Oregon District Court, Case No. 3:86-cv-01571-JU:
Zidel, et al v. Kobin & Meyer, et al

Tags No tags have been applied so far. Sign in to add some.
No Logo Arnold Zidell, Plaintiff

Jacob Tanzer
Ball Janik, LLP
Phone: +1 503 228 2525

v.
Tube Forgings of America, Inc., Defendant

Lois O. Rosenbaum
Stoel Rives, LLP
Phone: +1 503 294 9293
Fax: +1 503 294 9113
E-Mail: lorosenbaum@stoel.com

Zidell Explorations Incorporated, Defendant

Joyce A Harpole
Phone: +1 503 294 9586

Lois O. Rosenbaum
Stoel Rives, LLP
Phone: +1 503 294 9293
Fax: +1 503 294 9113
E-Mail: lorosenbaum@stoel.com

No Logo Zidell Incorporated, Defendant

Lois O. Rosenbaum
Stoel Rives, LLP
Phone: +1 503 294 9293
Fax: +1 503 294 9113
E-Mail: lorosenbaum@stoel.com

Joyce A Harpole
Phone: +1 503 294 9586

No Logo Zidell Marine Inc, Defendant

Joyce A Harpole
Phone: +1 503 294 9586

Lois O. Rosenbaum
Stoel Rives, LLP
Phone: +1 503 294 9293
Fax: +1 503 294 9113
E-Mail: lorosenbaum@stoel.com

No Logo ZRZ Realty Company, Defendant

Lois O. Rosenbaum
Stoel Rives, LLP
Phone: +1 503 294 9293
Fax: +1 503 294 9113
E-Mail: lorosenbaum@stoel.com

