Page 1
EFiled: Sep 29 2022 05:11AM EDT Transaction ID 68185211 Case No. 2022-0613-KSJM
Page 2
MARTIN LIPTON
HERBERT M. WACHTELL
THEODORE WH. MIRVIS
EDWARD D, HERLIHY
DANIEL A. NEFF
ANDREW R. BROWNSTEIN
STEVEN A. ROSENBLUM
JOHN F. SAVARESE
SCOTT K. CHARLES
JODI J, SCHWARTZ
ADAM O. EMMERICH
RALPH M. LEVENE
RICHARD G. MASON
DAVID M. SILK
ROBIN PANOVKA
DAVID A, KATZ
ILENE KNABLE GOTTS
JEFFREY H. WINTNER
TREVOR S. NORWITZ
BEN M. GERMANA
ANDREW ¢. NUSSBAUM
RACHELLE SILVERBERG
STEVEN A. COHEN
DEBORAH L. PAUL
DAVID C. KARP
RICHARD K. Kil JOSHUA R. CAMMAKER MARK GORDON JEANNEMARIE O'BRIEN WAYME HM. CARLIN STEPHEN RA. DI PRIMA NICHOLAS S. DEMHO IGOR KIRMAN JONATHAN HM. MOSES
T. EIKO STANGE WILLIAM SAVITT ERIc M. ROSOF GREGORY E. OSTLING DAVID B. ANCERS ANDREA K. WAHLQUIST ADAM J. SHAPIRO NELSON ©. FITTS JOSHUA M. HOLMES DAVID E. SHAPIRO DAMIAN G. DIDDEN TAN BOCZKO BY EMAIL David S. Mader, Esq.
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullrvan, LLP 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, NY 10010 WACHTELL, LIPTON, ROSEN & KATZ G1WEST S2ND STREET NEW YORK, N.Y.
1o019-6150 TELEPHONE: (212) 403-1000 FACSIMILE:
(212) 403-2000 GEORGE A. KATZ (1965-1989) JAMES H. FOGELSON (1967-1991) LEONARD M. ROSEN (1965-2014) QF COUNSEL MICHAEL H. BYOWITZ KENNETH 8. FORREST SELWYN B. GOLCBERG PETER C. HEIN JB KELLY HEYER G. KOPLOW JOSEPH G. LARSGN LAWRENCE 5. MAMOW DOUGLAS K. MAYER PHILIP MINDLIN OAVID S. NEILL HAROLD 5. NOVIKOFF LAWRENCE B. PEDDWITZ ERIC 5S, ROBINSON ERIC M. ROTH PAUL K. ROWE DAVID A. SCHWARTZ MICHAEL J. SEGAL ROSEMARY SPAZIANI ELLIOTT ¥. STEIN WARREN R. STERN LEG F, STRINE, JR.
PAUL VIZCARRONDO, JR,
PATRICIA A. VLAHAKIS.
AMY R. WOLF
MARC WOLINSKY
* ADMITTED IN DELAWARE
COUNSEL
DAVID M. ADLERSTEIN
SUMITA AHUJA
AMANDA K. ALLEXON
LOUIS J. BARASH
FRANCO CASTELLI
ANDREW J.H, CHEUNG
PAMELA FHRENKAANZ
KATHRYN GETTLES-ATWA
ADAM HM, GOGOLAK
NANCY B. GREENBAUM
MARK A. KOENIG
CARMEN xX.W. LU
J. AUSTIN LYONS ALICIA C. MeCARTHY HEIL M. SNYDER
S. CHRISTOPHER SZCZERBAN JEFFREY a. WATIKER Direct DIAL: (212) 403-/108 Direct Fax: (212) 403-2108 E-MaIL: BRWILSON@WLRK.cOM August 30, 2022 MATTHEW M. GUEST DAVID E. KAHAN DAVID K, LAM BENJAMIN HM. ROTH JOSHUA A. FELTHAN ELAINE F. GOLIN EMIL A. KLEINHAUS KARESSA L. CAIN RONALD ¢. CHEN GORDON S. MOODIE BRACLEY R. WILSON GRAHAM W. MELI GREGORY E. PESSIN CARRIE M. REILLY MARK F. VEBLEN SARAH K. EDDY VICTOR GOLOFELD BRANDON C. PRICE KEVIN 5S. SCHWARTZ MICHAEL §. BENN SABASTIAN ¥. NILES ALISON ZIESKE PREISS TIVANA J. DVORNIC JENNAE, LEVINE RYAN A. McLEOO ANITHA REDDY JOHN L. ROBINSON JGHN RF. SOBOLEWSKI STEVEN WINTER EMILY 0. JGHNSON JACOB A. KLING RAAJ 5. NARAYAN VIKTOR SAPEZHNIKOV MICHAEL J, SCHOBEL ELINA TETELBAUM ERICA E. HONNETT LAUREN M. KOFKE ZACHARY S, PFODOLSKY RACHEL B. REISHERG HARK A. STAGLIANG CYNTHIA FERNANOEZ LUMERMANN CHRISTINA C. HA NOAH @. YAVITZ
Re: Twitter, Inc. v. Musk, et al., C_A. No. 2022-0613-KSJM (Del. Ch.) Dear Mr. Mader:
Last night, defendants represented that they had substantially completed their document production. We have grave concerns about that representation. We have identified several major deficiencies that cast substantial doubt on defendants’ discovery efforts across the board:
First, our preliminary review of the text messages produced from Mr. Musk’s and Mr. Birchall’s devices has revealed substantial gaps in production corresponding to critical time petiods. For example, Mr. Musk’s production includes just four text messages from May 6 (three of which are non-substantive messages with Sean Combs, and the fourth of which is a
Page 3
WACHTELL, LIPTON, ROSEN & KATz David 8. Mader, Esq.
August 30, 2022 Page 2 message from Twitter’s Ned Segal) and zero text messages from May 7 through May |1 — a particularly critical period during which defendants allege Mr. Musk was reconsidering his acquisition of Twitter. Mr. Musk has likewise produced zero texts from a weeklong period around June 4, the date on which he determined to adopt the position that Twitter had breached the Merger Agreement. /d.
Mr. Musk and Mr. Birchall’s text message productions have other unexplained omissions. Most notably, defendants have not produced a single text message between Mr. Musk and Mr. Birchall from the period between May 2 and May 12, even though it is clear that these custodians texted each other regularly about relevant subjects. And the respective text message productions of both Mr. Musk and Mr. Birchall include messages that are missing from the other’s production. Moreover, in a text exchange from June 17, Robert Steel of Perella Weinberg Partners engages in a dialogue with Mr. Musk for which all of Mr. Musk’s replies are missing.
We ask that you account for these apparent deficiencies by 8:00 this evening, August 30.
Second, during the meet-and-confer process, you identified a review population of 50,435 documents for Mr. Musk and Mr. Birchall’s custodial records. This population has necessarily increased in light of defendants’ multiple agreements to add email accounts and search terms to their review. Yet defendants have produced only 1,660 documents, yielding a responsiveness rate of about 3%.
This improbable result causes us to question the responsiveness criteria that defendants have applied in their review process. By way of example, there were 4,086 documents returned just by the targeted term (“Mdau* OR MAU * OR Dau* OR UAM OR mMAU”) for Mr. Musk — but apparently /ess than half of those documents were identified for production. We do net understand how this could be so.
We ask that you account for defendants’ implausibly low rate of production by 8:00 this evening, August 30.
Third, defendants are subject to a court order requiring them to supplement their deficient responses to Twitter’s Interrogatory Nos. 1, 2, 12, and 17, including by providing full disclosure of “‘all persons with knowledge of or involvement in” the topics listed in those Interrogatories. Dkt. 221 at 5. On August 26, defendants purported to supplement their responses to bring them into compliance with the Court’s Order. Those supplemented responses identified only persons and entities Twitter already knew had relevant knowledge, and thus disclosed nothing.
Defendants’ production of text messages yesterday confirms that your revised interrogatory responses omitted many other individuals with whom Mr. Musk had substantive
Page 4
WacHTELL, LIPTON, ROSEN & Katz
David S. Mader, Esq.
August 30, 2022 Page 3
communications about the merger, including: Mr. Steel, Michael Kives of K5 Global; Ari Emanuel of Endeavor; Adeo Ressi of VC Lab; and Andrea Stroppa.
We believe defendants’ unwillingness to prepare complete interrogatory is
inexcusable and we intend to seek appropriate relief from the Court. In the meanwhile, we ask that you provide complete revised interrogatory responses by 8:00 this evening, August 30.
Sincerely,
fyb he b how
Bradley R. Wilson
Page 5
Exhibit B
Page 6
From: David Mader Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2022 11:34 PM To: Kirk, David E.
Cec: Silpa Maruri; Kathryn Bonacorsi; Emily Kapur; Andrew J. Rossman; Alex Spiro; Christopher Kercher; Matthew Fox; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP); Rosenello, Lauren N; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP); Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP); Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC); Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC); Savitt, William D.; Wilson, Bradley R.; Eddy, Sarah K.; McLeod, Ryan A,; Reddy, Anitha; Yavitz, Noah B.; Goodman, Adam L; Sadinsky, Alexandra P.
Subject: RE: Twitter v. Musk et al. - Significant Production Deficiencies Counsel, we are in receipt of the correspondence attached to your e-mail of 10:04 a.m. this morning and expect to provide a response, as well as supplemental interrogatory responses, tomorrow.
Regards, David David Mader Partner Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP.
51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, NY 10010 646.241.8334 Cell 212.849.7148 Direct 212,849,7100 FAX davidmader@quinnemanuel.com WWW..gUuinnemanuel.com NOTICE; The information contained in this e-mail message is intended only for the personal and confidential use of the recipient(s) named above. This message may be an attorney-client communication and/or work product and as such is privileged and confidential, If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by e-mail, and delete the original message.
From: Kirk, David E. <DEKirk@wirk.com> Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2022 10:04 AM To: David Mader <davidmader@quinnemanuel.com> Ce: Silpa Maruri <silpamaruri@quinnemanuel.com>; Kathryn Bonacorsi <kathrynbonacorsi@quinnemanuel.com>; Emily Kapur <emilykapur@quinnemanuel.com>; Andrew J. Rossman <andrewrossman@quinnemanuel.com>; Alex Spiro <alexspiro@ quinnemanuel.com>; Christopher Kercher <christopherkercher@quinnemanuel.com>; Matthew Fox <matthewfox@ quinnemanuel.com>; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP) <edward,micheletti@skadden.com>; Rosenello, Lauren N <Lauren.Rosenello@skadden.com>; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <kshannon@potteranderson.com>; Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <ckelly@potteranderson.com>; Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <jslights@wsgr.com>; Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <bsorrels@wsgr.com>; Savitt, William D. <wdsavitt@WLRK.com>; Wilson, Bradley R. <BRWilson@wirk.com>; Eddy, Sarah K. <SKEddy@wirk.com>; McLeod, Ryan A. <RAMcLeod@wirk.com>; Reddy, Anitha <AReddy@wirk.com>; Yavitz, Noah B. <NBYavitz@wirk.com>: Goodman, Adam
Page 7
L. <ALGoodman@wirk.com>; Sadinsky, Alexandra P. <APSadinsky@wlrk.com> Subject: Twitter v. Musk et al. - Significant Production Deficiencies
[EXTERNAL EMAIL from dekirk@wlrk.com]
Counsel, Please see the attached correspondence from Brad Wilson.
Regards,
David
Please be advised that this transmittal may be a confidential attorney-client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please do not read, copy or re-transmit this communication. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us by e-mail (helodesk@wirk.com) or by telephone (call us collect at 212-403-4357) and delete this message and any attachments.
Thank you in advance for your cooperation and assistance.
Page 8
Exhibit C
Page 9
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE TWITTER, INC., Plaintiff and Counterclaim-Defendant, Vv. C.A. No. 2022-0613-KSJM ELON R. MUSK, X HOLDINGS I, INC., and X HOLDINGS II, INC., Defendants and Counterclaim-Plaintiffs.
Smee” ge names” “names” ames” meee” acme” amet” acme nee et” ee” DEFENDANTS’ FOURTH SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF’S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANTS Pursuant to Court of Chancery Rules 26 and 33, Defendants and Counterclaim-Plaintiffs Elon R. Musk, X Holdings I, Inc., and X Holdings II, Inc. (“Defendants”), by and through their undersigned counsel, hereby provide their Fourth Supplemental Responses and Objections to the First Set of Interrogatories to Defendants, dated July 22, 2022 (each an “Interrogatory” and together the “Interrogatories’’), served by Plaintiff and Counterclaim-Defendant Twitter, Inc. in the above-captioned action (the “Action”).
GENERAL OBJECTIONS
l. Defendants hereby incorporate herein the General and Specific Objections in their August 5, 2022 Responses and Objections to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories. By making these Supplemental Responses, Respondents do not
Page 10
waive any of those General or Specific Objections or concede that their original responses do not fully answer the Interrogatories as limited by Respondents’ objections or are otherwise deficient. Respondents reserve the right to further amend any of their Responses and Objections to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories.
SPECIFIC RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS
INTERROGATORY NO. 1:
Identify all Persons with knowledge concerning, information relevant to, and/or possession, custody, or control over Documents or Communications relating to any of the allegations in the Complaint and/or any of the claims or arguments in the July 8, 2022 Letter, and, as applicable, describe the general subject matter of each such Person’s relevant knowledge or information or the general subject matter of the relevant Documents or Communications in their possession, custody, or control.
RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 1:
Defendants object to this Interrogatory as overbroad and as seeking information not relevant to the parties’ claims and defenses.
Subject to and without waiving their General Objections and specific objections, Defendants state that, based upon a reasonable inquiry and to the best of their knowledge at this time, the following is a list of persons with unique knowledge concerning the Merger, the Merger Agreement, and the parties’ claims and/or defenses in this Action:
1. Elon R. Musk (“Musk”). Knowledgeable as to the negotiation, execution, and termination of the Merger Agreement.
2. Jared Birchall. Knowledgeable as to the negotiation, execution, and termination of the Merger Agreement.
Page 11
10.
11.
12, 13, Bob Swan. Knowledgeable as to business and financial modeling for Twitter’s operations should the transaction have closed. Antonio Gracias. Knowledgeable as to business and financial modeling for Twitter’s operations, and transaction financing, should the transaction have closed.
Twitter, Inc. The full extent of Twitter directors, officers, employees, and contractors with relevant knowledge as to the negotiation, execution, and termination of the Merger Agreement, and Twitter’s business and operations, is information known only by Twitter itself.
Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP, Mike Ringler, Sonia Nijjar. Knowledgeable as to the negotiation, execution, and termination of the Merger Agreement.
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP. Alex Spiro. Knowledgeable as to the negotiation, execution, and termination of the Merger Agreement.
Morgan Stanley. Anthony Armstrong, Owen O'Keefe, Michael Grimes, Kate Claassen. Knowledgeable as to financial analysis and negotiation of the transaction.
Morgan Stanley Senior Funding, Inc. Andrew = Earl. Knowledgeable as to the bank debt financing commitments for the transaction.
Andreessen Horowitz, AH Capital Management, L.L.C. (a16z). Scott Kupor. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
A.M. Management & Consulting. Andrew Medyuck.
Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Aliya Capital Partners LLC. Ross Kestin. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
BAMCO, Inc. (Baron). Patrick Patalino. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Page 12
14.
15, 16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21, 22.
23, 24.
25.
26.
27.
Binance Capital Management Co., Ltd. Kaiser Ng. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Brookfield Asset Management, Inc. Nicholas Sammut, Nicholas Goodman. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
DFJ Growth IV Partners, LLC. Randall Glein. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Fidelity Management & Research Company LLC. Chris Maher. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Honeycomb Asset Management LP. Vick Sandhu.
Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Key Wealth Advisors LLC. Ahmad Razi Karim. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Lawrence J. Ellison Revocable Trust. Paul Marinelli. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Litani Ventures. Peter Rahal. Knowledgeable as an equity coinvestor alongside Musk.
Qatar Investment Authority. Ahmad Al-Khjani. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Sequoia Capital Fund, L.P. Douglas Leone. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Strauss Capital LLC. Daniel Strauss. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Tresser Blvd 402 LLC (Cartenna). Peter Avellone. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. VyCapital. Katja Lake, Daniel Schwarz. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Witkoff Capital. Zachary Witkoff. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Page 13
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33, 34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39, 40, HRH Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal Bin Abdulaziz Alsaud (Kingdom). Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Bank of America, N.A. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
BOFA Securities, Inc. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
Barclays. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger. MUFG. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger. Societe Generale. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
Mizuho Bank Ltd. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
BNP Paribas. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
BNP Paribas Securities Corp. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
Goldman Sachs. Knowledgeable as to the value of Twitter in connection with its modeling of the transaction and preparation of a fairness opinion.
J.P. Morgan. Knowledgeable as to the value of Twitter in connection with its modeling of the transaction and preparation of a fairness opinion.
Allen & Company LLC. Knowledgeable as to the value of Twitter in connection with its modeling of the transaction. Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP. Alan Klein. Knowledgeable as to the negotiation, execution, and termination of the Merger Agreement.
Page 14
Al.
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati PC. Marty Korman.
Knowledgeable as to the negotiation, execution, and termination of the Merger Agreement.
SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 1:
Subject to and without waiving the foregoing General Objections and specific objections, Defendants identify the additional entities, who are equity co-investors alongside Musk and as such, have knowledge of their equity investments: 42, 43.
44.
45, 46.
47.
48, 49, 50.
51.
52.
53.
54, AJG Growth Fund, LLC Bandera Partners, LLC Debala Trust (aka Karim Hakimzadeh) Eden Global Investments L.P.
GFNCI LLC
Manhattan Venture Partners X LLC Opportunity Fund X, a Series of Factorial Funds I LLC Qatar Holding LLC Santo Lira LLC Section 32 Fund 4, LP Tomales Bay Capital CGF ZHR IX, LP Tru Arrow Technology Partners CIV II, LP Yuxiang (Robin) Ren SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 1:
Subject to and without waiving the foregoing General Objections and specific objections, Defendants identify the additional entities as having knowledge regarding the topics called for in this Interrogatory:
Page 15
Knowledgeable as investors approached by Morgan Stanley on Defendants’ behalf regarding an equity investment:
55. Access Industries
56. Advent
57. Andrew Finn, Tim Urban, Quentin Koffey
58. Apollo
59. Aristotle Capital
60. ARK Investment Management LLC
61. Ashler Capital
62. Balyasny
63. BlackRock
64. Blackstone
65. Block.one (Michael Lubin)
66. BOND (Mary Meeker)
67. Boston Management/Eaton Vance
68. Brian Armstrong
69. Brinley Partners
70. California Regents
71. Capital Group
72. Carlyle
73. CDPQ 74, Centerbridge
75. Claure Group (Marcelo Claure)
Page 16
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
83, 84.
85.
80.
87.
88, 89, 90.
91.
92.
93.
94, 95.
96.
97.
98.
ClearBridge Clearlake Coatue Combs Enterprises Cowbird Capital CPPIB Craft Ventures D1 Capital DaGrosa Capital Partners Dash Wasserstein Diameter Dorilton Capital Dragoneer EL Acquisitions Steve Ellman Emilio Masci First Republic (Joe Gebbia) Founders Fund Francisco Partners Frank McCourt General Atlantic General Catalyst GIC Gigafund
Page 17
99.
100.
101.
102.
103.
104.
105.
106, 107.
108.
109.
110.
111, 112.
113.
114.
115.
116.
117.
118.
119.
120.
121.
GoldenTree Gregory Cohen (Rambleside) Greycroft Grok Ventures GSAM Guggenheim Hellman & Friedman Hither Creek Ventures (Zander Farkas) HPS Partners HRS Management Iconiq Insight IVP Jack Dorsey Jill Smoller John Catsimatidis K5 Global (Michael Kives) Ken Griffin Ken Howery Larry A Mizel LAUNCH (Jason Calacanis) Level Four LLC (Joe Rogan) Liontree
Page 18
122.
123.
124.
125.
126, 127.
128.
129.
130.
131.
132.
133, 134.
135.
136.
137, 138.
139.
140.
141.
142.
143.
144.
Long View (Crown) Lutetia Capital Marc Benioff Mark Cuban Mayor Bloomberg (Willett Advisors) Michael Pollack Mirae MSD Partners MSIM Private MSIM Public Naval Ravikant Nelk (John Shahidi) Nikesh Arora Nikko Asset Mgmt. (Americas) Norges North Fifth Services (Bill Ford) Nuveen (FIAA) Oaktree OTPP Owl Rock (Blue Owl) Palm Tree Crew Paradigm (Matt Huang) Pegasus Ventures
Page 19
145, 146.
147.
148.
149, 150.
151.
152.
153.
154, 155.
156, 157.
158.
159.
160.
161.
162, 163.
164.
165.
166.
167.
Peltz Pershing Square PIMCO Pomegranate (Clay Whitehead) Prometheus Red Apple Holdings, Inc.
Reid Hoffman Reprogrammed Interchange LLC Revere Capital Revere Securities Ross Gerber Safra Samuel Bankman-Fried (FTX) Scott Nolan Security Benefit Senator Sixth Street Skip Capital Skip Enterprises Pty Ltd Snowdevil Capital / Thistledown (Matt Cowin) Softbank Southpoint Capital S.P. Hinduja Private Bank Ltd
Page 20
168. SRS Investment Mgmt.
169. T. Rowe Price
170. TCV
171. Teknecap
172. Thor Halvorssen
173. Thrive
174. Thrivent 175, TPG
176. UC Regents (Jagdeep Bachher)
177. University of Michigan
178. Veritas Capital
179. Viking Global
180. Warburg
181. Web3 Foundation
182. YLEM (Bastian Lehmann) Knowledgeable as individuals with whom Mr. Musk discussed Twitter/the Merger generally:
183. Steve Jurvetson
184. Jason Calacanis
185. Joe Lonsdale
186. David Sacks THIRD SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 1: Subject to and without waiving the foregoing General Objections and specific objections, Defendants identify the additional entities and tndividuals as having
Page 21
knowledge regarding the topics called for in this Interrogatory based on communications produced by Defendants in this litigation:
187. Aaron Levie 188, Aaron Rappaport
189. Aashish Sharma
190. Abram Brown
191. Adeo Ressi 192, Adil Bhatia
193. Alanah Pearce (96997907 - @Charalanahzard)
194. Alex Berenson
195. Alex Stillings
196. Alex Swieca
198. Alexander Chernyak
199. Alexander Sherman 200, Alexandra Musk
201. Alwaleed bin Talal Al Saud
202. Alwaleed Tlal
204. Amir Efrati
205. Andraz Razen
Page 22
207. Andrea Stroppa (541882699 => @andst7)
209. Andrew Earls
210. Andrew Finn
211. Andrew Perlman 212, Andy Harrison
213. Angus Berwick
214. Anish Shah
215. Annie Palmer
216. Anshuman Mishra
217. Anthony Armstrong
218. Anthony Cicia
219. Anthony Scaramucci
220. Antoine Gara
221. Anton.Mayr
223. Ari Emanuel
224. Arif Ahmed
225. Ashlee Vance (81961201 - @ashleevance)
Page 23
226.
