ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO DISMISS AND VACATING HEARING by Judge Alsup granting [20] Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction (whalc2, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 10/23/2007)
No tags have been applied so far. Sign in to add some.
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
Document 50
Filed 10/23/2007
Page 1 of 10
1
2
3
4
5
6
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
7
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
8
9
11
For the Northern District of California
United States District Court
10
12
13
HANA HILSENRATH, OLIVER
HILSENRATH, NAMA HILSENRATH,
LIOR HILSENRATH, ELLA HOPE
HILSENRATH, ISAIAH BENJAMIN
HILSENRATH, SAUL NATHANIEL
HILSENRATH, and THE LIVING TRUST OF
MELANIE AND ANDRE HILSENRATH,
14
15
16
ORDER GRANTING
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO
DISMISS AND VACATING
HEARING
Plaintiffs,
v.
18
THE SWISS CONFEDERATION, THE
FEDERAL ATTORNEY GENERAL OF
SWITZERLAND, GERARD SAUTEBIN,
BRENT HOLTKAMP, and DOES 1–10,
19
Defendants.
17
No. C 07-02782 WHA
/
20
21
22
INTRODUCTION
Pro se plaintiffs sued defendants for freezing plaintiffs’ assets during a criminal
23
investigation. Defendants the Swiss Confederation, the Federal Attorney General of
24
Switzerland, Gerald Sautebin, and Brent Holtkamp (the “Swiss Defendants”) move to dismiss
25
the complaint. Plaintiffs are Hana Hilsenrath, Oliver Hilsenrath, Nama Hilsenrath,
26
Lior Hilsenrath, Ella Hope Hilsenrath, Isaiah Benjamin Hilsenrath, Saul Nathaniel Hilsenrath,
27
and the Living Trust of Melanie and Andre Hilsenrath. The Swiss Defendants claim that
28
(i) the Court lacks personal jurisdiction over them because of improper service by plaintiffs;
PDF Page 3
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
Page 2 of 10
(ii) the Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over plaintiffs’ claims because the Swiss
2
Defendants are entitled to sovereign immunity under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act;
3
(iii) the Court lacks personal jurisdiction over defendants Sautebin and Holtkamp due to these
4
defendants’ lack of sufficient contacts with the United States and California; (iv) plaintiffs’
5
claims are barred under the Act of State Doctrine; and (v) plaintiffs’ constitutional claims fail
6
because the acts complained of were taken by a foreign government in Switzerland. For the
7
reasons stated below, defendants’ motion to dismiss is GRANTED.
9
For the Northern District of California
Filed 10/23/2007
1
8
United States District Court
Document 50
STATEMENT
Plaintiffs are United States citizens who reside in California (Compl. at ¶ 16).
10
In April 2005, the Swiss authorities issued an international arrest warrant for Oliver Hilsenrath
11
(id. at ¶¶ 121–22). In May 2005, the Swiss Confederation ordered the freezing of assets held by
12
the Hilsenraths in two banks (Credit Suisse and UBS) because it was suspected that the assets
13
were stolen from a California-based company. Defendant Holtkamp, working on the behalf of
14
the Swiss Confederation, seized documents held by the two banks to trace allegedly illicit
15
financial dealings and business relationships in numerous countries (id. at ¶¶ 40–42, 56).
16
According to the complaint, in May 2005, this Court first sent Mr. Holtkamp its finding
17
that the Hilsenraths’ funds in Switzerland were not, in fact, the ill-begotten gains of theft.
18
Mr. Holtkamp and his colleagues nonetheless continued to investigate the Hilsenraths’ business
19
partners and maintain its freeze on their assets. In July and August 2005, Oliver Hilsenrath
20
traveled from the United States to Switzerland and was interrogated by Swiss officials. At the
21
conclusion of the interrogations, Mr. Holtkamp sent letters to the United States and
22
Mr. Hilsenrath stating that he did not have reason to believe that the Hilsenraths had illegally
23
transferred stolen funds to Switzerland. In those letters, Mr. Holtkamp promised to lift the
24
freeze on the Hilsenraths’ assets within three days; the funds, however, have remained frozen
25
until this day (id. at ¶¶ 43–48).
