SINGH v. TESLA, INC., et al. Document 1: Document

Filed March 7, 2023

BackBack to SINGH v. TESLA, INC., et al., Superior Court of California, County of Alameda Case No. 23CV028895

Complaint Filed by: Vincent Singh (Plaintiff) As to: Tesla, Inc. (Defendant); Tesla Motors, Inc. (Defendant)

Tags No tags have been applied so far. Sign in to add some.

SpacePlain English Get Plain EnglishSpaceComplaint Analysis Get Complaint AnalysisSpaceAdd a Flag Add a FlagSpaceAdd a Citation Add a CitationSpaceLink To Thread Link To Thread

  Source Document Tab Overlap Formatted Derived Text Tab Overlap Raw Derived Text Right End
PDF Page
1
PlainSite Cover Page
PDF Page
2
4 VINCENT CALDERONE (State Bar No. 164672) CALDERONE LAW FIRM 2321 Rosecrans Ave., Suite 1265 El Segundo, California 90245 Telephone: (424) 348-8290 vcalderone@calemploymentattorney.com 5 Attorneys for Plaintiff, VINCENT SINGH 1 2 3 6 7 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 8 FOR THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 ) Case No. ) VINCENT SINGH, an individual, ) COMPLAINT FOR: ) ) 1. RACE /COLOR /ANCESTRY DISCRIMINATION (GOVT. Plaintiff, ) CODE §12940, ET SEQ.); ) ) 2. RELIGIOUS DISCRIMINATION vs. ) (GOVT. CODE §12940, et seq.); ) ) 3. DISABILITY DISCRIMINATION (GOVT. CODE §12940, et seq.); TESLA, INC., a corporation; TESLA ) MOTORS, INC., a corporation and DOES ) 4. RACE /COLOR /ANCESTRY 1-50, inclusive, ) HARASSMENT (GOVT. CODE ) §12940, ET SEQ.); ) Defendants. ) 5. RELIGIOUS HARASSMENT (GOVT. CODE §12940, et seq.); ) ) 6. DISABILITY HARASSMENT ) (GOVT. CODE §12940, et seq.); ) ) 7. FAILURE TO ACCOMMODATE (GOVT. CODE §12940, et seq.); ) ) 8. FAILURE TO ENGAGE IN THE ) INTERACTIVE PROCESS ) (GOVT. CODE §12940, et seq.); ) ) 9. RETALIATION (GOVT. CODE §12940, et seq.); ) ) 10. FAILURE TO PREVENT ) HARASSMENT AND ) RETALIATION (GOVT. CODE ) §12940, et seq.); ) ) 11. WHISTLEBLOWER RETALIATION (LABOR CODE ) §6310); ) 1 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
3
) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 1 2 3 4 5 6 12. WHISTLEBLOWER RETALIATION (LABOR CODE §1102.5); 13. FAILURE TO SAFEGUARD MEDICAL INFORMATION (CIV. CODE §§ 56.20, 56.35, 56.36; and 14. WRONGFUL TERMINATION IN VIOLATION OF PUBLIC POLICY. 7 8 DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL 9 10 11 PLAINTIFF Vincent Singh alleges as follows on knowledge as to himself and his own acts, and on information and belief as to all other matters: 12 13 I. 1. PARTIES At all times mentioned herein, PLAINTIFF Vincent Singh (hereinafter, 14 “PLAINTIFF”) was an individual employed by Defendants Tesla, Inc. and Tesla Motors, 15 Inc. (hereinafter, collectively referred to as “DEFENDANTS”) as a Production Associate. 16 PLAINTIFF’ job was to work in DEFENDANTS’ factory located at 47700 Kato Road, in 17 the City of Fremont and County of Alameda, State of California, assembling components for 18 electrical batteries. PLAINTIFF was, at all relevant times, a resident in the County of San 19 Joaquin, State of California. PLAINTIFF is of mixed racial heritage, including South Asian 20 (Indian), Mexican, African American, and Fijian ancestry. PLAINTIFF practices the 21 Christian faith. 22 2. Tesla, Inc. and Tesla Motors, Inc. were, and still are, corporations duly 23 organized and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, are registered with the 24 Secretary of State of the State of California and are authorized to do business in the State of 25 California and are the joint employers of PLAINTIFF. At all times during the relevant time 26 period of liability, DEFENDANTS have done business within the County of Alameda, and 27 have, among other things, employed approximately 10,000 persons in the County of 28 2 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
4
1 Alameda, who have received wages and paychecks during the liability period, and 2 maintained a production facility of approximately 5.5 million square feet in the City of 3 Fremont, where PLAINTIFF worked, and maintain a significant corporate office, formerly 4 the corporate headquarters, in the City of Palo Alto, County of Santa Clara. 5 3. At all material times herein mentioned each of the Defendants named in the 6 caption and each Doe Defendant was an agent, employee and/or partner of the remaining 7 Defendants and, in doing the things herein alleged, was acting within the scope of such 8 agency, employment and/or partnership with the permission, authority and consent of his or 9 her co-Defendants. 10 4. Each business entity of Defendants, whether corporate, partnership, joint 11 venture, unincorporated association, public entity, or other business entity of unknown form, 12 and whether named or sued by fictitious name, is and, at all times mentioned herein was, in 13 some manner involved in the ownership and/or operation of the Defendants’ corporations 14 herein. Each of the individual Defendants, whether named or sued by fictitious name, 15 whether acting in an individual capacity or within or without their capacity as managerial 16 agent, servant, employee, officer, director, partner, or joint venturer of each of the business 17 entity of Defendants aforementioned in committing the acts or omissions as alleged herein 18 which resulted in damage to PLAINTIFF, is and at all times mentioned herein was also in 19 some manner involved in the ownership and/or operation of said Defendants’ corporations if 20 any, and in doing the things herein alleged was acting with the permission and consent and/or 21 knowledge, authorization or ratification of each of the business entity Defendants mentioned 22 above, unless otherwise stated herein. 23 5. PLAINTIFF is ignorant of the true names and capacities of Defendants sued 24 herein as Does 1 through 50, inclusive, and therefore sues these Defendants by such fictitious 25 names. PLAINTIFF will amend this complaint to allege the true names and capacities of 26 said Defendants when the same has been ascertained. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes 27 and thereon alleges that each of the fictitiously named Defendants is responsible in some 28 3 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
5
1 manner for the acts complained of herein. Unless otherwise stated, all references to named 2 Defendants shall include the Doe Defendants as well. II. 3 4 6. FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS PLAINTIFF was hired by DEFENDANTS through Indeed.com, an online 5 recruiting platform. During the interview and hiring process, PLAINTIFF informed 6 DEFENDANTS’ recruiter that he suffered from asthma. Once PLAINTIFF began working 7 for DEFENDANTS, his asthma malady was never brought up as a matter to be considered in 8 his work assignment until he complained about its being aggravated, as described in greater 9 depth, below. 10 7. PLAINTIFF began working for DEFENDANTS on or about October 11, 2021. 11 PLAINTIFF was hired as a production associate. In the department where PLAINTIFF was 12 assigned, there are giant tub mixers that combine powders for making battery components. 13 PLAINTIFF was tasked with whisking the powder and then inserting it into a machine, 14 which was part of production line for making batteries used in DEFENDANTS’ electric 15 motor vehicles. 16 8. During his employment with DEFENDANTS, PLAINTIFF performed as 17 expected or better, except when he was punitively assigned to dysfunctional equipment that 18 limited his productivity, as described in greater depth, below. 19 9. At the time, PLAINTIFF was unaware that he was being exposed to anode 20 powder, which caused him harmful health effects and aggravated his asthma. PLAINTIFF 21 first complained to his supervisor, Mr. Rohit Sharma (“Sharma”) about this; Sharma was 22 dismissive and argumentative in response to PLAINTIFF’s complaints. PLAINTIFF 23 continued to work mixing powders, despite the continued aggravation of his asthma. 24 10. After spending about two months in this initial department mixing anode 25 powder, PLAINTIFF complained to his manager, Opinder Baines (“Baines”), orally about 26 his asthma condition as it worsened. 27 28 4 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
6
1 11. Baines, who PLAINTIFF is informed and believes is also of Indian descent, 2 asked why PLAINTIFF wore a turban, and criticized his faith by telling him he is “not really 3 a Christian.” 4 12. After approximately three months of employment with DEFENDANTS, 5 PLAINTIFF was moved to a different work area where automatic feeders that assisted with 6 mixing process were not properly working. PLAINTIFF had to manually mix the powder in 7 a larger feeder, which caused the anode powder to form a dust cloud above the mixture. 8 PLAINTIFF breathed in this dust, which caused him several health issues including hives, 9 nausea, migraines, shortness of breath, and severely exacerbated his asthma. 10 13. In or around December 2021, PLAINTIFF complained to his supervisor, 11 Sharma, that the powder was causing him significant harm, that he already had asthma and 12 was suffering additional symptoms. 13 14. Rather than address PLAINTIFF’s health concerns, Sharma mocked 14 PLAINTIFF, telling him to “stop crying like a baby.” Sharma also insulted PLAINTIFF due 15 to his multi-racial background, making comments like “just feed the powder, little mutt,” and 16 calling him “stupid” and “retarded.” 17 15. After additional complaints by PLAINTIFF, Sharma told PLAINTIFF to get a 18 note from a doctor. PLAINTIFF went to his doctor at his local Kaiser Permanente hospital. 19 PLAINTIFF received a note from the doctor saying that due to his medical condition, 20 PLAINTIFF needed to stay away from the powder. 21 16. PLAINTIFF returned to work the following day and gave the doctor’s note, 22 containing private medical information, to his team lead, a man known to him as Jack K. 23 Jack K. told PLAINTIFF that he would give the doctor’s note to a supervisor. 24 25 17. A few minutes later, a coworker handed the doctor’s note to PLAINTIFF, saying he found it on the floor, where it was covered in dirt and black powder. 26 27 28 5 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
7
1 18. PLAINTIFF took the note to Sharma, explaining how it had been found on the 2 floor, and complained that his private medical information was being treated negligently. 3 Sharma ignored the complaints but took the note. 4 19. The following day, Sharma informed PLAINTIFF that he would take the 5 doctor’s note to Human Resources and directed PLAINTIFF to continue working in the same 6 location with the noxious powders. PLAINTIFF suffered an outbreak of hives, a severe 7 migraine, and respiratory difficulties, but continued to work. 8 9 20. On the third day after PLAINTIFF procured the doctor’s note, Sharma returned it to him and informed him that he was required to deliver it to HR himself. PLAINTIFF 10 took a photo of the doctor’s note and emailed it to Lewis Botsford (“Botsford”), a senior HR 11 staffer with DEFENDANTS. 12 21. Botsford did not respond until approximately 10 days later, two weeks after 13 PLAINTIFF received the doctor’s note, to inform PLAINTIFF that he was required to fill 14 out forms requesting accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”). In 15 the two weeks between PLAINTIFF’s securing the note to Botsford’s response, PLAINTIFF 16 was required to continue working in the same workspace with the same noxious powders that 17 the doctor told PLAINTIFF he should avoid—a fact of which Sharma was aware as soon as 18 PLAINTIFF received the doctor’s note. 19 22. PLAINTIFF attempted to get the ADA application filled, but there was a 20 problem between PLAINTIFF’s doctor and DEFENDANTS’ HR department, the details of 21 which were never fully explained to PLAINTIFF. DEFENDANTS made no further effort to 22 help PLAINTIFF resolve the problem and HR staff told him that they were not allowed to 23 help him fill out the paperwork. 24 23. In or about mid-December 2021, PLAINTIFF was assigned to work with a 25 more toxic powder, which required him to dress in a papr hazmat suit. This made it difficult 26 for PLAINTIFF to breathe, causing additional flare-ups of his health problems. The air 27 filtration system that feeds air into the suit further aggravated his situation and triggered 28 6 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
8
1 asthma attacks. PLAINTIFF sent an email to Botsford complaining about this transfer, its 2 impact on his health, and his belief that the transfer was meant to be an act of harassment by 3 his supervisors. PLAINTIFF was transferred back to his regular position within a few days. 4 24. While the problem with HR and the ADA application was ongoing, 5 PLAINTIFF continued to work in the same workspace with the same noxious powders, 6 which continued to cause him significant health problems. When PLAINTIFF complained to 7 his supervisors about the health problems, they continued to ignore his complaints, unless 8 they were belittling him for his health problems and making slurs about his mixed-race 9 heritage. PLAINTIFF complained to Botsford about these insults, but Botsford did not 10 11 respond. 25. Upon Botsford’s failure to respond to PLAINTIFF’s complaints, PLAINTIFF 12 contacted Botsford’s superior, HR Manager Tracy Thomas (“Thomas”). After PLAINTIFF 13 contacted Thomas, Botsford responded finally. PLAINTIFF told Botsford that he believed 14 Sharma was being told of PLAINTIFF’s complaints about Sharma’s abusive behavior, 15 because Sharma began acting with greater hostility against PLAINTIFF. 16 26. On or about December 27, 2021, PLAINTIFF complained to DEFENDANTS’ 17 employee relations staffer Benita Patel (“Patel”) about the ongoing abuse by his superiors. 18 This abuse included racial taunts, calling him “carpet boy” and “brown boy” in reference to 19 his Asian heritage, while also telling him to “quit acting like a nigger” and “stop 20 complaining, it’s just powder.” 21 27. On or about December 27, 2021, PLAINTIFF was called into a meeting with 22 his supervisors Baines, Corona, and Sharma. During this meeting, PLAINTIFF was asked 23 why he refused to work with the more toxic powder. PLAINTIFF explained that the papr 24 hazmat suit and air filtration system made his breathing difficult and triggered asthma 25 attacks, which constitutes a bona fide complaint about workplace health and safety. Later 26 that day, PLAINTIFF received an email from Sharma purporting to memorialize the 27 28 7 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
