt requests that this Honorable Court enter judgment against defendant Ward, in an amount which will fairly and adequately compensate him, plus prejudgment interest, costs and any other additional relief the Court deems just. JURY DEMAND Plaintiff demands a trial by jury on all issues triable by jury. Nancy A. Temple Katten & Temple, LLP 542 S. Dearborn, Suite 1310 Chicago, IL 60605 (312) 663-0800 Respectfully submitted, Timothy Schmitt By: s/Nancy A. Temple One of his Attorneys 5
PDF Page
7
Case 3:08-cv-50155 Document 1-2 Filed 07/25/2008 Page 1 of 2 08 C 50155
PDF Page
8
Case 3:08-cv-50155 Document1-2 Filed 07/25/2008 Page 2 of 2 6. By the parties signatures hereto, all Partners of JOHN W. SCHMITT PARTNERS, L.P. and all Members of the Management Company consent to and approve the above transaction and direct that it shall be completed as soon as possible following the signing by all parties of this Agreement or a counterpart thereof, but in no event later than fourteen days from the date of the last signing of this Agreement. All said parties further agree to execute a formal JOHN W. SCHMITT PARTNERS, L.P. assignment and amendment agreement to accomplish the above transfers. Dated this 4/ day of July, 2006. RS-THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY: LIMITED PARTNERS : my Pam S. McCorkle, Individually bon S he (oxtle. and as Sole Trustee in regard to the interest held in the Pam S. McCorkle, as Trustee of John W. Schmitt QTIP Trust under the John W. Schmitt Trust Dated the Marie A. Schmitt Trust Dated December 7, 1984 December 7, 1984 Partner - Units Held - 31.9 Member - Units Held - 43 S MCC : C Som 8. Lid borhee tan & fh as ke Pam S. McCorkle, i the John W. Schmitt QTIP Trust Member - ah He -under the Marie A. Schmitt Trust Dated December 7, 1984 MM pe VA 4 Partner - Units Held - 27.9 Mary Iva Rpngel 2 4 Member - its geld. - 13 Lon S cloth o Pam S. McCorkle, as Trustee of the Timothy W. Schmitt Trust CT. psine Q A. A under the Marie A. Schmitt Teresa A. Schmitt: “FFist Dated December 7, 1984 Member — Units fleld - 13 Partner — Units Held - 3.5 (een eS esa A. Schmitt Member - Units Held - 13 Partner - Units Held - 10 Pam S. McCorkle Partner - Units Held - 10 7) g4 hor taal Mary pa / Partner — Units ona - 10
Issues Laws Cases News Firms Entities Pro