Page 1
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/25/2017 05:52 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 50
INDEX NO. 151179/2017
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/25/2017
EXHIBIT K
Page 2
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/25/2017 05:52 PM
3/21/2017 Dear Mr. Putin, I Am Not Sidney Blumenthal NYSCEF DOC. NO. 50 INDEX NO. 151179/2017 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/25/2017 AdChoices Dear Mr. Putin, I Am Not Sidney Blumenthal Newsweek Kurt Eichenwald 10/11/2016 SHARE SHARE TWEET SHARE EMAIL © REUTERS/Ivan Sekretarev/Pool Russian President Vladimir Putin listens to German Vice Chancellor and Economy Minister Sigmar Gabriel during their meeting at the Novo-Ogaryovo state residence outside Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.
I am Sidney Blumenthal. At least, that is what Vladimir Putin seems to believe. An email from Blumenthal—a confidant of Hillary Clinton and a man, second only to George Soros at the center of conservative conspiracy theories—turned up in the recent document dump by Wikileaks. At a time when American https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/dear-mr-putin-i-am-not-sidney-blumenthal/ar-BBxgxMx 1/5
Page 3
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/25/2017 05:52 PM
3/21/2017
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 50
Dear Mr. Putin, I Am Not Sidney Blumenthal
INDEX NO. 151179/2017
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/25/2017
intelligence believes Russian hackers are trying to interfere with the presidential election, records have been fed recently to Wikileaks out of multiple organizations of the Democratic Party, raising concerns that the self-proclaimed whistleblowers group has become a tool of Putin’s government. But now that I have been brought into the whole mess —and transformed into Blumenthal—there is even more proof that this act of cyberwar is not only being orchestrated by the Russians, but that they are really, really dumb.
The evidence turned up thanks to the incompetence of Sputnik, the Russian online news and radio service established by the government controlled news agency, Rossiya Segodnya.
The documents that Wikileaks unloaded recently have been emails out of the account of John Podesta, the chairman of Clinton’s election campaign. Almost as soon as the pilfered documents emerged, Sputnik was all over them and rapidly found (or probably already knew about before the Wikileaks dump) a purportedly incriminating email from Blumenthal. The email was amazing—it linked Boogie Man Blumenthal, Podesta and the topic of conservative political fevered dreams, Benghazi. This, it seemed, was the smoking gun finally proving Clinton bore total responsibility for the terrorist attack on the American outpost in Libya in 2012. Sputnik even declared that the email might be the “October surprise” that could undermine Clinton’s campaign.
To understand the full importance of the story—and how much Putin and his Kremlin cronies must have been dancing with delight—I have to quote the top few paragraphs:
In a major revelation from the second batch of WikiLeaks emails from Clinton Campaign Chairman John Podesta it was learned that Hillary's top confidante Sidney Blumenthal believed that the investigation into Benghazi was legitimate because it was "preventable" and the result of State Department negligence.
In an email titled "The Truth" from Hillary's top confidante Sidney Blumenthal, the adviser writing to undisclosed recipients said that "one important point that has been universally acknowledged by nine previous reports about recip p Beng ng he Benghazi:
The attack was almost certainly preventable" in what may turn out to be the big October surprise from the Wik W WikiLeaks released of emails hacked from the account of Clinton Campaign Chair John Podesta.
iki Then came the money quote: "Clinton was in charge of the State Department, and it failed to protect U.S. personnell at Then an American consulate in Libya. If the GOP wants to raise that as a talking point against her, it is legitimate," said Blumenthal, putting to rest the Democratic Party talking point that the investigation into Clinton's management of the State Department at the time of the attack was nothing more than a partisan witch hunt.
Those words sounded really, really familiar. Really familiar. Like, so familiar they struck me as something I wrote. Because they were something I wrote.
The Russians were quoting two sentences from a 10,000 word piece I wrote for Newsweek, which apparently Blumenthal had emailed to Podesta. They had carefully selected the “of course” paragraph, which essentially tipped a hat to the reality that there were legitimate points of criticism regarding Clinton and Benghazi, all of which had been acknowledged in nine reports about the terror attack and by the former Secretary of State herself. But that was hardly the point of the story, “Benghazi Biopsy: A Comprehensive Guide to One of America’s Worst Political Outrages.” The piece is about the obscene politicization of the assault that killed four Americans, and the article slammed the Republican Benghazi committee which was engaged in a political show trial disguised as a Congressional investigation —the tenth inquiry into the tragedy.
Here is the real summation of my article, which the Russians helpfully failed to quote: “The historical significance of this moment can hardly be overstated, and it seems many Republicans, Democrats and members of the media don’t fully understand the magnitude of what is taking place. The awesome power of government—one that allows officials to pore through almost anything they demand and compel anyone to talk or suffer the shame of taking the Fifth Amendment—has been unleashed for purely political purposes. It is impossible to review what the Benghazi committee https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/dear-mr-putin-i-am-not-sidney-blumenthal/ar-BBxgxMx
2/5
Page 4
INDEX NO. 151179/2017
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/25/2017 05:52 PM
3/21/2017 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 50 Dear Mr. Putin, I Am Not Sidney Blumenthal RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/25/2017 has done as anything other than taxpayer-funded political research of the opposing party’s leading candidate for president. Comparisons from America’s past are rare. Richard Nixon’s attempts to use the IRS to investigate his perceived enemies come to mind. So does Senator Joseph McCarthy’s red-baiting during the 1950s, with reckless accusations of treason leveled at members of the State Department, military generals and even the secretary of the Army…The consequences, however, are worse than the manipulation of the electoral process. By using Benghazi for political advantage, the Republicans have communicated to global militants that, through even limited attacks involving relatively few casualties, they can potentially influence the direction of American elections.” Of course, this might be seen as just an opportunity to laugh at the incompetence of the Russian hackers and government press—once they realized their error, Sputnik took the article down. But this is not funny at all. The Russians have been obtaining American emails and now are presenting complete misrepresentations of them— falsifying them—in hopes of setting off a cascade of events that might change the outcome of the presidential election. The big question, of course, is why are the Russians working so hard to damage Clinton and, in the process, aid Donald Trump. That is a topic for another time.
For now, though, Americans should be outraged. This totalitarian regime, engaged in what are arguably war crimes in Syria to protect their government puppet, is working to upend a democracy to the benefit of an American candidate who uttered positive comments just Sunday about the Kremlin's campaign on behalf of Bashar al-Assad. Trump’s arguments were an incomprehensible explication of the complex Syrian situation, which put him right on the side of the Iranians and Syrians who are fighting to preserve the government that is the primary conduit of weapons used against Israel.
So no, Mr. Putin, I’m not Sidney Blumenthal. And now that you have been exposed once again, get the hell out of our election.
MORE
MOR
M OR FOR YOU Promoted Links by Taboola ola Vets V Ve ts could receive up to $42k with these VA benefits in Pennsylvania LendingTree Mortgage Quotes Try One of the Best CPAP Masks of 2016 Risk Free Easy Breathe Golfers Are Replacing Their Lob Wedge with THIS All-New Club C3i Golf Dem lawmaker tweets: 'Get ready for impeachment' The Hill On MSN Fremont detectives fatally shoot girl, 16, in car that rammed them San Francisco Chronicle On MSN New documents show Trump aide hid payments from Ukraine party with Moscow ties, lawmaker alleges The Washington Post On MSN https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/dear-mr-putin-i-am-not-sidney-blumenthal/ar-BBxgxMx 3/5
Back to 