9
1 meeting, but which grossly mischaracterized what had occurred and accused PLAINTIFF of 2 insubordination for refusing the assignment. 3 28. Around this time, PLAINTIFF reached such a level of stress and anxiety that 4 he reached out directly to DEFENDANTS’ CEO Elon Musk to inform him about the 5 constant abuse, harassment, and retaliation he faced. Musk did not respond. 6 29. Approximately two weeks after PLAINTIFF made his complaints to Botsford, 7 Thomas, and Patel, he was moved under a different supervisor, Omar Corona (“Corona”). 8 However, PLAINTIFF worked with the same noxious powder and his health condition 9 continued to suffer. 10 30. PLAINTIFF regularly overheard Corona using racial and ethnic slurs toward 11 other employees, including telling a Caucasian employee, “Get back in there, whitey, you’re 12 acting like a nigger.” Corona continued to use abusive language and racial slurs against 13 PLAINTIFF, calling him “carpet boy” or “brown boy” no fewer than 20 times. 14 31. Approximately one month after PLAINTIFF made his complaints to Botsford, 15 Thomas, and Patel, he was moved to another workspace where he was not required to work 16 with the noxious powders. His health condition steadily improved, including fewer 17 respiratory issues. 18 32. The reprieve was short-lived, as PLAINTIFF was returned to the powder- 19 mixing position three weeks later. His health began to deteriorate almost immediately upon 20 his return. 21 33. A short time after being reassigned to the powder mixing position, as his health 22 condition worsened, PLAINTIFF approached his team lead Jack K. and asked to go home on 23 a day when he was feeling especially ill. Jack K. told PLAINTIFF that if he left, he would 24 receive a “point” in DEFENDANTS’ attendance system. In this system, 10 points in a six- 25 month period is grounds for termination. 26 27 28 8 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
10
1 34. In addition to continuing the disregard for PLAINTIFF’s health concerns, Jack 2 K. also continued the pattern and practice of racial hostility, including calling PLAINTIFF a 3 “terrorist” in reference to his South Asian heritage. 4 5 6 35. On one such occasion, on or about January 3, 2022, PLAINTIFF was so upset that he had to repair to a restroom to keep from breaking down publicly. 36. As PLAINTIFF was returning to work from the restroom, he was approached 7 by Baines, who asked if PLAINTIFF were a “female,” as though that would be a reason for 8 him to spend so much time in the restroom. When PLAINTIFF responded that he was not 9 feeling well, Baines called him “a disgrace to Indians” and a “stupid Christian.” 10 37. Later that day, PLAINTIFF sent Patel an email recounting the above incident 11 with Baines, describing it as an example of harassment, intimidation, and retaliation by his 12 supervisors. Not long after sending his email, PLAINTIFF received an email from Baines 13 threatening discipline for his use of the restroom. PLAINTIFF replied to Baines and the 14 other supervisors cc’d on the email that this was another incident of harassment, 15 intimidation, and retaliation. 16 38. PLAINTIFF faced other incidents of harassment and retaliation, and specific 17 events meant to cause him public humiliation and ostracism. On at least three occasions, 18 PLAINTIFF’s department had pizza parties to which PLAINTIFF was not invited, and at 19 least one of which PLAINTIFF was specifically told he was excluded from and was barred 20 from entering the room. 21 39. In or about early February 2022, PLAINTIFF was informed that he would be 22 transferred to the winding department. PLAINTIFF had not requested a transfer. 23 PLAINTIFF later learned that the same day he was transferred out of it, everybody in the 24 department was given a $2.00 per hour pay increase. 25 40. In addition to being racially harassed and socially outcast, PLAINTIFF was 26 subjected to sabotage in his work. On at least three occasions, while PLAINTIFF was mixing 27 powder, he requested assistance from a coworker to replenish his powder supply. When the 28 9 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
11
1 coworker went to get more powder, the supervisor, Wade Bolinger (“Bolinger”), stopped the 2 coworker and engaged him in a conversation. Meanwhile, PLAINTIFF continued to yell to 3 the coworker that he was running out of powder. At some point, Baines came by to tell 4 PLAINTIFF that he was running low on powder and should have replenished his supply. 5 Before PLAINTIFF could explain that Bolinger was preventing the coworker from getting 6 more powder, Baines told PLAINTIFF he was doing a poor job and walked away. 7 41. In the winding department, where DEFENDANTS transferred PLAINTIFF to 8 avoid paying him a $2.00 per hour wage increase, there are 12 machines that wind, but some 9 produce worse or better yields of “jelly rolls”—internal battery components—based on their 10 current state of repair. In addition to receiving insufficient training on the winding machines, 11 PLAINTIFF alleges that he was assigned to machines in various states of disrepair that 12 routinely produced a smaller number of jelly rolls. PLAINTIFF believes this was deliberate 13 and another attempt to sabotage his work. 14 42. PLAINTIFF had to leave his work area about fifteen times per day to pick up 15 cathode and anode pancakes, which he had to retrieve from a warehouse on other side of 16 department. This effort constituted a five-minute walk to the supply, then sometimes a wait 17 on the material. On average, it was a 10-minute process followed by a five-minute walk back 18 to his workstation; he did this approximately 15 times per day. From that point, it took 19 additional five minutes to resupply and prepare his workstation to operate again. 20 43. At least one time, Bolinger confronted PLAINTIFF, saying PLAINTIFF had 21 been missing for a long time. PLAINTIFF explained that he was resupplying and accounted 22 for his time, all tasks that fell within his scope of duties. Bolinger in response said he did not 23 care and told PLAINTIFF he was getting a verbal warning. 24 44. The harassment continued with repeated accusations that PLAINTIFF was 25 unjustifiably away from his workstation when he was busy securing supplies necessary for 26 doing his work. Bolinger would call Baines, who would wait for PLAINTIFF, and upon his 27 return, falsely accuse him of going “missing” for two hours. PLAINTIFF would correctly 28 10 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
12
1 deny the accusation and direct Baines to the surveillance cameras to confirm his story. The 2 false accusation would stand, but without confirmation. 3 45. At some point in early 2022, PLAINTIFF began to be followed by another 4 employee, Ali E., who was a supervisor or superior in a different department. On one 5 occasion, PLAINTIFF was away from his workstation, Ali E., without any apparent 6 authority to question PLAINTIFF’s whereabouts, sent PLAINTIFF a text message asking 7 him why he was not at his workstation. PLAINTIFF responded to Ali E. and said to leave 8 him alone. PLAINTIFF forwarded the text exchange to Baines, who responded with a 9 “laughing face” emoji. 10 46. PLAINTIFF also faced disparate treatment on sick leave, as Bolinger and 11 Baines promised one thing but delivered another. On an occasion when PLAINTIFF was 12 feeling unwell at work and thought he might faint, he walked away from his workstation to 13 get a drink of water. When he did so, he was approached by Baines, who suggested that he 14 might be better off going home. After returning to work for about two hours, PLAINTIFF 15 determined that he could no longer work that day. PLAINTIFF approached Bolinger and said 16 he was not well and asked if he would get into trouble if he went home for the day. Bolinger 17 told PLAINTIFF that he would not get into any trouble. 18 47. When PLAINTIFF returned to work, he was ordered to attend a department 19 meeting where attendance issues were addressed. PLAINTIFF was directly challenged about 20 the previous week’s incident and two others where he had to leave work for illness. 21 PLAINTIFF replied that he had asked Bolinger if there was any problem with going home 22 early and was told there was not; Bolinger denied this occurred. PLAINTIFF received 23 disciplinary write-ups for these absences. 24 48. PLAINTIFF continued to be routinely assigned to winding machines that were 25 somehow faulty and did not produce at full capacity. While coworkers were rotated through 26 the machines, PLAINTIFF was ordered to use the faulty machines and was not provided a 27 28 11 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
13
1 winding partner which caused difficulty in the operations of the machines. Nonetheless, he 2 continued to reach or nearly reach his production quotas on a regular basis. 3 49. PLAINTIFF was also subjected to public humiliation, including being singled 4 out for ostracism, when team leaders pointed him out to new hires as someone to avoid, 5 pointing to him and describing him as “the wrong crowd” and someone they “should not 6 hang out with.” 7 50. After approximately three months in the winding department, PLAINTIFF 8 received a three-month review from Bolinger – the only performance review he received— 9 where he was criticized for failing to keep up with the production quotas. Bolinger 10 threatened PLAINTIFF that he would never advance in the company. PLAINTIFF was not 11 given a copy of the review. 12 51. In or about July 2022, PLAINTIFF complained to Baines that Ali E. was 13 continuing to follow and harass him, including following him to the restroom, which Baines 14 denied. PLAINTIFF asked how many other employees were being similarly surveilled; 15 Baines did not respond to the question. PLAINTIFF asked if this was discrimination against 16 him; Baines again did not answer the question. 17 52. In or about August 2022, PLAINTIFF overheard Ali E. say to another 18 employee words to the effect of “you’re being lazy. I thought Mexicans were supposed to 19 work harder.” Being part Mexican, PLAINTIFF took offense to this. He later complained to 20 HR about this and was led to believe that an investigation was undertaken. 21 53. On or about August 6, 2022, upon learning that Bolinger was being transferred 22 to Texas, PLAINTIFF sent a message to Ali E., Bains, Bolinger, and others, stating he 23 discovered on an internal HR portal several writeups that needed to be corrected before 24 Bolinger left because some came under Bolinger’s supervision, and because Bollinger had 25 given PLAINTIFF permission to take requested time off that he was then written up for. 26 PLAINTIFF stated that he felt these writeups were in effort to push him out and to fire him, 27 that he felt retaliated against and might take matters higher up. PLAINTIFF stated that he 28 12 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
14
1 loved his job at Tesla and wanted to be a part of its future in sustainable energy. 2 PLAINTIFF received no response to this message. 3 54. On or about August 8, 2022, PLAINTIFF wrote Aenoi V. Jones of Human 4 Resources in a higher division (“Jones”) that he tried to contact someone about his problems 5 with his supervisors but was being redirected to his direct HR contact with whom he did not 6 feel comfortable speaking because he believed that person communicated his complaints to 7 those he complained about and was requesting someone else to speak with about his 8 complaints. 9 55. Jones replied on August 8, 2022, directing PLAINTIFF to reach out to the 10 Senior HR Manager, Nicole Burgers (“Burgers”), and provided him with her email address 11 and phone number. 12 56. On or about August 8, 2022, PLAINTIFF called Burgers on the phone and told 13 her his work performance was being sabotaged, that he was experiencing discrimination and 14 harassment and told her about the investigation that he understood was started. Burgers told 15 PLAINTIFF she would look into the investigation. 16 57. On or about September 8, 2022, PLAINTIFF sent a text message to Burgers 17 stating that he has multiple writeups and just received a final writeup on the internal HR 18 portal. Burgers replied on September 9, 2022, stating she would look into it. 19 58. On or about September 8 or 9, 2022, PLAINTIFF sent a message to his direct 20 supervisors, HR, his HR manager’s manager, and their managers, totaling 10-11 recipients. 21 An investigator sent a message to PLAINTIFF stating she was working on the investigation 22 and asked him to give her more information, which he did. 23 59. Sometime thereabout, PLAINTIFF sent a message to Thomas, his direct HR 24 Manager, but she did not open his message, which he confirmed through “read receipts” in 25 the messaging app. PLAINTIFF’s message had similar content to what he told Burgers. 26 Thomas did not respond. 27 28 13 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
15