227.
228, 229.
230.
231.
232, 233.
234.
235.
236.
237.
238, 239.
240, 241, 242.
243, 244, 245.
Audra Johnson Austin Pang Bastian Lehmann Beau Davidson Ben Enowitz Ben Silverman Ben Wormsley Benjamin Goodman Benjamin Holland Benny Johnson Berkeley Fondren Bill Lee Blake Hall Bob Steel Bobby Allyn Brad S. Sheftel Bradford Betz Bradley Diener Brandon J. Sanford Brandon Kaufmann
Page 24
246, 247, 248.
249, 250.
251.
252.
253.
254, 255.
256, 257, 258, 259, 260.
261.
262, 263.
264, 265, Bret Johnsen Bret Taylor Brett Rochkind Brian Acton Brian Kingston Brian Schwartz Brian Snyder
Bryan Baum a C Ndu Ozor Cameron Winklevoss Carlos Slim Cary Thompson Cat Zakrzewski Cathie Wood (2361631088 => @CathieD Wood) Charles Sheehan Ching Liu Huang Chris Anderson Chris Stokel-Walker
Page 25
266. Chris Zhang
267. pe
269. Colin Stewart
270. Corey T. Kozak 271, CPG Grey (176774540 => @cgpgrey)
272. Craig Farr
273. Craig Robins
275. Dan Sundheim
276. Dana Hull
277. Daniel Brunt
278. Daniel Freeman
279. Daniel Tay
280. Darren Rovell
281. Dave Rubin
282. Dave Smith
283. David Dwek
284. David E. Kaufman
285. David George
Page 26
286, 287.
288.
289, 290, 291.
292, 293, 294.
295.
296.
297, 298.
299.
300.
301.
302.
303.
304.
305.
David Sacks David Solomon Dennis Baughman Derek Dillon Dick Costolo Dickson Law Diesel Peltz Dimitar Valchev Dinesh D-Souza Doug Leone Douglas M. Palmer Douglas MacMillan Dr. Bradley Jabour Dr. Ulf Poschardt Edward Ludlow Elif Bilgi Endeavor Eric A. Gray Eric Kirkland Errol Musk
Page 27
306.
307, 308.
309.
310.
311.
312.
313.
314.
315.
316.
317.
318.
319, 320.
321.
322.
323.
324, 325.
Evan Fiedler Faisal Baloch Faiz Siddiqui Fiona Osullivan Frank Malone Frank McCourt Gabrielle Bienasz Gabrielle S. Burke Garett Varricchio Gary Black Gavin Baker Gayle King George Galloway George Zachary Glenn Fuhrman Graham Brandt
Grimes (276540738 => @Grimezsz) Hannah Murphy Henry Blodget
Page 28
326.
327, 328.
329, 330.
331, 332.
333, 334.
335.
336.
337.
Hindenburg Research Hiromichi Mizuno (72862939 - @hiromichimizuno) History In Pics (1582853809 => @HistoryInPics) Hyun Joo Jin Ian Miles Cheong Jan Osborne Idena Team Thsan Essaid Imran Salahuddin Iqbaljit Kahlon Ira Ehrenpreis Ishay Levin 339.
340.
341.
342.
343.
344.
345.
Jack Dorsey James and Kathryn Murdoch James Demare James Fontanella-Khan James Gorman James Star Jamie Star
Page 29
346.
347.
348.
349.
350.
351.
352.
353.
354.
355.
356.
357.
358.
359.
360.
361.
362.
363.
364, 365.
Jared Groth Jason Calacanis (3840 - @Jason) Jason Zins Jean-Francois Astier Jeff Collins Jeff Gramm Jeff Skoll Jeff Wood Jeffery Stein Jeffrey Sprecher Jehn Balajadia a Jennifer King Jeremy Erlich Jeremy Parsels Jessie Mae Atkinson Jia Yang Jillian Svendsen Joe Lonsdale Joel Carter
Page 30
366.
367.
368.
369.
370, 371, 372.
373.
374, 375, 376.
377, 378, 379, 380.
381.
382.
383.
384, 385, John Carmack John Darsie John Glaister John Hering John Lamb John M. Brandow John P. Zito John Rich John Rose John Shahidi John Stoll a John Tuttle John-Christian Bourque Johnna Crider Johnna Lesch Jon Neuhaus Jonah Nolan Jonathan Schlecht Jonathan Silverman
Page 31
390.
391.
392.
393.
394, 395.
396.
397, 398, 399, A400.
401.
402.
403.
404.
405.
. Jordan Grossman . Joseph Jackson . Joseph Menn . Josh Raffaelli a Julia Bae Julian Mettmann Justin Riblet Justin Roiland Justin T. Smith Kara Swisher Karen Heller Karen Klores Karim Hakimzadeh Karin Fronczke Kassem Shafi Keith Cowing Kxelvin Ik. Chan Ken Griffin Ken Howery
Page 32
406.
407.
408.
409.
410, 411.
412, 413, 414.
415.
416.
417.
418.
419.
420.
421.
422.
423.
424.
425.
Kevin C. Brunner Kevin Fronczke Kevin Mitnick — Kevin Tu a Kimbal Musk Kojiro Shizuka Koushaw Ghaffarian Kristina Salen Kristy Mullen Kyle Corcoran Kyle Mann Lance Ulanoff Lauren Feiner Lauren Hirsch Laurence Braham Lawrence J. Ellison Leeder Hsu Lewis Shepherd Liana Baker
Page 33
426.
427.
428, 429.
430, 431.
432, 433.
434.
435.
436.
437.
438.
439, 440, 441, 442.
443, 444, 445.
Liv Boeree Lori Nicolet Ludwig Kiermaier Luke Nosek Lynn Martin Mansoor Ebrahim Al-Mahmoud Marc Andreessen Mare Merrill Mark Matousek Mark Pincus Martha Lane Fox Martin Viecha Mason Bissada Massimo (177101260 - @Rainmaker1973) Mathias Dépfner Matilda Simon-Ferrigno Matt Cowin Matt Durot Matt Huang
Page 34
446, 447, 448.
449, 450.
451, 452.
453.
454, 455.
456.
457.
458.
459, 460.
461, 462, 463.
464, 465, Matt Lichtenberg Matthew Koder Matthew Savage Maureen Dowd Melissa MacPherson Michael Dell Michael Izard Michael Kives Michael Liedtke Michael Tucker Michael Tully Michelle Lu Mike Huckabee Mike Schroepfer Nagesh Saldi Naor Amiel Natalie Moses Navaid Farooq Naval Ravikant Ned Segal
Page 35
466.
467.
468.
469.
470.
471, 472.
473.
474, 475, 476.
477.
478.
479, 480.
481.
482.
483.
484, 485.
Neil J. Parikh Nelson Peltz Nichie Gamer (1558996520 => @nichegamer) Nicholas Reimann Nicholas Sammut Nico Fine Nilam Ganenthiran Noah Echavarria Olivier Osty Omead Afshar Orlando Bravo Ortenca Aliaj Ottilie Hoyell — Owen O'Keeffe Parag Agrawal Pat O’Malley Paul Barrett Paul Cheung Paul Graham Paul Griffiths
Page 36
486. Paul Joseph Watson (18643437 => @PrisonPlanet)
487. Paul T. Marinelli
488. Peter Marsh
489. Peter P. Jones
490. Peter Weinberg
491. Philippe Laffont
492. Pinki Chaudhuri
493. Pueo Keffer
494. Quentin Koftey
495. Randy Glein
496. Reed Albergotti 497, Reed B. Rayman
498. Rehan Khursheed 499, Reid Hoffman
500. Richard Gallivan
501. Richard Hardegree 502, Richard Park
503. Richard Spencer
504. Richard von Wildemann
505. Rick Polhemus
Page 37
506 507, 508.
509.
510.
511.
512.
513, 514.
515.
516, 517.
518.
519.
520.
521.
522.
523.
524.
525.
Rishi D. Mangal Robert Herring Robert Ruberton Robert Zubrin Robin Ren Roelof Botha Ron Baron Ronald Gong Ross Gerber Ross Menachem Kestin Rupert Murdoch Ryan Israel Sam Fort Sam Harris Sam Shead Sam Teller Samiuddin Sami Sarang Gadkari
Page 38
526.
527, 528.
529.
530.
531, 532.
533.
534.
535.
536, 537.
538.
539.
540.
541.
542.
543.
544, 545.
Satoshi Nakajima Satya Nadella Scott Adams Scott Belsky (15698507 => @scottbelsky) Scott Coulter Scott Deveau Scott Harries Scott Nolan Scott Painter Sean C. Coburn Sean Combs Sean Edgett Sean Lynch Sekulic, Masa Serkan Savasoglu Shannon Bond Shaun Maguire Shawn W. Liu Shervin Pishevar Shivon Zilis (446719282 => @shivon)
Page 39
546. Shoaib Qureshi
547. Sindhu Sundar
548. Solomon Bier
549.
550. Sonu Kalra
551. Stacey Ferreira
- Hock
554. Stephen Oskoui 552.
553.
555. Stephen Pesche
556. Stephen Wolfram
557. Steve Davis
558. Steve Jurvetson
559. Steve Weiner
560. Steven Brown
561. Steven Crowder
562. Steven Messina
563. Steven Rattner
564. Stockton Bullitt
565. SwiftOnSecurity (2436389418 -> @SwiftOnSecurity)
Page 40
566, 567.
568.
569.
570.
571.
572.
573.
574.
575.
576.
577, 578.
579.
580.
581.
582.
583, 584.
585.
Sylvia Kaminska Talulah Riley Taly Kogon Tamim Jabr Tarik Brooks Tatum Hunter Taylor Wright Teddy Gleser Terrence Kontos Thierry Breton Thomas J. Sheehan Thor Halvorssen Tim Hughes Tim Urban Timothy Draper Todd Morgenfeld Tom Fitton Tom Krisher Tom Loef Tom Maloney
Page 41
586.
587.
588.
589.
590.
591.
592.
593.
594.
595, 596.
597.
598.
599.
600.
601.
602.
603.
604, 605.
Tom S. Hals Tom Swerling Tom van Loben Sels Tracey Chenoweth Trung Phan Universal Sci (2993230373 => @universal_sci) Vijaya Gadde Vikas Shah Vinod Jetley Viv Hantusch Wendi Murdoc Will Knight Will MacAskill William Ackma Willie Yglesias Winnie Kong Xavier Niel Yousef Mohamed Zheng Wang @billym2k Shibetoshi Nakamoto
Page 42
606.
607.
608.
609.
610.
611.
612.
613.
614, 615.
616, 617.
618.
619.
620.
621.
622.
623.
624, 625.
@erdayastronaut Everyday Astronaut @Teslarati @DoctorJack16 @waitbutwhy Tim Urban @evafoxU Eva Fox @murtakpak @LexFridman Lex Fridman @Cernovich Mike Cernovich (@WSBCHairman @MrStevenSteele Steven Steele @stevenmarkryan @Liz_Wheeler Liz Wheeler (@Boztank Boz @ostynhyss Ostyn Hyss (@ppathole Pranay Pathole @stockmktNewz @jspeedymorris22 Joe Morris @johnnaCriderl Johnna Crider (@wholemarsblog @uksaguy
Page 43
626.
627, 628.
629.
630.
631.
632.
633.
634.
635.
636.
637.
638.
639.
640.
641.
642.
643.
644, 645.
@blkmdl3 @teslaownersSV @politicalshort Nick Short @somospostpc Alex Barredo @BTC_Archive @ICannot_Enough James Stephenson @redletterdave Dave Smith @chrisjbakke Chris Bakke @garyblack00 Gary Black @johnkrausphotos John Kraus @engineers_ feed @dogeofficialceo @watcherguru @spideycyp_155 @RenataKonkoly Renata Konkoly @andst7 Andrea Stroppa @sawyermerritt Sawyer Merritt @cybrtrck @truth_tesla @cb_doge
Page 44
646.
647, 648.
649.
650.
651.
652.
653.
654.
655.
656.
657, 658.
659, 660.
661.
662.
663.
664.
665, @ajtourville @realmeetkevin Meet Kevin @shacknews @bloomberg @itsallrisky (@sourpatchlyds @libsofticktok (@obaidomer Obaid Omer @mn_google Patel Meet @catturd2 (@coindesk @squawksquare @its_menieb Mohamed Enieb @rationaletienne @mazemoore @dawggabriel Harold O Koenig @coffeetabletsla @fintwit_news @blkmdI3 @modl3pilot
Page 45
666. @teslarati
667. @occupymars42069
668. @mrstevensteele Steven Steele
669. @tarabull808
670. @jrdavidmitchell David Mitchell Jr
671. @veespike
672. @d2dev David Dales
673. @thecryptodaddi
674. @JaneidyEve Evelyn Janeidy Arevalo 675, @hamblinzeke
676. @drknowitalll6
677. @ajtourville INTERROGATORY NO. 2:
Identify all Persons with knowledge concerning, information relevant to, and/or possession, custody, or control over Documents or Communications relating to Your efforts to arrange, obtain, syndicate, and/or consummate the Debt Financing or the Equity Financing, including without limitation (i) any law firm, financial advisor, or other institution engaged to advise or assist You in connection with the Debt Financing or the Equity Financing; (ii) any other Person that worked on Your behalf and/or represented Your interests in connection with the Debt Financing or the Equity Financing; (iii) any actual or potential provider of the Debt Financing;
(iv) any law firm, financial advisor, or other institution engaged to advise or assist any actual or potential provider of the Debt Financing; (v) any actual or potential coinvestor in the Equity Financing; and (vi) any law firm, financial advisor, or other institution engaged to advise or assist any actual or potential co-investor in the Equity Financing, and, as applicable, describe the general subject matter of each
Page 46
such Person’s relevant knowledge or information or the general subject matter of the relevant Documents or Communications in their possession, custody, or control.
RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 2:
Defendants object to this Interrogatory as overbroad and as seeking information not relevant to the parties’ claims and defenses. Subject to and without waiving their General Objections and specific objections, Defendants state that, based upon a reasonable inguiry and to the best of their knowledge at this time, the following is a list of persons with knowledge regarding efforts to arrange, obtain, syndicate, and/or consummate the Debt Financing or the Equity Financing in connection with the Merger, the Merger Agreement, and the parties’ claims and/or defenses in this Action:
1. Elon R. Musk. Knowledgeable as to the debt and equity financing of the Merger.
2. Jared Birchall. Knowledgeable as to the debt and equity financing of the Merger.
3, Antonio Gracias. Knowledgeable as to business and financial modeling for Twitter’s operations, and transaction financing, should the transaction have closed.
4. Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP. Mike Ringler.
Knowledgeable as to the debt and equity financing of the merger.
5. Morgan Stanley. Anthony Armstrong, Owen O'Keefe, Michael Grimes, Kate Claassen. Knowledgeable as to financial analysis and negotiation of the transaction.
6. Morgan Stanley Senior Funding, Inc. Andrew Earl.
Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
Page 47
10, 11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16, 17.
18.
19, 20.
Bank of America, N.A. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
BOFA Securities, Inc. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
Barclays. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger. MUFG. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger. BNP Paribas. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
BNP Paribas Securities Corp. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
Mizuho Bank, Ltd. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
Societe Generale. Knowledgeable as to the debt financing of the Merger.
Andreessen Horowitz, AH Capital Management, L.L.C. (al16z). Scott Kupor. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
A.M. Management & Consulting. Andrew Medjuck.
Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Aliya Capital Partners LLC. Ross Kestin. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
BAMCO, Inc. (Baron). Patrick Patalino. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Binance Capital Management Co., Ltd. Kaiser Neg. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Brookfield Asset Management, Inc. Nicholas Sammut, Nicholas Goodman. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Page 48
21.
22, 23.
24.
25.
26, 27, 28.
29, 30, 31.
32.
33.
DFJ Growth IV Partners, LLC. Randall Glein. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Fidelity Management & Research Company LLC. Chris Maher. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Honeycomb Asset Management LP. Vick Sandhu.
Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Key Wealth Advisors LLC. Ahmad Razi Karim. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Lawrence J. Ellison Revocable Trust. Paul Marinelli. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. Litani Ventures. Peter Rahal. Knowledgeable as an equity coinvestor alongside Musk.
Qatar Investment Authority. Ahmad Al-Khjani. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Sequoia Capital Fund, L.P. Douglas Leone. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Strauss Capital LLC. Daniel Strauss. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Tresser Blvd 402 LLC (Cartenna). Peter Avellone. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk. VyCapital. Katja Lake, Daniel Schwarz. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Witkoff Capital. Zachary Witkoff. Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
HRH Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal Bin Abdulaziz Alsaud (Kingdom). Knowledgeable as an equity co-investor alongside Musk.
Page 49
SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 2:
Subject to and without waiving the foregoing General Objections and specific objections, Defendants identify the additional entities as equity co-investors alongside Musk, who, as such, have knowledge of their equity investments: 34.
35, 36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44, 45.
46.
AJG Growth Fund, LLC Bandera Partners, LLC Debala Trust (aka Karim Hakimzadeh) Eden Global Investments L.P.
GFNCI LLC
Manhattan Venture Partners X LLC Opportunity Fund X, a Series of Factorial Funds I LLC Qatar Holding LLC Santo Lira LLC Section 32 Fund 4, LP Tomales Bay Capital CGF ZHR IX, LP Tru Arrow Technology Partners CIV II, LP Yuxiang (Robin) Ren SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 2:
Subject to and without waiving the foregoing General Objections and specific objections, Defendants identify the additional entities as having knowledge regarding the topics called for in this Interrogatory:
Knowledgeable as mvestors approached by Morgan Stanley on Defendants’ behalf regarding an equity investment:
47.
48.
Access Industries Advent
Page 50
A9,
50.
51.
52.
53, 54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68, 69.
70.
71, Andrew Finn, Tim Urban, Quentin Koffey Apollo Aristotle Capital ARK Investment Management LLC Ashler Capital Balyasny BlackRock Blackstone Block.one (Michael Lubin) BOND (Mary Meeker) Boston Management/Eaton Vance Brian Armstrong Brinley Partners California Regents Capital Group Carlyle CDPQ Centerbridge Claure Group (Marcelo Claure) ClearBridge Clearlake Coatue Combs Enterprises
Page 51
72.
73.
74, 75, 70.
77, 78.
79.
BQ.
81.
82.
83.
84.
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
90.
91.
92.
93.
94.
Cowbird Capital CPPIB Craft Ventures D1 Capital DaGrosa Capital Partners Dash Wasserstein Diameter Dorilton Capital Dragoneer EL Acquisitions Steve Ellman Emilio Masci First Republic (Joe Gebbia) Founders Fund Francisco Partners Frank McCourt General Atlantic General Catalyst GIC Gigafund GoldenTree Gregory Cohen (Rambleside) Greycroft Grok Ventures
Page 52
95.
96.
97.
98.
99.
100, 101.
102, 103.
104.
105.
106.
107, 108.
109.
110.
111.
112.
113.
114.
115.
116.
117.
GSAM
Guggenheim Hellman & Friedman Hither Creek Ventures (Zander Farkas) IIPS Partners HRS Management Iconiq Insight IVP Jack Dorsey Jill Smoller John Catsimatidis K5 Global (Michael Kives) Ken Griffin Ken Howery Larry A Mizel LAUNCH (Jason Calacanis) Level Four LLC (Joe Rogan) Liontree Long View (Crown) Lutetia Capital Marc Benioff Mark Cuban
Page 53
118.
119.
120.
121, 122.
123.
124.
125.
126.
127.
128.
129.
130.
131.
132.
133.
134.
135.
136.
137.
138.
139.
140.
Mayor Bloomberg (Willett Advisors) Michael Pollack Mirae MSD Partners MSIM Private MSIM Public Naval Ravikant Nelk (John Shahidi) Nikesh Arora Nikko Asset Mgmt. (Americas) Norges North Fifth Services (Bill Ford) Nuveen (TIAA) Oaktree OTPP Owl Rock (Blue Owl) Palm Tree Crew Paradigm (Matt Huang) Pegasus Ventures Peltz Pershing Square PIMCO Pomegranate (Clay Whitehead)
Page 54
141, 142.
143.
144, 145, 146.
147.
148.
149.
150.
151.
152.
153.
154, 155.
156.
157.
158.
159.
160.
161.
162.
163.
Prometheus Red Apple Holdings, Inc.
Reid Hoffman Reprogrammed Interchange LLC Revere Capital Revere Securities Ross Gerber Safra Samuel Bankman-Fried (FTX) Scott Nolan Security Benefit Senator Sixth Street Skip Capital Skip Enterprises Pty Ltd Snowdevil Capital / Thistledown (Matt Cowin) Softbank Southpoint Capital S.P. Hinduja Private Bank Ltd SRS Investment Memt.
T. Rowe Price TCV Teknecap
Page 55
164. Thor Halvorssen
165. Thrive
166. Thrivent
167. TPG
168. UC Regents (Jagdeep Bachher)
169. University of Michigan
170. Veritas Capital
171. Viking Global
172. Warburg
173. Web3 Foundation
174. YLEM (Bastian Lehmann) Knowledgeable as, or about, actual or potential co-investors in the Equity Financing:
175, Anthony Scaramucci
176. Ari Emanuel
177. Ben Silverman
178. Brian Kingston
179. Carlos Slim
180. David Sacks
181. Dickson Law
182. Endeavor
183. Glenn Fuhrman
184. Jason Calacanis
Page 56
185. Joe Lonsdale
186. John Rose
187. Steve Jurvetson
188. Ken Griffin
189. Kimbal Musk
190. Lawrence J. Ellison
191. Navaid Faroog
192. Rick Polhemus
193. Satya Nadella 194, Sean Combs
195. Sean Lynch
196. Tamim Jabr
197. Thierry Breton
198. Will MacAskill INTERROGATORY NO. 3:
Identify all Persons with knowledge concerning any review or assessment conducted by You or on Your behalf (including without limitation any review or assessment conducted by or at the direction of Defendants’ Advisors), whether before or after the date of the Merger Agreement, relating to (1) the prevalence of false or spam accounts or bots on the Twitter platform; or (2) Twitter’s API or “firehose” data, including without limitation all experts, consultants, advisors, or other service providers that You and/or Defendants’ Advisors contacted, consulted, or retained in connection with any such review or assessment.
RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 3:
Defendants object to this Interrogatory as seeking information not relevant to
the parties’ claims and defenses. Defendants further object to this Interrogatory
Page 57
because it seeks information protected from disclosure as attorney work product or under the attorney-client privilege. Defendants further object to this Interrogatory because it seeks information that may be the subject of expert testimony. Defendants will make expert disclosures at the appropriate time, as required by the applicable tules and any further stipulations of the parties or Orders of the Court.
SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 3:
Subject to and without waiving the foregoing General Objections and specific objections, Defendants identify the following persons and entities with knowledge regarding analysis performed on Defendants’ behalf regarding the aforementioned topics: ToSomeone Inc. dba CounterAction (Trevor Davis and Andrew Therriault), Halo Privacy, Inc. (Mark Kearns, Seth Rodin, Kevin Casey, Dennis Duckworth), and Cyabra Strategy Inc. (Dan Brahmy, Yossef Daar, Ido Shraga). Defendants will make further expert disclosures regarding any underlying analysis at the appropriate time, as required by the applicable rules and stipulations of the parties or Orders of the Court.
SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 3:
Subject to and without waiving the foregoing General Objections and specific objections, Defendants state that Elon Musk and Jared Birchall communicated with and reviewed work produced by the entities and some or all of the tndividuals
previously identified in response to this Interrogatory, and that Skadden, Arps, Slate,
Page 58
Meagher & Flom LLP and Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP engaged, communicated with, and reviewed the work of the individuals and entities previously identified in response to this Interrogatory.
THIRD SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 3:
Subject to and without waiving the foregoing General Objections and specific objections, Defendants state Mike Ringler from Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP and Alex Spiro, Andrew Rossman, Christopher Kercher, and Silpa Maruri from Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP engaged, communicated with, and/or reviewed the work of the individuals and entities previously identified in response to this Interrogatory.
OF COUNSEL:
Alex Spiro Andrew J, Rossman Christopher D. Kercher Silpa Maruri QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLIVAN, LLP 5] Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, New York 10010
(212) 849-7000 DATED: August 31, 2022 917334-WILSROLA - MSW AS TO OBJECTIONS ONLY:
/s/ Edward B. Micheletti Edward B. Micheletti (ID No. 3794) Lauren N. Rosenello (ID No. 5581) SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE, MEAGHER & FLOM LLP One Rodney Square P.O. Box 636 Wilmington, Delaware 19899-0636
(302) 651-3000 Attorneys for Defendants and Counterclaim-Plaintiffs Elon R. Musk, X Holdings [, Inc., and X Holdings If, Inc.
Page 59
Exhibit D
Page 60
From: Jaclyn Palmerson Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 12:37 AM To: BRWilson@wlrk.com Cc: Kathryn Bonacorsi; Emily Kapur; Andrew J. Rossman; Alex Spiro; Christopher Kercher; Silpa Maruri; David Mader, Micheletti, Edward B; Rosenello, Lauren N; Matthew Fox; DEKirk@wirk.com; kshannon@potteranderson.com; ckelly@potteranderson.com; jslights@wsgr.com; bsorrels@wsgr.com; wdsavitt@WLRK.com; SKEddy@wirk.com; RAMcLeod@wirk.com; AReddy@wirk.com; NBYavitz@wirk.com; ALGoodman@wirk.com; APSadinsky@wirk.com Subject: Twitter v. Musk Attachments: 2022.09.01 - Letter from Mader.pdf Dear Counsel:
Please see the attached correspondence.
Best, Jackie Jaclyn Palmerson Associate Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, NY LO010 212-849-7104 Direct 212-849-7000 Main Office Number 212-849-7100 FAX jaclynpalmerson@quinnemanuel.com www.quinnemanuel.com NOTICE: The information contained in this e-mail message is intended only for the personal and confidential use of the recipient(s) named above, This message may be an attorney-client communication and/or work product and as such is privileged and confidential. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by e-mail, and delete the original message.
Page 61
GUINM GIMME trial lawyers | new york 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor, New York, New York 1aare-1601 | TEL (212) 849-7000 FAX (212) 849-7100 WRITER’S DIRECT DIAL No.
(212) 849-7148 WRITER’S EMAIL ADDRESS davidmader@quinnemanuel.com September 1, 2022 VA E-MAIL BRWILSON@WLRK.COM Bradley R. Wilson, Esq.
Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz 51 West 52nd Street New York, NY 10019 Re: Twitter, Inc. v. Elon R. Musk, et al., C.A. No. 2022-0613-KSJM (Del. Ch.) Dear Counsel:
I write in response to your August 29, 2022 and August 30, 2022 letters regarding purported deficiencies in Defendants’ document productions and interrogatory responses. L Plaintiff's August 29, 2022 Letter
A. Defendants’ Response to Interrogatery No. 3 Plaintiffs August 29, 2022 letter states that “Defendants’ response to Interrogatory No. 3 continues to fail to identify all natural persons with the specified knowledge, including in particular individual attorneys of the identified law firms.” Defendants disagree that their response to Interrogatory No. 3 is in any way deficient. However, to resolve this issue, Defendants will serve a supplemental response to Interrogatory No, 3 listing the partners from the law firms previously disclosed who have knowledge regarding the reviews or assessments discussed in Interrogatory No. 3.
B. Defendants’ Production of Data Scientist Analyses Defendants intend to fully comply with the Court’s August 25, 2022 Order. That Order clearly defined the Analyses that the Court found to have been put at issue and therefore not subject to the protection of Rule 26(b)(4)(B). Specifically, the Court defined the relevant “Analyses” as follows:
In May 2022, Defendants demanded information pursuant to Section 6.4 concerning Plaintiff's methods of calculating monetizable daily active usage or QUINN emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, lip ATLANTA | AUSTIN | BOSTON j BRUSSELS | CHICAGO | DOHA | HAMBURG | HONG KONG | HOUSTON | LONDON | LOS ANGELES | MANNHEIM | MIAMI | MUNICH | NEUILLY-LA DEFENSE | NEW YORK | PARTS { PERTH | RIYADH | SALT LAKE CITY | SAN FRANCISCO [SEATTLE | SHANGHAI | SILICON VALLEY | STUTTGART | SYDNEY | TOKYO | WASHINGTON, DC | ZURICH
Page 62
users (“mMDAU”). In response, Plaintiff provided its “firehose” data—t.e., a live feed of data concerning public accounts on Plaintiff's platform. Defendants then provided Plaintiffs firehose data to the Data Scientists, who conducted a “preliminary analysis” of that data. Based expressly in part on that preliminary analysis, Defendants terminated the Merger Agreement on July 8, 2022. Plaintiff filed suit, and Defendants responded with counterclaims that reference analyses performed by the Data Scientists (with the preliminary analysis, the “Analyses”) at least eight times.
August 25, 2022 Order on Plaintiffs Second Discovery Motion at 2 (footnotes omitted). Consistent with the Order, Defendants or their advisors (who have been subpoenaed) will produce the Analyses, together with documents and communications and drafts concerning the Analyses that do not contain any work product. If Defendants withhold any such documents, communications, or drafts on the basis that they contain or reflect work product, Defendants will provide a log.
IL. Plaintiff's August 30, 2022 Letter A, Defendants’ Text Message Production
Defendants disagree with any suggestion that their collection, review, or production of text messages has been mm any way deficient. At Plaintiffs request, Defendants conducted a linear review of all text messages with any contact sent or received between May 3, 2022 and May 16, 2022, a counterparty-specific linear review, and a review of text messages that hit on agreed-upon search terms. At Plaintiff's request, Defendants also reviewed all texts within an agreed-upon buffer period. After conducting this extensive review, Defendants produced over 1200 text messages from Mr. Musk and Mr. Birchall. Defendants’ document production—and, specifically, Defendants’ production of text messages—was substantially complete as of August 29. Plaintiffs accusations that there are “yust four text messages” on a certain day or “zero text messages” during a certain time period, in addition to being inaccurate, provide no support for Plaintiff's suggestion that there are responsive texts that Defendants have failed to produce. !
Nevertheless, Defendants will investigate Plaintiff's complaints and, in the event any responsive texts are found to have been inadvertently withheld, they will be produced promptly. Defendants will also produce any text messages between Mr. Musk and Mr. Birchall that were previously produced from the custodial files of one and not the other, although we confirm that Plaintiff has at least one copy of every such text.
B. Defendants’ Rate of Production
As to your second point, Defendants have reviewed over 49,000 custodial documents after threading and deduping. During the course of our early meet and confers, we repeatedly advised you that Plaintiff's search terms were not weil tailored to result in the likely identification of nonduplicative responsive documents. The fact that our good faith observations were borne out by
' Defendants did, in fact, produce text messages from May 11, 2022.
Page 2 of 3
Page 63
the review should not be the basis for negative inferences. Nor is it surprising, given what we told you.
To take your example of the search string “Mdau* OR MAU* OR Dau* OR UAM OR mMAU,” Defendants’ review of documents hit on by that term revealed a significant number of irrelevant, nonresponsive hits, including unsolicited e-mails asking Mr. Musk for money, e-mails containing the word “daughter,” and image files that the keyword search tool reads as random strings of characters, which are likely to hit on short search terms with a wildcard at the end, like MAU* or Dau*. Other irrelevant, nonresponsive hits include employee rosters or other documents that contain employee names that hit on one or more of the common names Plaintiff requested as search terms, such as Martha*, Bret*, Taylor*, Jack*, and Marty*.
Further, we fail to understand why a responsiveness rate of “less than half’ could be incomprehensible to you, given that your own review of documents hitting on the term “mDAU” (without a wildcard at the end) resulted in the exclusion of 76% of those documents from production. Indeed, such a substantial exclusion is far more surprising from Twitter, which uses the term “mDAU” extensively within its organization, than it is from Defendants. Notwithstanding the above, you misstate our production figures by nearly 25%, since Defendants had in fact produced 2,065 documents as of August 29, 2022 (the date preceding that of your letter). Your calculations are therefore incorrect.
Cc. Defendants’ Interrogatory Responses While Plaintiff complains that Defendants’ supplemental responses “identified only persons and entities Twitter already knew had relevant knowledge, and thus disclosed nothing,” Plaintiff is now asking Defendants to supplement their interrogatory responses based on text messages and other documents already within Plaintiff's possession. Such supplements will, again, disclose nothing new. Further, while you suggest Defendants “omitted... Michael Kives of K5 Global,” Mr. Kives and his affiliation with K5 Global are clearly disclosed in Defendants’ interrogatory responses. See Second Supplemental Response to Interrogatory No. |. In any event, together with this letter, Defendants will serve amended interrogatory responses that Defendants trust will resolve Plaintiffs concems.
Defendants reserve all rights. We are available to discuss upon request. Very truly yours, /s/ David Mader David Mader Page 3 of 3
Page 64
Exhibit E
Page 65
From: Kathryn Bonacorsi Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2022 11:49 PM To: Wilson, Bradley R.
Cc: Silpa Maruri; Emily Kapur; Andrew J. Rossman; Alex Spiro; Christopher Kercher; David Mader; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP); Rosenello, Lauren N; Matthew Fox; Kirk, David E; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP); Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP); Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC); Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC); Savitt, William D.; Eddy, Sarah K; McLeod, Ryan A; Reddy, Anitha; Yavitz, Noah B.; Goodman, Adam L; Sadinsky, Alexandra P.
Subject: RE: Twitter v. Musk Attachments: 2022.08.30 Mader Letter.pdf Counsel:
On behalf of Defendants, please see the attached correspondence.
Regards, Kate Kathryn Bonacorsi Associate Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, NY 10010 212-849-7312 Direct 212-849-7000 Main Office Number 212-849-7100 FAX kathrynbonacorsi@quinnemanuel.com www. quinnemanuel.com NOTICE: The information contained in this e-mail message is intended only for the personal and confidential use of the recipient(s) named above, This message may be an attorney-client communication and/or work product and as such is privileged and confidential, If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this decument in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by e-mail, and delete the original message.
Page 66
CLULTERED GOVAAEVOIEL triatiawvers | new york 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor, New York, New York rooro-i6ar | TEL (212) 849-7000 FAX (212) 849-7100 WRiITER’S DIRECT DIAL No.
(212) 849-7148 WRITER’S EMAIL ADDRESS davidmader@quinnemanuel.com
August 30, 2022 Via E-MAIL BRWILSON@WLRK.COM Bradley R. Wilson, Esq.
Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz 51 West 52nd Street New York, New York 10019 Re: Twitter, Inc. v. Elon R. Musk, et al., C.A. No. 2022-0613-KSIM (Del. Ch.) Dear Counsel:
Yesterday at 4:05 p.m. Twitter represented that it had substantially completed its document production. Twitter’s productions, however, reveal clear deficiencies that must be remedied immediately. We are continuing our review of Twitter’s productions, including the more than 80,000 pages that Twitter has produced in the last two days afone, and we reserve our rights to raise additional deficiencies. We nevertheless give notice of the following deficiencies that must be rectified immediately.
First, it appears that Twitter is either withholding obviously relevant and responsive documents or has not in fact made a “substantially complete” production. For example, a comparison between Twitter’s search term results and the materials it has produced reveal numerous obvious gaps in Twitter’s production, including the following:
1. Twitter has produced only 4,144 documents hitting on the term “mDAU,” even though, according to Twitter’s hit count, 17,527 documents hit on that term. It is highly implausible that 76% of the documents hitting on the term “mDAU” fall outside the scope of what Twitter has agreed to produce, which includes “(1) Board-level documents concerning mDAU; (2) management-level documents concerning mDAU; (3) documents concerning Twitter’s belief that mDAU is a key metric for Twitter, (4) documents concerning Twitter’s disclosure of its mDAU metric; (5) documents concerning Twitter's spam-estimation process for the fourth quarter of 2021; (6) documents concerning the relationship between mDAU and Twitter’s revenue or EBITDA; (7) Twitter’s recast of its mDAU on April 28, 2022; (8) Twitter's criteria for determining whether an account is quinn emmanuel Urquhart & sullivan, fp ATLANTA | AUSTIN | BOSTON | BRUSSELS | CHICAGO | DOHA | HAMBURG | HONG KONG | HOUSTON | LONDON | LOS ANGELES | MANNHEIM | MIAMI f MUNICH | NEWILLY-LA DEFENSE { NEW YORK ] PARIS} PERTH | RIYADH | SALT LAKE CITY | SAN FRANCISCO [| SEATTLE | SHANGHAI | SILICON VALLEY | STUTTGART | SYDNEY | TOKYO | WASHINGTON, DC | ZURICH
Page 67
included in mDAU; (9) documents relating to the impact of mDAU on Twitter’s performance metrics; and (10) communications with advertisers regarding the importance of mDAU and its impact on performance metrics.” Please describe what nonprivileged documents Twitter has that use the term mDAU and which are being withheld as nonresponsive.
2. Twitter has produced only 817 documents hitting on the term “UAM,” even though, according to Twitter’s hit count, 5,679 documents hit on that term. This tiny production is staggering, particularly given that the Court has ordered Twitter to produce all documents in Twitter’s review database “reflecting discussion of any other key metric identified by Defendants.” Indeed, even under Twitter’s narrower articulation of responsiveness, which the Court has rejected, it is implausible that over 85% of documents containing the phrase “UAM” do not “relate to Twitter’s belief that mDAU, and its related growth, is a key metric Twitter uses to measure success against its objectives and to show the size of its audience and engagement” or that those documents do not involve a comparison between the relative importance of mDAU and UAM. Please confirm when you intend to remedy this deficiency, which is in violation of the Court’s August 25 Order.
3. Twitter has produced only 130 documents hitting on the term “stickiness,” even though, according to Twitter’s hit count, 945 documents hit on that term. Once again, it would be remarkable if more than 85% of the documents hitting on the term “stickiness”—-which is a measure Twitter uses to measure the engagement levels of its mDAU—would not “relate to Twitter’s belief that mDAU, and its related growth, is a key metric Twitter uses to measure success against its objectives and to show the size of its audience and engagement.” Please explain the basis on which you have withheld more than eight hundred documents relating to this relevant term.
4. Twitter has preduced only 107 documents hitting on the term “TYTT”—which is an
acronym for “too young te tell,” a phrase used to describe users counted in mDAU that are
too new to be served any ads—even though, according to Twitter’s hit count, 289
documents hit on that term. It is facially implausible that more than 50% of the documents
hitting on the term “TYTT” would not “reflect[] Twitter’s knowledge or awareness that its mDAU count includes accounts that were not served or rendered any ads on one or more days when said accounts were included in the mDAU count.”
Further demonstrating the deficiency in Twitter’s production, Twitter has to date produced fewer than 100 documents total from its 23 Cognizant custodians. It is simply not believable that more than twenty individual document custodians would collectively produce fewer than 100 documents, suggesting either that Twitter has not substantially completed its production of documents from the custodian files of these individuals, or that Twitter has not adequately located all sources of responsive materials for these custodians, or that Twitter has withheld relevant documents. So that we may more comprehensively assess the deficiency in Twitter’s production with respect to these custodians, please provide hit counts for each and identify the total number of documents collected from each. Please also confirm when Twitter was first aware of the hit counts for these twenty-one custodians, and please describe the steps yon have taken to identify relevant sources of responsive materials for each, including the identification of non-email sources
Page 68
of relevant materials (e.g., Slack, email, text). Finally, we note that if there are in fact only 100 responsive documents from the Cognizant custodians, it is disturbing that in opposing Defendants’ motion to compel on custodians Twitter touted its addition of these custodians without informing the Court that they only possessed a de minimis number of responsive documents.
Second, as we have already indicated, the volume of materials Twitter produced in the hours and days immediately preceding the substantial completion deadline demonstrates a manifest failure by Twitter to comply with its obligations under the Scheduling Order. As of the substantial completion deadline, Twitter had produced approximately 41,000 documents. Of those, more than 18,000 documents—representing more than 40% of the total production—were produced within one hour of the substantial completion deadline. More than 25,000 documents— representing approximately 60% of Twitter’s total production—were produced on or after Saturday, August 27, two days before the substantial completion deadline. Moreover, Twitter appears to have intentionally held back many of the most relevant documents in its production until the end of the substantial completion period. For example, over 60% of the documents produced by Twitter that hit on the search term “mDAU,” 80% of the documents that hit on the search term “UAM,” 91% of the documents that hit on the search term “Stickiness,” and 96% of the documents that hit on the search term “TYTT” were produced less that one hour before the substantial completion deadline. These delayed productions suggests that Twitter is attempting to deprive Defendants of a reasonable opportunity to review Twitter’s documents in advance of depositions. We reserve all rights.
Third, with respect to the documents of Mr. Egon Durban in particular, Twitter’s production contains only 10 custodial documents—none of them e-mails—and has produced fewer than 100 e-mails to or from Mr. Durban, all from the custodial files of other custodians. The production of only four e-mails sent by a document custodian is cause for concern, and it suggests that Mr. Durban was using other forms of communications to discuss the matters at issue in this litigation. Accordingly, we reiterate our earlier request that Twitter agree to produce text and other non-email messages for Mr. Durban. To the extent Twitter continues to refuse to produce Mr. Durban’s texts and other non-email messages, please confirm that Mr. Durban’s texts and other messages are in fact within Twitter’s possession, custody, and control. Given that Twitter has previously agreed to collect documents from Mr, Durban’s non-Twitter e-mail account, we assume that they are.
Finally, Twitter’s productions raise significant concems regarding the manner in which Twitter has collected responsive materials. For example, Twitter has applied inappropriate responsiveness redactions in contexts where responsiveness is apparent. Twitter has produced a Slack Channel titled “tmp-uam-discussions,” (TWTR_ 000079793) which was explicitly set up to “consolidate[e] the various questions about UAM as a goaling metric for initiatives.” Obviously, the entire substantive content of this channel is highly relevant to Defendants’ counterclaims, yet more than half of the communications in this channel have been redacted as purportedly nonresponsive. Although Defendants agreed to allow Twitter to redact portions of large Slack conversations that did not hit on any search terms (and were not in close proximity to any search terms), Defendants have not agreed to allow Twitter to intentionally withhold responsive information, The same is true of the “tundra-deal-team’” Slack Channel (TWTR_000079519), which likewise has dozens of pages of communications redacted as non-responsive despite the
Page 69
obvious relevance of the entire Slack Channel. Please confirm that you will produce these Channels without redaction.
In addition to Twitter’s inappropriate responsiveness redactions, Twitter has produced, to date, only a handful of text messages in the form of screen shots, suggesting that Twitter has not conducted a forensically comprehensive collection and review of its custodians text messages. Please confirm that Twitter has collected all text messages from, at the very least, Twitter’s six agreed text custodians, and that Twitter has reviewed all of those texts according to its proposed August 23, 2022 protocol. If Twitter has not done so, please immediately explain why it has not. Please confirm whether Twitter has completed its production of text messages. If not, please explain why it has not, identify the custodians whose text messages have not been produced, and state when the production of text messages will be complete. Defendants of course reserve all rights, including the right to postpone depositions and/or seek relief from the Court.
Given the existing discovery schedule, Defendants request answers to the points raised above by the close of business tomorrow.
Very truly yours,
David Mader
Page 70
Exhibit F
Page 71
From: Wilson, Bradley R. <BRWilson@wirk.com> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 11:07 PM To: Kathryn Bonacorsi Cc: Silpa Maruri; Emily Kapur; Andrew J. Rossman; Alex Spiro; Christopher Kercher; David Mader; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP); Rosenello, Lauren N; Matthew Fox; Kirk, David E.; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP); Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP); Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC); Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC); Savitt, William D.; Eddy, Sarah K,; McLeod, Ryan A.; Reddy, Anitha; Yavitz, Noah B,; Goodman, Adam L,; Sadinsky, Alexandra P.
Subject: RE: Twitter v. Musk [EXTERNAL EMAIL from brwilson@wirk.com] Counsel, We write in partial response to your August 30 letter.