26
27
28
That same summer, two unidentified agents of the Swiss Confederation visited various
countries to investigate Hilsenrath business partners allegedly engaged in money-laundering.
2
PDF Page 4
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
Page 3 of 10
These agents told local authorities that they were investigating an international money
2
laundering ring, where eleven million illegally obtained American dollars were laundered
3
through Switzerland. This investigation caused substantial financial damage and
4
embarrassment to plaintiffs. In 2006, the United States government and district court sent
5
letters to the Swiss government, notifying them that the freeze was not warranted by any
6
prosecution pending in the United States. The Swiss Defendants remained silent and the funds
7
were never released to their owners (id. at ¶¶ 49–55).
9
For the Northern District of California
Filed 10/23/2007
1
8
United States District Court
Document 50
On February 6, 2007, however, Mr. Hilsenrath entered into a written plea agreement
with the government. Mr. Hilsenrath promised in the plea agreement he would “repatriate all
10
remaining money and assets presently held by the Swiss authorities or frozen by the Swiss
11
authorities in other jurisdictions, which [he estimated] as approximately $2,000,000. [He would]
12
deposit the money in an escrow account with the Court pending further order of the Court
13
distributing the assets. [He would] withdraw any claim to these assets and [would] file no
14
further actions in the future concerning the funds” (CR 03-00213, Doc. 366). He then pled
15
guilty to securities fraud and tax evasion.
16
Plaintiffs commenced action on May 27, 2007, alleging the following causes of action
17
against the Swiss Defendants: (i) deprivation of their assets collectively and indiscriminately in
18
violation of the Fourth and Fifth Amendments; (ii) unreasonable search and seizure in violation
19
of the Fourth and Fifth Amendments; (iii) recovery of lost property in violation of the Fifth
20
Amendment; (iv) recovery of lost business opportunities abroad in violation of the Fifth
21
Amendment; (v) personal damages to Hana Hilsenrath, such as fear, anguish, illness, and the
22
loss of the majority of her personal wealth; (vi) recovery of damages as the result of a breach in
23
due process in violation of the Sixth Amendment; (vii) recovery of legal fees in relation to the
24
Swiss freezes; (viii) deprivation of plaintiffs’ right to liberty in violation of the Fifth and
25
Fourteenth Amendments; and (ix) losses as the result of the forced liquidation of trust funds in
26
violation of the Fifth Amendment (id. at ¶¶ 89–134). The Hilsenraths seek millions of dollars
27
due to loss from the frozen funds, loss of business, legal fees, and personal damages (id. at ¶¶
28
3
PDF Page 5
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
Page 4 of 10
138–47). No lawyer represents any plaintiff. Mr. Hilsenrath is reminded once again that he
2
cannot represent anyone but himself. The other pro se plaintiffs must speak for themselves.
On July 9, 2007, the Court entered judgment against Mr. Hilsenrath in the criminal case.
4
He was convicted of committing securities fraud and income tax evasion (CR 03-00213,
5
Doc. 387).
6
ANALYSIS
7
For the Northern District of California
Filed 10/23/2007
1
3
United States District Court
Document 50
Defendants claim that plaintiffs lack subject-matter jurisdiction. The Court agrees. A
8
motion to dismiss may be asserted on grounds of lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. FRCP
9
12(b)(1). Plaintiffs erroneously argue that it is the district court’s discretion to award sovereign
10
immunity (Opp. at 3). The Supreme Court has held that the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act
11
is “the sole basis for obtaining jurisdiction over a foreign state in our courts.” Argentine
12
Republic v. Amerada Hess Shipping Corp., 488 U.S. 428, 434 (1989). The FSIA provides that
13
“a foreign state shall be immune from the jurisdiction of the courts of the United States and of
14
the States,” except as provided in Sections 1605 (general exceptions to the jurisdictional
15
immunity of a foreign state) and 1607 (counterclaims). 28 U.S.C. 1604. The FSIA “presumes
16
immunity. Jurisdiction is limited to cases in which the foreign state is not entitled to immunity
17
either under one of the enumerated exceptions contained in 28 U.S.C 1605 and 1607, or under
18
any applicable international agreement. If the claim does not fall within one of the exceptions,
19
the court cannot entertain the action and must dismiss the action against the foreign state for
20
lack of jurisdiction.” Security Pacific Nat. Bank v. Derderian, 872 F.2d 281, 285 (9th Cir.
