No one has written a summary of this case yet. Sign up or sign in to contribute one.

Complaints ComplaintDocument 1 4/16/1993 Amended ComplaintDocument 15 9/20/1993 Amended ComplaintDocument 32 4/19/1994 Responses Motion to DismissDocument 3 5/27/1993 Motion to DismissDocument 4 6/4/1993 CounterclaimDocument 10 8/26/1993 AnswerDocument 12 9/1/1993 AnswerDocument 19 12/21/1993 Motion to DismissDocument 26 2/2/1994 AnswerDocument 33 5/2/1994 AnswerDocument 34 5/2/1994 Summary Judgment Motion for Summary JudgmentDocument 42 7/28/1995

John R. Chin, Jr., Plaintiff

▼ Represented by Unknown Firm

Name	Phone	Fax	E-Mail

Dennis J Farina	+1 410 479 3900	+1 410 479 3968

▼ Represented by Wruck Paupore LLC - Dye/IN

Name	Phone	Fax	E-Mail

Richard S. Phillips, Sr.	+1 410 820 4455	+1 410 820 4715	dick@wplaw.com

Anne Arundel County, Defendant

Prince George's County, Defendant

▼ Represented by United States Government Accountability Office

Name	Phone	Fax	E-Mail

John Anthony Bielec	+1 202 512 2846	+1 202 512 8501	bielecj@gao.gov

William J. Goske, Defendant

▼ Represented by Unknown Firm

Name	Phone	Fax	E-Mail

Leonard L Lucchi	+1 301 486 1900	+1 301 486 0999
Terrence M McGrath	+1 301 776 7900	+1 301 776 7901

Office	Baltimore
Filed	4/16/1993
Jury Demand	Both
Demand	$1750000
Nature of Suit	440 - Civil Rights: Other
Cause	42 U.S.C. § 1983 Civil Rights Act
Jurisdiction	Federal Question
Disposition	Judgment - Jury Verdict
County	Prince George's
Terminated	5/9/1996
Origin	1
Reopened	None
Lead Case	None
Related Case
Other Court Case	None
Def Custody Status
Flag	CLOSED

Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription.

55	Filed: 3/14/1997, Entered: 3/14/1997	~Notice (other)
	NOTICE of Recorded Judgment in Circuit Court for Talbot County Circuit Court. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


54	Filed: 7/1/1996, Entered: 7/2/1996	Order
	ORDER "DENYING" Plaintiff's Bill of Costs. ( signed by Deputy Clerk 7/1/96 ) (c/m 7/1/96) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


53	Filed: 6/21/1996, Entered: 6/24/1996	Response in Opposition to Motion
	MEMORANDUM by William J. Goske in opposition to [52-1] Bill of costs by John R. Chin Jr. (c/s staff atty. & chambers) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


52	Filed: 5/31/1996, Entered: 6/3/1996	Bill of Costs
	Bill of costs by John R. Chin Jr. (c/s chambers & staff atty.) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


51	Filed: 5/9/1996, Entered: 5/10/1996	Order
	MEMORANDUM AND ORDER "AMENDING" the Order of Judgment passed by the Court on 3/13/96 to reflect that portion of the Court's Order of March 13, 1996, entering Judgment in favor of William J. Goske against John R. Chin, Jr. in the Amount of $100.00 is Struck; and "DISMISSING" all remaining claims. ( signed by Magistrate Judge William G. Connelly 3/8/96 ) (c/m 5/9/96-vm) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 5/9/1996, Entered: 6/3/1996	Terminated Case
	Case closed (cag, Deputy Clerk)


50	Filed: 4/19/1996, Entered: 4/19/1996	Order
	STIPULATION AND ORDER "ADVISING" that only the exhibits admitted into evidence were sent into the jury room during deliberation ( signed by Magistrate Judge William G. Connelly March 13, 1996) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


49	Filed: 4/19/1996, Entered: 4/19/1996	Exhibit
	Exhibit list by John R. Chin Jr. (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


48	Filed: 3/26/1996, Entered: 3/27/1996	Judgment*
	"ENTERING" JUDGMENT on the Counter-claim for John R. Chin Jr. against William J. Goske in the Amount of One Thousand Five Hundred Twenty-Three Dollars and Ninety-Nine Cents ($1,523.99); "ENTERING" Judgment in favor of William J. Goske against John E. Chin, Jr. in the Amount of One Hundred Dollars ($100.00); "DIRECTING" any and all prior rulings made by this Court disposing of any claims against any parties are incorporated by reference herein; and "DIRECTING" the case shll remain open pending the resolution of the 42 U.S.C. 1983 claim. ( signed by Magistrate Judge William G. Connelly 3/13/96 ) (c/m 3/27/96-cag) (jb 5.25%) (MICROFILMED 3/27/96) (cag, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 03/27/1996