In that letter, defendants raise concerns about certain redactions for responsiveness in Slack channels titled “tmp-uam-discussions” and “tundra-deal-team.” e® As to the tmp-uam-discussions Slack channel, because Twitter conducted its review of this document before the Court’s Order on Defendants’ Second Discovery Motion, not all messages discussing the UAM metric were identified as responsive by the reviewers. We advised you of this issue in an email sent on August 25, and offered to re-review any Slack channels we had gathered that contained the term “UAM” (among other terms) and modify the responsiveness redactions to take account of the Court’s Order. However, we explained in that email that “[o]ur willingness to do this is subject to the condition that it be understood that changing our responsiveness criteria for Slack messages in the midst of our review will result in Twitter producing a smaller number of Slack messages prior to the substantial completion deadline,” and accordingly asked defendants to “let us know by tomorrow [i.e. August 26] whether defendants would like us to re-review Slack messages in this manner.” Defendants did not get back to us on this inquiry, and thus Twitter produced this Slack channel without undertaking the re-review it had offered. Nevertheless, we have now re-reviewed the tmp-uam-discussions Slack channel in light of your letter, and we are producing this evening a replacement version that takes account of the Court's Order. e We likewise undertook to re-review the tundra-deal-team Slack channel after receiving your letter. Having done so, we agree that given the subject matter of the Slack channel, the responsiveness redactions were applied in error. We are therefore producing this evening a replacement version that will contain only privilege-based redactions.
We will endeavor to respond to the other issues raised in your August 30 letter tomorrow, as we previously advised.
Regards, Brad
Page 72
From: Wilson, Bradley R.
Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 8:24 AM To: Kathryn Bonacorsi <kathrynbonacorsi@quinnemanuel.com> Cc: Silpa Maruri <silpamaruri@ quinnemanuel.com>; Emily Kapur <emilykapur@quinnemanuel.com>; Rossman, Andrew
J. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <andrewrossman@quinnemanuel.com>; Alex Spiro <alexspiro@ quinnemanuel.com>; Kercher, Christopher D. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <christopherkercher@quinnemanuel.com>; Mader, David S. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <davidmader@quinnemanuel.com>; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP) <edward.micheletti@skadden.com>; Rosenello, Lauren N <Lauren.Rosenello@skadden.com>; Matthew Fox <matthewfox@quinnemanuel.com>; Kirk, David E. <DEKirk@wlrk.com>; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <kshannon@potteranderson.com>; Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <ckelly@potteranderson,com>; Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <jslights@wsgr.com>; Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <bsorrels@wsgr.com>; Savitt, William D. <wdsavitt@WLRK.com>; Eddy, Sarah K. <SKEddy@wirk.com>; McLeod, Ryan A. <RAMcLeod@wirk.com>; Reddy, Anitha <AReddy@wirk.com>: Yavitz, Noah B. <NBYavitz@wirk.com>; Goodman, Adam L. <ALGoodman@wilrk.com>; Sadinsky, Alexandra P. <APSadinsky@wlrk.com> Subject: RE: Twitter v. Musk Counsel, We are preparing a response to your August 30 letter. We expect to send it tomorrow. Regards, Brad From: Kathryn Bonacorsi <kathrynbonacorsi@quinnemanuel.com> Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2022 11:49 PM To: Wilson, Bradley R. <BRWilson@wirk.com> Ce: Silpa Maruri <silpamaruri@quinnemanuel.com>; Emily Kapur <emilykapur@quinnemanuel.com>; Rossman, Andrew J, (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <andrewrossman@quinnemanuel.com>; Alex Spiro <alexspiro@quinnemanuel.com>; Kercher, Christopher D. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <christopherkercher@quinnemanuel.com>; Mader, David S. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <davidmader@quinnemanuel.com>; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP) <edward.micheletti@skadden.com>; Rosenello, Lauren N <Lauren.Rosenello@skadden.com>; Matthew Fox <matthewfox@quinnemanuel.com>; Kirk, David E. <DEKirk@wirk.com>; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <kshannon@potteranderson.com>; Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <ckelly@potteranderson.com>; Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <jslights@wsgr.com>: Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <bsorrels@wsgr.com>; Savitt, William D. <wdsavitt@WLRK.com>; Eddy, Sarah K. <SKEddy@wlrk.com>; McLeod, Ryan A. <RAMcLeod@wirk.com>; Reddy, Anitha <AReddy@wirk.com>; Yavitz, Noah B. <NBYavitz@wirk.com>; Goodman, Adam L. <ALGoodman@wirk.com>; Sadinsky, Alexandra P. <APSadinsky@wlrk.com> Subject: RE: Twitter v. Musk *F* EXTERNAL EMAIL ***
Counsel:
On behalf of Defendants, please see the attached correspondence.
Page 73
Regards, Kate Kathryn Bonacorsi Associate Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, NY 10010 212-849-7312 Direct 212-849-7000 Main Office Number 212-849-7100 FAX kathrynbonacorsi@quinnemanuel.com www.guinnemanuel.com NOTICE; The information contained in this e-mail message is intended only for the personal and confidential use of the recipient(s) named above, This message may be an attorney-client communication and/or work product and as such is privileged and confidential. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by e-mail, and delete the original message, Please be advised that this transmittal may be a confidential attorney-client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please do not read, copy or re-transmit this communication. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us by e-mail (helpdesk@wirk.com) or by telephone (call us collect at 212-403-4357) and delete this message and any attachments.
Thank you in advance for your cooperation and assistance.
Page 74
Exhibit G
Page 75
From: Wilson, Bradley R. <BRWilson@wirk.com> Sent: Friday, September 2, 2022 9:01 PM To: Kathryn Bonacorsi Ca Silpa Maruri; Emily Kapur; Andrew J. Rossrnan; Alex Spiro; Christopher Kercher; David Mader; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP); Rosenello, Lauren N; Matthew Fox; Kirk, David E.; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP); Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP); Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC); Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC); Savitt, William D, Eddy, Sarah K.; McLeod, Ryan A,; Reddy, Anitha; Yavitz, Noah B.; Goodman, Adam L,; Sadinsky, Alexandra P.
Subject: RE: Twitter v. Musk Attachments: BRW letter to David S. Mader (9.2.2022).pdf [EXTERNAL EMAIL from brwilson@wirk.com] Counsel, Please see the attached letter.
Regards, Brad From: Wilson, Bradley R.
Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 11:07 PM To: ‘Kathryn Bonacorsi' <kathrynbonacorsi@ quinnemanuel.com> Ce: 'Silpa Maruri' <silpamaruri@quinnemanuel.com>; ‘Emily Kapur’ <emilykapur@quinnemanuel.com>; Rossman, Andrew J. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <andrewrossman@quinnemanuel.com>; 'Alex Spiro' <alexspiro@ quinnemanuel.com>; Kercher, Christopher D. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <christopherkercher@ quinnemanuel.com>; Mader, David S, (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <davidmader@quinnemanuel.com>; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP) <edward.micheletti@skadden.com>; 'Rosenello, Lauren N' <Lauren.Rosenello@skadden.com>; 'Matthew Fox’ <matthewfox@quinnemanuel.com>; Kirk, David E. <DEKirk@wlrk.com>; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <kshannon@potteranderson.com>; Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <ckelly@potteranderson.com>; Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <jslights@wsgr.com>; Sorrels, Bradley D, (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <bsorrels@wsgr.com>; Savitt, William D. <wdsavitt@WLRK.com>; Eddy, Sarah K. <SKEddy@wirk.com>; McLeod, Ryan A. <RAMcLeod@wirk.com>; Reddy, Anitha <AReddy@wilrk.com>; Yavitz, Noah B. <NBYavitz@wirk.com>; Goodman, Adam L, <ALGoodman@wirk.com>; Sadinsky, Alexandra P. <APSadinsky@wlrk.com> Subject: RE: Twitter v, Musk Counsel, We write in partial response to your August 30 letter.
In that letter, defendants raise concerns about certain redactions for responsiveness in Slack channels titled “tmp-uam-discussions” and “tundra-deal-team.”
Page 76
e As to the tmp-uam-discussions Slack channel, because Twitter conducted its review of this document before the Court’s Order on Defendants’ Second Discovery Motion, not all messages discussing the UAM metric were identified as responsive by the reviewers. We advised you of this issue in an email sent on August 25, and offered to re-review any Slack channels we had gathered that contained the term “UAM” (among other terms) and modify the responsiveness redactions to take account of the Court’s Order. However, we explained in that email that “[o]ur willingness to do this is subject to the condition that it be understood that changing our responsiveness criteria for Slack messages in the midst of our review will result in Twitter producing a smaller number of Slack messages prior to the substantial completion deadline,” and accordingly asked defendants to “let us know by tomorrow [i.e. August 26] whether defendants would like us to re-review Slack messages in this manner.” Defendants did not get back to us on this inquiry, and thus Twitter produced this Slack channel without undertaking the re-review it had offered. Nevertheless, we have now re-reviewed the tmp-uam-discussions Slack channel] in light of your letter, and we are producing this evening a replacement version that takes account of the Court’s Order. e We likewise undertook to re-review the tundra-deal-team Slack channel after receiving your letter. Having done so, we agree that given the subject matter of the Slack channel, the responsiveness redactions were applied in error. We are therefore producing this evening a replacement version that will contain only privilege-based redactions.
We will endeavor to respond to the other issues raised in your August 30 letter tomorrow, as we previously advised.
Regards, Brad From: Wilson, Bradley R.
Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 8:24 AM To: Kathryn Bonacorsi <kathrynbonacorsi@quinnemanuel.com> Cc: Silpa Maruri <silpamaruri@quinnemanuel.com>; Emily Kapur <emilykapur@quinnemanuel.com>; Rossman, Andrew
J. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <andrewrossman@quinnemanuel.com>; Alex Spiro <alexspiro@ quinnemanuel.com>; Kercher, Christopher D. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <christopherkercher@quinnemanuel.com>; Mader, David S. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <davidmader@quinnemanuel.com>; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP) <edward.micheletti@skadden.com>; Rosenello, Lauren N <Lauren.Rosenello@skadden.com>; Matthew Fox <matthewfox@quinnemanuel.com>; Kirk, David E. <DEKirk@wirk.com>; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP} <kshannon@potteranderson.com>; Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <ckelly@potteranderson.com>; Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <jslights@wsgr.com>; Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <bsorrels@wsgr.com>; Savitt, William D. <wdsavitt@WLRK.com>; Eddy, Sarah K. <SKEddy@wirk.com>; McLeod, Ryan A. <RAMcLeod@wirk.com>; Reddy, Anitha <AReddy@wirk.com>; Yavitz, Noah B. <NBYavitz@w!Irk.com>; Goodman, Adam L. <ALGoodman@wirk.com>; Sadinsky, Alexandra P. <APSadinsky@wirk.com> Subject: RE: Twitter v. Musk
Counsel, We are preparing a response to your August 30 letter. We expect to send it tomorrow. Regards, Brad
Page 77
From: Kathryn Bonacorsi <kathrynbonacorsi@quinnemanuel.com> Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2022 11:49 PM To: Wilson, Bradley R. <BRWilson@wirk.com> Ce: Silpa Maruri <silpamaruri@quinnemanuel.com>; Emily Kapur <emilykapur@quinnemanuel.com>; Rossman, Andrew
J. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <andrewrossman@quinnemanuel.com>; Alex Spiro <alexspiro@quinnemanuel.com>; Kercher, Christopher D. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <christopherkercher@quinnemanuel.com>; Mader, David S. (Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP) <davidmader@quinnemanuel.com>; Micheletti, Edward B. (Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP) <edward.micheletti@skadden.com>; Rosenello, Lauren N <Lauren.Rosenello@skadden.com>; Matthew Fox <matthewfox@quinnemanuel.com>; Kirk, David E. <DEKirk@wirk.com>; Shannon, Kevin R. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <kshannon@potteranderson.com>; Kelly, Christopher N. (Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP) <ckelly@potteranderson.com>; Slights, Joseph R. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <jslights@wsgr.com>; Sorrels, Bradley D. (Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC) <bsorrels@wsgr.com>; Savitt, William D. <wdsavitt@WLRK.com>; Eddy, Sarah K. <SKEddy@wirk.com>; McLeod, Ryan A. <RAMcLeod@wlrk.com>; Reddy, Anitha <AReddy@wirk.com>; Yavitz, Noah B. <NBYavitz@wirk.com>; Goodman, Adam L. <ALGoodman@wIrk.com>; Sadinsky, Alexandra P. <APSadinsky@wirk.com> Subject: RE: Twitter v. Musk *** EXTERNAL EMAIL ***
Counsel:
On behalf of Defendants, please see the attached correspondence.
Regards, Kate Kathryn Bonacorsi Associate Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, NY 10010 212-849-7312 Direct 212-849-7000 Main Office Number 212-849-7100 FAX kathrynbonacorsi@quinnemanuel.com www.quinnemanuel.com NOTICE: The information contained in this e-mail message is intended only for the personal and confidential use of the recipient(s) named above, This message may be an attorney-client communication and/or work product and as such is privileged and confidential. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited, If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by e-mail, and delete the original message.
Please be advised that this transmittal may be a confidential attorney-client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please do not read, copy or re-transmit this communication. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us by e-mail (helpdesk@wlrk.com) or by telephone (call us collect at 212-403-4357) and delete this message and any attachments.
Page 78
Thank you in advance for your cooperation and assistance.
Page 79
MARTIN LIPTON
HERBERT M. WACHTELL
THEGDORE WN. NIRVIS.
EDWARD D, HERLIHY
DANIEL A, NEFF
ANDREW R. BROWNSTEIN
STEVEN A. ROSENBLUM
JOHN F. SAYARESE
SCOTT K. CHARLES
JOD! J. SCHWARTZ
ADAM 0. EMNERICH
RALPH M. LEVENE
RICHARD G. MASON
DAVID HM. SILK
ROBIN FANOVKA
DAVID A. KATZ
ILENE KNABLE GoTTs JEFFREY M. WINTNER TREYOR S. NORWITZ BEN M, GERMANA ANDREW J, NUSSAAUH RACHELLE SILVERBERO STEVEN A, COHEN OE£BORAH L, PAUL DAVID C, KARP RICHARD . KIM JOSHUA R. CAMMAKER MARK GORDON JEANNEMARIE O'BRIEN WAYNE M. CARLIN STEPHEN FR. DIPRIMA NICHOLAS G. DEHKHO IGOR KIRMAN JONATHAN M. MOSES JT. EIKO STANGE WILLIAN SAWITT ERIC M. ROSOF GREGORY E. GSTLING DAVID B, ANDERS ANDREA K. WAHLQUIST ADAM J. SHAPIRO NELSON O, FITTS JOSHUA M. HOLHES OAVIO E. SHAPIRO DAMIAN G. DIODEN iAN BOCZHAO BY EMAIL David S. Mader, Esq.
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, NY 10010 Re:
Dear Mr. Mader:
We write in response to your letter of August 30, which addressed certain WACHTELL, LipTON, ROSEN & Katz SI WEST 52ND STREET NEW YORK, N.Y. 1OOI9-6150 TELEPHONE: (212) 403-1000 FACSIMILE:
(212) 403-2000 GEORGE A. KATZ (1965-1989) JAMES H. FOGELSON (1867-1891) LEONARD H. ROSEN (1965-2014) GF COUNSEL MICHAEL H. BYOWIT2Z KENNETH @. FORREST SELWYN B, GOLDBERG PETER C, HEIN JB KELLY MEYER G. KOPLOW JOSEPH D. LARSON LAWRENCE 5S. MAKOW DOUGLAS K. MAYER PHILIP MiNOLIN DAVID S. NEILL HAROLD 5S, NOVIKOFF LAWRENCE B. PEDOWITZ ERIC 5. ROBINSON ERIC 4. ROTH PAUL K. ROWE DAVID A. SCHWARTZ MICHAEL J. SEGAL ROSEMARY SPAZIANI ELLIOTT ¥. STEIN WARREN R. STERN LEO E. STRINE, JR.
PAUL ¥fZCARRONDO, JR.
PATRICIA A. WLAHAKIS.
AMY R. WOLF
MARC WOLINSKY
*‘ AOMITTED IN DELAWARE
DAVIO M. ADLERSTEIN
SUMITA AHUJSA
AMANDA K. ALLEXON
LOUIS J. BARASH
FRANCO CASTELLI
ANDREW J.H. CHEUNG
PAMELA EHRENKRANE
KATHRYN GETTLES-ATWA
ADAM M, GOGOLAK
COUNSEL
NANCY B. GREENBAUM
MARK A. KOENIG
CAANEN &.W. LU
J. AUSTIN LYONS
ALICIA C, McCARTHY NEIL M, SNYDER
5. CHRISTOPHER SZCZERBAN JEFFREY A. WATIKER Direct Diab: (212) 403-1108 Direct Fax: (212) 403-2108 E-Mai_: BRWitson@wLRK.com September 2, 2022 purported deficiencies in Twitter’s document production. unfounded and inaccurate. Twitter has produced more than 41,000 documents over the past MATTHEW HM. GUEST DAVID E. KAHAN DAVID K. LAM BENJAMIN M. ROTH JOSHUA A. FELTMAN ELAINE P, GOLIN EM:L A, KLEINHAUS KARESSA L, CAIN RONALD C. CHEN GORDON S, MOCDIE BRADLEY A. WILSON GRAHAM W. MELI GREGORY E. PESSIN CARRIE H. REILLY MARK F. VEBLEN SARAH K. EDDY VICTOR GOLDFELD BRANDGN ©. PRICE KEVIN S. SCHWARTZ MICHAEL 5S. BENN SABASTIAN ¥. NILES ALISGN ZIESKE PREISS TIANA J, DYORNIC JENNA E. LEVINE AYAN &. McLEGO ANITHA REDOY JOKM L, ROBINSON JOHN R, SOBGOLEWSKI STEVEN WINTER EMILY D. JOHNSON JACOB A. KLING RAAJ 5S. NARAYAN VIKTOR SAPEZHNIKOY MICHAEL J. SCHOBFiL ELINA TETELBAUH ERICA E. BONNETT LAUREN M. KOFKE ZACHARY 5. PODOLSKY RACHEL 6, REISBERG MARK A. STAGLIANO CYNTHIA FERNANDEZ LUMERMANN CHRISTINA Sc. HA NOAH B. YAVITZ Twitter, Inc. v. Musk, et al., C.A. No. 2022-0613-KSJM (Del. Ch.) Your assertion that Twitter’s document production is not substantially complete is month—including approximately 37,000 documents from custodial and centralized electronic files. Twitter’s production rate of such files (as a percentage of the documents reviewed) is approximately 17%. Defendants, by contrast, have produced just 1,660 custodial documents, with a responsiveness rate of roughly 3%.
Page 80
WACHTELL, LIPTON, ROSEN & Katz David S. Mader, Esq.
September 2, 2022 Page 2 Your claim that Twitter failed to comply with the rolling production requirement in the Scheduling Order is also meritless. Twitter devoted significant resources to its collection and review effort and worked in good faith to meet the substantial completion deadline, making more than a dozen productions along the way. The fact that Twitter made a large production on the day of the substantial completion deadline is neither surprising nor improper. Rather, it is a necessary byproduct of highly expedited litigation and entirely common in the Court of Chancery.
We turn now to the specific deficiencies that your letter identified:
First, with regard to Twitter’s production of documents containing the term “mDAU,” your statement in the August 30 letter that only 4,144 documents containing this term were deemed responsive is inaccurate, Twitter has produced more than 4,600 documents that contain the term “mDAU.” Your calculation also fails to account for documents Twitter is withholding on privilege grounds, which will be reflected on Twitter’s forthcoming privilege log. The reality is that Twitter has deemed responsive more than 40% of the documents that contain this term. This responsiveness rate aligns with reasonable expectations: Given the Court’s Order on Defendants’ Second Discovery Motion, not all documents that reference the term “mDAU” are required to be produced.
To test Twitter’s responsiveness determinations on documents containing the term “mDAU,” we reviewed a random sampling of documents contaimng that term that had been coded non-responsive. Most of the documents in the sample had been properly designated, but the sample did include a small number of documents that, although immaterial, are technically responsive. We are investigating this issue further and will provide an update over the weekend. Second, with regard to Twitter’s production of documents containing the term “UAM,” your letter was premature. Twitter expects to produce by tomorrow a significant number of additional “UAM” documents, in accordance with the Court’s Order on Defendants’ Second Discovery Motion.
Third, with regard to Twitter’s production of documents containing the term “stickiness,” we expect that additional documents containing this term will be produced by tomorrow as part of Twitter’s production of documents in response to the Court’s Order on Defendants’ Second Discovery Motion.
Fourth, with regard to Twitter’s production of documents containing the term “TYTT,” your understanding of this acronym is mistaken: It does not refer to accounts that “are too new to be served any ads.” Aug. 30 Letter at 2, As you know, defendants served a specific document request targeting TYTT accounts. In its response to this request, Twitter agreed to produce non-privileged documents that concer the “treatment of TYTT accounts in connection with the mDAU Audit for Q4 2021, or the actual or potential discussion of TYTT accounts with Defendants in connection with the Merger Agreement.” See Response to Request No. 1, Plaintiff's Responses and Objections to Defendants’ Revised Second Requests for Production of
Page 81
WACHTELL, LIPTON, ROSEN & Katz David S$. Mader, Esq.
September 2, 2022 Page 3 Documents Directed to Twitter, Inc. (Aug. 19, 2022). Twitter has endeavored to produce such documents, and defendants have made no colorable showing that the production is deficient. Fifth, with regard to the “Cognizant custodians”——whose emails were searched for the period November 1, 2021 to January 14, 2022, in accordance with our agreement on the email search protocol—our calculations indicate that Twitter has produced approximately 260 documents from their files, out of a total of approximately 4,600 such documents in the review population. Insofar as these individuals’ work on the mDAU Audit was only a small portion of the work they did for Twitter, these figures are not entirely surprising. Nevertheless, Twitter is investigating this issue further and will revert in prompt due course. In response to your inquities regarding non-email document sources for these custodians, as you know, Twitter did not agree to collect or review Slack messages or text messages for the Cognizant custodians, This issue is currently pending before the Court as it pertains to Slack messages.
Sixth, with regard to Twitter’s production of documents from Mr. Durban’s Silver Lake email account, your letter was premature. Twitter has now substantially completed its production of documents from that email account.
We do not agree to add Mr, Durban as a Messaging Platform Custodian and review and produce his text messages. As you know, we reached an impasse on that issue more than a week ago.
Finally, we do not understand the basis for the assertion in your letter that Twitter has produced only a “handful” of texts. Twitter has produced hundreds of text messages from its Messaging Platform Custodians, ali in accordance with Twitter’s August 23 Message Protocol. Twitter expects to make a final production of text messages from these custodians tomorrow.! Sincerely, fyb he [how Bradley R. Wilson
} We responded separately yesterday to the concerns you raised in the August 30 letter about certain Slack channels in Twitter’s production.