Joyce A Harpole
Phone: +1 503 294 9586

Read between the lines with PlainSite Pro.
Citations, analytics, filtering, commenting, judge profiles, and more—as low as $99 per month.
Office Portland
Filed 12/11/1986
Jury Demand Plaintiff
Demand $950000
Nature of Suit 190 - Contract: Other
Cause Section 28 U.S.C. § 1332 Diversity-Other Contract
Jurisdiction Diversity
Disposition Dismissed - Settled
County Multnomah
Terminated 8/14/1990
Origin 1
Reopened None
Lead Case None
Related Case
Other Court Case 90-35791[C/A 9th Circuit]
Def Custody Status
Flags APPEAL, FRC, TERMINATED
 130 Filed: 12/19/1988, Entered: 1/26/1989 Memorandum
Supplemental memorandum in oppos to mot for leave to file 3rd pty complaint by defts Zidell (former employee)
 131 Filed: 12/22/1988, Entered: 1/26/1989 Memorandum in Opposition
Pltf's response to mot of defts Kobin & Meyer to file 3rd pty complaint (former employee)
 132 Filed: 1/5/1989, Entered: 1/26/1989 Memorandum
Supplemental memorandum in oppos to atty defts' mot for leave to file 3rd pty complaint by defts Zidell (former employee)
 133 Filed: 1/9/1989, Entered: 1/26/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF HRG: on mot of dets Kobin & Meyer, et al for leave to file 3rd pty complt for indem #126. ORD taking U/A. ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 134 Filed: 1/9/1989, Entered: 1/26/1989 Transcript
Reporter's Transcript of proceedings had 10/31/88 before MA (former employee)
 135 Filed: 1/17/1989, Entered: 1/26/1989 Memorandum in Opposition
Reply memo of defts Kobin & Meyer, et al in support of motion for leave to file 3rd pty complaint for indemnity (former employee)
 136 Filed: 1/18/1989, Entered: 1/26/1989 Findings & Recommendation
F & R ref to MA Defts' mot for lv to file 3rd pty complaint #126 should be denied (ntfd) Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 137 Filed: 1/23/1989, Entered: 1/26/1989 Motion for Extension of Discovery & PTO Deadlines
Unopposed MOTION to extend discovery cutoff & PTO dates , Exped Consid Req (former employee)
 138 Filed: 1/30/1989, Entered: 1/31/1989 Objections to Findings & Recommendation
Objections of defts Kobin & Meyer, et al to [136-1] F & R pursuant to 28 USC 636(b)(l)(B) OA REQ (former employee)
 139 Filed: 2/2/1989, Entered: 2/3/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: granting motion to extend discovery cutoff & PTO dates [137-1] ; setting pretrial order ddl for 5/30/89 ; setting discovery ddl for 5/1/89 , ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 -- Filed: 2/13/1989, Entered: 2/13/1989, Terminated: 2/27/1989 Order
Findings and Recommendations to Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 140 Filed: 2/13/1989, Entered: 2/13/1989 Response to Objections to Findings & Recommendatio
Response to objections to findings and recommendation by plaintiff (former employee)
 141 Filed: 2/17/1989, Entered: 2/21/1989 Motion Hearing Court Filing
RECORD OF ORD: Set objs of defts Kobin & Meyer #l38 to F & R of 1/30/89 #l36 MON, 3/6/89 noa, M/C of Judge MARSH. ORD Defts Kobin & Meyer's req for OA #138 Denied. (ntfd c/d) Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 142 Filed: 2/21/1989, Entered: 2/22/1989, Terminated: 3/30/1989 Motion to Amend/Correct
MOTION by plaintiff to amend complaint (former employee)
 143 Filed: 2/23/1989, Entered: 2/24/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: Set pltf's motion to amend complaint [142-1] MON, 3/27/89 M/C (noa) (ntfd c/d) Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 144 Filed: 2/27/1989, Entered: 2/27/1989, Terminated: 2/27/1989 Order
ORDER re Findings and Recommendations motion F & R. Adopting JU F & R Defts' mot for lv to file 3rd pty complaint #126 DENIED. (ntfd c/d) Signed 2/27/89 microfilmed 2/27/89 Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 145 Filed: 3/8/1989, Entered: 3/9/1989 Memorandum in Opposition
Memo of atty defts in oppos to pltf's mot to amend complaint [142-1] (former employee)
 146 Filed: 3/9/1989, Entered: 3/10/1989 Order
ORDER dismissing case as to party Norman B Kobin (deceased) Signed 3/9/89 microfilmed 3/10/89 Magistrate George E. Juba ntfd (former employee)
 147 Filed: 3/27/1989, Entered: 3/28/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF Submit w/out OA & taking under advisement on 3/27/8 motion to amend complaint [142-1] ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 148 Filed: 3/30/1989, Entered: 3/31/1989 Order
ORDER granting motion to amend complaint [142-1] ntfd Signed 3/30/89 microfilmed & ent 3/31/89 Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 149 Filed: 4/3/1989, Entered: 4/4/1989 Amended Complaint
AMENDED and supplemental complaint for negligence & declaratory relief J/T demand (former employee)
 150 Filed: 4/6/1989, Entered: 4/7/1989 Motion for Extension of Discovery & PTO Deadlines
