Freeman v. Schointuch, et al Document 85: Order
Filed August 10, 2001
Back to Freeman v. Schointuch, et al ,
Maryland District Court
Case No. 1:98-cv-00958-JHY
ORDER GRANTING [65-1] motion of Defendant's to Exclude Expert Testimony by Dr. Grace Ziehm, DENYING [81-1] motion of Plaintiff for Reconsideration of the court's 7/9/01 Order, GRANTING [66-1] motion for Summary Judgment in favor of the Defendants on all remaining claims in the case, and DENYING all pending motions not previously ruled on by the Court without prejudice as Moot. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 8/10/01 ) (c/i 8/10/01) (jlb, Deputy Clerk)
No tags have been applied so far. Sign in to add some.
Add a Flag Add a Citation Link To Thread
Link To
1 (3/30/1998): Complaint - COMPLAINT filed; FILING FEE $ 150.00 RECEIPT # B148395 (sls, Deputy Clerk)
6 (4/28/1998): Answer - ANSWER to Complaint by Whitney, Bailey (Attorney Douglas G. Worrall). (c/s) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)
7 (4/29/1998): Answer - ANSWER to Complaint by Richard Schointuch (Attorney David F. Albright Sr.),; jury demand. (c/s) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)
10 (5/1/1998): Answer - ANSWER to Complaint by Gipe Associates (Attorney Pamela D. Huang) (c/s) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)
11 (6/3/1998): Order - INFORMAL LETTER ORDER "ADVISING" counsel of scheduling conference to be held on 6/17/98 at 3:00 p.m. as therein set forth. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Susan K. Gauvey 6/2/98 ) ...
12 (6/4/1998): Answer - ANSWER to Complaint by Bohlin, Cywinski, Jacob J. Gzesh (Attorney Pamela Huang Gilman). (c/s) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)
15 (8/12/1998): Order Referring Case to Magistrate Judge - CONSENT ORDER REFERRING CASE to Magistrate Judge Daniel E. Klein Jr. to conduct any and all further proceedings in the case including trial, ...
17 (1/19/1999): Notice of Appearance - NOTICE of attorney appearance for Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski by Lee & McShane and striking the appearance of Carr Goodson Lee & Warner. (cag, Deputy Clerk...
18 (5/7/1999): Status Report - STATUS REPORT by Bohlin, Cywinski, Jacob J. Gzesh, Gipe Associates, Richard Schointuch, Chrissann Freeman AND APPROVAL J. Grimm 5/3/99. Please prepare a new schedule and...
19 (5/18/1999): Motion for Summary Judgment - MOTION with memorandum in support by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski for Summary Judgment Defendants' Statement of Material Facts not in Dispute and Exh...
20 (5/18/1999): Scheduling Order - AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER (signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 5/17/99) (c/m 5/17/99 jnf) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
21 (6/1/1999): Motion to Compel - MOTION with memorandum in support by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Compel Physical and Mental Examination of Plaintiff and Exhibits 1 & 2 (c/s-Mag. Grimm) (mms...
22 (6/7/1999): Correspondence - CORRESPONDENCE by Court to Counsel for Defendant Gipe Associates returning pleading-Motion for Order to Compel Plaintiff to Disclose Dr. Ziem's Prior Legal Cases. (mms,...
23 (6/10/1999): Motion for Extension of Time - MOTION by Chrissann Freeman to Extend Time for Filing Response to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment (mms, Deputy Clerk)
24 (6/10/1999): Order - ORDER granting [23-1] motion of Plaintiff to Extend Time for Filing Response to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment (Signed: by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 6/7/99 ) (c/m...
25 (6/15/1999): Response in Opposition - RESPONSE by Chrissann Freeman in opposition to [21-1] motion to Compel Physical and Mental Examination of Plaintiff by Bohlin, Cywinski, Gipe Associates and At...
25 (6/15/1999): Motion for Protective Order - CROSS-MOTION by Chrissann Freeman for Protective Order and Attachments. (c/s Mag. Grimm) (jlb, Deputy Clerk)
26 (6/18/1999): Response in Opposition - RESPONSE by Chrissann Freeman in opposition to [19-1] motion of Defendants for Summary Judgment by Bohlin, Cywinski, Gipe Associates and Exhibits (c/s-Mag. Gri...