Page 82
Exhibit H
Page 83
WeaA
(LSD) THSETZ Pe-TO-2z0z
“Yq BNO XY JaTUM} Sy} SAOW PNoOYs | 3S2I U] “NOY T Ul slay} UO Sueow & wel} azi|ea | ¢sepuayes Apwuud anoA |I9s Kees YseqIAg S1Ng ‘MOU IYSU XN U! sue SUIYT MOLY |
(153) TT+L0:TZ pZ-TO-2z0z
pd}! AJLUIPIOOI WAY] AACY OF SUILU OG U! B/qe|IEAe NoA aly alqeua-s/ ued NOA usyy PUe LU! NOA Jay [LIM YIM JUNIE INGA JO} WAZ [12 AUIGesIp Agi xy ues AeyL, pexn
(153) 60:85:02 7Z-T0-ZZ0Z
23! SJEUIPIOOD WAY] BABY OF SUIL OG Ul a[qe[IeAe NoA vty VW ajqeua “34 UPD NOA UB] PUR UI NOA 33] [JIM Y2IYM JunoIe sNOA 305 YAz |e SUNGesIp Agi xij ue AayL
(189) EE:25:02 PZ-LO-ZZ07
( Has SBUIIIS X8|V
yead yO
(189) LEBEOZ VZ-TO-Zz0z
aw & Uodn eouo ‘mau au] AjaA 0} auoYd plo JNOA pasn am auNsse |
(LSD) 6S:¥T-02 ¥2-L0-¢z07z
| EE 2241195 21
Mou Aqayes 3g ISML JO Peay slay? YM Sureuuo}
(15D) 71-02 7Z-TO-Z2z0z
( HAS “( SdUl||DS X81
a B
"apo dnyseq ayl asn 2,upip | se ‘aud mau SILA UO JOM atm | BYEW 07 B/Ge SEM | MOY ans JON
(159) 8E°ET:OzZ v2-LO-Zz0z
Appaiip suijese4 oy AddeY
(183) 82:50:02 7Z-LO-2z0z
“71 YENI SUDLOM aue Aay | “SWesy sau Aq siy7 3%!| saZUBYI BYEW O} pley Aran UI apew aa,Aauy os asayz JdA0 Aypeutaqul ajyord Ysiy patapisuod s| JuNOIIe INOA UpIL
(159) SS:€0:02 72-L0-Zz0z
lua|goid 2 (jas yi Way) YIM BWIYS2ey Os|e UeD |
(LSD) Le LZ6T PZ-10-2202
pood spunos
(183) 9E‘TZ:6T vZ-TO-2Z0Z
sauly|aS X3[V
a 2 =: ES 224s ew
| ee - CC eS
( | a HE «2015 x21
(
ES»: <2 25201
{
a .-: EE «2495.21
a 5204S XIV
MOU azepdn ve JO} Susy “UOOS SIS OF WAZ INOA yasas euuod Ajjnyadoy ase Au pue (YEY)AQUaD! AW WuyUOd 0} LUeY3 YIM PSull1adk3 - SA
(15D) £0:BT:6L vZ-TO-2Z0Z
“aeay 0} [e018 “WO
(1S) €#:TZ:€zZ TZ-LO-Zz0z
| 2s
dde uolewyuod ay YIM pa|qeus Jope}omy aney | 1Ng
(153) SO:DZ°EZ TZ-L0-Zz0z
=a:
Jaya Aw yaey 0} Bury auoawos $s} }|
(153) ZS°6T-EZ Te-TO-2z0Z
JaTUM | {Nod 0} ssaa3e peY [9S NOA ainsua 0} 93949 0} PaIWEM ING JdWARe JOWWeIS E SI S14 Suluuinssy “sjlewWa Jase/ puomssed uszop e pue lela UOReADeSp BUD Bas | ING Sunsod JON
(159) TE*6T-€t TZ-TO-ZZ07
| CO
( A EE
eduiujAue dursod Junosse 457M} AW 5|
(1S) BS:ZT-€% Lz-ToO-Ecoz
Jag yo durAejs wy
(1S3) TLT€2 Te-TO-2z0z
( : <: EE <2 15 “210
( :\-s <2 25 av
pe Terres)
TWILNSO\|ZNO3 ATHSIH
AyjuaoaJ P3ii}},UaAey |
(159) O€:ZT:€Z TZ-LO-270z
sidwiaye sjasad piomssed swios duipnpu| ‘weds Ul pjay S|IPUe Jo Jaquunu e Mes | 240 JUNODIe JADIM LINDA ssaoJe 0 alge NOA ase - UO}Z
(15D) ES:60:E2 TZ-L0-Zz0z
Page 84
SBIDEIS OUOIUY
“SSaUXJEP BY} 02150] Be 9M JO SAA] Ind WJM Puajap Sulyany 0} peau am ajdiouud esi siyy "Jey JOWeU! OU SassalyewW BuyINY ayy OL “UO[Y NOA LAIM %OOT WE |
(13) O€°LT"20 SO-£0-ZZ0Z
“JYS|ING S| yulyT NOA ey Sulynods aey NOA auoawos $31 UaYM JsOlu sJeTelW Yeads 8214
{159) ZO‘OT:ZO SO-E0-ZZ07
Ayaex3
(189) Z?60°Z0 SO-E0-2z02
SEIDBID OUOIUY
“WONN]SUOD UESWeLy au] yo Suld ayy si eyy "py BJeY am aq Ajasigaid 1! Moye PyNoys a,
(1S) 6€°60:20 S0-E0-7c0z
SPNEID OIUO]UY
“NOA YUM sade 900T | YSU Ajje}O} ae NOA™S|nu SuIyINJ SI SIYL
(13) 05:80:20 SO-E0-2202
SPIJEID OWUOWUY
SPIDEID O1UO}UY
SPIDEID OUD
a : 215 2 (
eS : =; RS 2415-61 ( |
15 Xalv¥
sBul||9S Xe] v
( SHUn||NS X8|'7
(
Saunas xa|¥
) sdunyias xe |v (
a : -; ee 5221135 21
ee ..: ae...
) ssulys xery
a 2
4195S
00} S}Ulod pood awos yng “WYS|/Ng $0 1907]
(153) S€:80°Z0 S0-E0-2Z07
SuUIUIELa1Ua syInb smau Jay} pull | ‘Ayenpy
(153) Z0:80°20 SO-£0-7z0z
"SSQUPPE dj tay) YOO|G OF ploy uaaq SABY 3/\\ ‘S8DJNOS SMU LeIssny JayqO |BJaAes pue Aepol eissny Suiuueq Mel E passed N34
(1s) Ev:20:Z0 SO-E0-ZZ02
SEIDEID OUDIUY
Uo|y UO SuIOS SLBA "yseeds ad. 4 Taam] INA Mes |" MOM
(15D) 7P:90-20 SO-EO-ZZ02
I 512
~ G7 8pod dnydeq Jey? aves 0} Japulwed Puy, Pex!
(15D) S0°ET:E2 ¥2-TO-7c07
| EE 205x217
@ spoo dny2eq Jey} BARS 0} JapUl lua puiy
(159) 62:00:EZ #Z-TO-ZZ0z
—:
jS{UeYL
(153) EESS:22 Z-TO-ZZ07Z
EE 28S
paysadsns si Ajuo ddy
(1S3) Lv 9:22 pe-TO-ZzZ02
| PE ©2085 x1
Wiz < Aqunsag < sseoge Junodse pue Anaas <sduimes y4z ajqeue ued noA uy aauo puy
(183) 6E:TS-@z ve-TO-c202
a:
p@{O UL YD2Q JOS 07 B/QV,, PRAM
(ISD) [9:05:22 vZ-L0-2Z07
219 UL peg 33d 02 a/qY
(159) 99:0¥:@Z PZ-TO-ZZ0z
EE 2555 %1v
MOU Ul Foy 0} Ayy asea|d “PS[GesIP WAT
(1S9) ¥0:9E:22 PZ-LO-CTOT
| es
Ale NOA 1 AdUEYS ay} syew Oj Apeal BE aM -UOZ,, PAN
(15) ZO:SE:Z2 ¥Z-L0-ZZ07Z
— SSUIIIIS XB
BIE NOA J! SAUeYD Sy} SyewW 0} Apes aie OM -UO}A
(189) 9T-EE:ZzZ vZ-LO-CZ07z
| s
|, Papaau BW!LaIe4 ON “a|Geua-as PUP UI UBS Ajayelpawiu! Ud NOA UBU] pue y4Z alqesip Aaya aau0 UL UBIs 0} Nod Bunxe3 Isnl WW,} Alje=spl Ply “Pood spunos, Payxr
(1$D) 82:85:12 PZ-LO-ZZ02
| EE £24415 217
“papaau sul |aIe4 ON ‘a|qeua-a pue ul ues Ajajelpauutu! ued NoA ualy pue y3zZ a[qesip Aayy aauo U! UBIs OF NOA Sulyxay ysnf w,| A[/Bep! Puy “Pood spunos
(LSD) S#:Ov'TZ pZ-L0-2z07
es
2g pasu J! Way} au jaaey 0} Ayatig |/29 242 Yo days ued | Ing
(159) 80:SE:1Z ve-T0-2z0z
JLNSQISNOSD ATHOIR
Page 85
a]Epsuo7 aor
) a}2psuo7 sor
a | °: EE 5-12-25 o1woay
—I——, 2:
Soe
zz eee
SEIEIDH OIUOIUY
men EE «2225 cay
Bap! Susaiaqul Jadns
(103) 70-85-02 97-£0-7z0z
“JeTIM] OF pauaddey Sey JEYUM 0} JUAl|ISaJ 531 OS JUS BUOP Sq O} Sey YSN! 4! Jom payesyjdwo. 3Us! SIY] “paysee sg [1M 1 3) pulyaq Aue pazljejueo eB sey 41 J) “}OQUOD pue soUaN|U! OF Ad] [JIM SJaSTUSAPE PU SJUSLWULISAOS JEU] BAJE SIBLINS BABY NOA asIMUsUIO "jepOW BuisiusApe Ue BABY 3,Ue3 3 “SUOp Sey [URIS JEYM dy] JIG VY “Ul SeQuUeApe AlLO ‘[oI0jO1d BLA UMO
7,US0p Jey} SHOs JO UONepUNo e Aq papuny ‘}o20}01d aaunos Uado Ue aq ISNW! UI aAaljaq |
(LO3) TE:ZS:0Z 9Z-E0-Zz0z
PANZGRIUSOOUOYEZB=VaOe=Se/9E TLS Cre Lod 2/205 L/SMels/SNWUO|e/WO2 Janimy/ (sayy
41AS 294!| YOO] Upinoys yey} (10D) 9vET-0Z 9Z-E0-Zz0zZ HS NO} (109) O€-ET-0Z 9Z-E0-Zz07 | -_ a eae! BMWS| (L109) Z0:2T-8t 9¢-E0-7z0z
spel pel
ye] | Ayn si siuy *Auedwos @ aq 3,Ue9}| ‘papssu si Wuopeld mau eB ‘sa,
(19) OD:ZT!ST 9Z-£0-2207
a/Epsuoy aor
iMONGN103 UAPPIY SI MOU USL BABY aM JeUM,, PBACT
(103) ZE:ZT:ET Z-E0-ZzZ0z
32S
jUodnu02 Uapply si mou YSU aveU am Jeu,
(LOD) TEZTET pe-E0-7702
des
Ajainjosay
(109) ST:ZT:ET ¥2-£0-ZZ0Z
dss
« G|Y4ssosuad Ayrjays AIeIVIqIe BABY JOU O} paau sasenbs ayqnd ing -(: sjashw
Azes9 $$3] PUNOS ||,| OS NOA SUI UED| MON "4282 Bq AZeID UW! Suiusiay Joy Sulysnd w,| seap! BY} JO BUO S! SIU] pue jeasjad Adi|od GOD ay} Je MOLOWWO} SSB18U03 JO SJaquiaw OT Jano
0} dulyeads Ajjenqe w,|-1aaM] ,201Nos vado aq pjnoys WYIJos]e Jay, JNOA BAq] |,, Pax
(109) TEZT:€L $2-£0-2202
xx jdjay 0} FuiuyAue op |]M | “Wisi-ayom JYBY
0} SUILIALUOS OP Op asea|d “PiJOM Jy} SuAIaJUI SI 11YS SIU} Puy “ajeIs SAIssewW e UO Suaauisua Je190s Joy sjea1pes Aq pasn dulaq 51 pue yojdxa oj Asea AUSASAljng ‘aya YO! yy UeY Suipueys PYOM-\E21 S1OWW Sey OS PU “WOpe|d |el30s e se ||aM SE Wea1s SMa E Os|e S31 asNeIaq “JETIM] SI Je 40 1SJOM ayy pue ‘aj!| Wapow Jo aBynoIs |yj SI eIPSW |BIDOS YUU AQseuay |
(Ld) OS:TO:EL Fe-€0-7Z0Z
‘diyssosuaa Ays}ays AIBIGJe BABY JOU 0} paau sajenbs 31\qnd ing
*(: yjasAw Azes9 ssa] punos||,, os nOAay2 ued] MON “YIa} Big AzeI9 wi Suljusiss Joy Suiysnd LW, | SPAP! BU} JO Aud SI SI] pUe eaqa! ADIJOd {OS Su} Je MOOWO} ssatTUOD JO SJBqLUALU OOT J8A0 0} Bupjeads Ajjen}re WwW, - JaaM4 ,22INOs Usdo aq pjnoys WY WORE seQIML,, INCA BAg] |
(103) 90:25°2T pZ-E0-Z20z
#85
, eypaads-aayy Aj|PSIPes }1 ayewW pue Jay Ang noA ued IO, payn
(109) T2:2S:2T p2-€0-ZZ07Z
#125
xX ydaads 33.1 Yoddns Ayedoid 0} 1 aBueys pue y Ang aqAely
(LOD) PE:ZS°2T #e-E0-2207
TL
xX JETUIM| Woy sawos Ayipidnys yon as
(Lad) 6:S+:2T 7Z-E0-ZZ20Z
iL
eysaads-aauy Al/eo!/ped 21 SyEW Pue JaWIML Ang NoA Wed 19
(LOD) ZO:Sb-2T p2-E0-Z202
mh
gJE2|ueqInd os awosaq suoAaAa sey AY/, “ayof Suan B SEM “AepO} 7 Jnoge Jue} alam | pue yedley -Azeso si uolsuadsns 103 sag UO|Aqeg BY
(Ld9) BEEv-2T PZ-E0-Z20Z
iL
“ANVSNI Sulod si equawy
(L039) OF:0¥-2T 7Z-£0-Z20Z
Xx gjeseald ‘I ajejap uey) pue JaqIMy Ang nod ueD
(LGD) OZ:6E*ZT v2-E0-Zc02
iL BS
2 SSBUJJEP SY} 0} 150] VE OM JO SaAl| JNO YIM puajap AuLjIN! 0 paau am ajdiauid 251 Siu" JEYUM JaQewW OU SasseuyeU AUIYIN BY} OL ‘UO]A NOA LAIM %OOT WE |,, PAA]
(LSD) SG:ZT:Z0 SO-£0-Z202
“payoxe Sunied we | Suueams ayy joy Alias
(183) BE:ZT-20 SO-E0-zZz0z
N3dISZNOD ATHSIH
Page 86
es .:: a == a o's. 13g AODWON
JaLIM] eye ueqing uosy
BE) 25 seed
a 22142 wg AQQWON JayUM CULE i) Yeqing u083
} wost||3 Ae7
2s I eeo27G 483 { uosi|}y Ae]
ueging uoz3
=a ES » =; I 0 2011 1033
Has yoel 932!
1S EE 202
48S yoe! ae!
15 I 0722
42S JojAeL alg | 2° 4e13=2
Aep je ajqixa}y [am se ABpol nos YM yeads 0} Jaded 5! 84 MouY | pue dele” ytiMm yo 103 Isnp Aepo} yeads 07 aynuiw e sAeYy NOA UaYM MOLY BWW IS] “JO|Ae| Je4g SI SIU] |
(LOD) OZ:ET:ST £2-£0-220Z
4198S
uosy SyUeUL
(LD) §S:TO:ST £Z-E0-7202
GsAep Maj IxXau SUOP S1Yt yes ueDaMacdel “AjyIINb pueMoy siyy aAOW
UBD BM Os Way} JO Saly} MIEYD 0} NOA JO} S| dejsX9N “p4EOq UO PUE PaA[OAU! duraq noA jo yadsod jnoge payjoxa suoAJaAa-UO]Z “NOAM SUOWeSsJeAUOD Aw uo payag slay “uo M payauvon ae no, - (AQ8 Jo peay) EYWeW pue (UeWIJeYD) Jag (08D) Fee BuoAlBAS I}
(La9) ZT:TO:ST £2-£0-2Z07
(| EE osi)3 Ae5
“aJNS
(109) OZ:9S'ZT £Z-E0-2z07
“AGA JO} JUaIUAAUOD JaAaUAaYM AEPO} JeY9 5,87] “dn - MoO||O} aAeH
(103) 6T:S0:60 Z¢-E0-2202
=e |e:
EMOU 4/22.02 JUEM
(109) S@:Z¥:2O Lt-E0-2Z02
3 Aue]
GA sani] Jeyjoue paau am yull op | “os 10 Aep 1xau ay] UL NOA YM Jey OF By!) P,| ‘UO|Z
{1GD) LE90:20 £2-E0-c720¢
*pleog JaYIML 34} Sulpseseu st 3|
(LD) pEeri2Z 9Z-E0-Ez0z
“JUSWOLU e BABY NOA UBYM |/e9 BSBa|g “UOIA SI SIU.
(Lad) £S:8b:2Z 9Z-E0-Z20Z
,, Uado {Ng “s}qnop aney ysn/ | ‘voIdo ysaq ByI Ajay! SAL, P24
(Lad) 05:9S:TZ 9Z-E0-Zz0z
uado ing ‘signop aaey jsn| | ‘uo4do ysaq ayy Ajay! $7)
(Lad) GE:SS:TZ 9¢-E0-ZZ07
H®5
poezl|esquasap sey) mau Sulyyewos Suop pue volyavip Jayaq e Ul 13}71M] SAOW OF SulAd] yOG YOM Sal YUL |
{L09) E@:7S:1Z 9Z-E0-ZzZ07
#85
AJOW ssnasip AjBUULAp $137
(La9) £T:€S:TZ 9Z-€0-ZZ0Z
125 2! pel! poe! pe!