MOTION by defendant Kobin & Meyer, PC, etc to extend discovery cutoff & PTO dates Exped Consid Req (former employee)
 151 Filed: 4/11/1989, Entered: 4/12/1989 Notice of Appeal - Magistrate Judge Decision to Di
Appeal from Magistrate's Order pursuant to 28:636(b)(l)(A) [ referred to Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh ] by atty defts concerning order [148-2] (former employee)
 152 Filed: 4/14/1989, Entered: 4/14/1989 Description not available
ANSWER by defendant Zidell Marine, Inc., defendant Zidell Explorations,, defendant Zidell Inc., defendant Emery Zidell, defendant Zrz Realty CO. to Amended & suplmntl complt (former employee)
 153 Filed: 4/18/1989, Entered: 4/19/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: granting motion to extend discovery cutoff & PTO dates [150-1] discovery 6/30/89; PTO 7/28/89 , ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 154 Filed: 4/24/1989, Entered: 4/25/1989 Memorandum in Opposition
Pltf's opposition to attorney defts' req for reconsideration (former employee)
 155 Filed: 5/1/1989, Entered: 5/2/1989 Motion Hearing Court Filing
RECORD OF ORD: SET Deft's notice of Appeal from Magistrate's Order pursuant to 28:636(b)(l)(A) [151-1] on M/C of Judge MARSH MON, 5/15/89 noa (ruling on submissions) ntfd Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 156 Filed: 5/16/1989, Entered: 5/17/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: deft's appeal #151 of Magis JUBA's Order #148 granting pltf's mot to amend is DENIED ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 157 Filed: 5/19/1989, Entered: 5/19/1989, Terminated: 5/22/1989 Motion to Amend/Correct
Stipulated MOTION to amend complaint #157 affid of Sarah J. Ryan (former employee)
 158 Filed: 5/22/1989, Entered: 5/24/1989 Order
ORDER granting motion to amend complaint to add Tube Forgings of America, Inc. [157-1] ORD: all orders issd to date in this case shall apply to TFA to same extent as to the other Zidell defts ntfd Signed 5/22/89 microfilmed & ent 5/24/89 Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 159 Filed: 5/25/1989, Entered: 5/26/1989 Description not available
Second AMENDED and Supplemental complaint for negligence and declaratory relief Jury Trial Demanded (former employee)
 160 Filed: 5/26/1989, Entered: 5/30/1989 Description not available
ANSWER by defts Kobin & Meyer, PC, Charles L Kobin, Norman B Kobin, Paul R Meyer, Daniel J Seifer, John Spencer Stewart, David R Trachtenberg, Elizabeth Yeats to second amended and supplemental complaint (former employee)
 161 Filed: 6/1/1989, Entered: 6/2/1989 Description not available
ANSWER and counterclaims by defts Tube Forgings of America, Zidell Marine, Inc., Zidell Explorations,, Zidell Inc. & Zrz Realty CO. to second AMENDED COMPLAINT and Supplemental complaint (former employee)
 162 Filed: 6/23/1989, Entered: 6/26/1989 Motion for Extension of Discovery & PTO Deadlines
MOTION by atty defts to extend discovery cutoff and PTO dates #162 Exped Consid Req (former employee)
 163 Filed: 6/26/1989, Entered: 6/27/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: granting motion to extend discovery cutoff and PTO dates [162-1] Discovery extend to 8/29/89, PTO 9/28/89 , ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 164 Filed: 6/27/1989, Entered: 6/28/1989 Reply
Reply by plaintiff to counterclaim of Kobin & Meyer defts (former employee)
 165 Filed: 6/27/1989, Entered: 6/28/1989 Reply
Reply by plaintiff to counterclaim of defts Zidell Explorations, Zidell, Inc., ZRZ Realty Co, Zidell Marine, and Tube Forgings of America, Inc. (former employee)
 166 Filed: 6/28/1989, Entered: 6/28/1989 Order Court Filing
PROTECTIVE ORDER: ntfd Signed 9/26/89 Judge Otto R. Skopil (former employee)
 167 Filed: 9/14/1989, Entered: 9/18/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: Scheduling Conf TUE, 10/3/89, 10:30 in chmbrs , Req by deft's cnsl. ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 168 Filed: 9/20/1989, Entered: 9/21/1989 Scheduling
Stipulation and ORDER to postpone pto lodging until 10/3/89 sched conf: pto lodging date to be reset 10/3/89 , ntfd Signed 9/20/89 Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 169 Filed: 10/3/1989, Entered: 10/4/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: satisfy conf date , ORD deft's mot for s/j file by 10/24/89; response by 11/14/89; reply by 11/29/89. A hrg date will set after motion filed , ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 170 Filed: 10/24/1989, Entered: 10/25/1989 Order Court Filing
ORDER approving partial settlement. Neither stip of parties nor this ord is intended to affect the allocation of proceeds of this settlement between Arnold Z & Sidell Corp, which remains to be determined by Dist Court. This settlement approved. (see settlement ?) ntfd Signed 10/23/89 Judge Otto R. Skopil (former employee)
