Name: Rosenblatt, et al v. Exxon Company, et al :: Maryland District Court :: Federal Civil Lawsuit No. 1:90-cv-01186-JRH
Creator: Maryland District Court
Published: 1990-04-27
License: https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/
Keywords: court documents, legal case, docket, PACER, Maryland District Court

Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription.

--	Filed: 11/1/1991, Entered: 11/20/1991	Terminated Case
	Case closed (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


61	Filed: 8/19/1991, Entered: 8/23/1991	Order
	ORDER (dated 8/14/91), "ADOPTING" Report and Recommendation of Magistrate Judge; granting in part, denying in part [32-1] motion for Summary Judgment; "GRANTING" Motion of Defendant Exxon for Summary Judgment as to Courts V,VII,VIII and IX (fraud and tortious interference) and as to any claim Mr. Rosenblatt may be asserting in Count VI (breach of contract); "DENYING" Motion of Defendant for Summary Judgment as to Counts I-IV, and VI (as to Mr. Wenger), without prejudice to renewal; "AFFIRMING" the dismissal of the cross-claim, without prejudice; "GRANTING" Motion of Plaintiff Rosenblatt for Leave to Amend the Complaint and to add new parties, except as to proposed New Counts IX,X,XI,XII (fraud and and tortious interference), "DENYING" as to which leave to Amend; "DENYING" Motion of Plaintiff Rosenblatt for Protective Order and Motion to Modify Scheduling Order as Moot; "DENYING" Motion of Plaintiff Rosenblatt for Partial Summary Judgment, and Motion of Plaintiff Wenger for Partial Summary Judgment without prejudice to renewal; "REMANDING" case to state court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1447(e); "CLOSING" the case. ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (c/m 8/20/91, daf) MICROFILM DATE 8/23/91 (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


60	Filed: 8/5/1991, Entered: 8/6/1991	Objection to Report and Recommendations
	OBJECTION by Plaintiff B. Earl Wenger to [59-1] report and recommendations. (c/s) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


59	Filed: 7/18/1991, Entered: 7/18/1991	Order on Report and Recommendations
	REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Magistrate Catherine C. Blak e . (dated 7/17/91) Case no longer referred to Magistrate Catherine C. Blake Objections to R and R due by 7/29/91 (c/m 7/17/91, bc) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


58	Filed: 4/1/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Order
	Request (Blake, U.S. Mag/Judge) and ORDER "Staying" discovery schedule and "Postponing" trial date pending outcome of decisions on motions ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


57	Filed: 3/28/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion for Protective Order
	MOTION with memorandum in support by Thomas Rosenblatt for Protective Order and Local rule 104.7 certificate (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


56	Filed: 3/25/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Reply to Response to Motion
	SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM REPLY by Thomas Rosenblatt to supplemental response to [22-1] motion for Leave to File amended complaint and to add additional parties (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


55	Filed: 3/22/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Support of Motion
	SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM by Exxon Corporation in support of [32-1] motion for Summary Judgment (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


54	Filed: 3/19/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition to Motion
	SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM by Exxon Corporation in opposition to [22-1] motion for Leave to File amended complaint and to add additional parties and exhibits A thru D. (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


53	Filed: 3/19/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion for Protective Order
	MOTION with memorandum in support by Exxon Corporation for Protective Order and exhibit A (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


52	Filed: 3/19/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition to Motion
	SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM by B. Earl Wenger in opposition to [32-1] motion for Summary Judgment (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


51	Filed: 3/12/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Support of Motion
	SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM by Thomas Rosenblatt in support of [22-1] motion for Leave to File amended complaint and to add additional parties (Exhibits A thru K received 3/13/91) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


50	Filed: 3/11/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Notice of Appearance
	NOTICE of attorney appearance for Exxon Corporation by Ann B. Sarno (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


49	Filed: 3/11/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Remark
	Supplemental exhibits to opposition of Plaintiff, Wenger, to motion of Defendant, Exxon (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


