6400 PLEASURE AVENUE, et al v. MARKEL PRODUCTS, et al :: New Jersey District Court :: Federal Civil Lawsuit No. 1:92-cv-00387-JFG

Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription.

--	Filed: 5/17/1994, Entered: 5/17/1994	Terminated Case
	Case closed (Settled) (lc)


63	Filed: 5/16/1994, Entered: 5/17/1994	Substitution of Attorney
	SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT, SCOVILL, INC. (lc)


62	Filed: 5/16/1994, Entered: 5/17/1994	Order
	ORDER dismissing action without prejudice and without costs. (signed by Chief Judge John F. Gerry) (lc)


61	Filed: 4/28/1994, Entered: 5/2/1994	Pretrial Order
	JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER filed (signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen) (lc)


60	Filed: 4/5/1994, Entered: 4/7/1994	Order
	MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER denying defendants Nutone, Inc., Scovill, Inc., and Norstat, Inc. the motion for Summary Judgment of the individual plaintiffs' claims. (signed by Chief Judge John F. Gerry) (lc)


59	Filed: 4/4/1994, Entered: 4/5/1994	Remark
	Letter on behalf of the defendant Scovill, Inc. to join in the application of deft. Nutone Inc. for an order dismissing the individual claims of Cheryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen. (lc)


58	Filed: 3/31/1994, Entered: 3/31/1994	Minutes-Miscellaneous
	Minute entry: Proceedings recorded by Ct-Reporter: Ted Formaroli; Minutes of: 3.31.94; The following actions were taken, [56-1] motion for an order dismissing the claims of plaintiffs Cheryl Graham and Raymond Hagen because the Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over each claim taken under advisement/DECISION RESERVED. Terminating [56-2] hearing Motion hearing set for 9:30 3/31/94 on [56-1] motion. By Chief Judge John F. Gerry. (lc)


--	Filed: 3/29/1994, Entered: 3/29/1994	Set/Reset Deadlines:
	Deadline updated; Motion hearing set for 9:30 3/31/94 for [56-1] motion for an order dismissing the claims of plaintiffs Cheryl Graham and Raymond Hagen because the Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over each claim (lc)


--	Filed: 3/29/1994, Entered: 3/29/1994	Set/Reset Deadlines:
	Deadline updated; Motion hearing set for 9:30 3/31/94 for [57-1] motion for an order to Dismiss the individual claims of Plaintiffs Cheryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen (lc)


57	Filed: 3/17/1994, Entered: 3/17/1994, Terminated: 4/5/1994	Motion to Dismiss
	Notice of MOTION for an order to Dismiss the individual claims of Plaintiffs Cheryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen by deft. NORSTAT, INC., Motion hearing set for 9:30 3/31/94 on [57-1] motion "Brief Submitted" (lc) Modified on 03/29/1994


56	Filed: 2/28/1994, Entered: 3/1/1994	Motion to Dismiss
	Notice of MOTION for an order dismissing the claims of plaintiffs Cheryl Graham and Raymond Hagen because the Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over each claim by Deft. NUTONE, INC., Motion hearing set for 9:30 3/31/94 on [56-1] motion (Certificate of Service attached thereto) (lc) Modified on 03/29/1994


55	Filed: 2/28/1994, Entered: 2/28/1994, Terminated: 5/17/1994	Answer to Crossclaim
	ANSWER by deft. SCOVILL, INC. to [52-1] cross claim. (lc)


54	Filed: 2/28/1994, Entered: 2/28/1994, Terminated: 5/17/1994	Answer to Crossclaim
	ANSWER by deft. SCOVILL, INC. to [50-2] cross claim. (lc)


53	Filed: 2/14/1994, Entered: 2/15/1994	Certificate Of Service.
	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of [52-1] Answer to Fourth Amended Complaint, etc. (lc)


52	Filed: 2/14/1994, Entered: 2/15/1994	Counterclaim
	COUNTERCLAIM by deft. NORSTAT, INC. against plaintiffs CHERYL ANN GRAHAM, and RAYMOND HAGAN. (lc)