27 (6/18/1999): Order - ORDER SETTING date for telephone conference (signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 6/18/99) (c/m 6/18/99 jnf) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
28 (6/29/1999): Motion to Substitute Attorney - MOTION by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Substitute Attorney and withdraw Carr Goodson Lee & Warner as attorneys for defendants (mms, Deputy Clerk...
28 (6/29/1999): Order - ORDER granting [28-1] motion to Substitute Attorney and withdraw Carr Goodson Lee & Warner as attorneys for defendants terminated attorney Pamela Huang Gilman for Bohlin, Cywin...
29 (6/30/1999): Reply to Response to Motion - REPLY by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Opposition of Plaintiff to their [21-1] motion to Compel Physical and Mental Examination of Plaintiff with E...
29 (6/30/1999): Motion for Protective Order - CROSS MOTION by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski for Protective Order (with Exhibits 1 - 6 ) (c/s-Mag. Grimm) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
30 (7/2/1999): Reply to Response to Motion - REPLY by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Opposition of Plaintiffs to [19-1] their motion for Summary Judgment and Exhibits 1 & 2 (c/s - Mag. Grimm) (m...
31 (7/15/1999): Order - MEMORANDUM AND ORDER denying [19-1] motion of Defendant for Summary Judgment (signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 7/14/99) (c/m 7/15/99 jnf) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
32 (7/16/1999): Motion to Compel - MOTION with memorandum in support by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski for Order to Compel Plaintiff to Disclose Dr. Grace Ziem's Prior Legal Cases with Exhibits 1 &...
33 (7/16/1999): Order - ORDER SETTING date for Telephone Status Conference as to Rule 35 issue. (signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 7/15/99) (c/m 7/16/99 jnf) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
34 (8/2/1999): Response in Opposition - RESPONSE by Chrissann Freeman in opposition to [32-1] motion for Order to Compel Plaintiff to Disclose Dr. Grace Ziem's Prior Legal Cases by Bohlin, Cywinski, G...
35 (8/10/1999): Reply to Response to Motion - REPLY by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Opposition of Plaintiff to their [32-1] motion for Order to Compel Plaintiff to Disclose Dr. Grace Ziem's Pr...
36 (8/23/1999): Scheduling Order - SECOND AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER (signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 8/23/99) (c/m 8/23/99 jnf) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
37 (8/30/1999): Motion to Compel - MOTION with memorandum in support by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Compel Plaintiff to Produce Grace Ziem, M.D. for Deposition and for Sanctions Certificate o...
38 (9/2/1999): Order - ORDER DIRECTING counsel for plaintiff to produce additional FRCP 26 disclosures relating to medical expert Dr. Grace Ziem. Court has no authority to consider ex parte communicat...
39 (9/20/1999): Motion for Extension of Time - MOTION by Chrissann Freeman to Extend Time to Repond to Defendants' Motion for Order Compelling Plaintiff to Produce Grace Ziem for Deposition (mms, Depu...
40 (9/20/1999): Order - ORDER granting [39-1] motion of Plaintiff to Extend Time to Repond to Defendants' Motion for Order Compelling Plaintiff to Produce Grace Ziem for Deposition and that the Defend...
41 (9/20/1999): Order - ORDER granting [21-1] motion of Defendant to Compel Physical and Mental Examination of Plaintiff and testing which is authorized will not emply any substances known to be toxic...
42 (9/22/1999): Response in Opposition - RESPONSE by Chrissann Freeman in opposition to [37-1] motion of Defendants' for an Order to Compel Plaintiff to Produce Grace Ziem, M.D. for Deposition and for...
42 (9/22/1999): Motion for Miscellaneous Relief - CROSS-MOTION by Chrissann Freeman to Limit Deposition Examination (c/s-Mag. Grimm) (mms, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 09/23/1999
43 (10/5/1999): Motion for Extension of Time - CONSENT MOTION by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Extend Time to file a reply (cc Mag. J. Grimm) (slf, Deputy Clerk)
44 (10/12/1999): Order - ORDER granting [43-1] motion to Extend Time to file a reply is extended to 10/12/99. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 10/5/99) (c/m jf) (slf, Deputy Clerk)
45 (10/12/1999): Reply to Response to Motion - REPLY by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Plaintiff's Opposition to their [37-1] motion to Compel Plaintiff to Produce Grace Ziem, M.D. for Depositio...