48	Filed: 3/7/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 3/7/1991	Order
	ORDER granting [48-1] motion for Vernon Sevier to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Norman P. Ramsey ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


48	Filed: 3/7/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 3/7/1991	Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice
	MOTION by Exxon Corporation for Vernon Sevier to Appear Pro Hac Vice (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


47	Filed: 3/7/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 3/7/1991	Order
	ORDER granting [47-1] motion to Dismiss Count V, VII, VIII, and IX of complaint with prejudice ( signed by Judge Norman P. Ramsey ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


47	Filed: 3/7/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 3/7/1991	Motion to Dismiss
	MOTION by B. Earl Wenger, Exxon Corporation to Dismiss Count V, VII, VIII, and IX (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


46	Filed: 3/5/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 3/5/1991	Order
	ORDER granting [46-1] motion to Withdraw [19-1] motion for Protective Order ( signed by Magistrate Catherine C. Blake ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


46	Filed: 3/5/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 3/5/1991	Motion to Withdraw
	MOTION by B. Earl Wenger to Withdraw [19-1] motion for Protective Order (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/5/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Remark
	Held Sub Curia (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/5/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Remark
	Argument of Counsel (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/5/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Oral Motion
	MOTION in open court by B. Earl Wenger to Dismiss cross claim of Plaintiff Rosenblatt "Granted" Held Sub curia as to whether dismissal is with or without prejudice (Paper #16) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 3/5/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion Hearing
	Motion hearing held before Blake, U.S. Mag. re: [33-1] motion for partial Summary Judgment, [32-1] motion for Summary Judgment, [31-1] motion for partial Summary Judgment , [25-1] motion to modify scheduling order , [24-1] motion to amend complaint, [19-1] motion for Protective Order at , [16-1] motion to Dismiss cross claim (ER: Goldsmith) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


45	Filed: 2/28/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Support of Motion
	SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM of points and authorities by B. Earl Wenger in support of [16-1] motion to Dismiss cross claim and exhibits 1 thr 4. (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


44	Filed: 2/4/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 2/4/1991	Order
	ORDER granting [44-1] motion to Withdraw [40-1] opposition response only as it pertains to Wenger's claims for tortious interference with contract (Count VII) and with prospective business relations (Count VIII) ( signed by Magistrate Catherine C. Blake ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


44	Filed: 2/4/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 2/4/1991	Motion to Withdraw
	MOTION by B. Earl Wenger to Withdraw [40-1] opposition response (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


43	Filed: 1/30/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Order Referring Case to Magistrate Judge
	AMENDED ORDER REFERRING CASE to Magistrate Catherine C. Blake for hearing, propoesed findings of fact and making recommendations as to dispositive pretrial matters ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


42	Filed: 1/17/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Order Referring Case to Magistrate Judge
	ORDER REFERRING CASE to Magistrate Catherine C. Blake for hearing and determination of non dispositive pretrial matters, specifically all motions ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


41	Filed: 1/11/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Support of Motion
	MEMORANDUM by Exxon Corporation in support of [32-1] motion for Summary Judgment (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


40	Filed: 1/7/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition
	RESPONSE by B. Earl Wenger in opposition to [32-1] motion for Summary Judgment and memorandum (Withdrawn: See Pleading No. 44) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


39	Filed: 1/3/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 1/3/1991	Order
	ORDER granting [39-1] motion to Extend Time to reply to opposition of plaintiff to its motion for summary judgment till 1/11/91 ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


39	Filed: 1/3/1991, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 1/3/1991	Motion for Extension of Time
	MOTION by Exxon Corporation to Extend Time to reply to opposition of plaintiff to its motion for summary judgment till 1/11/91 (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


38	Filed: 12/21/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition to Motion
	MEMORANDUM by Thomas Rosenblatt in opposition to [32-1] motion for Summary Judgment and exhibits A and B. (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