21
1989).
22
A “foreign state” includes “a political subdivision of a foreign state or an agency or
23
instrumentality of a foreign state.” 28 U.S.C. 1603(a). An “agency or instrumentality of a
24
foreign state” means any entity that is “a separate legal person, corporate or otherwise,” “an
25
organ of a foreign state or political subdivision thereof,” and “is neither a citizen of a State of
26
the United States.” 28 U.S.C. 1603(b). Here, the Swiss Confederation, which is the federal
27
government of Switzerland, is a foreign state. The Office of the Attorney General is an agency
28
4
PDF Page 6
For the Northern District of California
United States District Court
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
Document 50
Filed 10/23/2007
Page 5 of 10
1
or instrumentality of Switzerland. Similarly, Defendants Holtkamp, who is a Federal Attorney
2
employed by the Office of the Attorney General, and Sautebin, who is a Federal Examining
3
Magistrate, are agencies or instrumentalities of a foreign state. None of them is a United States
4
citizen (Holtkamp Decl. at ¶¶ 2, Sautebin Decl. at ¶¶ 2–3). If plaintiffs’ claims do not fall into
5
one of the exceptions, this Court cannot exercise jurisdiction over defendants.
6
Defendants claim that, because plaintiffs fail to allege any facts demonstrating that any
7
exception to the FSIA applies, plaintiffs’ claims should be entirely dismissed. The exceptions
8
to sovereign immunity are: (i) the foreign state has waived its immunity; (ii) the action is based
9
upon a commercial activity; (iii) rights in property were taken in violation of international law
10
and the property had some nexus to commercial activity in the United States; (iv) rights in
11
property in the United States acquired by succession or succession are in issue; (v) money
12
damages are sought against a foreign state for personal injury or death, or damage to or loss of
13
property occurring in the United States; (vi) the action is brought to enforce an arbitration
14
agreement between plaintiffs and defendants; and (vii) money damages are sought against a
15
foreign state for personal injury or death that was caused by torture, extrajudicial killing,
16
aircraft sabotage, or hostage taking. 28 U.S.C.1605(a)(1)–(7). This order does not discuss the
17
other exceptions under 28 U.S.C. 1605 and 1607 because they deal with maritime liens,
18
mortgages, and counterclaims.
19
Exceptions (iv), (vi), and (vii) clearly do not apply. The rights in property in the
20
United States acquired by succession or gift or rights in immovable property situated in the
21
United States are not in issue. This action is not being brought to enforce an arbitration
22
agreement between plaintiffs and defendants. Finally, plaintiffs are not seeking money damages
23
for personal injury or death caused by torture, extrajudicial killing, aircraft sabotage, or hostage
24
taking.
25
Under 28 U.S.C. 1605(a)(1), a federal court would have jurisdiction if “the foreign state
26
has waived its immunity either explicitly or by implication, notwithstanding any withdrawal of
27
the waiver which the foreign state may purport to effect except in accordance with the terms of
28
5
PDF Page 7
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
For the Northern District of California
Filed 10/23/2007
Page 6 of 10
1
the waiver.” In their moving papers, the Swiss Defendants claim that they did not waive their
2
sovereign immunity. Plaintiffs counter that defendants waived their immunity on
3
August 27, 2007, when the Swiss Confederation “served Plaintiffs with an appealable order in
4
the matter of its so-called criminal action against Plaintiffs via the US Department of
5
Justice/Criminal Division” (Opp. at 8). Plaintiffs cite Siderman de Blake v. Republic of
6
Argentina, 965 F.2d 699 (9th Cir. 1992), which held that a foreign state implicitly waived its
7
sovereign immunity when evidence showed that it deliberately involved United States courts in
8
its efforts to persecute the plaintiff.