60. 1 On or about September 23, 2022, PLAINTIFF was called on the phone by 2 Daniel Donenfeld, HR Partner, Vehicle Engineering & Cell Manufacturing Operations 3 (“Donenfeld”) and James Wall, who is the manager above Baines (“Wall”). Donenfeld left 4 PLAINTIFF a voice mail and Wall sent a message to him on an internal messaging app, 5 asking if they could schedule a call that day. PLAINTIFF confirmed, and they later spoke to 6 PLAINTIFF together and told him that due to safety reasons, PLAINTIFF’s status of 7 employment changed to termination and that it's a final decision that cannot be changed. 8 They also mentioned they reviewed the warnings on his profile and told PLAINTIFF to 9 email HR if he has any questions. 61. 10 PLAINTIFF sent a message to Donenfeld stating that his verbal and non-verbal 11 warnings were invalid, and Mr. Donenfeld replied “Hi Vincent, all allegations were raised to 12 appropriate parties and action is taken.” 62. 13 On or about October 9, 2022, PLAINTIFF sent an email to Donenfeld asking 14 the reason he was terminated. Donenfeld wrote back that “The reason for your termination is 15 because it is more likely than not that you violated Tesla's policy.” 63. 16 17 On or about October 21, 2022, PLAINTIFF replied to Mr. Donenfeld asking which policy was violated. PLAINTIFF never received any reply from Mr. Donenfeld. 64. 18 PLAINTIFF alleges that he was terminated for pretextual reasons motivated by 19 discrimination based on race, religion, and disability, and in retaliation for complaining 20 about harassment and health and safety hazards. 65. 21 As a result of the unlawful conduct by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 as set 22 forth in this Complaint, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer economic damages, 23 serious emotional suffering and damages, and other damages as will be proved at the time of 24 trial. III. 25 26 27 28 66. EXHAUSTION OF ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES Prior to the institution of this lawsuit, Plaintiff’s attorney, Calderone Law Firm, filed a verified complaint on behalf of Plaintiff with the California Department of Fair 14 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
16
1 Employment and Housing (“DFEH”) now referred to as the Civil Rights Department using the 2 DFEH online system, pursuant to Government Code section 12900 et seq., alleging that the 3 acts described in this complaint violated the Fair Employment and Housing Act (“FEHA”). 4 Prior to the Complaint being submitted using the DFEH online system, Plaintiff verified the 5 contents of the complaint and gave his attorney’s permission to submit the verified complaint 6 on his behalf to the DFEH. The complaint was verified by Plaintiff pursuant to Government 7 Code 12900 et seq. The DFEH issued “right to sue” letter, a copy of which is attached hereto 8 marked as Exhibit “A.” Therefore, all conditions precedent to the institution of this lawsuit 9 have been fulfilled. 10 11 12 13 14 15 IV. FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION Racial /Color/Ancestry Discrimination in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 67. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 68. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 16 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for racial, color, and ancestry 17 discrimination because they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 18 69. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 19 Does 1-50, and was at all times qualified for the position. PLAINTIFF is of multi-racial 20 heritage, including Indian, Mexican, African American, and Fijian ancestry. 21 70. The FEHA prohibits unlawful discrimination based on race, color, or ancestry. 22 California Government Code Section 12940 (a) provides it is an unlawful employment 23 practice “[f]or an employer, because of the race … color … [or] ancestry … of any person … 24 to discharge the person from employment … or to discriminate against the person in 25 compensation or in terms, conditions or privileges of employment.” 26 27 28 71. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 subjected PLAINTIFF to adverse employment actions based on his race, color, or ancestry including, but not limited to, severe and 15 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
17
1 pervasive harassment of PLAINTIFF in his employment because of his race, including but 2 not limited to references to his Indian heritage, calling him “carpet boy” and “terrorist” and 3 “a disgrace to Indians”; refences to his Mexican heritage and use of insults like “lazy” and 4 harmful stereotypes like “Mexicans are supposed to work harder”; refences to his African- 5 American heritage, including repeated use of the epithet “nigger”; and references to his race 6 and color, generally, with slurs like “brown boy” and “little mutt.” 7 72. PLAINTIFF repeatedly complained about the severe and pervasive racial, 8 color, and ancestry discrimination and harassment he faced from his supervisors but received 9 no reprieve from the abusive treatment. 10 11 12 73. PLAINTIFF’s multi-racial heritage was a motivating reason for the above- described conduct by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50. 74. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 13 and intentional discriminatory actions, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment 14 benefits, and suffered damages for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of 15 which will be proven at trial. 16 75. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 17 conduct and intentional discriminatory actions, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to 18 suffer anxiety, worry, embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional 19 distress. The amount of such damages will be proven at trial. 20 76. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 21 acts—including but not limited to those carried out by Baines, Bolinger, Corona, and 22 Sharma—were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were 23 directed or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for 24 PLAINTIFF’s rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to 25 constitute oppression, fraud or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling 26 PLAINTIFF to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an 27 example of DEFENDANTS. 28 16 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
18
1 77. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 2 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 3 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 4 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 5 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 V. SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION Religious Discrimination in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 78. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 79. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 13 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for religious discrimination 14 because they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 15 80. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 16 Does 1-50, and was at all times qualified for the position. PLAINTIFF is an adherent of the 17 Christian faith. 18 81. The FEHA prohibits unlawful discrimination based on religion. California 19 Government Code Section 12940 (a) provides it is an unlawful employment practice “[f]or 20 an employer, because of the … religious creed . . . of any person . . . to discharge the person 21 from employment . . . or to discriminate against the person in compensation or in terms, 22 conditions or privileges of employment.” 23 82. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 subjected PLAINTIFF to adverse employment 24 actions based on his religion including, but not limited to, severe and pervasive harassment 25 of PLAINTIFF employment because of his religion, including but not limited to calling him 26 a “stupid Christian” and “not a real Christian.” 27 28 17 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
19
1 83. PLAINTIFF repeatedly complained about the severe and pervasive religious 2 discrimination and harassment he faced from his supervisors but received no reprieve from 3 the abusive treatment. 4 5 6 84. PLAINTIFF’s religion was a substantially motivating reason for the above- described conduct by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50. 85. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 7 and intentional discriminatory actions, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment 8 benefits, and suffered damages for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of 9 which will be proven at trial. 10 86. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 11 conduct and intentional discriminatory actions, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to 12 suffer anxiety, worry, embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional 13 distress. The amount of such damages will be proven at trial. 14 87. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANT’s and Does 1-50's 15 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 16 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 17 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 18 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 19 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 20 DEFENDANTS. 21 88. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 22 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 23 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 24 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 25 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 26 27 28 VI. THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION Disability Discrimination in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 18 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
20
1 2 3 89. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 90. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 4 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for disability discrimination 5 because they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 6 91. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 7 Does 1-50, and was at all times qualified for the position. PLAINTIFF suffers from asthma, 8 which is recognized as a disability under the FEHA. See Ca. Dept. of Cor. v. State Personnel 9 Bd. (2004) 121 Cal.App.4th 1601, generally. PLAINTIFF’s asthma was a fact known to 10 DEFENDANTS. 11 92. The FEHA prohibits unlawful discrimination based on disability. California 12 Government Code Section 12940 (a) provides it is an unlawful employment practice “[f]or 13 an employer, because of the … physical disability. . . of any person . . . to discharge the 14 person from employment . . . or to discriminate against the person in compensation or in 15 terms, conditions or privileges of employment.” 16 93. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 subjected PLAINTIFF to adverse employment 17 actions based on his physical disability including, but not limited to, severe and pervasive 18 harassment of PLAINTIFF employment because of his disability, including but not limited 19 to calling him “lazy,” questioning his manhood by asking if he was a “female,” telling him to 20 “quit crying like a baby,” minimizing his breathing difficulties because “it’s just powder,” 21 and other slights, insults, denigrations, and attempts to publicly humiliate him. 22 94. PLAINTIFF repeatedly complained about the severe and pervasive disability 23 discrimination and harassment he faced from his supervisors but received no reprieve from 24 the abusive treatment. 25 26 95. PLAINTIFF’s disability was a substantially motivating reason for the above- described conduct by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50. 27 28 19 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
21
1 96. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 2 and intentional discriminatory actions, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment 3 benefits, and suffered damages for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of 4 which will be proven at trial. 5 97. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 6 conduct and intentional discriminatory actions, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to 7 suffer anxiety, worry, embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional 8 distress. The amount of such damages will be proven at trial. 9 98. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 10 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 11 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 12 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 13 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 14 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 15 DEFENDANTS. 16 99. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 17 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 18 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 19 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 20 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 21 22 23 24 25 26 VII. FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION Racial/Color/Ancestry Harassment in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 100. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 27 28 20 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
22
1 101. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 2 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for racial, color, and ancestry 3 harassment because they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 4 102. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 5 Does 1-50, and was at all times qualified for the position. PLAINTIFF is of multi-racial 6 heritage, including Indian, Mexican, African American, and Fijian ancestry. 7 103. The FEHA prohibits unlawful harassment based on race, color, or ancestry. 8 California Government Code Section 12940 (j)(1) provides it is an unlawful employment 9 practice “[f]or an employer … because of the race … color … [or] ancestry … to harass an 10 11 employee ….” 104. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 subjected PLAINTIFF to severe and pervasive 12 harassment of PLAINTIFF in his employment because of his race, color, and ancestry, 13 including but not limited to references to his Indian heritage, calling him “carpet boy” and 14 “terrorist” and “a disgrace to Indians”; refences to his Mexican heritage and use of insults 15 like “lazy” and harmful stereotypes like “Mexicans are supposed to work harder”; refences 16 to his African-American heritage, including repeated use of the epithet “nigger”; and 17 references to his race and color, generally, with slurs like “brown boy” and “little mutt.” 18 105. PLAINTIFF repeatedly complained about the severe and pervasive racial 19 harassment he faced from his supervisors but received no reprieve from the abusive 20 treatment. 21 22 23 106. PLAINTIFF’s multi-racial heritage was a substantially motivating reason for the above-described conduct by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50. 107. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 24 and intentional harassment, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and 25 suffered damages for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be 26 proven at trial. 27 28 21 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