‘AJOW SSNIS|P UBD /\ ‘dN JSS PJEH “SBJEYs SSe/D [ENP OU PUe ‘Auedwos JO %€ PUe ‘BOA aU peyY AjUO | Ing ‘spleMypeq pue pidnys Ajayajdwos sem 1Yysnoyy | yoy *qsL aJOLU Se NOA AUIPpe Mes PUP BSJBAE 4S] Jadns ysnl si pleog au SI UOSead U/W 343 4UIL|
(LOD) ES:TS'TZ 9Z-€0-27207
ere Ee
SINUIW e JO} UE ING JauUIp OF [NO peay 01 1Nog
(Lad) OS:8E: Te 9Z-E0-7z0z
4198S
23/E] 0] JuaWOW e BABY NOA og
(Ld) 65:VE:TZ 9Z-E0-ZZ07
HS
, BU JO} SEM }] SE PAY SE ‘SAea| 01 YOM 0} papaal | paploap | awh
yz Inoge s,1eu) ‘OU ples pueog ino pue ‘pseog ino Uo NOA Jad Od Jsepsey AW Ped | ‘Ut eu0a ISIANDE 34} Poy am UAYM y2eg “SAEM a]qesnseswiW! UI djay yap pjnod puke ‘aoueyodtu! $4) 483 “yon os aze9 NOA asnesaq “UEAp |]E SEM | JaYe 1 INOGE NOA YAIM [23 03 PSIUEM |,, POAC]
{L09) ZPOZ TZ 9Z-E0-220Z
a
“BW JO} Sem Ul SE PJEY SE ‘aARs| OF 410M OF pspssu | pap|jap | BWI SUL INOge Sey! “OU ples pyeog sno pue ‘pjeoq ino uo noA ag oO} Jsapsey AW pals | ‘UL |WOD ISIAQIe aU] pey am Uday xorg “Shem aigesnseawuu! Ul djay Jap pjnod pue ‘aquepyodwi
11193 ‘yan os aue2 noA asnezaq “Iea/> |/2 SEM | Jaze P ynoge NOA ULIM ¥/22.02 pa]UeM |
(109) EZ: €0: LZ 9Z-E0-Zz02
aaa
07 B|ge We | J! jal 0} 4}! P|
(105) #Z:10:Te 9Z-€0-2z0z
“UIs JEUISLIO ay] Sem Jey, “Aued Wiad 2 Uaag JaAau AAEY Pinoys y| "JOIQjO1d e se PSLE}S JOM] “SaHEIS| UW ANG XI} PUB YOM
sIUL Op 07 puayU! | “Auedwos Jo 3no Ajayajdivaa vay} pue Ab|A| pil prog 18341} dUy JO LU,]
(105) SE:O0'TZ 9Z-£0-cz0z
WILNSCISNOD ATHSIH
Page 87
aS |: 2°:
0.2/2 I 105200
437M) CULE ueging uosy HS . 2; ER 22000 sere
|S
) 4185 === | Jaujdog seiyjeW |
JojAeL yeig
Jaujdog seiyjell
ee Pe eo
1 01213200
JojAel 3eig
AOQWON JeQIML PYLE
Jom SulyjAue ayew ||! Ing adoung u! Wi! - ay aney NOA UaYyM JeUD e aAeY 0] WEE AW,|- Seed pue yaig O} payer BA,NOA MOUY - AOBWOU JAM] JO TIEYS BYYEIA) WW] ‘ugly ABH
{LOD) 75°65:9T O£-E0-cz07
Jaujdod selyjer|
“UNJ 3q [JIM “3/G2Op S| “Snoues Ww, |
(LOD) 8E:€0:ST O£-£0-Z202
dS
Pap! dunsaie}u|
(La9) ZU:BS:7T OF-EO-Z707
Jaujdoq seiyiey|
‘AOBNOWSP OF UONNGLIUOD JES Bag PINoM "yoaads aauj Jo Wojeyd anu 2 Ysijqeyse puy “NOA Joy 4 UN ayy en Ang noA 3,uOp AY
(LOD) LE-vStyT OF-EO-Z20Z
SeIed
ésAep Jo ajdnos }xeu Sy Ul Ess Aeg au} Ul }8SW OL age ale NOA UaYyM MOLY SN Ja] NOA UeD jUGOS FUNeSW O} PBNUJ 4007
(LQ3) 9Z:2Z:TT OF-E0-ZZ0Z
ues
gABUOW JO SJUNoWe agny arey ay se0q
(La3) Zev2:TZ 62-£0-2Z02
AOQHWON JavImy EYL
(1 aaey noA Jey | SE 3]qUOU 00} JOU plAoa adoy osje) adoung ul Ww] - aw BAeY MOA USM Jey B SABY OF uaay - Seted pue 1asg 0} pay[e} 3A,NOA MoU --AOSWOU Jey] JO JIEYS EYWe|! W,| ‘Uoly AayH
(LOD) OO-EE:TT 6Z-E0-ZZ0Z
a ED SVee IM a : 2s sve
"JBUaIS UO Say pu ee - $] JAQUUNU SY ‘WONSAJIp JeUI Ul LOya
juiof ajqissod e ynoge WIY YIM WEL OL JUEM NOA J] “PJM BY} JO} Ja}8q }1 BUew Woy) pue y Sulseypind ul payseaqul Ajjequajod uaaq ayyan 2 Joy sey (6rrbsqspSZqS=uUse/peny-UeLWyveq -wes/a|yold/Woa'saquosmmm//:sd314) PAL 4-UELUYUEg Les Joqe0qe|/O2 AL Ing “pulLU ANOA UO 5,JEYM 5] SIU} JI BINS JOU LW,| 'Yaaads al) PUB JAM] INOge Je}IMy UO |jod INCA Mes | - AaH
(LOD) TZ:ZT:80 6Z-E0-CZ0Z
seued
Jeo Suusaursua joyidoyny bse) e SulysiuL 3sny,, pax
al
(LqD) 65:20:72 £2-E0-7207
18S
\/29 ZusauiZua Jojidoiny ejsay © Sulysiuy isn
(1a3) £2:20:7@ £e-€0-220e
snoger 4a
*JeaDIML Ang pue-' ysaads aad x9eq Bujig 0} Binquayny Aep-aye| 2 Joy SWI, gUMOP BuIas Wed’ 31H
(Ld3) E¥:6Z:TZ L£7-E0-ZZ0Z
CE i:
« BUD|[E} OF PIEMIOY HOOT {S4JOM JEUL, PAN
(103) SE:@Z:ST £2-£0-2202
“BULy|E} 0} PIEAUOJ YOO] [SYLOM JEL
(La3) £2°22:ST £Z-£0-2Z202
He5
28 punose WYsIUO} Sdeulad
(LOD) OS:EZ:ST £2-£0-ZZ0Z
gese4
Seieg--a|gixal Jadns wW,| - SOM SWI] JEYM MOUY Sw JB] ASeAld “4/2} 02 BAC] PINOM
(LOD) 8Z:6T:ST £2-€0-ZZ0Z
8S
(Jeaid spunos wids no NoA yDouy Wer} — Jeay 0} AOS, pax
(LGD) pZ:ST:ST /2-€0-Zz0z
75
jeei8 spunos widy “Ino NOA ¥D0Uy Wed I — Jeay 02 AOS
(Ld3) 8T-ST:ST £2-£0-Z707
rei JS ——aes | gee =] 2011: a 2COUON
J3qUML eye ueqing uoz3
_iias: —— | JOJAB| Ja4g
=:
7JEYD 0} BAO! PINON ‘AlJBJIP paysuuod aq 0} Wea - UO}3 Ad}
(LO9) v2:7T:ST £2-£0-27207
es
Jayyeam ay) Japun amyl] 2 we Os ‘pIAoD Jo aseo Jou e aney | suds aqAeW —y1OM Pino AYSIU} 13127
(L093) ST:pT:ST £2Z-E0-Z2202
WILNSCIFNOS AIHDIK
Page 88
Jo|Ael Jag JO|ABL Ja4g
Jo|AeL 29g
1°
JojAel Jag
ae $25 zs 021 3c I 20500
Jay | PYLE uequng uosy
eS JojAe, 3249 JBM CYLIEW
JojAel aig
a=] 12S 320 = 0112: “0 WON
JBTWM eyUeW ueging wos
) 38S
Ajaqenud jaa ued am aoe|d & uo Sujoyy “asor ues u WdoE9 Je pue] OF 4Y8I13 AW peaoty Aljnjssa2ons 10
(L09) €¢:ZT:80 TE-E0-2c02
i SLs
BUI} [Bad Ul paysod y0g NoA daay jJ/MNOA Jeu J8ULIp BABY LED BM Os asOy UES Ul BuIpUe} pure Jal|429 Su/pue] UO BUDIOM)
(109) 6€:72:40 TE-E0-207
7 -oreL =
SWIULSW oY} Ul Jal|Jes PUe, OI DAN Wo IYsIy AW dn sAoW! ued | 41 aes 0] ZunjJOM we | gelayMawos WdgE6 Je JeawW UeD aM Sdeyad ‘udoE:g ye PUELYEO Ul PUel |
(109) 8z:S0°40 TE-E0-2z0e
or
JOM SINOY OT SSO} ul Bw] Aue ByBW WED |
(105) S€:00:40 TE-£0-2z02
Aepol|
(109) €2:0%:90 TE-€0-Zc07
GAPpII4 JO Aepsinyy ueaw nod op ,MoOWO}, Ag
(LOD) T#:BE:90 TE-E0-7202
HPS
{HIB} 0} JL91D “BLWOI|aM SOW 3J,NOA
(103) 9$S:7t£0 TE-E0-7Z07
ADQWON JayIM| EYVE|
iam daays - 0) 42} UI 75 Uno ayo INCA UL OYM moUy SN 39) S| - UOPy Bully B42 JO} YON AsyUeYL
(109) ES:ZZ°€0 TE-E0-Z207
HEIs e SACUL
(103) 82:02:10 TE-£0-2z07
“SINOY OT 3SOuy Ul euUyAUe Jaa WED | Os “sjqixaly Jue s#unaaw esa) A) 4UsjUpIW punoJe Wedsp pue wdz puNoJe MO1IOWWO} aso UES Ul PUE| |
(a3) 96:60:00 Te-E0-2207
ans
(Lad) SE:vT:Ez O£-€0-220
ADHWON JaDIML BYLE
NOA Suljyesw O} PJEMIOJ Suljoo} (1Sdq WET) 13D Weot NoAAR ||| NoA Up yO 4
(103) 8PE0:TZ O£-E0-ZzZ07
IPISWIEI [ILM
auinbay pjnom ng ajqissod aqAew si qgT-85.~ Op pjnod | qg-Es~ Ase@ aq pInOM GE-TS..., =PIES By Pue aynqljUOD [druid WU! Pinos ay yon moy Inoge payse| "GOES 02 7eY1 duung (sanjea paleys yim) saadojdwia Apea siy pue ‘grZS YUOM S,3H (,09NY,, SUlEp noA Moy uo spuadaq
a DISV2EIN [IM] @punoie eq p,nod 4) yam IxXAU UNSNYy Ysin Yai | Puy “Aj/ewuou Seweyeg ay Ul paseqsaH| (109) AO‘9E:/T OF-€0-CZ0Z
IDISWOEIAL [ILM unsny| (L09) OF PEZT OF-E0-2202 UI NOA Jaw 02 UMOP aq P,ay ples ay PU payse | Esp! at SSNISIP Oj paqsasaqu! alam NoA 4
IPISWIEIAL TILA ,aupueuly) (109) OP EE:ZT OF-ED-2Z07
a 011 32/2 I 109U0N JeluM] BYE ueging uoBy
“WEE. [UN dn Aljensn wW,| 2SJOM Swuiy /e1}US> YsIUG] Bye] ||e9 e sdeylsd ‘pood spunos
(103) vE:80°ZT O&-€0-2Z07
WLLNAGIANOD ATHSIH
Page 89
HEYSVSEIAL IIL,
Ej TEISVS2 IA ILM HS JojAel eg
|
JojAe, Jag
Js
JojAe| Jag
JojAe] alg JojAej Jalg
Has JOJAbL 39419
1s
JojAel 331g
7s
JoOjAe] ya4g
Js
JojAe| Jag
|
JojAel jasg
IPISWSEIA TIL
[Ja OF AVIUeUINY Jo aunyn, wWa}-SUO| ayy Buyew 0} payesipap Aya, jos yonw AreA
(LD) 85:9@:TZ TE-E0-7Z07
rs 512s
AWIY JO} YINOA No,
(LaD) ZS"p2:T2 TE-E0-7z0z
sojAe 1 Jalg
SoA Aj[esiseg
(LOD) ST-OT-TZ TE-E0-Zz07
) 18S
yas alaow a1ydAjes0de-3sod e& ay! Spunos
(LGD) 95:60:Tz TE-E0-7z0e
JOJABL Jaug
Jaw am Jaye ssaulsng Su|sa}e9 EB LE\s 0} UCM 3M BSe3 Ul S¥dN41 PSUOPUege Puy
(L9) €f:S0:1Z TE-EO-Zz0z
A195
"SUILU GT INOge ul aJeu) “Aem AW UO
(Lad) ZeZO'TZ TE-E0-ZZ0Z
HPS
(j3,USe0p OM) SA@XUOP PUL SIOEFJ} BAO] NOA SYUIYI WYYWOR|e S,quqsy agael
(109) ZT-ZO0:T2 TE-€0-Zz0z
H8S
ALUOSAME EYEH
(L039) 92:LO:Tz TE-£0-2Z02
JojAel Jag
fd sASyuOp pue SioyeJ] Sie asay} pue Vode ayy Jeau quaule Ue 10) Supjoo| auam Aayy yUIYy | “Auased Suneaw e pey aa, e2e]d Jsepsam Sy} JOY SUM SIYL
(LGD) 80:TO:TZ TE-£0-ZZ07
dojAel aig
BWWIUEAW 34} UI dn yoqeo Wed | pue SeleY PUe S19L]} Jed NOA JoADUSYM els URED aM OS suluaAa [Je Fa4y 3Ng Jales Suipue] $1 auejd Aw asnesaq Aiea yg e aq 0} Sulos We | ‘paod spunos
(103) TO:0€-6T TE-£0-2Z02
—
“Jaljiee JO) Auz | [IM 3g “OE:Z Ag aay} 383 01 age aq Ajuo WYAIA] “SW JEY) 0} BsO|D Ajqeqoid
(LO3) 61:82:61 TE-E0-27202
JO|AE] Jag GUg|Z NOA Joy ¥JOM wWdy SA0g) (LOD) L7-Zz-6T TE-EO-C707 1ojAe | 3219 al sissalppeeul| (L3) 90:22:61 Te-E0-Zz0z 49S asimayt] (La) Ly:6T-6T TE-E£0-Z70z
yas SUJUOW Maj E JO} JUBIsIsse OU BuIAeY AJ) 0} pepioap | pue Aqeg e pey uyar (LOD) Tei6T-6T TE-€0-Z2202 [PYSWOEIA) IILAA 21X93] BIA OM] NOA OF]U! 0} BLU By!) NOA Pino”, (L059) S#:ST-6T TE-£0-2202
jUOSiad Ul YyI]O0q NOA aas 03 Pa}i9xy “AW 304 5>J0/y,
(LOD) Zv-OS:ZT TE-EO-27072
) 40[Ae 1 Josg
“HONMESISAUO2 INO O} PJEMIOJ BUNYOO] “‘punose sduiyy saqw 01 JUBM 10 SUa9U09 AUe BABY NOA JO J8Y}9 J! MOU} BW 87 “SI11S1F0] UO UYay 0} 4NO pares SJUPSISSE ING “SSOP UES eau adUApIsal ayeALId e ye Wid/ FUJULYUOS 312 aM ay] SPUNOS 7
(Lad) ZS:SZ:ZT TE-E0-ZZ0Z
[IPISWOEIAN [LAA
24X83} EIA OM} NOA O4ZU! 0} BL ay!] NOA PINON
(LOD) SE:9p:9T TE-E0-7202
4S
‘ajdoad Juasouu! Aupw os Leos Aauy pue adualadxe Jasn aj} Uo WYsI|q JOfew e $3] ‘Paysnsd 9d oO} spasau Ajjead Jem, UO weds ojd/up
(L093) 6vEZ:ST TE-E0-2z07
HAS
poo3 spunos
(Lad) 8Z:67:2T TE-£0-27207
Page 90
eT Ja}YML PYLEW =z | |JBussig paver
JeHIM1 IE 39 5] OYM NOA YIM Yanoj Ul Yaspy Ueas Ind oj duos wi] - pares ry - sly} ajenaidde - uojy syueyL
(LdD) OF: ST:ZT E0-vO-ZZ07
fee
ee Jor, Cyne ‘ I 642118 poser
H°S
*pieog JSVUML ayy ULOf Alngadoy 0} aw 494 Moj]e 0} BuOP aq 0} YsoMaded JueyoOduI S| |18Y3 ‘paler
(LGD) SZ:Z1:2T €0-vO-Zz07
EE | 2: a ©0588 JUL eYveN |4P-s paver
“(POO Ajwey Aw suns) pazer YM (AOD/WON J3yM1) BYVeIW dun sauUOD
(103) ST:9T-ZT €0-v0-Z707
gAepo} aw} Auewsa5 wdoT pue wid uaamiag SluITaLOs 4/2} pj|NoI—1S3 UO WwW]
(109) $Z:T+#:60 Z0-70-Z2Z02
*AURWIS5 Ul W,| @ABPOL JaLe] 4je1 WED aM aqAe/y
(L093) 95:9€:22 TO-pO-2z0z
i!H
(109) O@:ZS:0Z TO-vO-2Z07
jJansuaym (SaU14y} Ja4.0 10) JAYIML Jnoge yeyd 0} Addey—uojy NGA yaa) 0} JeB15
(109) 9¥:SE:ZT TO-vO-2z072
IDISWIE TAT AA
TOBOSSS0ZERVOSERSDT/SNIEIS/PUTYaINA NY /LuossaIMG //:sd4y
(LOD) ZEveTL TO-v0-Zz02
J PISWOELA THAN
TAPIUBLUNY JO Binjnj ay} sAcIdWI 0} 188A SIY} ATS-IOOTS Sulnow - 32am) YoUNe| (SAeUOJU! Stow) jene ay1sajay puy
(LOD) TEP: TO-vO-2z0z
JWASWOELAL TILA
Dze2eb0 EQSXEbINSSIAbO=VS07Z=SeOPPLTZZ2pTSPyZG6OST/snye1s/punjemnynpaqy/wos vary //:scdy
(LOD) Ttve TT To-70-Z202
HPISWIPIN [LAA
2H S4]| JUBIW NOA WYsNoy | - Yo Fu/siApe wW,| YIIYM ‘puny aanjny ayy ‘UORepUNOY sly WOs) eam} IST Idy ayi sssay “Wes sy [aaj e jad oy JueMm noA sed ul puy
(103) 60:7b:TT TO-70-Zz02
i paAolua Ajjeay “suosead a[diq)nw Joy ajqeiowa|\)
(103) OZSS:TO To-rO-cz0z
BYeY syoog AOWaW ay} Jol auo Ajayuyeq
(103) ZS?80:TO TO-bO-Z2202
40|ABL J34q
SIUBIQUIE 34) 0} pappe Suajdor|ay aaueE||larns UeldoysAp pure sAsxUOp AY, ‘qeold Aljzay
(Ld9) 6£:87:00 TO-70-ZZ0z
(: JBULIP JeaID
(LD) 82:27:00 TO-70-7z0Z
>: svoen im
40
(LdD) €Z:E€:00 To-vO-2z0z
ITPISWIE IAT LAA
le CSCSC
(peaisul adessatu! pasn ‘yom 3,usaop |eusis)
(109) OP:ZE°TZ TE-EN-Zz0z
WPISWIEIN [IAN
jUOIeSJaAuOI poo e aAeY P,NOA yUIUT | OS “JAM, BuIANg pue ‘jam OF Sinyny uNJ-Bug] Avan ayy Sunjew ‘sawed u! sysalequ! aAey yO NOA “UO|y PUR Wes ‘YIOq NOA SuIsnposu! £,as8y ‘ABH
(103) SO:ZE:TZ TE-E0-Zz0z
JEUSIS Asn [IAA LEO
(103) ST:42-Te TE-€0-ZZ207
Buns Ua} 4O
(109) 9@:9Z:T TE-E0-ZZ0z
TWLLNSCIANOS ATHSIH
Page 91
77S 20.1352
Pe
JO|ABL 121g
Hes
JO[ABY Ja1g
HS Be1ed
JaTUM, EyLE \ a |2U21q Paer
Te
EE |:
Zd|GEIIEAE NOA ase Aa}
(LOD) ZE6%:B0 vO-PO-ZZ0z
— 2 255065 20;
j Aigeluap ajqisnejd JueMm Ajay!) Pseog ay3 uO
sala) 843 - plnays Ady. ing a1ay] UO Sulo8 sjeqes 3/3!) pue suorsizap diysiosuas ayy yo yoda, Aue 38540 Sunadai |[nj JF wavs j,Usaop pieag ay] NOAJaq)| “YW sdUaNyU! oO] Bjqe a1,NoA adoy “eeu SulAeS sue ASU] ,,UPW JOOP yIeg,, “SWOSSME - JaQIM! Ul 3235 BU] Bas 0} Pali9xy
(09) £€SS:20 pO-vO-ZZ0Z
if #807
(LOD) SP:4E:40 PO-po-Zz0z
‘uonsaddns AW UM snoles sem | ¢ pelold Jeyi Ulof Pinoys am Jayjyam ssnasip am [[eYS G|uolnsaxa IseJ jISeAU! JaNIM | ayy 0} sJesBUCD
(103) 90:42:90 7O-r0-ZZ02
, suluaddey ae SsulY] poos pPseay |,, pax
(109) 00:22:22 €0-vO-Zz07z
ED 2 2s RR 212 se- 207 ULYUS) Ua] [ar UUs) Wey a 228) h00 see ) 25 s2ujdog seen ypel yoe! Tes JS yaef yoel yoef yaef
Bujuaddey aie ssuiyy pood pieay |
(L03) 67'02:8T €0-70-Z202
EE) (25
WINOA UUM BUPOM 0} PJEMIO4 JULYOO|
puy “dunjeads 07 piemios Suyoo7 “Aqjods aq Aew uondases AW SJayMm Led Ajuo ayy Ss] JeLy PUE OM AW UUM ayy B YL} 01 SulUue| “ajqeilene ale NOA UaYyM 1xXa_ ‘“Aep |e Bady We |,, PaxN
(LOD) ZO:SS'7T E0-P0-ZZ0Z
]NDA YLIM FulyJOM 0] PJEMIO) 8u1joo) puly ‘durjeads oj puemsoy Suryoo “Ayjods aq AewW Uoljdased AW a1ayM Led A[uo aly 51 JEY] PUE SyIM AW YUM BHLY & BE] 0} SUUVE]Y “alqeyleAe ave NOA UaYM 3x2! “AEP |]P Bay We |
(LdD) TSTS:¥T £0-PO-Ze0z
) Has
*MOJIOWO}
AWITAUE 9/2} 0} B3.y JN ‘UIASNY OF Ul]Jag Wo JO Bye] 0} jNOge Jsn/ WwW] ~poos spunos
(LO) 90:TS:bT €0-70-2Z02
) ses
j7@213 spunos
(Ld) 8Z:SE'vT £0-v0-¢707
*LONeSJaAUOl JIgnd ay) pue JeyIML sAoiduu! Oj ajqissod se Ajanqzajja se awl} InoA asn 02 SAeM SUIPUY PUE Ajaso[) BuNjJOM 07 PJEMIOJ YOO) Pue AuUNLodda auj Jnoge payioxa Jadns w,| “Apease Jeg pue YEW Wo. paeay noA Padxe |
(109) 6vE2:PT EO-PO-7z0z
os) Tee
a/qIXIy — 1YSIy & UO Jes 0} Jnoge ase NOA ay) SPUNDS “MOsIOWO} JO APO} 4/22 07 SLU] SAEY NOA UAYM MOLY BW Jaq “eYWe| 0} ayods ysnr
(Ld) #P:S0:ET £0-v0-ZZ0z
ans
(L093) Fret 2 £0-PO-Z2202
2201, 0. I 42418 ave
i er
pausiuy ysn[ am pseog au3 APjas 01 S4I| p,|
(LD) ZO:8r-EL EO-vO-ZC0z
ES 2 >: ES |) oe JVM. CULE ) euse puer
AOHWON JayIM, ByLey|
ESUIL G 10} JEYD O} a[QeIIEAe NOA ale - UO
(LOD) Te:Lv:ZT EO-PO-Ze0Z
Ts a) o5eoN JaTUML eye er’ |JE4DI1g PSser
es 2s Jaq, EYLEW
|!242419 pauer
ADHWON JAHN PYLE
7
(103) 9T:02:2T €0-70-cz0z
75h 8 FF
Wod-UoIssaoxa@palel 2|IBWa AW 0} SIOp Su puas JO SwJAUe ||e9 WI aAeY ses] Pood spunos
(103) #T:6T:2T EO-v0-220Z
TWILNAGISNOS ATHSIH
Page 92
ED 2: 2,000 senpew nn fem
Jam eye ‘| [}eusig paler
se5 ) AogWON JaTUM | eYPEN ) eupig paler
HS
ains
(109) SO:7S:TT pO-PO-2707
4185S
“Wey PUNOJE Ulieg WO) paaLwe | {pal|29 Jeg UaYM dn axyom ysl | ‘Awos
(10D) LEES°TL #O-vO-Zz0z
#85
sn 10 Ujoq 0} puas UEI NO,
(103) TO:ES'TT PO-PO-Zz0z
Es ) ADQWON JBLUM | CYLEIA | eyssig peer
ES | (2s RE 22:00 sempew | Ce
daujdog SeIuyel 2S EE 85 vay
AQHWON JAVIML EYLIEL]
noA yUeYL “Sinoy Jo ajdnoa yXsuU Ul SUOD SIyr Jad 0} uaay Aljea. 31am -as5]a BUDSWOS O} OF PINOYS J MOUY al J2] “YOOPapUN |xYEysA|Is PUE UOFe Se BwWeS SY} Sq | [IM 1) éNOA 0} passnasip Aa || Aspuers ay} puas pjnous | NOA Sj Bulwnsse w,| ‘palef- Aepo} Apjainb A gugye sty) aaow UBD aM aaITe NOA JeY3 Jag WOY JEaY 0} JeAD “"ULO}sS B syiNb oy. dn ayom nod - uola SuUILIOW
(103) SS:OF TT pO-vO-ZZ0T
Jaujdog seyjel
é Suay} Woy 11 aye] pue Aepsaupayy Jo uaa yeads am jJ]eYS “yaem E JO} MOLIOWO} [WeIW OF BujOd We |
(LOD) 9Z:6T:TT vO-vO-ZZ0z
yey 03 Addey ‘ains
(Ld) ZS:ST TT 70-vO-Zz0z
aij 2 9A07,, Pen
(109) 62:ST:TT ¥O-PO-Zz0z
ES 2: EE 2275205 207
[8s ) Weysaig paler 2S GE) j:euo1a peer H8S ueging uos3 425 veg 48S ueqing wod3
11° 201061 3920
ai MULGelUAp ajqisnejd jueM Ajay!| Pieog 8y3 UO Sess]
aU} - pjnoys AaYY jng Bay2 UO BUIOT 5/eqed 3/141) PUB sUOIsIDap diysiosuad aj 40 Yodai Aue aes Jo Sumiodal |Jnj a3 wana 3,UsdOp Pyeog ayy NOA Jaq | ~} aavaN|jul 0 alge a,NOA ado} “eeu SuiAes ase Aayy Ue Oop y2eg, “ewuOsaMe - JSYIM Ul a215 34] Bas 0} PSUIXG,, P=
(La9) €Z:ST:TT v0-p0-ZZ07
) Weysuig pases