37	Filed: 12/21/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 12/21/1990	Order
	ORDER granting [37-1] motion to Extend Time to file opposition to motion for summary judgment to 12/31/90 ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


37	Filed: 12/21/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 12/21/1990	Motion for Extension of Time
	MOTION by B. Earl Wenger to Extend Time to file opposition to motion for summary judgment to 12/31/90 (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


36	Filed: 12/17/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition to Motion
	MEMORANDUM by Exxon Corporation in opposition to [31-1] motion for partial Summary Judgment (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


35	Filed: 12/17/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition to Motion
	MEMORANDUM by Exxon Corporation in opposition to [33-1] motion for partial Summary Judgment (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


34	Filed: 12/11/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 12/11/1990	Order
	ORDER granting [34-1] motion to Extend Time to reply to motion of defendant for summary judgment to 12/21/90 ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


34	Filed: 12/11/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 12/11/1990	Motion for Extension of Time
	MOTION by Thomas Rosenblatt to Extend Time to reply to motion of defendant for summary judgment to 12/21/90 (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


33	Filed: 12/4/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion for Summary Judgment
	MOTION with memorandum in support by B. Earl Wenger for partial Summary Judgment and attachments. (c/s) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


32	Filed: 11/30/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 8/19/1991	Motion for Summary Judgment
	MOTION with memorandum in support by Exxon Corporation for Summary Judgment , request for hearing and exhibits A thru F. (c/s) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


31	Filed: 11/30/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion for Summary Judgment
	MOTION by Thomas Rosenblatt for partial Summary Judgment , Request for hearing and exhibits A thru F. (c/s) (Exhibits Filed Separately) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


30	Filed: 11/26/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Reply to Response to Motion
	REPLY by Thomas Rosenblatt to response to [22-1] motion for Leave to File amended complaint and to add additional parties and request for hearing. (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


29	Filed: 11/19/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 11/19/1990	Order
	ORDER granting [29-1] motion to Strike appearance of Linda Richardson ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


29	Filed: 11/19/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 11/19/1990	Motion to Strike
	MOTION by Exxon Corporation to Strike appearance of Linda Richardson (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


28	Filed: 11/14/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition to Motion
	MEMORANDUM by Exxon Corporation in opposition to [25-1] motion to modify scheduling order and exhibits A and B (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


27	Filed: 11/14/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition to Motion
	MEMORANDUM by Exxon Corporation in opposition to [22-1] motion for Leave to File amended complaint and to add additional parties (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


26	Filed: 11/8/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Scheduling Order
	SCHEDULING ORDER setting Pretrial conference for 9:15 5/7/91 ; Pretrial order to be submitted on or before 4/29/91 ; Voir Dire/Jury instructions due 5/13/91 Jury trial set for 10:00 5/20/91 ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


25	Filed: 10/31/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion for Miscellaneous Relief
	MOTION by Thomas Rosenblatt to modify scheduling order and affidavit (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription.

24	Filed: 10/31/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion for Miscellaneous Relief
	MOTION by Thomas Rosenblatt to withhold issuance of summons (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


23	Filed: 10/31/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Amended Complaint
	PROPOSED AMENDED COMPLAINT by Thomas Rosenblatt and request for jury trial, (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


22	Filed: 10/31/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion for Leave to File
	MOTION with memorandum in support by Thomas Rosenblatt for Leave to File amended complaint and to add additional parties (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


21	Filed: 10/19/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Notice of Appearance
	NOTICE of attorney appearance for Thomas Rosenblatt by G. Macy Nelson (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


20	Filed: 10/15/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Response in Opposition to Motion
	MEMORANDUM by Exxon Corporation in opposition to [19-1] motion for Protective Order and exhibit A (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


19	Filed: 10/2/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion for Protective Order
	MOTION with memorandum in support by B. Earl Wenger for Protective Order (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


18	Filed: 9/28/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 9/28/1990	Order
	ORDER granting [18-1] motion to Extend Time to complete discovery to 10/31/90 ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