52	Filed: 2/14/1994, Entered: 2/15/1994	Crossclaim
	CROSSCLAIMS by deft. NORSTAT, INC. against Co-Defts. NUTONE, INC., and SCOVILL, INC. (lc)


52	Filed: 2/14/1994, Entered: 2/15/1994	Answer to Amended Complaint
	ANSWER by NORSTAT, INC. to Fourth amended complaint with jury demand. (lc)


51	Filed: 2/7/1994, Entered: 2/7/1994, Terminated: 5/17/1994	Answer to Crossclaim
	ANSWER by deft. NUTONE, INC. to [44-2] cross claim filed by defendant Norstat, Inc. (lc)


50	Filed: 2/7/1994, Entered: 2/7/1994, Terminated: 5/17/1994	Answer
	ANSWER to Fourth Amended complaint with jury demand and CROSSCLAIM by NUTONE, INC. against NORSTAT, INC. and SCOVILL, INC. (lc)


49	Filed: 2/7/1994, Entered: 2/7/1994	Counterclaim
	COUNTERCLAIM by deft. SCOVILL, INC. against Plaintiffs CHERYL ANN GRAHAM and RAYMOND HAGAN. (lc)


49	Filed: 2/7/1994, Entered: 2/7/1994, Terminated: 5/17/1994	Answer to Amended Complaint
	ANSWER TO FOURTH AMENDED COMPLAINT with jury demand and CROSSCLAIM by deft. SCOVILL, INC. 10/23/92 against NUTONE, INC., NORSTAT, INC. (lc)


48	Filed: 1/31/1994, Entered: 2/1/1994	Summons Returned Executed
	RETURN OF SERVICE of Third Amended Complaint executed by Certified Mail as to NORSTAT, INC. 1/18/94 Answer due on 2/7/94 for NORSTAT, INC. (lc)


47	Filed: 1/21/1994, Entered: 1/21/1994, Terminated: 5/17/1994	Answer
	ANSWER to complaint and CROSSCLAIM by deft SCOVILL, INC. against deft. NORSTAT, INC. (lc)


46	Filed: 1/14/1994, Entered: 1/19/1994	Amended Complaint
	PLAINTIFFS' FOURTH AMENDED COMPLAINT. (lc)


44	Filed: 1/5/1994, Entered: 1/6/1994	Certificate Of Service.
	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE re: [43-1] Answer. (lc) Modified on 01/11/1994


43	Filed: 1/5/1994, Entered: 1/6/1994	Answer to Amended Complaint
	ANSWER TO THIRD AMENDED COMPLAINT with jury demand and CROSSCLAIM by deft. NORSTAT, INC. against defts. SCOVILL, INC. and NUTONE, INC. (lc) Modified on 01/11/1994


42	Filed: 1/5/1994, Entered: 1/5/1994	Order
	ORDER that the complaint be dismissed in its entirety pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(c) for failure to properly plead that each plaintiff's claim satisfies the amount in controversy required to afford this court subject matter jurisdiction, SUBJECT, however to the plaintiffs' right to file an amended complaint within 14 days of this order to state the amount in controversy for each plaintiff with sufficient specificity. (signed by Chief Judge John F. Gerry) (lc) Modified on 01/11/1994


41	Filed: 1/5/1994, Entered: 1/5/1994	Minutes-Miscellaneous
	Minute entry: Proceedings recorded by Ct-Reporter: Ted Formaroli; Minutes of: 1/5/94; The following actions were taken, granting [32-1] motion for an order dismissing the individual claims of Cherryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen Against Nutone, Inc. for Lack of subject matter jurisdiction etc. Terminating [32-2] hearing Motion hearing set for 9:30 10/01/93 on [32-1] motion. (Motion Granted, subject to plaintiffs' right to file an Amended Complaint within 14 days) By Chief Judge John F. Gerry. (lc) Modified on 01/11/1994