23
1 108. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 2 conduct and intentional harassment, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer 3 anxiety, worry, embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional distress. 4 The amount of such damages will be proven at trial. 5 109. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 6 acts—including but not limited to those carried out by Baines, Bolinger, Corona, and 7 Sharma—were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were 8 directed or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for 9 PLAINTIFF’s rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to 10 constitute oppression, fraud or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling 11 PLAINTIFF to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an 12 example of DEFENDANTS. 13 110. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 14 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 15 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 16 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 17 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 18 19 20 21 22 23 VIII. FIFTH CAUSE OF ACTION Religious Harassment in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 111. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 112. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 24 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for religious harassment because 25 they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 26 113. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 27 Does 1-50, and was at all times qualified for the position. PLAINTIFF is an adherent of the 28 Christian faith. 22 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
24
1 114. The FEHA prohibits unlawful harassment based on religion. California 2 Government Code Section 12940 (j)(1) provides it is an unlawful employment practice “[f]or 3 an employer, because of … religious creed . . . to harass an employee ….” 4 115. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 subjected PLAINTIFF to severe and pervasive 5 harassment of PLAINTIFF employment because of his religion, including but not limited to 6 calling him a “stupid Christian” and “not a real Christian.” 7 116. PLAINTIFF repeatedly complained about the severe and pervasive religious 8 harassment he faced from his supervisors but received no reprieve from the abusive 9 treatment. 10 11 12 117. PLAINTIFF’s religion was a substantially motivating reason for the above- described conduct by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50. 118. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 13 and intentional harassment, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and 14 suffered damages for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be 15 proven at trial. 16 119. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 17 conduct and intentional harassment, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer 18 anxiety, worry, embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional distress. 19 The amount of such damages will be proven at trial. 20 120. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 21 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 22 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 23 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 24 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 25 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 26 DEFENDANTS. 27 28 23 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
25
1 121. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 2 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 3 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 4 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 5 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 6 7 8 9 10 11 IX. SIXTH CAUSE OF ACTION Disability Harassment in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 122. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 123. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 12 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for disability harassment because 13 they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 14 124. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 15 Does 1-50, and was at all times qualified for the position. PLAINTIFF suffers from asthma, 16 which is recognized as a disability under the FEHA. PLAINTIFF’s asthma was a fact known 17 to DEFENDANTS. 18 125. The FEHA prohibits unlawful harassment based on disability. California 19 Government Code Section 12940 (j)(1) provides it is an unlawful employment practice “[f]or 20 an employer … because of … disability … to harass an employee….” 21 126. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 subjected PLAINTIFF to severe and pervasive 22 harassment of PLAINTIFF because of his disability, including but not limited to calling him 23 “lazy,” questioning his manhood by asking if he was a “female,” telling him to “quit crying 24 like a baby,” minimizing his breathing difficulties because “it’s just powder,” and other 25 slights, insults, denigrations, and attempts to publicly humiliate him. 26 27 28 127. PLAINTIFF repeatedly complained about the severe and pervasive harassment he faced from his supervisors but received no reprieve from the abusive treatment. 24 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
26
1 2 3 128. PLAINTIFF’s disability was a substantial motivating reason for the above- described conduct by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50. 129. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 4 and intentional harassment, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and 5 suffered damages for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be 6 proven at trial. 7 130. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 8 conduct and intentional harassment, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer 9 anxiety, worry, embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional distress. 10 11 The amount of such damages will be proven at trial. 131. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 12 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 13 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 14 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 15 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 16 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 17 DEFENDANTS. 18 132. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 19 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 20 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 21 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 22 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 23 24 25 26 27 28 X. SEVENTH CAUSE OF ACTION Failure to Accommodate in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 133. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 25 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
27
1 134. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 2 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for failure to accommodate 3 because they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 4 135. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 5 Does 1-50, was at all times qualified for the position, and at all times suffered from asthma, a 6 disability under the FEHA. PLAINTIFF’s asthma was a fact known to DEFENDANTS. 7 136. The FEHA prohibits unlawful failure to make reasonable accommodations for 8 disability. California Government Code Section 12940 (m)(1) provides it is an unlawful 9 employment practice “[f]or an employer … to fail to make reasonable accommodation for 10 11 the known physical or mental disability of an applicant or employee.” 137. PLAINTIFF requested reasonable accommodations by complaining about 12 noxious powders in his workspace aggravating his asthma and causing respiratory 13 difficulties, among other health consequences. PLAINTIFF secured a note from his doctor 14 ordering that PLAINTIFF be taken out of the workspace where noxious powders were 15 causing him harm by aggravating his asthma. PLAINTIFF provided the doctor’s note to 16 DEFENDANTS. 17 138. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 failed and/or refused to make reasonable 18 accommodation to PLAINTIFF’s physical disability despite being aware of the doctor’s note 19 requiring PLAINTIFF to be taken out of the area where noxious powders were aggravating 20 his asthma. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that reasonable accommodations were 21 available, such as transfer to different departments or other vacancies that did not involve 22 mixing noxious powders that aggravated his asthma. 23 24 25 26 139. DEFENDANTS failed and refused to accommodate PLAINTIFF’s disability by transferring him to a position that would not aggravate his asthma. 140. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct and intentional acts in failing and/or refusing to reasonably accommodate PLAINTIFF’s 27 28 26 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
28
1 disability, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and suffered damages for 2 which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be proven at trial. 3 141. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 4 conduct, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer anxiety, worry, embarrassment, 5 humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional distress. The amount of such damages 6 will be proven at trial. 7 142. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 8 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 9 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 10 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 11 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 12 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 13 DEFENDANTS. 14 143. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 15 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 16 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 17 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 18 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 XI. EIGHTH CAUSE OF ACTION Failure to Engage in the Interactive Process in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 144. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 145. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for failure to engage in the interactive process because they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 27 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
29
1 146. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 2 Does 1-50, was at all times qualified for the position, and at all times suffered from asthma, a 3 disability under the FEHA. PLAINTIFF’s asthma was a fact known to DEFENDANTS. 4 147. The FEHA prohibits unlawful failure to engage is a good-faith interactive 5 process. California Government Code Section 12940 (n) provides it is an unlawful 6 employment practice “[f]or an employer … to fail to engage in a timely, good faith, 7 interactive process with the employee … to determine effective reasonable accommodations, 8 if any, in response to a request for reasonable accommodation by an employee … with a 9 known physical or mental disability.” 10 148. PLAINTIFF requested reasonable accommodations by complaining about 11 noxious powders in his workspace aggravating his asthma and causing respiratory 12 difficulties, among other health consequences. PLAINTIFF secured a note from his doctor 13 ordering that PLAINTIFF be taken out of the workspace where noxious powders were 14 causing him harm by aggravating his asthma. PLAINTIFF provided the doctor’s note to 15 DEFENDANTS. 16 149. PLAINTIFF repeatedly sought to engage in a good-faith, interactive process 17 with DEFENDANTS to find a reasonable accommodation, but DEFENDANTS repeatedly 18 failed and/or refused to participate, unnecessarily delaying any response for weeks and 19 ultimately refusing to participate, citing DEFENDANTS’ formalistic rules to justify the 20 refusal to participate. 21 150. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 failed and/or refused to discuss making 22 reasonable accommodation to PLAINTIFF’s physical disability despite being aware of the 23 doctor’s note requiring PLAINTIFF to be taken out of the area where noxious powders were 24 aggravating his asthma. 25 151. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 26 and intentional acts in failing and/or refusing to engage in a timely, good-faith, interactive 27 process to try to identify reasonable accommodation for PLAINTIFF’s disability, 28 28 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
30