47	Filed: 3/22/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Order
	ORDER Re: Return of Exhibits. ( signed by Magistrate Judge William G. Connelly 3/13/96 ) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


46	Filed: 3/22/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Remark
	Verdict Sheet (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/13/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Remark
	Court Security officer Sworn: Donald Thomas (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/13/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Remark
	Closing arguments of counsel (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/13/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Remark
	Court's charge to the jury. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/13/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Jury Trial Held
	JURY TRIAL - Day 2 held before Connelly, USMJ. (ER: Mach) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/12/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Remark
	Opening statements (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/12/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Description not available
	Jurors Empannelled and Sworn (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/12/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Description not available
	Jurors Sworn and examined on voir dire (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/12/1996, Entered: 3/22/1996	Jury Trial Held
	JURY TRIAL - Day 1 held before Connelly, USMJ. (Reporter Mach) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


45	Filed: 1/31/1996, Entered: 1/31/1996	Memorandum
	MEMORANDUM "SETTING" new date for Trial. ( signed by Magistrate Judge William G. Connelly 1/31/96 ) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 10/20/1995, Entered: 10/23/1995	Scheduling Conference
	Scheduling conference held before Motz, C.J. (jas, Deputy Clerk)


44	Filed: 8/28/1995, Entered: 8/30/1995	Stipulation of Dismissal
	STIPULATION of dismissal with Prejudice as to Terry Wilson and Paul D. Grossman and "APPROVAL". (signed Chief Judge J. Frederick Motz 8/28/95) (c/m 8/30/95-cag) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


43	Filed: 8/14/1995, Entered: 8/15/1995	Order
	STIPULATION AND ORDER "EXTENDING" the time for Plaintiff to respond to Motion of Defendants for Summary Judgment. ( signed by Chf Judge J. F. Motz 8/14/95 ) (c/m 8/14/95-gs) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


42	Filed: 7/28/1995, Entered: 7/28/1995, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Motion for Summary Judgment
	MOTION with memorandum in support by Terry Wilson, P. D. Grossman for Summary Judgment and Exhibits. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


41	Filed: 7/18/1995, Entered: 7/19/1995, Terminated: 7/18/1995	Order
	ORDER granting [41-1] joint motion to Extend Time for defendants to file motions for summary judgment to July 28, 1995 ( signed by Chf Judge J. F. Motz on 7/17/95)(c/m 7/18/95 cham) (mdw, Deputy Clerk)


41	Filed: 7/18/1995, Entered: 7/19/1995, Terminated: 7/18/1995	Motion for Extension of Time
	JOINT MOTION by Terry Wilson, P. D. Grossman to Extend Time for defendants to file motions for summary judgment (mdw, Deputy Clerk)


40	Filed: 5/8/1995, Entered: 5/8/1995	Notice of Appearance
	NOTICE of attorney appearance for Prince George's Co. by John Anthony Bielec and Striking the Appearance of Kimla Thompson Milburn. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


39	Filed: 3/10/1995, Entered: 3/14/1995, Terminated: 3/10/1995	Order
	ORDER granting [39-1] letter/motion of Plaintiff for an Extension of the Discovery Process to 5/30/95. ( signed by Chf Judge J. F. Motz 3/10/95 ) (c/m 3/10/95-mec) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


39	Filed: 3/10/1995, Entered: 3/14/1995, Terminated: 3/10/1995	Motion for Extension of Time
	LETTER/MOTION by John R. Chin Jr. for an Extension of the Discovery Process . (cag, Deputy Clerk)


38	Filed: 12/21/1994, Entered: 12/21/1994	Order
	ORDER granting [37-1] motion of Wilson and Grossman for Physical Examination. ( signed by Chf Judge J. F. Motz 12/20/94 ) (c/m 12/21/94-cag) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


37	Filed: 12/16/1994, Entered: 12/16/1994, Terminated: 12/21/1994	Motion for Miscellaneous Relief
	MOTION by Terry Wilson, P. D. Grossman for Physical Examination . (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


36	Filed: 11/16/1994, Entered: 11/17/1994	Notice of Appearance
	NOTICE of attorney appearance for Prince George's Co. by Kimla Thompson Milburn and Striking the Appearance of Alan E. D"Appolito. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


35	Filed: 10/28/1994, Entered: 10/28/1994	Scheduling Order
	MODIFIED SCHEDULING ORDER ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 10/27/94 ) (c/m 10/28/94-gs) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 10/26/1994, Entered: 10/28/1994	Scheduling Conference
	Scheduling conference held before Motz, J. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