9
United States District Court
Document 50
The Ninth Circuit, however, draws a distinction between Siderman and cases like the
10
one before this Court. Diplomatic processes carried out through the powers of the executive —
11
not the judicial — branch do not constitute a waiver of sovereign immunity. Blaxland v.
12
Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions, 323 F.3d 1198, 1206 (9th Cir. 2003).
13
In Blaxland, “the Australian government did not itself apply to our courts for assistance but
14
instead invoked its rights under the Extradition Treaty by applying to the executive branch of
15
our government [to secure the plaintiff’s extradition].” Ibid. Here, the Swiss Department of
16
Justice and Police transmitted a request for service to the United States Department of Justice,
17
the executive branch, pursuant to Article 22 of the Treaty Between the United States of America
18
and the Swiss Confederation on Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters (Opp. Exh. H).
19
This order finds that the request was part of a diplomatic process carried out through the powers
20
of the executive branch and therefore did not constitute a waiver of sovereign immunity.
21
There is also the commercial-activity exception. The foreign state is not immune if
22
“the action is based upon a commercial activity carried on in the United States by the foreign
23
state; or upon an act performed in the United States in connection with a commercial activity of
24
the foreign state elsewhere; or upon an act outside the territory of the United States in
25
connection with a commercial activity of the foreign state elsewhere and that act causes a direct
26
effect in the United States.” 28 U.S.C. 1605(a)(2). The Supreme Court has held that “a state is
27
immune from the jurisdiction of foreign courts as to its sovereign or public acts . . . but not as to
28
6
PDF Page 8
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
For the Northern District of California
Filed 10/23/2007
Page 7 of 10
1
those that are private or commercial in character.” Saudi Arabia v. Nelson, 507 U.S. 349,
2
359–60 (1993). A foreign state engages in commercial activity when it exercises “only those
3
powers that can also be exercised by private citizens, as distinct from those powers peculiar to
4
sovereigns. Put differently, a foreign state engages in commercial activity for purposes of the
5
restrictive theory [of foreign sovereign immunity] only where it acts in the manner of a private
6
player within the market.” Id. at 360 (quotations omitted). The Swiss Defendants did not act as
7
private players in the market. Rather, they exercised powers peculiar to sovereigns —
8
they investigated Mr. Hilsenrath’s criminal activities in Switzerland and other countries, issued
9
a warrant for his arrest, and froze his assets pending criminal investigation. Plaintiffs’ claims
10
United States District Court
Document 50
do not fall under the commercial-activity exception.
11
Another exception to foreign sovereign immunity is the “takings exception” —
12
when there were “rights in property taken in violation of international law are in issue and that
13
property or any property exchanged for such property is present in the United States in
14
connection with a commercial activity carried on in the United States by the foreign state;
15
or that property or any property exchanged for such property is owned or operated by an agency
16
or instrumentality of the foreign state and that agency or instrumentality is engaged in a
17
commercial activity in the United States.” 28 U.S.C. 1605(a)(3). The Ninth Circuit has held
18
that, “[a]t the jurisdictional stage, we need not decide whether the taking actually violated
19
international law; as long as a claim is substantial and non-frivolous, it provides a sufficient
20
basis for the exercise of our jurisdiction.” Altmann v. Republic of Austria. 317 F.3d 954, 968
21
(9th Cir. 2002). Here, plaintiffs’ claims are not “substantial and non-frivolous.” The Swiss
22
Defendants froze plaintiffs’ asset during the course of a criminal investigation. Mr. Hilsenrath
23
later entered a written plea agreement with the government in which he pled guilty to securities
24
fraud and tax evasion. According to the terms of his plea agreement, Mr. Hilsenrath would
25
“repatriate all remaining money and assets presently held by the Swiss authorities or frozen by
26
the Swiss authorities in other jurisdictions, which [he estimated] as approximately $2,000,000.
27
[He would] deposit the money in an escrow account with the Court pending further order of the
28
7
PDF Page 9
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
Page 8 of 10
Court distributing the assets. [He would] withdraw any claim to these assets and [would] file no
2
further actions in the future concerning the funds.” It is frivolous to claim that freezing assets
3
during a legitimate criminal investigation violated international law.