 171 Filed: 10/24/1989, Entered: 10/25/1989 Motion for Partial Summary Judgment
MOTION by deft Zidell Corps for partial summary judgment #171 (former employee)
 172 Filed: 10/24/1989, Entered: 10/25/1989 Memorandum in Support
Memorandum by defts Zidell corps in support of motion for partial summary judgment [171-1] (former employee)
 173 Filed: 10/27/1989, Entered: 10/27/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: SET dft Zidell motion for partial summary judgment [171-1], MON, M/C 12/11/89 (noa) ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 174 Filed: 11/2/1989, Entered: 11/2/1989 Affidavit
Affidavit of non-involvement Jacklyn M. Bartruff (former employee)
 175 Filed: 11/2/1989, Entered: 11/2/1989 Affidavit
Affidavit of Lois O. Rosenbaum (former employee)
 176 Filed: 11/17/1989, Entered: 11/20/1989 Memorandum in Opposition
Memorandum by plaintiff in opposition to motion for partial summary judgment [171-1] (former employee)
 178 Filed: 11/20/1989, Entered: 11/22/1989 Order
ORDER of Dismissal w/prej dismiss party Kobin & Meyer, PC, Charles L Kobin, Daniel J Seifer, John Spencer Stewart, David R Trachtenberg, Elizabeth Yeats, Paul R Meyer , The Counterclaim of dets Zidell Explorations, Zidell, Inc., ZRZ Realty, Zidell Marine, Tube Forgings of America against pltf is not a part of the settlemetn & not affected by this order. ntfd Signed 11/20/89 microfilmed & ent 11/22/89 Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 179 Filed: 11/20/1989, Entered: 11/22/1989 Order
Stipulation and ORDER: extending time to file opposition to defts' mot for part s/j [171-1] by 11/17/89 & deft Zidell Corp reply by 12/6/89 , ntfd Signed 11/20/89 Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 177 Filed: 11/21/1989, Entered: 11/22/1989 Affidavit
Affidavit of Arnold Zidell in support of pltf's memo in opposition to defts' mot for part s/j #176 (former employee)
 180 Filed: 11/29/1989, Entered: 11/29/1989 Transcript
Reporter's Transcript of proceedings had 8/22/88 (former employee)
 181 Filed: 12/1/1989, Entered: 12/1/1989 Reply to Motion
Reply by defendants Zidell Corporations in support of defts' motion for partial summary judgment [171-1] (former employee)
 182 Filed: 12/11/1989, Entered: 12/14/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: taking under advisement on 12/11/89 motion for partial summary judgment [171-1] ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 183 Filed: 12/18/1989, Entered: 12/19/1989 Order
ORDER deft Zidell Corp.'s mot for s/j [171] should be Denied. Pltf to retain costs & atty fees subject to tbe limitations stated. ntfd Signed 12/18/89 microfilmed 12/19/89 Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 184 Filed: 12/27/1989, Entered: 12/27/1989 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ord pursuant ot FRCP 60(a) the court changes the amount of Arnold Zidell's impermissible expenses listed as $24,858 on page 4 of the order to $24,3l8.00. ORD Arnold Zidell to submit information to the court & deft's regarding the amt of penalty case fees included in the original sum he sought as atty fees. ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 185 Filed: 1/4/1990, Entered: 1/4/1990, Terminated: 2/16/1990 Objection
Objections by defts Zidell Corps' to Magistrate's order 12/18/89, OA REQ (former employee)
 186 Filed: 1/9/1990, Entered: 1/9/1990 Response to Objections To Magistrate Judges Order
Response by plaintiff to defts' objections to Magis Order of 12/18/89 (former employee)
 187 Filed: 1/18/1990, Entered: 1/19/1990 Motion Hearing Court Filing
RECORD OF ORD: Set for Hrg defts' objections #185 to Magis's order #183 before Judge Marsh FRI, 2/2/90, 3:30 pm. ORD defts' req for OA on #185 granted. ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 188 Filed: 1/25/1990, Entered: 1/26/1990 Motion Hearing Court Filing
RECORD OF ORD: RESET defts' objection [185-1] to Magis's order #183 from 2/2/90 to TUE, 2/6/90, 8:30 before Judge MARSH. ntfd Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 189 Filed: 2/6/1990, Entered: 2/8/1990 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF HRG: ORD by 2/9/90, pltf to submit ltr re moving costs. ORD: defts' obj #185 to Magis ord #183 U/A. ntfd Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 190 Filed: 2/16/1990, Entered: 2/16/1990 Order
ORDER adopt F & R #183 of Magis Juba as modified above and defts' motion for s/j #171 DENIED. ntfd Signed 2/16/90 microfilmed & ent 2/16/90 Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 191 Filed: 4/9/1990, Entered: 4/9/1990, Terminated: 5/14/1990 Motion for Attorney Fees
Petition by plaintiff for attorneys' fees #191 (former employee)
 192 Filed: 4/9/1990, Entered: 4/9/1990 Affidavit
Affidavit of Jacob Tanzer regarding motion for attorneys' fees [191-1] (former employee)