18	Filed: 9/28/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 9/28/1990	Motion for Extension of Time
	MOTION to Extend Time to complete discovery to 10/31/90 (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


17	Filed: 9/26/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Scheduling Order
	REVISED SCHEDULING ORDER ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


16	Filed: 9/26/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Motion to Dismiss
	MOTION with memorandum in support by B. Earl Wenger to Dismiss cross claim (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


15	Filed: 9/26/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Crossclaim
	CROSSCLAIM by Thomas Rosenblatt against B. Earl Wenger (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


14	Filed: 7/26/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 7/26/1990	Order
	ORDER granting [14-1] motion to Extend Time to file motion to compel ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


14	Filed: 7/26/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 7/26/1990	Motion for Extension of Time
	MOTION by Exxon Corporation to Extend Time to file motion to compel (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


13	Filed: 6/16/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Order
	MARGINAL ORDER granting [11-1] motion to Strike appearance of Steinkoenig as counsel (See Paper No. 11) ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


12	Filed: 6/1/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Scheduling Order
	SCHEDULING ORDER ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


11	Filed: 6/1/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 6/16/1990	Motion to Strike
	MOTION by B. Earl Wenger to Strike appearance of Steinkoenig as counsel (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


10	Filed: 6/1/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 6/1/1990	Order
	ORDER granting [10-1] motion to Substitute Attorney terminated attorney Gary A. Wais for B. Earl Wenger, attorney Stephen L. Snyder for B. Earl Wenger, attorney Stephen L. Snyder for Thomas Rosenblatt Added Kristine M. L. Steinkoenig ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


10	Filed: 6/1/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 6/1/1990	Motion to Substitute Attorney
	MOTION by Thomas Rosenblatt, B. Earl Wenger to Substitute Attorney (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


9	Filed: 5/29/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 5/29/1990	Order
	ORDER granting [9-1] motion for Paul F. Liebman to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


9	Filed: 5/29/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 5/29/1990	Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice
	MOTION by Exxon Company, USA for Paul F. Liebman to Appear Pro Hac Vice (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


8	Filed: 5/29/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 5/29/1990	Order
	ORDER granting [8-1] motion for William J. Stack to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


8	Filed: 5/29/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991, Terminated: 5/29/1990	Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice
	MOTION by Exxon Corporation for William J. Stack to Appear Pro Hac Vice (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


7	Filed: 5/22/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Scheduling Order
	SCHEDULING ORDER ( signed by Judge John R. Hargrove ) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


6	Filed: 5/16/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Remark
	Local rule 103.3 statement of Plaintiff (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 5/3/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Remark
	Notice of filing mailed to counsel (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


5	Filed: 4/30/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Answer
	ANSWER to Complaint by Exxon Corporation (Attorney John E. Griffith Jr.), (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


4	Filed: 4/27/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Summons Issued
	SUMMONS(ES) issued for Exxon Corporation (copy-filed in Prince Georges County) (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


3	Filed: 4/27/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Jury Demand
	DEMAND for jury trial by Thomas Rosenblatt, B. Earl Wenger (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


3	Filed: 4/27/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Complaint
	COMPLAINT, Interrogatories and request for production of documents filed; (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


2	Filed: 4/27/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	~Notice (other)
	NOTICE of filing of notice of removal (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


1	Filed: 4/27/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Notice of Removal
	NOTICE OF REMOVAL; FILING FEE $ 120 RECEIPT # 73287 (mdd, Deputy Clerk)


--	Filed: 4/27/1990, Entered: 4/20/1991	Remark
	ALL OF THE ABOVE PLEADINGS FILED IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR PRINCE GEORGES COUNTY (mdd, Deputy Clerk)

AI text generation	None
AI document summarization	None
AI-augmented search	None
AI-generated images	None
AI chat or Q&A interface	Linkable via MCP
Third party AI contribution in government documents	Possible