40	Filed: 12/29/1993, Entered: 1/3/1994	Answer to Amended Complaint
	ANSWER TO THIRD AMENDED COMPLAINT with jury demand and CROSSCLAIM by deft. SCOVILL, INC. against NUTONE, INC., and NORSTAT, INC. (lc)


--	Filed: 12/9/1993, Entered: 12/9/1993	Summons Issued
	SUMMONS(ES) on Amended Complaint issued for deft. NORSTAT, INC. ( 35 Days) (Mailed to Counsel) (lc)


39	Filed: 12/8/1993, Entered: 12/9/1993	Amended Complaint
	PLAINTIFFS' THIRD AMENDED COMPLAINT.AM, RAYMOND HAGAN, 6400 (lc)


38	Filed: 12/8/1993, Entered: 12/9/1993	Stipulation
	STIPULATION TO AMEND COMPLAINT. (lc)


37	Filed: 12/6/1993, Entered: 12/9/1993	Pretrial Order
	FINAL SCHEDULING ORDER filed (signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen) (lc)


--	Filed: 12/2/1993, Entered: 12/7/1993	Scheduling Conference
	Scheduling conference held before Magistrate Joel B. Rosen on 12/2/93. (lc)


--	Filed: 11/22/1993, Entered: 11/22/1993	Set/Reset Deadlines:
	Deadline updated; Motion hearing set for 9:30 12/17/93 for [32-1] motion for an order dismissing the individual claims of Cherryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen Against Nutone, Inc. for Lack of subject matter jurisdiction etc. (femp)


--	Filed: 10/26/1993, Entered: 10/26/1993	Summons Issued
	THIRD PARTY SUMMONS(ES) issued for Third party defendant NORSTAT, INC. (35 Days) (Mailed to Counsel) (lc)


36	Filed: 10/18/1993, Entered: 10/19/1993	Third-Party Complaint
	THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT by deft. NUTONE, INC. against NORSTAT, INC. WITH JURY DEMAND. (lc)


--	Filed: 10/6/1993, Entered: 10/6/1993	Set/Reset Deadlines:
	Deadline updated; Motion hearing set for 9:30 11/19/93 for [32-1] motion for an order dismissing the individual claims of Cherryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen Against Nutone, Inc. for Lack of subject matter jurisdiction etc. (femp)


35	Filed: 10/1/1993, Entered: 10/6/1993	Order
	ORDER granting defendant Nutone, Inc.'s [28-1] motion for leave to file a Third Party Complaint within 10 days of the day of the entry of this order, and Counsel of the parties will appear before the court for a scheduling conference on 11-9-93 at 9:30 a.m. (signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen) (lc)


34	Filed: 9/27/1993, Entered: 10/1/1993	Minutes-Miscellaneous
	Minute entry: Proceedings recorded by Ct-Reporter: None; Minutes of: 9.27.93; The following actions were taken, granting [28-1] motion for leave to file a Third Party Complaint. Order to be entered. Terminating [28-2] hearing Motion hearing set for 9:30 9/3/93 on [28-1] motion. By Magistrate Joel B. Rosen. (lc)


--	Filed: 9/17/1993, Entered: 9/21/1993	Set/Reset Deadlines:
	Deadline updated; resetting/continuing motion for leave to file athird party complt to 10/1/93 ORAL AGR 9:30am before JBR (ln)


33	Filed: 9/14/1993, Entered: 9/14/1993	Certification
	CERTIFICATION of Kenneth R. Perry Re: [32-1] motion for an order dismissing the individual claims of Cherryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen Against Nutone, Inc. for Lack of subject matter jurisdiction etc. (lc)


32	Filed: 9/14/1993, Entered: 9/14/1993, Terminated: 1/5/1994	Motion to Dismiss
	Notice of MOTION for an order dismissing the individual claims of Cherryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen Against Nutone, Inc. for Lack of subject matter jurisdiction etc. by deft. NUTONE, INC., Motion hearing set for 9:30 10/01/93 on [32-1] motion BRIEFS SUBMITTTED (ORAL ARGUMENT REQUESTED) (lc) Modified on 09/14/1993