1 PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and suffered damages for which he 2 seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be proven at trial. 3 152. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 4 conduct, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer anxiety, worry, embarrassment, 5 humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional distress. The amount of such damages 6 will be proven at trial. 7 153. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 8 acts were carried out by its’ managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 9 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 10 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 11 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 12 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 13 DEFENDANTS. 14 154. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 15 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 16 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 17 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 18 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 19 20 21 22 23 24 XII. NINTH CAUSE OF ACTION Retaliation in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 155. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 156. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 25 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for retaliation because they are 26 employers who regularly employ five (5) or more persons. 27 28 29 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
31
1 157. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 2 Does 1-50, was at all times qualified for the position, and at all times suffered from asthma, a 3 disability under the FEHA. PLAINTIFF’s asthma was a fact known to DEFENDANTS. 4 158. California Government Code Section 12940(h) makes it unlawful for an 5 employer "to discharge, expel, or otherwise discriminate against any person" because the 6 person has opposed practices forbidden by this part" or "because the person has filed a 7 complaint, testified, or assisted in proceeding under this part." The FEHA also prohibits 8 retaliation against employees seeking reasonable accommodations for disability. California 9 Government Code Section 12940 (m)(2) provides it is an unlawful employment practice 10 “[f]or an employer … covered by this part to … retaliate or otherwise discriminate against a 11 person for requesting accommodation under this subdivision, regardless of whether the 12 request was granted.” 13 159. PLAINTIFF requested reasonable accommodations by complaining about 14 noxious powders in his workspace aggravating his asthma and causing respiratory 15 difficulties, among other health consequences. PLAINTIFF secured a note from his doctor 16 ordering that PLAINTIFF be taken out of the workspace where noxious powders were 17 causing him harm by aggravating his asthma. PLAINTIFF provided the doctor’s note to 18 DEFENDANTS. 19 160. DEFENDANTS retaliated against PLAINTIFF by engaging in a series of 20 violations large and small, including public humiliations, being ostracized, being transferred 21 to deny him a pay increase, putting him under surveillance and having him followed at work, 22 harassing him for using the restroom, and other adverse workplace actions. PLAINTIFF was 23 regularly assigned to faulty equipment that made it difficult or impossible to meet his 24 production quotas, which led to him receiving negative performance reviews. 25 DEFENDANTS also retaliated against PLAINTIFF by terminating his employment, 26 substantially motivated by PLAINTIFF’s engaging in protected activity of complaining and 27 opposing harassing, and discriminatory conduct in the workplace. 28 30 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
32
1 161. PLAINTIFF complained about these acts of retaliation to DEFENDANTS’ HR 2 and employee relations staff on many, many occasions. PLAINTIFF’s complaints did not 3 result in any action being taken against his tormenters. 4 162. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 5 and intentional acts in failing and/or refusing to engage in a timely, good-faith, interactive 6 process to try to identify reasonable accommodation for PLAINTIFF’s disability, 7 PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and suffered damages for which he 8 seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be proven at trial. 9 163. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 10 conduct, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer anxiety, worry, embarrassment, 11 humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional distress. The amount of such damages 12 will be proven at trial. 13 164. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 14 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 15 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 16 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 17 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 18 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 19 DEFENDANTS. 20 165. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 21 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 22 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 23 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 24 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. 25 26 27 28 XIII. TENTH CAUSE OF ACTION Failure to Prevent Harassment, Discrimination, and Retaliation in Violation of California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (Govt. Code § 12940, et seq.) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 31 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
33
1 2 3 166. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 66, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 167. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 are subject to the laws of the State of 4 California and are entities subject to suit under the FEHA for failure to prevent harassment, 5 discrimination, and retaliation because they are employers who regularly employ five (5) or 6 more persons. 7 168. At all relevant times, PLAINTIFF was an employee of DEFENDANTS and 8 Does 1-50, was at all times qualified for the position, and at all times suffered from asthma, a 9 disability under the FEHA. PLAINTIFF’s asthma was a fact known to DEFENDANTS. 10 169. The FEHA requires employers to take reasonable steps to prevent harassment, 11 discrimination, and retaliation. See California Government Code Section 12940 (j)(1), 12 stating in part, “An entity shall take all reasonable steps to prevent harassment from 13 occurring.” California Government Code Section 12940 (k) provides it is an unlawful 14 employment practice “[f]or an employer … to fail to take all reasonable steps necessary to 15 prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring.” 16 170. Throughout his employment with DEFENDANTS, PLAINTIFF suffered 17 severe and pervasive harassment, discrimination, and retaliation based on his religion, race, 18 disability, and requests for reasonable accommodation. This unlawful abuse took the form of 19 racial and religious slurs, abusive epithets, ostracism, mockery, public humiliation, 20 surveillance, and punitive assignment to faulty equipment resulting in inability to meet 21 production quotas which in turn led to negative performance reviews. 22 171. PLAINTIFF complained about these acts of harassment, discrimination, and 23 retaliation to DEFENDANTS’ HR and employee relations staff on many, many occasions. 24 PLAINTIFF’s complaints did not result in any action being taken against his tormenters. 25 26 172. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct in failing and/or refusing to take all reasonable steps to prevent harassment, discrimination, and 27 28 32 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
34
1 retaliation, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and suffered damages 2 for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be proven at trial. 3 173. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 4 conduct, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer anxiety, worry, embarrassment, 5 humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional distress. The amount of such damages 6 will be proven at trial. 7 174. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 8 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 9 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 10 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 11 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 12 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 13 DEFENDANTS. 14 175. The California Government Code Section 12965(b) provides for an award of 15 reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred by the prevailing party in an action brought 16 under its terms. PLAINTIFF has employed and will continue to employ attorneys for the 17 initiation and prosecution of this action. PLAINTIFF has incurred and will continue to incur 18 attorneys' fees and costs herein and is entitled to an award of attorneys’ fees and costs. XIV. ELEVENTH CAUSE OF ACTION Whistleblower Retaliation (Labor Code §6310) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 19 20 21 22 23 24 176. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 65, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 177. California Labor Code Section 6310 (a), which addresses workplace safety, 25 states, “No person shall discharge or in any manner discriminate against any employee 26 because the employee has done any of the following: (1) Made any oral or written complaint 27 to the division, other governmental agencies having statutory responsibility for or assisting 28 33 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
35
1 the division with reference to employee safety or health, their employer, or their 2 representative.” 3 178. California Labor Code Section 6310 (b) states, “Any employee who is 4 discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner 5 discriminated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer because 6 the employee has made a bona fide oral or written complaint to … their employer, or their 7 representative, of unsafe working conditions, or work practices, in their employment or place 8 of employment … shall be entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and 9 work benefits caused by the acts of the employer.” 10 179. PLAINTIFF repeatedly complained to his supervisors about noxious powders 11 in his workspace aggravating his asthma and causing respiratory difficulties, among other 12 health consequences. PLAINTIFF secured a note from his doctor ordering that PLAINTIFF 13 be taken out of the workspace where noxious powders were causing him harm by 14 aggravating his asthma. PLAINTIFF provided the doctor’s note to DEFENDANTS. These 15 acts by PLAINTIFF were protected conduct under Labor Code Section 6310 (a). 16 180. DEFENDANTS retaliated and discriminated against PLAINTIFF by engaging 17 in a series of violations large and small, including public humiliations, being ostracized, 18 being transferred to deny him a pay increase, putting him under surveillance and having him 19 followed at work, harassing him for using the restroom, and other adverse workplace actions. 20 PLAINTIFF was regularly assigned to faulty equipment that made it difficult or impossible 21 to meet his production quotas, which led to him receiving negative performance reviews. 22 Such acts of retaliation against PLAINTIFF for his making bona fide complaints about 23 matters of workplace safety violate Labor Code Section 6310 (a). 24 181. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 25 and intentional acts in retaliating against PLAINTIFF, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and 26 employment benefits, and suffered damages for which he seeks to be made whole pursuant 27 to Labor Code Section 6310 (b), the exact amount of which will be proven at trial. 28 34 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
36
1 182. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 2 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 3 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 4 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 5 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 6 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 7 DEFENDANTS. 8 XV. TWELFTH CAUSE OF ACTION Whistleblower Retaliation (Labor Code §1102.5) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 9 10 11 183. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 65, 12 inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 13 184. Labor Code Section 1102.5 (b) states, in pertinent part, “An employer … shall 14 not retaliate against an employee for disclosing information … to a person with authority 15 over the employee or another employee who has the authority to investigate, discover, or 16 correct the violation or noncompliance, … if the employee has reasonable cause to believe 17 that the information discloses a violation of state or federal statute, or a violation of or 18 noncompliance with a local, state, or federal rule or regulation.” 19 185. PLAINTIFF repeatedly complained to DEFENDANTS, by and through its’ 20 HR department, which had the authority to investigate, discover, or correct the violation, 21 about the severe and pervasive discrimination, harassment, and retaliation he faced in the 22 workplace, which PLAINTIFF reasonably believed violates the FEHA, a state statute. 23 PLAINTIFF’s complaints to HR were therefore protected acts under Labor Code Section 24 1102.5. 25 186. DEFENDANTS retaliated against PLAINTIFF by engaging in a series of 26 violations large and small, including public humiliations, being ostracized, being transferred 27 to deny him a pay increase, putting him under surveillance and having him followed at work, 28 35 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
37