34	Filed: 5/2/1994, Entered: 5/2/1994, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Answer
	ANSWER to Complaint by P. D. Grossman (Attorney John F. Breads Jr.); jury demand. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


33	Filed: 5/2/1994, Entered: 5/2/1994, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Answer
	ANSWER to Complaint by Terry Wilson (Attorney John F. Breads Jr.); jury demand. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


32	Filed: 4/19/1994, Entered: 4/20/1994	Amended Complaint
	SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT by John R. Chin Jr., (Answer due 4/29/94 for P. D. Grossman, for Terry Wilson, for Anne Arundel County, for Prince George's Co., for William J. Goske ) amending [15-1] amended complaint. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


31	Filed: 4/5/1994, Entered: 4/6/1994	Order
	ORDER "DIRECTING" that [26-1] and [26-2] motions of defendants, Grossman and Wilson for summary judgment and to dismiss shall be treated as one motion to dismiss; "GRANTING" [26-1] motion of defendants, Grossman and Wilson to dismiss; and "GRANTED" motion of plaintiff for leave to file a second amended complaint on or before April 19, 1994 ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz April 5, 1994) (c/m 4/5/94-gl)(MICROFILMED 4/6/94) (mdd, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 04/06/1994


30	Filed: 4/5/1994, Entered: 4/6/1994	Order
	ORDER/LETTER "REVISING" the scheduling order, as therein set forth ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz April 5, 1994) (c/m 4/5/94-chambers) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 4/4/1994, Entered: 4/6/1994	Telephone Conference
	Tele-conference held before Motz, J. (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


29	Filed: 2/22/1994, Entered: 2/22/1994	Response in Support of Motion
	REPLY MEMORANDUM by Terry Wilson, P. D. Grossman in support of their [26-1] motion to Dismiss. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


28	Filed: 2/22/1994, Entered: 2/22/1994, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Response to Motion
	RESPONSE by John R. Chin Jr. to [26-1] motion of Grossman and Wilson to Dismiss, [26-2] motion for Summary Judgment. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


27	Filed: 2/3/1994, Entered: 2/4/1994	Order
	ORDER "DIRECTING" there shall be separate trials of the Issues relating to Plaintiff's Claim against Defendants Goske, Wilson, and Grossman. ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 2/3/94 ) (c/m 2/3/94-jt) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


26	Filed: 2/2/1994, Entered: 2/2/1994, Terminated: 6/20/1994	Motion to Dismiss
	MOTION with memorandum in support by Terry Wilson, P. D. Grossman to Dismiss , or alternatively for Summary Judgment . (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


25	Filed: 1/27/1994, Entered: 1/27/1994	Summons Returned Executed
	RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to Terry Wilson 1/19/94 Answer due on 2/8/94 for Terry Wilson. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


24	Filed: 1/13/1994, Entered: 1/27/1994	Order
	ORDER granting [13-1] motion of Plaintiff for Leave to File Amended Complaint. ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 1/13/94 ) (c/m 1/14/94-gs) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


23	Filed: 1/13/1994, Entered: 1/14/1994	Memorandum
	MEMORANDUM ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 1/13/94 ) (c/m 1/13/94-gs) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 1/13/1994, Entered: 1/14/1994	Status Conference
	Status conference held before Motz, J. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


22	Filed: 1/10/1994, Entered: 1/10/1994	Summons Issued
	SECOND SUMMONS(ES) issued for Terry Wilson, P. D. Grossman. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


21	Filed: 1/10/1994, Entered: 1/10/1994	Remark
	Request of Plaintiff for Reissuance of Summons as to Terry Wilson and P.D. Grossman. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription.

20	Filed: 1/10/1994, Entered: 1/10/1994	Local Rule
	Local Rule 103.3 Certification of Plaintiff. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


19	Filed: 12/21/1993, Entered: 12/21/1993, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Answer to Counterclaim
	ANSWER by John R. Chin Jr. to [10-2] counter claim. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


18	Filed: 12/21/1993, Entered: 12/21/1993	Notice of Appearance
	NOTICE of attorney appearance for John R. Chin Jr. by Richard S. Phillips. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


17	Filed: 9/21/1993, Entered: 9/21/1993, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Response to Motion
	RESPONSE by Anne Arundel County to [13-1] motion of Plaintiff for Leave to File Amended Complaint and Exhibits 1 and 2. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


16	Filed: 9/20/1993, Entered: 9/20/1993	Summons Issued
	SUMMONS(ES) issued for Terry Wilson, P. D. Grossman. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