46 (10/19/1999): Order - ORDER denying [42-1] cross motion of plaintiff to Limit Deposition Examination, granting in part [37-1] motion to Compel Plaintiff to Produce Grace Ziem, M.D. for Deposition; ...
47 (10/26/1999): Motion for Attorney Fees - MOTION by Bohlin, Cywinski, Gipe Associates for Attorney Fees and costs (cc Mag. J. Grimm) (slf, Deputy Clerk)
48 (11/4/1999): Motion for Extension of Time - JOINT MOTION by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Extend Discovery and Dispositive Motions Deadlines . (c/s) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)
48 (11/4/1999): Order - ORDER granting [48-1] joint motion of defendants Gipe Associates, Inc. and Bohlin, Cywinski & Jackson to Extend Discovery and Dispositive Motions Deadlines by third amended sch...
49 (11/4/1999): Scheduling Order - THIRD Amended SCHEDULING ORDER. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 11/3/99) (c/m 11/5/99) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)
50 (11/12/1999): Response - RESPONSE by Chrissann Freeman to [47-1] motion for Attorney Fees and costs by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski. (c/s Mag. Grimm) (cag, Deputy Clerk)
51 (11/22/1999): Reply to Response to Motion - REPLY by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Plaintiff's response to their [47-1] motion for Attorney Fees and costs (c/s Mag. Grimm) (cag, Deputy Clerk...
52 (12/6/1999): Order - ORDER AWARDING Defendants Attorneys fees for the additional days of deposition ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 12/3/99 ) (c/m 12/6/99-jmf) (cag, Deputy Clerk)
54 (2/11/2000): Scheduling Order - FOURTH AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER and DIRECTING a Status Report to be due on 5/31/00 and Dispositive Motions to be submitted by 6/15/00. ( signed by Magistrate Judge P...
55 (3/6/2000): Motion for Miscellaneous Relief - MOTION with memorandum in support by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski for Order Precluding Grace Ziem, M.D. from Testifying at Trial due to Violation ...
56 (3/14/2000): Order - ORDER REQUESTING Counsel for Plaintiff to submit opposition memorandum to Motion to Exclude Dr. Ziem's testimony by 3/22/00 and any reply by defendants to be submitted by 3/29/...
57 (3/22/2000): Response in Opposition - RESPONSE by Chrissann Freeman in opposition to [55-1] motion for Order Precluding Grace Ziem, M.D. from Testifying at Trial due to Violation of This Court's Or...
58 (3/29/2000): Reply to Response to Motion - REPLY by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Plaintiff's Opposition to their [55-1] motion for Order Precluding Grace Ziem, M.D. from Testifying at Trial...
59 (3/30/2000): Order - MEMORANDUM AND ORDER denying [55-1] motion for Order Precluding Grace Ziem, M.D. from Testifying at Trial due to Violation of This Court's Orders and ORDERING Defendant's Couns...
60 (6/2/2000): Scheduling Order - FIFTH AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 6/1/00) (c/m 6/2/00 jnf) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
61 (6/6/2000): Motion to Withdraw - MOTION by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski for Brandon M. Gladstone to Withdraw as Attorney (mms, Deputy Clerk)
61 (6/6/2000): Order - MARGINAL ORDER granting [61-1] motion for Brandon M. Gladstone to Withdraw as Attorney (Terminated attorney Brandon Gladstone for Bohlin, Cywinski, attorney Brandon Gladstone fo...
62 (10/4/2000): Scheduling Order - SIXTH AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 10/2/00) (c/m 10/3/00 jnf) (jnl, Deputy Clerk)
63 (2/2/2001): Motion to Amend/Correct - JOINT LETTER/MOTION by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski, Chrissann Freeman for Seventh Amended [62-1] Scheduling Order (c/s) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
64 (2/6/2001): Scheduling Order - SEVENTH AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER (signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 2/1/01) (c/m 2/6/01 chambers) (mms, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 02/07/2001
65 (4/5/2001): Motion for Miscellaneous Relief - MOTION with memorandum in support by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Exclude Expert Testimony by Dr. Grace Ziehm with Exhibits 1-20 (c/s-Mag. Grim...
66 (4/13/2001): Motion for Summary Judgment - MOTION with memorandum in support by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski for Summary Judgment with Exhibits 1-6 (c/s-Mag. Grimm) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
67 (4/24/2001): Motion for Extension of Time - MOTION by Chrissann Freeman to Extend Time to File Her Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Exclude Expert Testimony by Dr. Grace Ziem (c/s) (mms, Deputy ...