1 harassing him for using the restroom, and other adverse workplace actions. PLAINTIFF was 2 regularly assigned to faulty equipment that made it difficult or impossible to meet his 3 production quotas, which led to him receiving negative performance reviews. Such acts of 4 retaliation against PLAINTIFF were substantially motivated by PLAINTIFF’s making bona 5 fide complaints to DEFENDANTS’ HR department for unlawful harassment, retaliation, and 6 discrimination in violation of the FEHA. 7 187. As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 8 and intentional harassment, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and 9 suffered damages for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be 10 11 proven at trial. 188. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 12 conduct and intentional harassment, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer 13 anxiety, worry, embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, and serious emotional distress. 14 The amount of such damages will be proven at trial. 15 189. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 16 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 17 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 with a conscious disregard for PLAINTIFF’s 18 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 19 oppression, fraud, or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 20 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 21 DEFENDANTS. 22 190. Labor Code §1102.5 (f) states, “In addition to other penalties, an employer that 23 is a corporation … is liable for a civil penalty not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000) 24 for each violation of this section.” PLAINTIFF seeks a $10,000 civil penalty pursuant to 25 California Labor Code §1102.5 (f) against DEFENDANTS. 26 27 28 36 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
38
1 191. Labor Code §1102.5 (j) states, “The court is authorized to award reasonable 2 attorney’s fees to a plaintiff who brings a successful action for a violation of these 3 provisions.” XVI. THIRTEENTH CAUSE OF ACTION Failure to Safeguard Medical Information (Civil Code §§ 56.20, 56.35, 56.36) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 4 5 6 7 8 9 192. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 65, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 193. California Civil Code Section 56.20 (a) states, “Each employer who receives 10 medical information shall establish appropriate procedures to ensure the confidentiality and 11 protection from unauthorized use and disclosure of that information.” 12 194. California Civil Code Section 56.35 states, “In addition to any other remedies 13 available at law, a patient whose medical information has been used or disclosed in violation 14 of Section 56.10, 56.104, 56.107, or 56.20 or subdivision (a) of Section 56.26 and who has 15 sustained economic loss or personal injury therefrom may recover compensatory damages, 16 punitive damages not to exceed three thousand dollars ($3,000), attorney’s fees not to exceed 17 one thousand dollars ($1,000), and the costs of litigation.” 18 195. California Civil Code Section 56.36(b) states, “In addition to any other 19 remedies available at law, an individual may bring an action against a person or entity who 20 has negligently released confidential information or records concerning him or her in 21 violation of this part, for either or both of the following: 22 (1) Except as provided in subdivision (e), nominal damages of one thousand 23 dollars ($1,000). In order to recover under this paragraph, it is not necessary 24 that the plaintiff suffered or was threatened with actual damages. 25 (2) The amount of actual damages, if any, sustained by the patient.” 26 27 28 196. PLAINTIFF entrusted to his team lead, Jack K., a note from his doctor ordering that PLAINTIFF be taken out of the workspace where noxious powders were 37 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
39
1 causing him harm by aggravating his asthma, which constitutes medical information that 2 DEFENDANTS were obligated to take care to keep private under Civil Code Section 56.20. 197. 3 The note was later returned to PLAINTIFF by a coworker who found it 4 discarded on the factory floor. Under the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, it is inescapable that 5 Jack K. failed to take care and willfully or negligently disclosed PLAINTIFF’s private 6 medical information to an unknowable number of PLAINTIFF’s coworkers. 198. 7 As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct, 8 by and through Jack K., PLAINTIFF has suffered damages for which he seeks to be made 9 whole pursuant to Civil Code Section 56.36(b), the exact amount of which will be proven at 10 11 12 trial. 199. authorized by Civil Code Sections 56.35 and 56.36 (b). XVII. FOURTEENTH CAUSE OF ACTION (Wrongful Termination in Violation of Public Policy) (Against DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50) 13 14 15 16 17 PLAINTIFF additionally seeks nominal and punitive damages as permitted and 200. PLAINTIFF realleges and incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 65, inclusive, of this Complaint as though fully set forth herein. 201. DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 terminated PLAINTIFF in retaliation for his 18 complaints about harassment, discrimination, and retaliation he faced due to his race, 19 religion, and disability, and in retaliation for making complaints about health and safety 20 concerns in his workplace. 21 202. In doing so, DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 violated of the public policy set 22 forth in the California Fair Employment and Housing Act, Government Code Section 12900, 23 et seq., which prohibits discrimination against employees based on race, religion, and 24 disability, and which prohibits retaliation against employees who complain about facing 25 harassment, discrimination, and retaliation. 26 27 28 203. In doing so, DEFENDANTS and Does 1-50 also violated of the public policy set forth in Labor Code Section Sections 1102.5 and 6310, which protects the rights of 38 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
40
1 employees to bring bona fide complaints of unlawful conduct in the workplace and 2 workplace health and safety issues without fear of reprisal. 204. 3 As a proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful conduct 4 described above, PLAINTIFF has lost earnings and employment benefits, and suffered 5 damages for which he seeks to be made whole, the exact amount of which will be proven at 6 trial. 7 205. As a further proximate result of DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's wrongful 8 conduct described above, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer anxiety, worry, 9 embarrassment, humiliation, mental anguish, and emotional distress. The amount of 10 11 damages of which will be proven at trial. 206. PLAINTIFF is informed and believes that DEFENDANTS’ and Does 1-50's 12 acts were carried out by its managerial employees, officers and directors, and were directed 13 or ratified by DEFENDANTS and DOES 1-50 with a conscious disregard of PLAINTIFF’s 14 rights and with the intent to vex, injure, and annoy PLAINTIFF, such as to constitute 15 oppression, fraud or malice under California Civil Code Section 3294, entitling PLAINTIFF 16 to punitive damages in a sum appropriate and sufficient to punish and make an example of 17 Defendants and Does 1-50. 18 WHEREFORE, PLAINTIFF prays for judgment as set forth below. PRAYER FOR RELIEF 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1. For general damages, according to proof on each cause of action for which such damages are available; 2. For special damages, according to proof on each cause of action for which such damages are available; 3. For compensatory damages, according to proof on each cause of action for which such damages are available; 4. For punitive damages, according to proof or each cause of action for which such damages are available; 39 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
41
1 5. For pre-judgement and post-judgement interest according to law; 2 6. For reasonable attorneys' fees incurred in this action on those causes of action for 3 which such fees are recoverable under the law; 4 7. For costs of suit incurred in this action; and 5 8. For such other and further relief as the Court deems proper and just. 6 7 8 PLAINTIFF HEREBY DEMANDS A TRIAL BY JURY OF ALL CAUSES OF ACTION ALLEGED HEREIN. 9 10 Dated: March 7, 2023 CALDERONE LAW FIRM 11 12 13 14 ___________________________ Vincent Calderone Attorney for PLAINTIFF Vincent Singh 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 40 COMPLAINT
PDF Page
42
EXHIBIT A
PDF Page
43
STATE OF CALIFORNIA I Business, Consumer Services and Housing Agency Civil Rights Department GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR KEVIN KISH, DIRECTOR 2218 Kausen Drive, Suite 100 I Elk Grove I CA j 95758 800-884-1684 (voice) i 800-700-2320 (TTY) I California's Relay Service at 711 calcivilrights.ca.gov I contact.center@dfeh .ca.gov February 10, 2023 Vincent Calderone 2321 Rosecrans Ave ., Suite 1265 El Segundo, CA 90245 RE: Notice to Complainant's Attorney CRD Matter Number: 202302-19577802 Right to Sue: Singh/ Tesla, Inc. et al. Dear Vincent Calderone: Attached is a copy of your complaint of discrimination filed with the Civil Rights Department (CRD) pursuant to the California Fair Employment and Housing Act, Government Code section 12900 et seq. Also attached is a copy of your Notice of Case Closure and Right to Sue. Pursuant to Government Code section 12962, CRD will not serve these documents on the employer. You must serve the complaint separately, to all named respondents. Please refer to the attached Notice of Case Closure and Right to Sue for information regarding filing a private lawsuit in the State of California. A courtesy "Notice of Filing of Discrimination Complaint" is attached for your convenience. Be advised that the CRD does not review or edit the complaint form to ensure that it meets procedural or statutory requirements. Sincerely, Civil Rights Department CRD - ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
44
STATE OF CALIFORNIA I Business, Consumer Services and Housing Agency GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR KEVIN KISH, DIRECTOR Civil Rights Department 2218 Kausen Drive, Suite 100 I Elk Grove I CA 195758 800-884-1684 (voice) 1800-700-2320 (TTY) I California's Relay Service at 711 calcivilrights.ca.gov I contact.center@dfeh.ca.gov February 10, 2023 RE: Notice of Filing of Discrimination Complaint CRD Matter Number: 202302-19577802 Right to Sue: Singh/ Tesla, Inc. et al. To All Respondent(s): Enclosed is a copy of a complaint of discrimination that has been filed with the Civil Rights Department (CRD)) in accordance with Government Code section 12960. This constitutes service of the complaint pursuant to Government Code section 12962. The complainant has requested an authorization to file a lawsuit. A copy of the Notice of Case Closure and Right to Sue is enclosed for your records. This matter may qualify for CRD's Small Employer Family Leave Mediation Pilot Program. Under this program, established under Government Code section 12945.21, a small employer with 5 -19 employees, charged with violation of the California Family Rights Act, Government Code section 12945.2, has the right to participate in CRD's free mediation program. Under this program both the employee requesting an immediate right to sue and the employer charged with the violation may request that all parties participate in CRD's free mediation program. The employee is required to contact the Department's Dispute Resolution Division prior to filing a civil action and must also indicate whether they are requesting mediation. The employee is prohibited from filing a civil action unless the Department does not initiate mediation within the time period specified in section 12945.21, subdivision (b) (4), or until the mediation is complete or is unsuccessful. The employee's statute of limitations to file a civil action, including for all related claims not arising under section 12945.2, is tolled from the date the employee contacts the Department regarding the intent to pursue legal action until the mediation is complete or is unsuccessful. You may contact CRD's Small Employer Family Leave Mediation Pilot Program by emailing DRDOnlinerequests@dfeh.ca.gov and include the CRD matter number indicated on the Right to Sue notice. Please refer to the attached complaint for a list of all respondent(s) and their contact information. No response to CRD is requested or required. Sincerely, CRD - ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
45
STATE OF CALIFORNIA I Business, Consumer Services and Housing Agency Civil Rights Department GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR KEVIN KISH, DIRECTOR 2218 Kausen Drive, Suite 100 I Elk Grove I CA I 95758 800-884-1684 (voice) 1800-700-2320 (TTY) I California's Relay Service at 711 calcivilrights.ca.gov I contact.center@dfeh.ca.gov Civil Rights Department CRD - ENF 8D RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
46
STATE OF CALIFORNIA I Business, Consumer Services and Housing Agency Civil Rights Department GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR KEVIN KISH , DIRECTOR 2218 Kausen Drive, Suite 100 I Elk Grove I CA I 95758 800-884-1684 (voice) j 800-700-2320 (TTY) I California's Relay Service at 711 calcivilrights.ca.gov I contact.center@dfeh.ca.gov February 10, 2023 Vincent Singh RE: Notice of Case Closure and Right to Sue CRD Matter Number: 202302-19577802 Right to Sue: Singh/ Tesla, Inc. et al. Dear Vincent Singh: This letter informs you that the above-referenced complaint filed with the Civil Rights Department (CRD) has been closed effective February 10, 2023 because an immediate Right to Sue notice was requested. This letter is also your Right to Sue notice. According to Government Code section 12965, subdivision (b), a civil action may be brought under the provisions of the Fair Employment and Housing Act against the person, employer, labor organization or employment agency named in the above-referenced complaint. The civil action must be filed within one year from the date of this letter. This matter may qualify for CRD's Small Employer Family Leave Mediation Pilot Program. Under this program, established under Government Code section 12945.21, a small employer with 5 -19 employees, charged with violation of the California Family Rights Act, Government Code section 12945.2, has the right to participate in CRD's free mediation program. Under this program both the employee requesting an immediate right to sue and the employer charged with the violation may request that all parties participate in CRD's free mediation program. The employee is required to contact the Department's Dispute Resolution Division prior to filing a civil action and must also indicate whether they are requesting mediation. The employee is prohibited from filing a civil action unless the Department does not initiate mediation within the time period specified in section 12945.21, subdivision (b) (4), or until the mediation is complete or is unsuccessful. The employee's statute of limitations to file a civil action, including for all related claims not arising under section 12945.2, is tolled from the date the employee contacts the Department regarding the intent to pursue legal action until the mediation is complete or is unsuccessful. Contact CRD's Small Employer Family Leave Mediation Pilot Program by emailing DRDOnlinerequests@dfeh.ca.gov and include the CRD matter number indicated on the Right to Sue notice. CRD - ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