Furthermore, the frozen assets remained in Switzerland and other European countries;
5
they were not “present in the United States in connection with a commercial activity carried on
6
in the United States by the foreign state.” Nor were they “owned or operated by an agency or
7
instrumentality of the foreign state and that agency or instrumentality is engaged in a
8
commercial activity in the United States.” Credit Suisse and UBS held the assets when the
9
Swiss Defendants ordered the freeze. These two private banks are not agencies or
10
For the Northern District of California
Filed 10/23/2007
1
4
United States District Court
Document 50
instrumentalities of Switzerland because they are not organs of a foreign state.
11
According to 28 U.S.C. 1605(a)(5), another possible exception is when “money
12
damages are sought against a foreign state for personal injury or death, or damage to or loss of
13
property, occurring in the United States and caused by the tortious act or omission of that
14
foreign state or of any official or employee of that foreign state while acting within the scope of
15
his office or employment; except this paragraph shall not apply to — (A) any claim based upon
16
the exercise or performance or the failure to exercise or perform a discretionary function
17
regardless of whether the discretion be abused.” Under the plain language of the statute, this
18
exception does not apply if the plaintiff’s claim were based upon the exercise of discretion by
19
the foreign state (or official or employee while acting within the scope of his office or
20
employment). In determining whether the acts of the foreign state or officials are within the
21
discretionary function exception, the Ninth Circuit considers two factors: (i) whether the
22
government employee had any discretion to act or if there were an element of choice as to
23
appropriate conduct; and (ii) whether the decisions were grounded in social, economic, and
24
political policy, concentrating on the nature of the conduct, rather than the status of the actor.
25
Risk v. Halvorsen, 936 F.2d 393, 395 (9th Cir. 1991). The Ninth Circuit further held in Risk
26
that, “[a]lthough these acts may constitute a crime under California law, it cannot be said that
27
28
8
PDF Page 10
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
For the Northern District of California
Filed 10/23/2007
Page 9 of 10
1
every conceivably illegal act is outside the scope of the discretionary function exception.” Id. at
2
397.
3
United States District Court
Document 50
Here, the Swiss Confederation, the Federal Attorney General of Switzerland,
4
Mr. Sautebin, and Mr. Holtkamp froze plaintiffs’ assets in the course of a criminal
5
investigation. Mr. Sautebin and Mr. Holtkamp were acting within the scope of their offices;
6
they were in charge of the criminal investigation against the Hilsenraths. They had discretion in
7
deciding whether they would conduct the investigation and whether or not to effect the freeze.
8
Furthermore, the decision to enforce Swiss criminal law was grounded in social, economic,
9
and political policy. Because this order finds that defendants’ actions were discretionary and
10
grounded in public policy, the tortious activity exception to the FSIA does not apply.
11
Aside from these statutory exceptions, plaintiffs argue that the principle of jus
12
cogens and the Second Hickenlooper Amendment, 22 U.S.C. 2370(e)(2), prohibit the Swiss
13
Defendants from asserting sovereign immunity in violation of international law. This order
14
finds that plaintiffs’ arguments are misplaced. First, the Ninth Circuit has explicitly stated that
15
“[t]he fact that there has been a violation of jus cogens does not confer jurisdiction under the
16
FSIA.” Siderman, 965 F.2d at 719. Second, the Second Hickenlooper Amendment also does
17
not apply. The Hickenlooper Amendment states:
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no court in the United
States shall decline on the ground of the federal act of state
doctrine to make a determination on the merits giving effect to the
principles of international law in a case in which a claim of title or
other right to property is asserted by any party including a foreign
state (or a party claiming through such state) based upon (or traced
through) a confiscation or other taking after January 1, 1959, by an
act of that state in violation of the principles of international law,
including the principles of compensation and the other standards
set out in this subsection: Provided, That this subparagraph shall
not be applicable (1) in any case in which an act of a foreign state
is not contrary to international law or with respect to a claim of
title or other right to property acquired pursuant to an irrevocable
letter of credit of not more than 180 days duration issued in good
faith prior to the time of the confiscation or other taking, or (2) in
any case with respect to which the President determines that
application of the act of state doctrine is required in that particular
case by the foreign policy interests of the United States and a
27
28
9
PDF Page 11
Case 3:07-cv-02782-WHA
1
Document 50
Filed 10/23/2007
Page 10 of 10
suggestion to this effect is filed on his behalf in that case with the
court.