4o
(103) 7S:TO-TT vO-rO-cz0z
H8S
SUlfy BLY NOge EYL) OF ¥/E7 Bsealq
(109) S2:TO:TT vO-vO-2202
ueging uosy
Vv
(LOS) TT:6S:0T vO-vO-Zz0z
485
“WEY 72 UjJag WO} O05 ‘e2yey dn Sly syoOM (£9 SIH "Joug 0} ayods snr
(103) 05:85:0T vO-70-ZZ07
ueqing uosg
YN 01 SUlAly 3 DWIAUE ]Je9 SJUBWOWW Mal e BAeY NOA 4! - IH
(LOD) 8#:9%:60 7O-vO-C707
JojAe| Jaug
yoeq ale noA uayM dese |[eD “SUOMEIIUNWLWOS UD a}euIpsa03 0} dese yeads 02 ay] PINOM “Burj Das BY} UaAIS,
(L093) 70:01:60 70-r0-2202
ad Aq siaqsey| OJEI9 ¥
(La9) £T:80°60 70-70-2202
JUaWSIJOJUa [ENIDE JO JA BY} Bq 0} MaIA [eaIYOd//esnyjnd Aanes e sey OUM BuOaLUOS BAeY Ing Ajea spiepuejs ay} Ino Ae] osje pjnom | (7241 10} dn a4,nOA wi yasuly ssog ayy Ayjeiadsa) yeuy ayeSAeU 0} Moy PUe JapIm, Uo seq SiaTUIM IYBY Buys] Jo awed ayedyap eB aq [| 3
(109) ZE:20°60 PO-70-2Z07
J Uidaq ajyeq ayy
337 Jem 23g [jim 3] “AS€2 ag 1OU PM I3Ng, SuwoNeidag 7 dalg syalysan|g auy Jo snpox3 :¢ days usiedwes ainssaid payeulplo003 “z days siasn si! JO} Wo ped ayy awelg -T days cuaddey 3ygiw Jey] SAUIY3 ayy JO awios Ino ZuIAE] semU> sate saoge ay jisucije|nyeszu05
(Ld) O€:ZS:80 vO-70-ZZ0Z
TWILNSGISNO3D ATHDIF
Page 93
¢o>
uegoy aor
uesoy aor
JojAe) yosg AOL)WON) JOTUML PYLE)
js Oem
SPIE
“JEYD 0} A|GeIEAe W,| “Wes INOA U! JUsUIaaIZe parepdn ue aney Pinoys NoA
(LOD) O€:ZT:TZ pO-PO-2202
JojAe | 21g
Opa
| ScAuZMELUO} MID=1HOl=se Le locPLLPOce pooULS L/snieis/UeYisuny/ui0s JeTM4/7-sGRy
(LOD) Ov-6T:02 PO-70-Zz0z
BAY
}! BBS 0} Sag] ‘YSNOU} aAow Big "MOU | MOUY | [07
(109) £O°9€:8T vO-v0-ZZ02
) Has
MO||O} 0} BS00U9 JOU Aew Jo Aew Asyz YOIYyM ‘ad1Ape ping {IM |
(LOD) EZ:E¢:9T vO-vO-ZZ02
[a 0350 507
ggow Addey diysiosuas ayy Woy Jam ayesaql| 0} Surod nod auy
(LOD) 05:9€:9T vO-vO-2Z0Z
uo|y “euniny ay} u! asueYyd ABwi SIU] Jaquiew pieog aarsaye ue Suraq wo aw JusAaid pjnom sjuSUnWLweS Bun quand Au 30 I SUNUIYA Jaye “Ing ‘pseog JayIML dy) JO Sw Suapisuos JOY NoA yueYL
(LD) Te: TS:ST O-vO-Ce0e
| $188
AUIIGe UA BABY 3OU OP |
(109) 9T:Z¥ST vO-PO-Zz07
ajay
jO| Mou jlef s6y}1M| JO INO sn ysnq NOA ued aS
(LOD) #e:6E:ST vO-7O-ZZ07
Zaeg
|
, BUOP 5,JEY} SE UOOS Se J]29 |] “paler uM auoyd ay} Uo YsN/,, paxN
(109) S#TT:ST p0-vO-Zz0Z
a 2s
“AUOp S,JEY] SE UOOS Se |JED || ‘peser yim auoyd ay} Uo 4snyp
(109) 62:90:ST 7O-70-Zz07
JUSWOW eB BABY NOA UAYM al [/E9 Bseald “|Nydjay AlaA aq ||IM JeUL
(109) SPEO'ST PO-PO-ZZ0z
24M} P/NOA 41 4/21 02 Addey
(L093) #¥:62-HT #O-7O-ZZ0z
— a:
48S
ains
(103) €€PT-vT pO-v0-ZZ0z
gSaNUILW aA SAeY NOA Og
(103) 7Z:ET-bT O-vO-ZzZ07
a 2: TD 12002
AQQWON JaVIM) eye
UONesJaAU0S Jno4 sad se Ajyoinb auop siyi 38d O} uaay A-qUaWeedFe Jues WIYUOD Oo} YIOg NOA SurAdo> ysnp
(103) 8E°9P:ZT O-vO-ZZ07
) AogWON [jeyssig paler
AOHWON JEM) EYE
yaeq paled alow ana Ing $,UO3q Se aes [IEW Aq SU08 sje - SI} Ja}
(109) 6E:Z2T pO-PO-Zz0z
JOIN, PYLE Jeysiig paler
) AoQWON I cswon JSTIML EUVE
<oop'77202 + |udy yeud -Juawaasy uoneJsdoo5 J8]3)m1 - JUBLUNIOp"|WAUIssazqsdplomjUSWNIOpAaalS -S] ELUJOy/LUXUedo"pUA/UONes|dde -Juawyseny>
(LOD) BEZeT PO-vO-ZZ0z
7 ccc ay yes
*sayIM, Ang pue “QIH,, PRAM
“
yaaads saiy y9eq Fulg o1 Bunquayinyg Aep-sJaye] 2410) aw) guMOp duljijas ule,
(Ld9) TS:vOZT PO-pO-zZzZ0z
JaRIML EYLEW JEYDJIg PREF
) Aogwon | JAQQWON JaHIM EYE
(109) E:00'ZT vO-vO-ZZ0Z
(LdD) 92:00:2T po-vO-2202
‘= ies | 4yas )aogwon Has J3}IML EUV ) e4sitg Per Mes )AoQwON Has JaTUML EYLEA \Jeyazig payer
jJeuwa Jo We
(La) 90:00°2ZT 70-70-2202
J8}UM EYLEW | __— ie Polen
=. a | ROS WON EE OSWON en eer
BIDUM MOU BWW 4a] $[d “ewe Aq 4) éqUas Wf ay!| NOA pjnam Moy Sje7 “Alessadau salsojode on
(LD) LS°Z4S° TT vO-v0-2207
TWILNSCISNOD ATHDIH
Page 94
ase! sel
3125 >> 2! 22!
J2TUML CULE IN D E4219 peer a] 3S oe yasg
Ss 01 32
2S
*payenaidde Anessa aq Pinom AeYL “Bulop Jou 10 SuWOp W,] quINp Fulyyawios 51 Jay 4! |ESOAJadns aq aseald
(LOD) 9T:6Z:£T SO-PO-2z0
49S
, Bqissod Ajjeuy sem z! pawes] | vay jeuoNoWwe Agana jog “aw Suo} & Jog 3) paluem 3A,) “siy) Sulop ai,nod saiddey 3q 7,upjnos | jSAem|y,, Pac]
(L103) OF:82:ZT SO-vO-2Z02
EH
“ajqissod Ajjeul) sem pi pauiea | Usym euo|jOWS Ajaa JO “SW Bug] e JOL 11 payveM aA,] "SIU Sulop 3J,noA Jaiddey aq 1,Upjnos | jsAem|y
(LOD) ES:OT-ZT SO-PO-2z0z
= ss
J UOMesIBAUCS qeaid ‘SHUeuL
(L053) 7Z:80:ZT S0-v0-ZZ02Z
ypel yaef
awinAue
(LOD) TT:82:ST SO-70-7e207Z
HPS
EA/ENUSpPlUos 3/2} 0} SWI} POos es} UaU/\,
(109) £S°42:ST S0-vO-ZZ02
juem nod SuryjAue YSno1yd 92} 0} aay SABMIy “A/G 1a} 5! preog ayy Jaauaua a[q|pasau! Ue s| Jeieg “AjasUaLULU|
(L093) 05:00:ST S0-70-Z20z
jasimay| (L03) 80:SS°ET SO-P0-2z0z “ayay awes ‘eypey| syUeYL| (L09) ZO-SS:ET SO-O-Zez0~ asimayxlq| (100) SetrS°EL SO-v0-2202
2188
[Inydjay aq ued | adoyY *AjeyNjosqy
(109) E£:ES-ET SO-PO-Zz207
wef ye!
Bod pal A4nrepa=as 1 c=Se LLOPOSELVESEGLELISL/SMels/yJel/Wios Jala //SCY
(103) £T:£0:80 SO-70-ZZ0z
yaef ye!
[Surujol 40} noA YUBUL
(La3) #T:40:80 SO-7O-ZZ0z
JO|AC1 aig
no payom siuy jnjyayelZ pue NoA YyIM 440M 0} payoxe WE |
(103) O%:95:40 SO-70-2202
48S
JaUML PYLE) |JPyQig paler
eS | -s 012:
) ACS WON | “CDWON JeqIm) eyTeW
“NOA Zuaaw O} PueMuOY OO] Ajjeas | “sueAMe| JO JadeueW pood e Jou wW,| ~Juawaesde IsJiJ ay} JO ding ay. ynoge asidojode | *pseog ay} Aujulol a4,noA paljuyy os wWL,|
(103) 90:25:40 SO-pO-Z207
GONG NANUESOGAINIXGS=P8TZ=5e SOSLSESESESGOZELTST/snqeqs/eseied/wos sayy //:sdqy
seled jpayoxeasadns| (109) 9€°T #40 S0-70-77202 joo) (L109) 60-O%:40 S0-v0-ZZ0z wse| (L109) 9T°S€:40 S0-v0-Z202
éAQUOYs No aUIpUaS
(103) 6T:TE:Z0 SO-O-ZZ0Z
poog spunos
(a3) 9:50:20 S0-r0-2z0z
jUO|Z BWODa/\ “Wa3-5ud}
AY} Ul JASUOIs sn SyxeW 0} ‘WOOo!pieog ay} Ul PUe “JAM UO paau am Jem Alexa SI YUM SdIAUSS SU} JO JUD asualU! pue JaAaljag S}euoIssed e yO S,ay ‘asja je BAOgY ~AUM *pseog Jno 0] anjea 12343 SUg p/NOM Sy JEU} BW O} 4ea/9 SUIEIaq 1 ‘syaaM USI! UW! UO|J YM suoijesiSAuoad USNoJY| jp4eog Jno o} ysnWUo|a® Suiuiodde o1,am Jey] ses Oo] paysxe WwW]
(109) OZ:8T:TO S0-vO-zz0z
Jae BW IED aseajd
(LOD) 22:25:22 7O-v0-2Z07Z
Je malAas Bulgua YeIeds e UO ASNI WwW,| ‘aINS
* w
(LD) ZS:TS'Zz vO-O-ZZ07
SEL DAOW 0} JOZea W,| ¢JYI O} SUILU Maj e SAL}
(La3) 6T:2b:22 tO-P0-ZZ0Z
.panolddy, paaoy| (10) 6S:Lv-2z vO-v0-7207
paaroiddy| (LOD) #2:S2:TZ vO-vO-ZZ02
womrg| (Lad) St-s7@:Tz vO-rO-zzo0z T SQAYZMYLUOY Ub=pgZOT=S2 LETEZPTLPOZEPSGOTST/Ssnieis/UueYydisun.a/Wwosdsnimy//:sdy,, 1e paysney]
T¥ILNSCISNO9 ATHDIH
Page 95
eS
, WELW U] pOod JOU WJ PUE Pip HEU} JYsNOYA JaAau |, Je paysne]
(19) T0:60:20 90-P0-ZZ02Z
BUN S|ABD 85
"Suo|e WED | BOjaq S22 ayl aq Pinoys Jeyy Wsnoyi Apealje dejeg Ing “Ja}Uad BY} O} BJOWW BAOW P|NOYs JayIML
(109) 8¥:80°40 90-0-Z70z
EE 205 27
UJewW UW) POOs Jou wW,| Pue ~* PIP i! TeYy7TYANOYI Java |
(10D) £T:80:20 90-v0-2z02
Hes
]O2{U09 91ND JOU 5! %G. ZUIUMQ
(109) €5:£0°20 90-7O-2202
#195
uonodoJd Jo Jno UMO|G Buijes Busy} sym] ajloum syL
(L053) $E:40:40 90-70-2207
8S
Bury a|Ae5
SuIWos S| YONG JIpa JaDIML
(La9) 6€:€0:40 90-70-2202
™ JUBWOW Buy Jo JeSy BUl
ul y2eq Bye} 07 UCM olde! BM WYs Aes ||e SM“ YU] BUT INOY PZ e YIM Sunes pa Jay Baw] |Sd Zee¢ OP 0} paau | Op Jey ~~ Acid JaIMY INOA YM Ayjelsadss jssmasip 0} yonW
OS aw UM UMOp Ys Jadod @ Op 0} 40) Apeal NOA auy (ays) BW! passiw NoA ane} [e134 ade
(109) 60:T2Z:S0 90-70-2z0z
ES : =: ES 5 2):0y vnsor
*WaL} 0}
NoA Banposu! pjnays | "WEY [}01} e OU Pue UOsJad jee, B ale Aauy 1ey} Aja pynos yy asn oF asoys a[doad yi “ul Sy “Ja}qIM 0} PAULI 0} BI!U Sq P|NOM TELA AIWUSp! SBYWSA FEY Wweisoid 2 aaey jalveg pue piaeq spuslyy AW “Jey, Jo Joumo Aquofew ae NOA Jeu} BAO] Suyany |
(LOD) ET:SE:TO 90-70-2702
slaJduaiyy 2)
“MOU 1,UPIP | INg ‘som ayy U Ajjenye sem Yf
(105) ZO°EZ:TO 90-70-2202
) Staaduaiuy es] staiduasuy BL]
“aing “SOM ayy Ul used Apeauye pey WU “YeBA YO jUps oy) Ay oO} Wayr 303 Apealje noA puy
(109) 60:62:00 90-r0-2z0z
) sleuduasy3 24)
Slasdualuy 2]
& [4eaoysnd e a4,no,
(109) 30:42:00 90-70-zz0z
siasduaiuyy ei]
“ulol au SAeY 03 pley Alea. paysnd Aayy jpseog Jay! au UO! 0} ]UEM BAe 1,UPIP | “EYEH
(109) ¥Z:92:00 90-PO-ZZ207
slaiduasyy 2] slasduasyz 24]
@ ifueH
jsdiy BOS NOA BAS UeD | PU YW] ‘SAaMILULWIOD dU JO AOD/WON 3tj3 Suiulof uo ueyd nod 4]
(109) 02:61:00 90-v0-2z07
3eleq| _ Ny 25
DIGTESINNZ DIDNZ
“SIT =TROL=5 0S PSLCPOLISLOSPITSL/smals/UEADEWuUanays/Wol JatiMi77-sany
(109) €0:0Z¢z SO-PO-7Z07
Aueuuwns poos Ayal
(Ld9) T0:0Z-ez SO-vO-Zz0z
yu MLE UL 9D2q BUIJED,, PEAT
(La3) vE'TO:TZ SO-v0-2Z0Z
SUILU Maye Ul 9eq dulyj/eD
(LGD) £2:TO:LzZ SO-r0-ZZ0Z
uoos ye) jSyJom dy
(109) OO:ZE°ZT SO-pO-Zz0z
1 OP [IM Jap 3ng NOA ISNA |, PEAT
{Ld9) 8T-SE:ZT SO-v0-CZ07
Jeyl Jaye swijAueO gawy yo wdy
(109) 6O:SE:ZT SO-pO-ZZ0Z
“g2Ua|OIA B}EIOApE Ajqoydxe yey} asou] pue syunoz3e Weds Jo! Jdaoxa ‘sueg JUaUeWWEd puImUN OF yeaid ag pinoy
(LOD) 2Z:vE5ZT SO-PO-ZZ07
CSW} JEUM “Yea,
(103) €0:VE:ZT SO-7O-720z
op jep ing noAysn4y |
(LOD) TI:ZELT SO-7O-Z70Z
2IYBIUO} Jaye] 12} 0} Say NOA aay FYDEP YIM UOesWeAUOD JeeId e pey 1snf
(L095) Z7:0ELT SO-0-7z07
TWLLNSGISNOD ATHSIH
Page 96
1s a 73
“qLuNp sse] ae suoisedsns AW Jeu} Os Wea} duaaulsua JayIM| By} Woly a1epdn ue a3 0} }ead Bq pynom 4
(LOD) 000% TT Z0-vO-2z07
ains| (109) SZ:6€:TT 40-v0-2Z02 TMGHOUIO} AT/IGE|[EAE AUP BABY NOA Op—Jxau yeads am UBYM s1OW JeBYy OF eAg| PINOM| (LOI) vE-ES‘OT LO-vO-Cc0e ‘sauozawiy| (109) €S°LS:0T 0-v0-cz07
JEqo|# ssoioe a.uepUaTe azIWIKeW O} SUIAL) “SewWI} JayJO Jsadsns Ved | asa —<egb capa UIWW Gp BJO} NOA JO} Jom yaam 1Xau JYDed ETT NYL/pam Jo Aue pinoy “sAemAue jenyIA 10} Suiziwiydo aq jj aM Os UOSsuad Ul aq |/IM adUaIpNe JO %ST-DT noge Ajuo pue Aejap e Jo 8uo| 00} SUISTED Si [API] AW ZAIENUIA Yaam Jxou saAo|dwe 104 eyb e Op oJ a[ge aq NoA Pino
Wod Jato) esejed
(109) 6T:8E:0T 40-70-Z702
é [ewe snoA s3e4mM ‘Nag
(109) Zp EEOT £0-P0-Zz0z
BUO]S BUO YUM SPliq OM} IND BAe} pjnod Jey? SiWy Inoge IWsnou] e eney |
(LD) Te-EE:0T L0-70-7Z0e
"SIU} URY} SAUO LORIE Jamo] Wana - LOReIO/dxa Jew! SILy puNoJe seap! Jo IsOY VY
(LOD) Tv262:0L £0-7O0-ZZ0z
BYEH
(109) 90:/S'ET 90-7O-zz02
pel yoel
(j002 o1d/u3 Bujjouwold) d=angAloys=jal ude ju=J9442JO¥SNWUO]Z/Wosyoogesey WwW //:sdyy ‘au84j3 Jano sedsep yo dwems ay} ul Junozle ,paljiian, & Sasa) 2>]| 54007
(105) TE:S#ET 90-PO-Z202
spel spel
PLOSLOOECSUSELLITSL/Sqess/ CLEAR NHEIN/WOD eq My //-SON4
(LOD) TE:SPET 90-70-ZZ0z
Jaujdog seiyiel,
EE :; RE 21 500 sexe
J0/pue japow ssauisng SUNSIXe ay] U| SIUBpIyUOd OU “Jel} SI aod Beyse yo
jeinjoOrus ou Jey DIE SN » ‘suUHeJadO puny oj uanNs ae ‘Bulag Suj3 ayy OJ pue Anpeays MoJ3 sanuanal pe SJaTIM] » :SSBUISNG 84} JO B}2}5 JUIN 89d S1EY4s BAOS” ('Z “WYYWOF}e JayjOUe Yad NOA spusjjo JEU} JU|IUOD JUEM 1,UOP PUe SYeYMOUS E 34,NOA JSS ‘SWIYOs/e Jo} asejdzaxsew eB ayesi2 WAY] » = “JUSTUOI SLUNSUOS PUe ysod of Squal|3 AUeW JO 9UD Sq PINOMJaWIML » § “(Sidy Wado YM BIg auleISq PUB PSHE}s JBM jS]O0I au). 0) y9eq) uado awosag pinoys Sid “aINJINIISeJU! paz! Ua.ap UO UNI IsNW pusyIeq ay yng ‘Asea JOU $j] “(Aygan|g “2'a) |oso}ONd yomyau [e1Das pazl|esjUazap e suidojanap
uo SUpJOM Usag aney 1243 Jam Je sjaloid Fuiysnd desy {may » uawadeuew
PU JUSWUaA0 YDIym Jo ssa/pseZai ‘LW43} SUo] Pelosuas aq IED JONIM JEU} JUELIEM JEL sainsesw Sunuawajdu Aq aaueysisal diysiosuaa aunsug e = INVLS|S3u-diysiosuas Jayim | aye :z dais (qT © “AydesZoudod jesaj! sod (¢) ‘AduUajola aJOWOI, (Z) ‘suas Weds JO weds puas 0}. a91AJas Ino asp) (T) 20) aaiZe suasn JAM ‘BUIMO}[OJ AY} OF (Saded Jo spaipuny MoU) SBaas jo sulla) Sulonpas Ayenpes Aq 3ayA-dIysiosues 3! BYE! °T days (eT ,yoeads aaly aajos ("Tt :uejd awe 4 Ayjenb oddns 0} pied pue payoddns-pe jo Uopeuiquios
2 0} [POW SsaLIsNg ay2 YLYs PUE IUSLUPLAWe sd} BY} JO Iids sya YM saljdwos Ayny
yeul seep! fo axed yaysew ado ue ‘yovads aay Jo auOqyIeq |EGO|E ay] JaIM| DEI |e # ‘aold S1eYs 1e]) Aq payayaJ se pe peap eS! |aPOW ssBUisnq JUS.INI aly (u) pue ‘Ades30WeSp aAas JOU Seop U (!) Ing ‘Pood Aeud SI Npold Bio2 ayy os <= ‘sajdiouud yaeeds aaj OF aJaype Jou seop 7! ey] Walgoid e sl y3ng ‘asenbs uo} 29nd Oe} ap als S13! “OND smeis #
(100) €0:0b:60 90-v0-ZZ02
BE 4: EE 20600 sere)
HaDIML Inge |jea Yoys y
(103) Ev-€Z60 90-70-7Z0Z
SOISNOD ATHOIR
Page 97
)31°S I e120
i} JOd NO,
(103) ZEOv-6T LO-v0-2Z207
“swia|qosd UdIsap JNpold/|esUYIa] SAjOS Buldjay Sao] | Ing “9UOAUe Jo ssoq a4) dq PjNoYs sucAue YUIY) 1,UOp epuny | “{YyNIs Jw Diop ayey | ‘Apyues4
(LOD) 8T:07:6T L0-70-ZZ07
*O} NOA OULD 0}. JBBU/FUa 1Saq BY} aq IYFIW OUM OAUOI JEL} Jaye MOLY ||| ‘01 123 am aseym aas s}a/ pue OFD JO Pesaysul JaaUITUA Ue ay!| BW Jea.9 - OAUOD }xeU JNO Ul
(109) 60:6E:6T LO-v0-Z202
©
(LOD) SE-8£:61 £0-vO-ZZ0Z
,, BWI] JUG] & 10) SSeqapoa Jno ul Uaag BAeY pue O1D Bq Ol pasn |,, paxyn
(LOD) SZ:8E:6T £0-70-2Z07Z
-ajdoad jo sadAy ya / seseueW Weigold YIM UeYy Sulwuewdod alodpsey op 0} a[ge sue OUM SIsauIsuUS YIM Jayjag Aem saeLequ! |
(L039) ST:8E:6T ZO-P0-ZZ07
*suonsanb nod jo AUB AUP JaMSUe LIED | OS
(103) £S:4€:6T £0-v0-2Z02
“SW BuO] & JOJ aseqapod Jno Ui! uaaq aAeY Pue OID Bq Oo} pasn|
(109) 2P:LE-6T £0-70-ZZ0Z
SIBBA OZ 4104 DEMOS AInp AAeay aj01M |
(L093) OS:9€:6T 40-70-2202
“suO|ysagans AW JO SsaUqUINp aly ayeqijes DW day [IM SIU, “ASEGapOd Ja}YML BU} JO S/IEJSp /EIIUYI97 BY] PUE}SIApUN O3 By!) PjNoM |
(109) ZESE:6T £O-70-ZZ202
“sapls YJOq UO UOMEWWJOJU! JSagU! 0} NOA 0} W/E] Wes} 8uq pue jonpolg AW sAey + "noA YUM ALI} YINW se puads 0} poos sn{ — aseyd siyj ul puy
(La3) 6%SEGT £0-O-Z702
“AYM PUY "JOU “SA UO SSasZ0Jd ByELU |], SAUD YDIYM NA |[A4 |],| PU - SEAP! SU ||e Jeay oO] Juem |
(103) 90:SE:6T £0-pO-2z0z
“Buizewe) (109) St-vE:6L £0-v0-2Z0Z WINWIXeW dg 0} JaIM, JUeM snl | psey coy Surysnd Ww, 4) WW] Ing ‘Seapl JO UO} e aney | jawosamy| (LOD) pT:E€:6T £0-pO-7Z07
‘puewuoy Aued WO BY} SUIAOW Ut! |NJdjal AJOA SI S14} YUILY | - APEUA QU! [OWN] aly sildsaq “UONsa1IpP aANIsod e Ul sh BAOW 03 BUIY] poo e yuIY) | pu - payadxa SISIYL SaA Puy "SOM EUM MOUY AW Jay - MOLOWO IyI9ed dogs Jaye ajqixar Ajje}O3 WwW]
(109) 6P:ZE6T LO-PO-Z70Z
jSUOMESIBAUDI JNO BAO} | ‘Puaysam SIY} SWIAUE Jo IYSIU MOLOWO} 4/2} UPD | "dn 2UAS 0} poos aq pjnom ‘yea, ‘pajzedxe sy
(Ld) BE:OE-ET L0-v0-Ez0e
(j}9e1J030]Ne UWEpP) swosame,,
(La9) €¢:6Z:6T L0-70-220Z
Apaas
(103) 60:62:6T £0-vO-7Z0Z
‘asuduns 2 S| siy} JO BUOU - 34! JNOge y/e} OF Adde} “aalje,Uasaids 3,Us! S14} OS ‘pieog ayy
uo Zulg nod ynoge payoxe si Jeu Aqofew quays ase] & si aay} yuruy | - /Ajno-saAo|dwa Jay \snw/ /0/70/Z7Z0Z/Ad0}OuUIeI/ Woo Jsoduopsuiysem Mmm //:sdyy :sadessaw YOE|s JEUIAIU Wl, Syea] 10 5}0) +Apeal|e payea) yy INoge AUedwwiod 0} jlewa AWW cos|y
(109) 20:82:61 40-70-2207
“Ld ETT Ny ua WIAIY 84} Puy “spea] Jonpold pue Bua jews YIM Ld ETT Pan OAUOD & LUYLIOS IM OS *}002 49
(103) OT:9Z:6T LO0-v0-Z7207
"SHJOM Ld TL SINYL ‘Alexa
(Ld) 8E-0F:8T LO-70-2202
Jeodd SOM pen UO Ld WETT
(LO) t¥:8E:8T 20-70-7702
de7gh ay} 1Oj yaam ]XSuU yJom 3yI9ed ETT ABPsIny] pinoy “sauojs
BIPSW WO, NOA Jnoge suoNduinsse axewW Jo pealsu! Ajedip yeads nod seay ysn! oj ajdoed 404 51 [BOS ‘AepsaysaA ples NOA Sy “UOSBad SLUOS JOJ NOA ay!) 3,UOp Al|esauad Pue panrjoau!