15	Filed: 9/20/1993, Entered: 9/20/1993	Amended Complaint
	AMENDED COMPLAINT by John R. Chin Jr. , (Answer due 9/30/93 for Prince George's Co., for William J. Goske ) amending [1-1] complaint against Terry Wilson, P. D. Grossman. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


14	Filed: 9/20/1993, Entered: 9/20/1993	Order
	ORDER granting [13-1] motion of Plaintiff for Leave to File Amended Complaint. ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 9/20/93 ) (c/m 9/20/93-cag) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


13	Filed: 9/16/1993, Entered: 9/17/1993, Terminated: 9/20/1993	Motion for Leave to File
	MOTION by John R. Chin Jr. for Leave to File Amended Complaint and Proposed Amended Complaint. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


12	Filed: 9/1/1993, Entered: 9/1/1993, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Answer
	ANSWER to Complaint by Prince George's Co. (Attorney Alan E. D'Appolito). (cag, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 12/21/1993


11	Filed: 8/31/1993, Entered: 9/1/1993, Terminated: 8/31/1993	Order
	ORDER granting [11-1] motion of Plaintiff for Keith R. Anderson to Withdraw as Attorney (Terminated attorney Keith R. Anderson for John R. Chin). ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 8/31/93 ) (c/m 9/1/93-cag) (cag, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 12/21/1993


11	Filed: 8/31/1993, Entered: 9/1/1993, Terminated: 8/31/1993	Motion to Withdraw
	MOTION by John R. Chin Jr. for Keith R. Anderson to Withdraw as Attorney . (cag, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 12/21/1993


10	Filed: 8/26/1993, Entered: 12/21/1993	Counterclaim
	ANSWER to Complaint and COUNTERCLAIM by William J. Goske against John R. Chin Jr. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


9	Filed: 8/2/1993, Entered: 8/2/1993	Scheduling Order
	SCHEDULING ORDER ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 7/30/93 ) (c/m 8/2/93-gs) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


8	Filed: 8/2/1993, Entered: 8/2/1993	Order
	ORDER "DIRECTING" Plaintiff's Claims against Anne Arundel Co. are voluntarily dismissed; Plaintiff will file an amended Complaint on or before 8/30/93; Plaintiff's state law claims against Prince George's Co. are voluntarily Dismissed; and Prince Georges's Co. withdraws its Motion to dismiss and will file an answer on or before 8/30/93. ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 7/30/93 ) (c/m 8/2/93-gs) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


7	Filed: 8/2/1993, Entered: 8/2/1993	Memorandum
	MEMORANDUM ( signed by Judge J. F. Motz 7/30/93 ) (c/m 8/2/93-gs) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 7/30/1993, Entered: 8/2/1993	Status Conference
	Status conference held before Motz, J. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


6	Filed: 7/1/1993, Entered: 7/1/1993, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Response to Motion
	RESPONSE by John R. Chin Jr. to [3-1] motion of Anne Arundel Co. to Dismiss. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


5	Filed: 7/1/1993, Entered: 7/1/1993, Terminated: 5/9/1996	Response to Motion
	RESPONSE by John R. Chin Jr. to [4-1] motion of Prince George's Co. to Dismiss under State Law. (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


4	Filed: 6/4/1993, Entered: 6/4/1993, Terminated: 6/20/1994	Motion to Dismiss
	MOTION with memorandum in support by Prince George's Co. to Dismiss under State Law . (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


3	Filed: 5/27/1993, Entered: 5/28/1993	Motion to Dismiss
	MOTION with memorandum in support by Anne Arundel County to Dismiss , or alternatively for Summary Judgment . (c/s) (cag, Deputy Clerk)


2	Filed: 4/20/1993, Entered: 4/20/1993	Summons Issued
	SUMMONS(ES) issued for William J. Goske, Prince George's Co., Anne Arundel County. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


1	Filed: 4/16/1993, Entered: 4/20/1993	Jury Demand
	DEMAND for jury trial by John R. Chin Jr. (cag, Deputy Clerk)


1	Filed: 4/16/1993, Entered: 4/20/1993	Complaint
	COMPLAINT filed; FILING FEE $ 120.00 RECEIPT # 12382 (cag, Deputy Clerk)

To request information suppression, updates, or additions, contact us about this docket.

Bulk Download

Download multiple documents

PACER Shortcuts

To update this case yourself, sign into PACER (paid PACER subscription required)

AI text generation	None
AI document summarization	None
AI-augmented search	None
AI-generated images	None
AI chat or Q&A interface	Linkable via MCP
Third party AI contribution in government documents	Possible

Chin v. Goske, et al