2
The italicized portions indicate why the Hickenlooper Amendment does not apply to the facts of
3
this case. Plaintiffs’ assets were not frozen in violation of the principles of international law;
4
the Swiss Defendants had ordered the freeze because Mr. Hilsenrath was under a criminal
5
investigation. Moreover, even though the Ninth Circuit has not directly addressed this issue,
6
other circuits have held that the Hickenlooper Amendment only applies to property located in
7
the United States. See, e.g., Empresa Cuvana Exportadora De Azucar y Sus Derivados v.
8
Lamborn & Co., 652 F.2d 231, 237 (2d Cir. 1981); Compania de Gas de Nuevo Laredo, S.A. v.
9
Entex, Inc., 686 F.2d 322, 327 (5th Cir. 1982). Here, the property has remained in Switzerland
10
Given the Court’s conclusion that defendants are immune from suit under the FSIA,
For the Northern District of California
United States District Court
and the other European countries.
11
12
it does not need to reach defendants’ other arguments regarding improper service,
13
insufficient contacts, the Acts of State Doctrine, and plaintiffs’ failed constitutional law claims.
14
CONCLUSION
15
The FSIA provides the exclusive means for a United States federal court to exercise
16
jurisdiction over a foreign state and its instrumentalities. Unless a claim falls under one of the
17
numerous FSIA exceptions, a court will lack subject-matter jurisdiction over the claim.
18
Here, plaintiffs’ claims did not fall under any of the statutory exceptions. The Court has no
19
subject-matter jurisdiction over their claims. Defendants’ motion to dismiss is therefore
20
GRANTED with prejudice. The hearing set for November 1, 2007, is hereby VACATED.
21
22
IT IS SO ORDERED.
23
24
Dated: October 23, 2007.
25
WILLIAM ALSUP
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
26
27
28
10
Rule Not Applied Stated the right rule, then did not follow it
Moderate
Argument Mischaracterized Answered an argument nobody made
Moderate
Fabricated Quotation Put words in quotation marks that the cited source does not contain
Minor
Citation Error Clerical error in a citation
Minor
Citation Error Clerical error in a citation
Minor
Record Misread Got the facts in the record wrong
Minor
Record Misread Got the facts in the record wrong
This is a 10-page order by Judge William Alsup of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, filed October 23, 2007 (ECF 50). It granted a motion to dismiss brought by Switzerland, its Office of the Attorney General, and two Swiss officials: Federal Attorney Brent Holtkamp and Federal Examining Magistrate Gerard Sautebin. The plaintiffs were Oliver Hilsenrath, his wife Hana, five other family members and a family trust, all without lawyers.
This Judicial Analysis works through the opinion and identifies any errors and oversights in the judge's reasoning — authorities misread, arguments left unaddressed, conclusions reached without support. It continues for another 24 paragraphs. Read the entire analysis with PlainSite Pro or Pro Se.
About this analysis. This is automated commentary and opinion by Think Computer Corporation about a public court filing. It was written by an AI model (Claude Opus 5.5) under PlainSite’s scoring method and may contain errors. Each finding identifies the page or source it rests on so readers can judge it for themselves. Last revised October 2, 2026 at 1:12 PM EDT.
Terms such as “Wrong Outcome,” “Reassignment Warranted” or “Apparent Bias” state PlainSite’s assessment under that method. They are not findings by any court, bar or disciplinary authority, and no court has adopted them unless the analysis says so.
This is not legal advice. Reading it creates no attorney-client relationship, and Think Computer Corporation is not a law firm.
The author of this document, a party to the case or anyone else may submit a response or request a correction. Each one is checked against the record, and a corrected analysis carries the date of its latest revision.
Third party AI contribution in government documents
Possible
Document content is reproduced directly from government sources. Some filings in our database may themselves contain AI-generated content submitted by third parties to government agencies.