aJ@ Nod Jeu} Jasdn aie ouMm ajdosd Wo. swos osje yng — ~ asueyd aas 02 adoy noAIeUM
‘sn Yl Sdedus 02 4UeM 0} MOY ‘AjeuosIad ued NOA AYM ‘SuaeW YW AWM PUe JEQIML JO BuNyny ay} Noe aaaljaq NOAeyM puNnole sow Ing - yidap / seap! alyMads OJ! Jad Jou oO} suonsanb 4sow Josdxe | ‘pres Adu} - Eb Jo peaye UoljesuaAuOs Sua + Jonpoid e dn yas |jim- daa
(LOD) 60:0Z-CT LO-v0-770z
TH |LNACINOD ATHSIH
Page 98
)gles syuawAed| (109) 8€:S0°01 60-70-2207 SapNnyjoul PUB UIEYD920}q E UO Paseq SI ey} Papaeu si AUedtWOD elpaw je}I0s Mau B YUILP | ) IST) [EGLUID) [JAM SE SIY2 JO) Slay OP pjnod NOA 5}07 “pelea pue sulzewe {LdD) 9Z:€0:0T 60-70-7207 —————_— ISNA |EGUY aue siamod SUNOA Su} pue (YIN se Ody/UD Jou) Eqayy UO deap snp aA,| “BOW Wes] 02 BQ] P,| ) 3185] [seed | ) 8S “STEAL JOM] BYE} OF Jao ue syewW |M| (LGD) BT-EDOT 6O-”O-Zz0z
ES BeIEd ) 318 “Sly JO SISeM eS! SIU) "PILOG ByrSuwiol jou wW,|| (LGD) PO'EO:0T 6O-O-ZZ0Z
) HS Besed ) 31S £}289M Sy} auop Jez NoA pip yeym| (LGD) ¥ZZO:OT GO-PO-ZZOT
1°S Fee BEJEd "mou 1yBy asauy| (LOD) SE:TO‘OT 60-vO-2z0z
7,UaJe 3M {Ng ‘paDeJsip Jad 3,UOP PUE JUAl|Isel BIOL B/E SM S1SYM aop|d 2 07389 0) Auedwio3
au Sy]| p,| Pue - NOA qsnu7. 0} pue VeTM, Ul avaljag nod AyM pueyssepun Oo} ‘noA MOUY
01 303 aydoad dyay [fim WIN 243 adoy | “410M Op Oo} Aqyige no Sunny 2 Moy pue Mou 4Yysu UOIDEIISIP JEUSS7U! JO |BA3] BY] UO BANIadsJad NOA apiacid noA.o} 8%! p,| “Heads OM Bw xen “3x8 U09 JUBLIND ay} Ul Jaya Jay) ayew aw Suidjay you sj Jeyy MOA 4J93 0} Ayqisuodsal Aw $31 9Ng - JayUML Inoge asje BuiyzAue Jo ,@SUIAP JOIN | SL, BMY O} BS1y DUE NOA
aassew aq pinoasiyt| (109) O<Ez:E0 60-P0-Zz0z
STI! |EqUUIY|
"PNoja Sy} Ul SSeqelep ay} passasse Jey] Buoy InoA uo dde ayy] Jan & SI adaid pays] = (LGD) ST-E2:€0 60-PO-Zz0z
“MO||OJ NOA Ssayy pue siamoljos] (109) O£-ZZ:E0 60-70-2207
JNOA ‘NOA Aq panlared JO 0} JU|S adessaw |/2 Se Jam Se “AIOWaW U! saBessaly UEYDxI0/q
j[e zo Adoz e sdaay 7eu} aSeqeJeEp ouuI}-jeaJ BAISSEWW BS} ajzznd au jo araid puosas ay) “paaqUeiend si yeeds ea24) (109) 00:02°€0 60-70-7c0z
Os ‘SOU 0} JeO1Y] OU SI BJaYyL “sjoq pue Weds Jo AyOfew Jser ay} INO 4nd [JIM YS! “ureyo au} UO AgessawW INOA JaysI93J OF JUNOWe Auly e Aed OJ aAEY NOA “JEHIM 3%] syul|/sadessow qxa} HOYs pue syuaWAed YjOq saop Jey} WeysAs eIpaLy [PIDOs UIEYII0)q 2 JOY Eep! UE SAR | yeaa! (103) 9S'¥LEZ 80-70-2702
si} BuIyDIeI aq pinoysam| (LOD) 00-9S:zz BO-PO-ec0e
S14} BMY] JINIS Jo yDIS OS We || (LOD) 9S:OT-ZZ BO-PO-Cc0z
<SuUd Wid GD'OL OT 3 80-70-2202 JoYsUaaTIS - Sud/ezew! - JuaWYeny> (LO3) 9S:OT-ZZ 80-70-7202
Ajoys eq EIN] (LD) ZTv-0Z BO-FO-2Z0Z
veSUl Sp NOE Ul |/ED,, PAT (109) S€:0%:6T 800-2207
ESuIW Sp ynoge UI eD| {LdD) BZ:Ov6T 8O-7O-Cz0z
jmoux| (LOD) LEZEGT 80-v0-270T
|W 437 Jam Je SueausSua ynoge yeyd e aney oO} WeM NOA J MOU AUIVETs ajqe|!ere W,| *(03D) Fesed YUM snss! APQUSP! B43 ASIEs |[IM (LGD) SPZ5:S0 80-70-2207
) pue}ioy Unsne
‘Auedwod 3uj (01U09 3 ,UOp os YayM) Jom%~GuUMOySN!|) (LGD) GS: TS'S0 80-PO-CZOT pueliow unsne
‘unis Auequawayddns aw puas 0} wa/qoid ou yng ‘Jepusjes Aw! Uo Sajep OM} ay} Ind Apeauye | (103) SZ:Zv6T 20-70-2202
,assaippe| (LO) 82:Tr-6t 20-70-2707 [IEW JNOA 0} JUS SAWAU! JEpUs|ed a1] NOA Og "MOUOWOY duryeads 0} pseMio) Oo", Pay] éssaippe |leWa InoA oO} Juas SayAU! Jepuayjed 3y]| NOA Og ‘MOJIOWO Suiyeads 07 PIEMIO} 4007 (109) SO:Tt6T L£O-70-ZZ0Z
TWWILNSgiaNo°
Page 99
278175
‘Aepo} Sunjeads 0} Premso! SUyOO| LW,| “ABpo} ado AJIWELINOA UM Yelp 2 BIBYS 0} WES1INO Pays AA,| “MOIIOLUO} Y-8 INO U! PajIa|/Je4 aq ||IM SIYL “PJEO 34} UO! O07 Fuiuyjap ase noA yey Aepsajsad Seed YIM JX9] INOA Sulspaj mousy
(L039) £0:TO:7T OT-70-7Z07
oe
PIeEAUOL YJed JNOA SUIPUEysJapuUn ynoge Asuagin alow Jaaj pue sam} INOA UBas BABY | ZSuIUaAe Siu] YeSds NOA UeI — ABH
(109) 72:02:27 60-70-2207
7s
nod yueyL
(105) TZ:8T-ZT 60-70-2Z07
) Hes
7s ore 22
MOJJOLWO} 4/2} UED ING ‘jo Bye} 0} JNOGe Ww]
(109) £Z:TT:ZT 60-70-2207
ISMN EQUI
3/34} 1No a}doad peg jo s}o7 ‘uloz}1g Aeme SUIAIS 8) ,NOA Jeu] WEDS ay} SunOWOId ajdoad 3dS | UAYM AZEI9 BWW SAALIP } “INO SJALWWEDS FUNYjIIY BNAspMalD osje pjNor sYysld Zuo,
(109) 60:SS:0T 60-P0-cz0z
1 2075) NL T6
PJBM} YJEd BY] PUE MaIA JO JUIOd UNOA pueysiapun Ajdaap | ins sxew pue joald uappns ayy Inoge pueysiapun o3 JUeM IsN[ yng uidd INOA 4a8 | “pPseog sy paulo! NoA aouls SINOY pz INoge Uaaq Sey I FSW UM YPNoIY} SIU} 4/2} O} SSINUIW QT aye] NOA ue}
(Ld3) Ev:0E:0T 6O-P0-ZZ07
) 8S
ee
90] uoluIdO s,yeF St SIUL
(103) vT:82-0T 60-7O-Zz0c
JO|Ae| Jalg ) 4185
“AUECWO2 aJeAUd 2 Se BUOP ag Pinoys SulLnyanijsel Os “a]qusey YOO] SUBGWINU JY} aYeLU [[IM SuasN Bye) Swsind se ‘Auedwoo d1\qnd B5e Op oO} PJeY SI siyL
(109) 40:82:01 60-pO-2Z0Z
JojAe| Jaug ) HAS
Papesu s! uolyse aIs21q
(103) 6S:92Z:0T 60-70-ZZ07
) 18S
er
JOM 1,U0M Seed YM 2unjeys Ag sayIMy SUIXI4
(109) pP:9Z:0T 60-P0-Z202
<=. eI
Ajjuauino 3,UOp | g]X91U03 SU) PUBISJapUN UES | OS SA}NUIW BAL, BABY NOA OG ‘pesiyy je] BY] MES |
(L035) SO:92:0T 60-p0-cz0z
Jajjo a} BALd aye] e J2adxs aseald
(103) 62:S2:0T 60-70-2702
ASN JEQUID)
Pe
Adouyqueyiyd/uolsinnse/Ue/yas03u) Aledo Ue spe al} pue seAlqzeauo
BUT INO FUL || 3 ‘SPE BY} 1O) SBeYd OU 5) aJaY] VEY JayI0 Ing ‘suayo} Jo JUNOWe 1391e| YINW E BYES 0} SABY P[NOM suasivaApe Syl “ANjEA Ppe Jey Spe UO |IOA Pinos (ol JUEM NOA Jl aqon Aud) Sian paysasaqul Jo JUBUCdWOD FUNOA ay) “asey} INO spe poos swos sue aay)
(L093) TT:ZT-0T 60-v0-2207
)IsnIAI [EQUI
SUS WasIWaApe BJEY | SIBSN SYA JO WaUsq dy} 104 Ajaind ssauisng asny e aq [fF aJe9s YIUM,, PAA
(103) S¥:ET:0T 60-70-2207
ISNA) EQUI,
S]USWASIHBAPE a32y | ‘Siasn ay} JO Wave ayy JO) Ajaind ssauisng asny e aq |!M 2! BjEIS YM,
(LOD) ST:ET:0T 60-70-7207
ASTIN TEGUID|
aad mol AlsA Be yng aa~uas asn Joy Aed e $1! Juisnaape spaeu JOU pjnom NOA “uayxO} UMO INOA BSN PIP NOA J
(LOD) ZZ:2T-OT 60-v0-Zz07
10S 2021 228
EXJEL NOA UeD “UO}}eSI2AU0I 7X9] JNOA pauOrUsW pue aw pales isnf se1eq
(LOD) EE:OT:0T 60-v0-Ez07
YSN [EQUIDY
ASMA) EQUA!)
juIgaq SSWes Bu} 49] Ng ‘sUOD pUe sald ‘sJaamy SuNajap Woy ajdoad sjuaasid uleysxI0)/g
(LOD) 6S:£0°0T 60-¥0-Z07
Ls
aq]e} aM Ue}
(LGD) 90:40:0T 60-70-2207
ISNA! [EQUI
ANIEA Ul BLU! IBAO MOB |[IM HI BAISUaXS OF BAL 1,USA0q “sod O} Ja|/BM INOA Ul UaYO BUI PjO O21 BABY P,no, gea1ANas BY}.M payelosse uayo) e MAed Way) SsAey pinoy
(LGD) TS:S0:0T 60-70-ZZ07Z
WILNSCIANOD ATHSIH
Page 100
) ) sas SIAEQ aes
SIAEQ BAa1S
) Saniy JBEUDIA ) SAADy JPEUDIIA
) SOAIY JBEYSINN
1S 01.0155
dg wes
2yJOM PIN JayIML+ueysx90/q MOY UO {sod e OS} JAM jNoge ¥!2) 0} BAg| pijnom—uo]y Mig
(109) £2:0€:80 pI-?0-2Z20Z
SIAEQ 8A215
‘insdjay aq pynom sraauidua UeYs\20/g }1 MOLY aL 3B] ‘SUIM g UE} 4] JO} JOO1 0} UB|d YDIYM aINSION jsuIZeUTy
(LD) 6€:90:80 pT-vO-Zz0e
) Bury ajAeg
SSB|9 SY} Ul SPI} JAY} BUy S}!] JOU Ble NOA ples | ByI|"" UANOP SIYI WIN} SJapfoysseys MOY MOLY MOU 1,UOp| ,2AoW eIsdued,, e Aes Aepoy Jo spy ayy Se S| S14} SIE} O} Bde} J8yI8F0} uMOp JIS P|NoYs am YUIUA NOAI,UOg MON jMOMA JATUM Ang 0} Busao Jo Jayp1y SulAng NOA {NOTA
(109) 20:05:90 vT-70-220@
4S
ObOL DAPOLONIF THIS OIO=) SUL =Se SOU LSOT9SS9bTISTLS L/s74e1s/4SNWUG|e/Wos isa //-sany
(LOD) ZS: :90 pT-70-c202
) 418s
“quaWWDs yey Jo ysodau Jo quawilwos Jad aZog [79 aqAewW Aed 0} aAey p,NOA os ‘s}ualUWOD Se UoMpesuen BY} Ul pappaqwa ae ,,s}aaM1,, 84) ASYM JS) JO UOIsIBA paseg-uleYsyI0/q E Sig Weld AI
(109) 9:90 ¥T-PO-Zz0z
OP | IU
(103) SETH TZ ET-PO-ZzZ0z
JojAe | j3j¢
“lew jeuosied AW ‘piemuos Suj08 wosews @ojAejq asn aseayd ‘osyy “ewe unod panladal | SUILWIUOD
(LaD) OS:8T:TZ ET-v0-ZZ07
Ppaspamouxay
(La) 92:S0:T2 ET-v0-7z0z
uojy ‘syuey, “suosenb
Aue aaey noA4g! Wead AW YzM MOA auUOD oO} AddeY “BulWJOW a4} Ul 3IGnd aq [jn Yorym *\YS1U0} J8}9] 12440 UE NGA Puss |[JM | “SICAL JAM, SUPE} YIM PIEMUOY SACL OJ paplrep aney | —AqAe3 Snowas Jo JaqjeW e Ajsnolago SI Siu} — UolIeJaq||ap Jo SAep |e1aAas ayy
(109) £S:Z¥6T €T-7O-Zz0z
SEAT [BEUDIIN
Jaa OF JUEM PUE dn |/Ns5 34,NOA ased Ul Ys UO spue| ay UAYM NOA jews 03 addijiyd 1/83 1],| Ped 0] Papesy wW,| |JUEISISSe Jee15 e NOA pull 0} paan
(109) ZE:TO'LO ET-70-Zz0z
“B]-HBUEYS Ee TOOT Wooy 3YsIU0} Aq slWO2 ued ay “10
(LOD) £5:9€:00 ET-7O-720Z
Ang poo ‘ews Jadns sa} ja70y INOA ul Sut OZ a4!) Op Ajysauoy pynos no, (SuginJoa2 UM dyay 0} WIY pjo} |) Bunyny ayy Ul SuLog OW! Jas 0} sJUeM:puly spunod Yadeds € 10 7 YSe] Pld e|SAL JO UON|Ig E SUMO Ja}}IM_ UO seSp! sluos sey
(109) 7S:9T:00 ET-p0-2Z20Z
ZqUEM ay Saop Ajpexa EU
(a3) 60:ZT:00 €T-r0-Zz072
) SBALy PEYIIW
dysaq au] Aue,
(L093) LyES'€Z ZT-hO-7Z02
SaAly [BEY
é4s3q jo auiy Jejnanied Auy
{Ld3) 0S:6h°€2 @T-v0-cZ07
) Has
aqael
(LaD) AS'TeEz ZT-vO-ZZ0z
) SAAD BEAN)
EMOJOWO} JOANOSUEA Ut JUOYeT addijiyd sas 07 atuy Aue aaey
(L093) TT:ZTEZ ZI-pO-ZZ02
) 4185
“WIY O} pay]ed | UBUA MalA SpIeP OS|2 SEM JEU] “SUOP SI 2eY} BIO SpayteW aiignd ay} 0} uinjas pue ainjoanyse ‘ayeAld JayIM) 842} 0} ‘UolUIdo AW Ul “Jazaq SI 3]
(LOD) SE:SPST OT-v0-2Z02
) s8S
pood spunos
(La3) 2Z:7ST OT-vO-Zz0z
TWILNSCISANOD ATHSIH
Back to 