47
STATE OF CA LIF ORN IA I Business, Consumer Serv ices and Housing Agency Civil Rights Department GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR KEVIN KISH, DIRECTOR 2218 Kausen Drive, Suite 100 I Elk Grove I CA 195758 800-884-1684 (voice) 1800-700-2320 (TTY) I California's Relay Service at 711 calcivilrights.ca.gov I contact.ce nter@dfeh.ca.gov To obtain a federal Right to Sue notice, you must contact the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) to file a complaint within 30 days of receipt of this CRD Notice of Case Closure or within 300 days of the alleged discriminatory act, whichever is earlier. Sincerely, Civil Rights Department CRD - ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
48
1 COMPLAINT OF EMPLOYMENT DISCRIMINATION BEFORE THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 2 Civil Rights Department Under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (Gov. Code,§ 12900 et seq.) 3 4 5 In the Matter of the Complaint of Vincent Singh 6 7 8 9 10 11 CRD No. 202302-19577802 Complainant, vs . Tesla, Inc. 1 Tesla Road Austin, TX 78725 Tesla Motors, Inc. 1 Tesla Road Austin, TX 78725 12 Respondents 13 14 15 1. Respondent Tesla, Inc. is an employer subject to suit under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) (Gov. Code,§ 12900 et seq .). 16 2.Complainant is naming Tesla Motors, Inc. business as Co-Respondent(s). 17 3. Complainant Vincent Singh, resides in the City of, State of . 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 4. Complainant alleges that on or about September 23, 2022, respondent took the following adverse actions: Complainant was harassed because of complainant's ancestry, national origin (includes language restrictions), color, religious creed - includes dress and grooming practices, disability (physical, intellectual/developmental, mental health/psychiatric), race (includes hairstyle and hair texture). Complainant was discriminated against because of complainant's ancestry, national origin (includes language restrictions), color, religious creed - includes dress and grooming practices, disability (physical, intellectual/developmental, mental health/psychiatric), race (includes hairstyle and hair texture) and as a result of the discrimination was terminated, denied hire or promotion, reprimanded , suspended, denied accommodation for religious 26 -1Complaint- CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed: February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
49
1 beliefs, denied work opportunities or assignments, denied or forced to transfer, denied accommodation for a disability. 2 3 4 5 Complainant experienced retaliation because complainant reported or resisted any form of discrimination or harassment, requested or used a disability-related accommodation, requested or used a religious accommodation, participated as a witness in a discrimination or harassment complaint and as a result was terminated, denied hire or promotion, reprimanded, suspended, demoted, denied work opportunities or assignments, denied or forced to transfer, denied accommodation for a disability. 6 7 8 g 1O 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 2S Additional Complaint Details: At all times mentioned herein, PLAINTIFF Vincent Singh (hereinafter, "PLAINTIFF") was an individual employed by Defendant Tesla, Inc. and/or Tesla Motor, Inc. (hereinafter, "DEFENDANT") as a Production Associate. PLAINTIFF' job was to work in DEFENDANTS' factory located at 47700 Kato Road, in the City of Fremont and County of Alameda, State of California, assembling components for electrical batteries. PLAINTIFF was, at all relevant times, a resident in the County of San Joaquin, State of California. PLAINTIFF is of mixed racial heritage, including South Asian (Indian), Mexican, African-American, and Fijian ancestry. PLAINTIFF practices the Christian faith. PLAINTIFF was hired by DEFENDANT through Indeed.com, an online recruiting platform. During the interview and hiring process, PLAINTIFF informed DEFENDANT's recruiter that he suffered from asthma. Qnce PLAINTIFF began working for DEFENDANT, his asthma malady was never brought up as a matter to be considered in his work assignment until he complained about its being aggravated, as described in greater depth, below. PLAINTIFF began working for DEFENDANT on or about October 11, 2021. PLAINTIFF was hired as a production associate. In the department where PLAINTIFF was assigned, there are giant tub mixers that combine powders for making battery components. PLAINTIFF was tasked with whisking the powder and then inserting it into a machine, which was part of production line for making batteries used in DEFENDANT's electric motor vehicles. During his employment with DEFENDANT, PLAINTIFF performed as expected or better, except when he was punitively assigned to dysfunctional equipment that limited his productivity, as described in greater depth, below. At the time, PLAINTIFF was unaware that he was being exposed to anode powder, which caused him harmful health effects and aggravated his asthma. PLAINTIFF first complained to his supervisor, Mr. Rohit Sharma ("Sharma") about this; Sharma was dismissive and argumentative in response to PLAINTIFF's complaints. PLAINTIFF continued to work mixing powders, despite the continued aggravation of his asthma. After spending about two months in this initial department mixing anode powder, PLAINTIFF complained to his manager, Opinder Baines ("Baines"), orally about his asthma condition as it worsened. Baines, who PLAINTIFF is informed and believes is also of Indian descent, asked why PLAINTIFF wore a turban, and criticized his faith by telling him he is "not really a Christian." After approximately three months of employment with DEFENDANT, PLAINTIFF was moved to a different work area where automatic feeders that assisted with mixing process were not properly working. PLAINTIFF had to manually mix the powder in a larger feeder, which caused the anode powder to form a dust cloud above the mixture. PLAINTIFF breathed in 26 -2Complaint- CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed: February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
50
1 this dust, which caused him several health issues including hives, nausea, migraines, 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 g 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 shortness of breath, and severely exacerbated his asthma. In or around December 2021, PLAINTIFF complained to his supervisor, Sharma, that the powder was causing him significant harm, that he already had asthma and was suffering additional symptoms. Rather than address PLAINTIFF's health concerns, Sharma mocked PLAINTIFF, telling him to "stop crying like a baby." Sharma also insulted PLAINTIFF due to his multi-racial background, making comments like "just feed the powder, little mutt," and calling him "stupid" and "retarded." After additional complaints by PLAINTIFF, Sharma told PLAINTIFF to get a note from a doctor. PLAINTIFF went to his doctor at his local Kaiser Permanente hospital. PLAINTIFF received a note from the doctor saying that due to his medical condition, PLAINTIFF needed to stay away from the powder. PLAINTIFF returned to work the following day and gave the doctor's note, containing private medical information, to his team lead, a man known to him as Jack K. Jack K. told PLAINTIFF that he would give the doctor's note to a supervisor. A few minutes later, a coworker handed the doctor's note to PLAINTIFF, saying he found it on the floor, where it was covered in dirt and black powder. PLAINTIFF took the note to Sharma, explaining how it had been found on the floor, and complained that his private medical information was being treated negligently. Sharma ignored the complaints but took the note. The following day, Sharma informed PLAINTIFF that he would take the doctor's note to Human Resources and directed PLAINTIFF to continue working in the same location with the noxious powders. PLAINTIFF suffered an outbreak of hives, a severe migraine, and respiratory difficulties, but continued to work. On the third day after PLAINTIFF procured the doctor's note, Sharma returned it to him and informed him that he was required to deliver it to HR himself. PLAINTIFF took a photo of the doctor's note and emailed it to Lewis Botsford ("Botsford"), a senior HR staffer with DEFENDANT. Botsford did not respond until approximately 10 days later, two weeks after PLAINTIFF received the doctor's note, to inform PLAINTIFF that he was required to fill out forms requesting accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act ("ADA"). In the two weeks between PLAINTIFF's securing the note to Botsford's response, PLAINTIFF was required to continue working in the same workspace with the same noxious powders that the doctor told PLAINTIFF he should avoid-a fact of which Sharma was aware as soon as PLAINTIFF received the doctor's note. PLAINTIFF attempted to get the ADA application filled, but there was a problem between PLAINTIFF's doctor and DEFENDANT's HR department, the details of which were never fully explained to PLAINTIFF. DEFENDANT made no further effort to help PLAINTIFF resolve the problem and HR staff told him that they were not allowed to help him fill out the paperwork. In or about mid-December 2021, PLAINTIFF was assigned to work with a more toxic powder, which required him to dress in a papr hazmat suit. This made it difficult for PLAINTIFF to breathe, causing additional flare-ups of his health problems. The air filtration system that feeds air into the suit further aggravated his situation and triggered asthma attacks. PLAINTIFF sent an email to Botsford complaining about this transfer, its impact on 26 -3Complaint- CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed: February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
51
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 g 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 his health, and his belief that the transfer was meant to be an act of harassment by his supervisors. PLAINTIFF was transferred back to his regular position within a few days. While the problem with HR and the ADA appl ication was ongoing, PLAINTIFF continued to work in the same workspace with the same noxious powders, which continued to cause him significant health problems. When PLAINTIFF complained to his supervisors about the health problems, they continued to ignore his complaints, unless they were belittling him for his health problems and making slurs about his mixed-race heritage. PLAINTIFF complained to Botsford about these insults, but Botsford did not respond . Upon Botsford's failure to respond to PLAINTIFF's complaints, PLAINTIFF contacted Botsford's superior, HR Manager Tracy Thomas ("Thomas"). After PLAINTIFF contacted Thomas, Botsford responded finally. PLAINTIFF told Botsford that he believed Sharma was being told of PLAINTIFF's complaints about Sharma's abusive behavior, because Sharma began acting with greater hostility against PLAINTIFF. On or about December 27, 2021 , PLAINTIFF complained to DEFENDANT's employee relations staffer Benita Patel ("Patel") about the ongoing abuse by his superiors. This abuse included racial taunts , calling him "carpet boy" and "brown boy" in reference to his Asian heritage, while also telling him to "quit acting like a nigger" and "stop complain ing, it's just powder." On or about December 27, 2021, PLAINTIFF was called into a meeting with his supervisors Baines, Corona, and Sharma. During this meeting, PLAINTIFF was asked why he refused to work with the more toxic powder. PLAINTIFF explained that the papr hazmat suit and air filtration system made his breathing difficult and triggered asthma attacks, which constitutes a bona fide complaint about workplace health and safety. Later that day, PLAINTIFF received an email from Sharma purporting to memorialize the meeting, but which grossly mischaracterized what had occurred and accused PLAINTIFF of insubordination for refusing the assignment. Around this time, PLAINTIFF reached such a level of stress and anxiety that he reached out directly to DEFENDANT's CEO Elon Musk to inform him about the constant abuse, harassment, and retaliation he faced . Musk did not respond. Approximately two weeks after PLAINTIFF made his complaints to Botsford, Thomas, and Patel, he was moved under a different supervisor, Omar Corona ("Corona"). However, PLAINTIFF worked with the same noxious powder and his health condition continued to suffer. PLAINTIFF regularly overheard Corona using racial and ethnic slurs toward other employees, including telling a Caucasian employee, "Get back in there, whitey, you're acting like a nigger." Corona continued to use abusive language and racial slurs against PLAINTIFF, calling him "carpet boy" or "brown boy" no fewer than 20 times . Approximately one month after PLAINTIFF made his complaints to Botsford, Thomas, and Patel , he was moved to another workspace where he was not required to work with the noxious powders. His health condition steadily improved , including fewer respiratory issues. The reprieve was short-lived, as PLAINTIFF was returned to the powder-mixing position three weeks later. His health began to deteriorate almost immediately on his return . A short time after being reassigned to the powder mixing position, as his health condition worsened, PLAINTIFF approached his team lead Jack K. and asked to go home on a day when he was feeling especially ill. Jack K. told PLAINTIFF that if he left, he would receive a 25 26 -4- Complaint- CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed : February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