68 (4/24/2001): Order - ORDER granting [67-1] Motion of Plaintiff to Extend Time to File Her Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Exclude Expert by Dr. Grace Ziem ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. G...
69 (5/7/2001): Response in Opposition - RESPONSE by Chrissann Freeman in opposition to [65-1] Motion of Defendant to Exclude Expert Testimony by Dr. Grace Ziehm by Bohlin, Cywinski, Gipe Associates wi...
70 (5/11/2001): Motion for Extension of Time - MOTION by Chrissann Freeman to Extend Time for Plaintiff to file her Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment (c/s) (mms, Deputy Clerk)
71 (5/11/2001): Order - ORDER granting [70-1] Motion to Extend Time for Plaintiff to file her Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 5/11/01 )...
72 (5/18/2001): Response in Opposition - RESPONSE by Chrissann Freeman in opposition to [66-1] Motion for Summary Judgment by Bohlin, Cywinski, Gipe Associates with Exhibits 1-5 (ENTIRE PLEADING FILED...
73 (5/24/2001): Motion for Extension of Time - CONSENT MOTION by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Extend Time to File Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Exclude (c/s) (mms, D...
74 (5/24/2001): Order - ORDER granting [73-1] Consent Motion of Defendants to Extend Time to File Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Exclude ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. ...
75 (5/25/2001): Reply to Response to Motion - REPLY by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to plaintiff's opposition to their [65-1] motion to Exclude Expert Testimony by Dr. Grace Ziehm and Attachments...
76 (5/31/2001): Order - ORDER GRANTING Defendants' request for Hearing and DIRECTING Counsel to contact Court to schedule Daubert/Kumbo Hearing. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 5/29/01) (c/...
77 (6/1/2001): Motion for Extension of Time - CONSENT MOTION by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Extend Time to file reply to plaintiffs oppposition to their motion for summary judgment (jnl, Depu...
78 (6/4/2001): Order - ORDER EXTENDING the time for defendants to file their reply to 6/8/01 ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 6/1/01 ) (c/i 6/4/01) (jnl, Deputy Clerk)
79 (6/8/2001): Reply to Response to Motion - REPLY by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to plaintiff's opposition to their [66-1] motion for Summary Judgment and Exhibits (c/s USMJ Grimm) (jnl, Deputy...
-- (7/9/2001): Motion Hearing - Motion with memorandum in support by Gipe Associates, Bohlin, Cywinski to Exclude Expert Testimony by Dr. Grace Ziehm. Court rendered Oral Opinion "Granting" Motion for...
81 (7/23/2001): Motion for Reconsideration - MOTION by Chrissann Freeman for Reconsideration of the court's 7/9/01 Order granting defendants' motion to exclude the testimony of Dr. Grace Ziem . (c/s) ...
82 (7/31/2001): Order - ORDER REQUESTING Defendants to withhold filing of opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Reconsideration. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Paul W. Grimm 7/30/01) (c/i 7/31/01 ms) (mm...
There was a problem locating the requested document.
PDF Page
1
PlainSite Cover Page
PDF Page
2
Case 1:98-cv-00958-JHY Document 85 _~— Filed 08/10/2001 Page 1 of 1
nn FRED
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT me RCE RECENT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND AUG 19 ann
CHRISSANN FREEMAN CLERK US. OTRICT COU
R ' in OISTRICT OF MARYLAND
Plaintiff oePur
v. : CIVIL ACTION NO. Y-98-958
RICHARD SCHOINTUCH, et al.
Defendants
ORDER
For the reagons stated on the record during the July 9, 2001
Rule 104(a) hearing, and in the Court's memorandum to counsel,
issued August 10, 2001, it is this [co aay of August 2001, hereby
ORDERED:
1. That Defendant's Motion to Exclude Expert Testimony by
Dr. Grace Zeim is GRANTED;
2. That Plaintiff's Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED;
3. That Summary Judgment is GRANTED in favor of the
Defendants on all remaining claims in the case;
4, That all pending motions not previously ruled on by the
Court are DENIED, without prejudice as moot;
5. that the Clerk is directed to CLOSE this case; and
6. that the Clerk is directed to mail a copy of this Order
and the foregoing Memorandum to couns of record.
Paul 1 Grimm \
United States Magistrate Judge
may