 193 Filed: 4/9/1990, Entered: 4/9/1990 Affidavit
Affidavit of Arnold Zidell regarding motion for attorneys' fees [191-1] (former employee)
 194 Filed: 4/12/1990, Entered: 4/12/1990 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: SET pltf's petition for attorneys' fees [191-1] on M/C, MON, 5/14/90. ntfd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 195 Filed: 4/19/1990, Entered: 4/20/1990 Memorandum in Opposition
Response to pltf's petition for attorneys' fees [191-1] (former employee)
 196 Filed: 5/1/1990, Entered: 5/2/1990 Reply to Motion
Reply by plaintiff to response to motion for attorneys' fees [191-1] (former employee)
 197 Filed: 5/14/1990, Entered: 5/15/1990 Order
ORDER granting pltf's petition for attorneys' fees [191-1] as modified. Pltf receive $45,505.25 in atty fees & $27,485.88 in costs. ntfd Signed 5/14/90 microfilmed & ent 5/15/90dcd Magistrate George E. Juba (former employee)
 198 Filed: 5/24/1990, Entered: 5/24/1990, Terminated: 5/24/1990 Objection
Objections by plaintiff to order re recovery of costs and attorney's fees [197-2] (OA REQ) (former employee)
 199 Filed: 6/6/1990, Entered: 6/6/1990 Motion Hearing
RECORD OF ORD: SET pltf's objection [198-1] on M/C, MON 6/25/90 (noa). Pltf's rerq for OA part of #198 Denied. ntfd Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 200 Filed: 6/8/1990, Entered: 6/11/1990 Reply
Response to pltf's objs to order re recovery of costs & attys' fees [198-1] (former employee)
 201 Filed: 6/19/1990, Entered: 6/19/1990 Reply
Reply to response to pltf's objections to order regarding recovery of costs and attys' fees. by plaintiff Arnold Zidell (cpriestley)
 202 Filed: 6/25/1990, Entered: 6/25/1990 Order
ORDER affirm Magis JUBA's order & pltf's objs #198 denied. (see file) ntfd Signed 6/25/90 Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 203 Filed: 8/14/1990, Entered: 8/14/1990 Judgment
JUDGMENT: Dism w/prej see settlemt: Pltf award settlement fund attys' fees & costs $467,979 & atty fees & costs $45,505.25 & $31,616.44 respectively , ntfd Signed 8/14/90 microfilmed & ent 8/14/90 Honorable Malcolm F. Marsh (former employee)
 204 Filed: 8/15/1990, Entered: 8/15/1990, Terminated: 10/24/1990 Bill of Costs
Bill of costs submitted by Zrz Realty CO., Zidell Explorations,, Zidell Inc., Zidell Marine, Inc., Tube Forgings of America (former employee)
 205 Filed: 8/15/1990, Entered: 8/15/1990 Affidavit
Affidavit of Lois O. Rosenbaum regarding bill of costs [204-1] (former employee)
 206 Filed: 8/22/1990, Entered: 8/22/1990 Objection
Objections by plaintiff to Zidell Corp's bill of costs [204-1] and brief (former employee)
 207 Filed: 8/23/1990, Entered: 8/24/1990 Reply
Response by Zidell Corps' to pltf's objections to cost bill [206-1] (former employee)
 -- Filed: 9/12/1990, Entered: 9/12/1990 Notification of Appeal Sent
Notification form sent to US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit/cnsl (former employee)
 -- Filed: 9/12/1990, Entered: 9/12/1990 Fee Paid
Received C/A fee of $: 100.00 D/C fee of $: 5.00 ( Receipt # 92240) (former employee)
 208 Filed: 9/12/1990, Entered: 9/12/1990 Notice of Appeal
Notice of appeal by plaintiff Arnold Zidell from Dist. Court decision [203-3] (former employee)
 209 Filed: 9/19/1990, Entered: 9/21/1990 Bond
SUPERSEDAS Bond (St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins.) in amount of $ 500.00 Bond No. 400 HM 0l08 filed by plaintiff Arnold Zidell (former employee)
 -- Filed: 9/24/1990, Entered: 9/24/1990 Certificate of Record by Clerk to USCA
Certificate of Record Transmitted to US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit / cnsl copied (former employee)
 210 Filed: 9/24/1990, Entered: 9/24/1990 Transcript Designation and Order Form
Transcript Designation and Ordering Form for date(s) none requested (former employee)
 -- Filed: 10/24/1990, Entered: 10/24/1990, Terminated: 10/24/1990 Order
Costs taxed for Zrz Realty CO., Zidell Inc., Zidell Explorations,, Zidell Marine, Inc., Tube Forgings of Ame in the sum of $ $1021.33 against pltf Arnold Zidell (former employee)
 211 Filed: 10/24/1990, Entered: 10/24/1990 USCA Order
C/A ORD dkt stmt 11/1/90; R/T desgn form file 10/12/90; C/rptr file r/transcripts 11/13/90; Applt br 12/31/90; Appellee 1/28/91 (former employee)
 -- Filed: 8/19/1993, Entered: 8/19/1993 Federal Records Center Information
CASE FILE SENT TO THE FRC Accession number 21-93-0076 Location number 638323 Box 8 of 163 (former employee)

Update this case via PACER (Paid subscription required)

PACER Shortcuts

Statistics

This case has been viewed 17 times.

No comments have been added yet. Sign in to post a comment.
Space
Issues Laws Cases Pro Pro Se Articles Firms Entities
Issues Laws Cases Pro Pro Se Articles Firms Entities
 
PlainSite
Need Password Help?