52
1 "point" in DEFENDANT's attendance system. In this system, 10 points in a six-month period is grounds for termination. 2 In addition to continuing the disregard for PLAINTIFF's health concerns, Jack K. also continued the pattern and practice of racial hostility, including calling PLAINTIFF a "terrorist" 3 in reference to his South Asian heritage. On one such occasion, on or about January 3, 2022, PLAINTIFF was so upset that he had 4 to repair to a restroom to keep from breaking down publicly. As PLAINTIFF was returning to work from the restroom, he was approached by Baines , who 5 asked if PLAINTIFF was a "female," as though that would be a reason for him to spend so much time in the restroom. When PLAINTIFF responded that he was not feeling well, Baines 6 called him "a disgrace to Indians" and a "stupid Christian." 7 Later that day, PLAINTIFF sent Patel an email recounting the above incident with Baines, describing it as an example of harassment, intimidation, and retaliation by his supervisors. 8 Not long after sending his email, PLAINTIFF received an email from Baines threatening discipline for his use of the restroom. PLAINTIFF replied to Baines and the other supervisors g cc'd on the email that this was another incident of harassment, intimidation, and retaliation. PLAINTIFF faced other incidents of harassment and retaliation, and specific events meant 10 to cause him public humiliation and ostracism. On least three occasions, PLAINTIFF's department had pizza parties to which PLAINTIFF was not invited, and at least one of which 11 PLAINTIFF was specifically told he was excluded from and was barred from entering the room. 12 In or about early February 2022, PLAINTIFF was informed that he would be transferred to the winding department. PLAINTIFF had not requested a transfer. PLAINTIFF later learned 13 that the same day he was transferred out of it, everybody in the department was given a $2.00 per hour pay increase. 14 In addition to being racially harassed and socially outcast, PLAINTIFF was subjected to sabotage in his work. On at least three occasions, while PLAINTIFF was mixing powder, he 15 requested assistance from a coworker to replenish his powder supply. When the coworker went to get more powder, the supervisor, Wade Bolinger ("Bolinger"), stopped the coworker 16 and engaged him in a conversation. Meanwhile, PLAINTIFF continued to yell to the 17 coworker that he was running out of powder. At some point, Baines came by to tell PLAINTIFF that he was running low on powder and should have replenished his supply. 18 Before PLAINTIFF could explain that Bolinger was preventing the coworker from getting more powder, Baines told PLAINTIFF he was doing a poor job and walked away. 19 In the winding department, where DEFENDANT transferred PLAINTIFF to avoid paying him a $2.00 per hour wage increase, there are 12 machines that wind, but some produce worse 20 or better yields of "jelly rolls"-internal battery components-based on their current state of repair. In addition to receiving insufficient training on the winding machines, PLAINTIFF 21 alleges that he was assigned to machines in various states of disrepair that routinely produced a smaller number of jelly rolls. PLAINTIFF believes this was deliberate and 22 another attempt to sabotage his work. PLAINTIFF had to leave his work area about 15 times per day to pick up cathode and anode 23 pancakes, which he had to retrieve from a warehouse on other side of department. This effort constituted a five-minute walk to the supply, then sometimes a wait on the material. On 24 average, it was a 10-minute process followed by a five-minute walk back to his workstation; 25 26 -5Complaint - CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed: February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
53
1 he did this approximately 15 times per day. From that point, it took additional five minutes to 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 g 1O 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 resupply and prepare his workstation to operate again. At least one time, Bolinger confronted PLAINTIFF, saying been missing for a long time. PLAINTIFF explained that he was resupplying and accounted for his time, all tasks that fell within his scope of duties. Bolinger in response said he did not care and told PLAINTIFF he was getting a verbal warning. The harassment continued with repeated accusations that PLAINTIFF was unjustifiably away from his workstation when he was busy securing supplies necessary for doing his work. Bolinger would call Baines, who would wait for PLAINTIFF, and upon his return falsely accuse him of going "missing" for two hours. PLAINTIFF would correctly deny the accusation and direct Baines to the surveillance cameras to confirm his story. The false accusation would stand, but without confirmation. At some point in early 2022, PLAINTIFF began to be followed by another employee, Ali E., who was a supervisor or superior in a different department. On one occasion, PLAINTIFF was away from his workstation, Ali E., without any apparent authority to question PLAINTIFF's whereabouts, sent PLAINTIFF a text message asking him why he was not at his workstation. PLAINTIFF responded to Ali E. and said to leave him alone. PLAINTIFF forwarded the text exchange to Baines, who responded with a "laughing face" emoji. PLAINTIFF also faced disparate treatment on sick leave, as Bolinger and Baines promised one thing but delivered another. On an occasion when PLAINTIFF was feeling unwell at work and thought he might faint, he walked away from his workstation to get a drink of water. When he did so, he was approached by Baines, who suggested that he might be better off going home. After returning to work for about two hours, PLAINTIFF determined that he could no longer work that day. PLAINTIFF approached Bolinger and said he was not well and asked if he would get into trouble if he went home for the day. Bolinger told PLAINTIFF that he would not get into any trouble. When PLAINTIFF returned to work, he was ordered to attend a department meeting where attendance issues were addressed. PLAINTIFF was directly challenged about the previous week's incident and two others where he had to leave work for illness. PLAINTIFF replied that he had asked Bolinger if there was any problem with going home early and was told there was not; Bolinger denied this occurred. PLAINTIFF received disciplinary write-ups for these absences. PLAINTIFF continued to be routinely assigned to winding machines that were somehow faulty and did not produce at full capacity. While coworkers were rotated through the machines, PLAINTIFF was ordered to use the faulty machines and was not provided a winding partner which caused difficulty in the operations of the machines. Nonetheless, he continued to reach or nearly reach his production quotas on a regular basis. PLAINTIFF was also subjected to public humiliation, including being singled out for ostracism, when team leaders pointed him out to new hires as someone to avoid, pointing to him and describing him as "the wrong crowd" and someone they "should not hang out with." After approximately three months in the winding department, PLAINTIFF received a threemonth review from Bolinger - the only performance review he received-where he was criticized for failing to keep up with the production quotas. Bolinger threatened PLAINTIFF that he would never advance in the company. PLAINTIFF was not given a copy of the review. 25 26 -6Complaint- CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed: February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
54
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 g 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 In or about July 2022, PLAINTIFF complained to Baines that Ali E. was continuing to follow and harass him, including following him to the restroom, which Baines denied. PLAINTIFF asked how many other employees were being similarly surveilled; Baines did not respond to the question. PLAINTIFF asked if this was discrimination against him; Baines again did not answer the question. In or about August 2022, PLAINTIFF overheard Ali E. say to another employee words to the effect of "you're being lazy. I thought Mexicans were supposed to work harder." Being part Mexican, PLAINTIFF took offense to this. He later complained to HR about this and was led to believe that an investigation was undertaken. On or about August 6, 2022, upon learning that Bolinger was being transferred to Texas, PLAINTIFF sent a message to Ali E., Bains, Bolinger, and others, stating he discovered on an internal HR portal several writeups that needed to be corrected before Bolinger left because some came under Bolinger's supervision, and because Bollinger had given PLAINTIFF permission to take requested time off that he was then written up for. PLAINTIFF stated that he felt these writeups were in effort to push him out and to fire him, that he felt retaliated against and might take matters higher up. PLAINTIFF stated that he loved his job at Tesla and wanted to be a part of its future in sustainable energy. PLAINTIFF received no response to this message. On or about August 8, 2022, PLAINTIFF wrote Aenoi V. Jones of Human Resources in a higher division ("Jones") that he tried to contact someone about his problems with his supervisors but was being redirected to his direct HR contact with whom he did not feel comfortable speaking because he believed that person communicated his complaints to those he complained about and was requesting someone else to speak with about his complaints. Jones replied on August 8, 2022, directing PLAINTIFF to reach out to the Senior HR Manager, Nicole Burgers ("Burgers"), and provided him with her email address and phone number. On or about August 8, 2022, PLAINTIFF called Burgers on the phone and told her his work performance was being sabotaged, that he was experience discrimination and harassment and told her about the investigation that he understood was started. Burgers told PLAINTIFF she would look into the investigation. On or about September 8, 2022, PLAINTIFF sent a text message to Burgers stating that he has multiple writeups and just received a final writeup on the internal HR portal. Burgers replied on September 9, 2022, stating she would look into it. On or about September 8 or 9, 2022, PLAINTIFF sent a message to his direct supervisors, HR, his HR manager's manager, and their managers, totaling 10-11 recipients. An investigator sent a message to PLAINTIFF stating she was working on the investigation and asked him to give her more information, which he did. Sometime thereabout, PLAINTIFF sent a message to Thomas, his direct HR Manager, but she did not open his message, which he confirmed through "read receipts" in the messaging app. PLAINTIFF's message had similar content to what he told Burgers. Thomas did not respond. On or about September 23, 2022, PLAINTIFF was called on the phone by Daniel Donenfeld, HR Partner, Vehicle Engineering & Cell Manufacturing Operations ("Donenfeld") and James Wall, who is the manager above Baines ("Wall"). Donenfeld left PLAINTIFF a voice mail and Wall sent a message to him on an internal messaging app, asking if they could schedule a 26 -7Complaint- CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed: February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
55
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 g 10 call that day. PLAINTIFF confirmed, and they later spoke to PLAINTIFF together and told him that due to safety reasons, PLAINTIFF's status of employment changed to termination and that it's a final decision that cannot be changed. They also mentioned they reviewed the warnings on his profile, and told PLAINTIFF to email HR if he has any questions. PLAINTIFF sent a message to Donenfeld stating that his verbal and non-verbal warnings were invalid, and Mr. Donenfeld replied Hi Vincent, all allegations were raised to appropriate parties and action is taken. On or about October 9, 2022, PLAINTIFF sent an email to Donenfeld asking the reason he was terminated . Donenfeld wrote back that "The reason for your termination is because it is more likely than not that you violated Tesla's policy." On or about October 21, 2022, PLAINTIFF replied to Mr. Donenfeld asking which policy was violated. PLAINTIFF never received any reply from Mr. Donenfeld. PLAINTIFF alleges that he was terminated for pretextual reasons motivated by discrimination based on race, religion, and disability, and in retaliation for complaining about harassment and health and safety hazards. As a result of the unlawful conduct by DEFENDANT and Does 1-50 as set forth in this Complaint, PLAINTIFF has suffered and continues to suffer economic damages, serious emotional suffering and damages, and other damages as will be proved at the time of trial. 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 -8Complaint - CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed: February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
PDF Page
56
1 VERIFICATION 2 3 4 5 6 I, Vincent Singh, am the Complainant in the above-entitled complaint. I have read the foregoing complaint and know the contents thereof. The same is true of my own knowledge, except as to those matters which are therein alleged on information and belief, and as to those matters, I believe it to be true. On February 10, 2023, I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct. Stockton, CA 7 8 9 \ Vincent sin gh (Feb 13, 2023 10:39 PST) 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 -911---------------------------------~ Complaint- CRD No. 202302-19577802 27 Date Filed : February 10, 2023 28 CRD-ENF 80 RS (Revised 12/22)
Issues Laws Cases News Firms Entities Pro