--	Filed: 9/14/1993, Entered: 9/14/1993	Set/Reset Deadlines:
	Deadline updated; Motion hearing set for 9:30 10/1/93 for [32-1] motion for an order dismissing the individual claims of Cherryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen Against Nutone, Inc. for Lack of subject matter jurisdiction etc. (lc) Modified on 09/21/1993


30	Filed: 8/17/1993, Entered: 8/17/1993	Letter
	LETTER by the Clerk returning Notice of Motion to dismiss the claims of pltfs. Cherryl Ann Graham and Raymond Hagen FOR FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH LOCAL RULE 12 N. (lc)


31	Filed: 8/13/1993, Entered: 8/18/1993	Pretrial Order
	JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER filed (signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen) (lc)


29	Filed: 7/23/1993, Entered: 7/26/1993	Certificate Of Service.
	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE re:[28-1] Notice of motion to file a Third-party complaint. (lc)


28	Filed: 7/23/1993, Entered: 7/26/1993, Terminated: 10/1/1993	Motion for Leave to File
	Notice of MOTION for leave to file a Third Party Complaint by defendant NUTONE, INC. [28-1] motion referred to Magistrate Joel B. Rosen, Motion hearing set for 9:30 9/3/93 on [28-1] motion (Certificate of Service attached thereto) "ORAL ARGUMENT REQUESTED (lc)


26	Filed: 4/20/1993, Entered: 4/21/1993	Order
	ORDER denying as moot plaintiffs' [25-1] motion for sanctions against deft. NUTONE, INC. for failure to comply with court's order compelling discovery (signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen) (lc) Modified on 04/21/1993


27	Filed: 4/16/1993, Entered: 4/23/1993	Minutes-Miscellaneous
	Minute entry: Proceedings recorded by Ct-Reporter: None; Minutes of: 4/16/93; The following actions were taken, denying as moot [25-1] motion for sanctions against deft. NUTONE, INC. for failure to comply with court's order compelling discovery. Order to be entered. By Magistrate Joel B. Rosen. (lc)


Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription.

25	Filed: 3/16/1993, Entered: 3/17/1993, Terminated: 4/20/1993	Motion for Sanctions
	Notice of MOTION for sanctions against deft. NUTONE, INC. for failure to comply with court's order compelling discovery) by plaintiffs, CHERYL ANN GRAHAM, RAYMOND HAGAN, 6400 PLEASURE AVENUE [25-1] motion referred to Magistrate Joel B. Rosen, Motion hearing set for 9:30 4/16/93 on [25-1] motion (MEMO SUBMITTED) . (lc) Modified on 03/17/1993


23	Filed: 2/16/1993, Entered: 2/19/1993	Pretrial Order
	FINAL SCHEDULING ORDER filed (signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen) (lc)


24	Filed: 2/12/1993, Entered: 2/19/1993	Order
	ORDER that defendant, Nutone, Inc. provide complete and responsive answers/responses to plaintiffs' First Request for a Production of Documents, Plaintiffs' Second Set of Interrogatories and plaintiffs' First Set of Interrogatories 4,5,7-20,23-42, 46,48,49 and 56 by Monday 3-8-93. (signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen) (lc)


22	Filed: 10/15/1992, Entered: 10/15/1992, Terminated: 5/17/1994	Answer
	ANSWER to Complaint by deft. NUTONE, INC. (lc)


21	Filed: 10/5/1992, Entered: 10/6/1992	Order
	CONSENT ORDER that the time for defendant Nutone, Inc. to answer is extended until 10-23-92. reset answer due for 10/23/92 for NUTONE, INC. ( signed by Chief Judge John F. Gerry) (lc)


20	Filed: 9/4/1992, Entered: 9/14/1992	Summons Returned Executed
	RETURN OF SERVICE of Summons and Complaint executed (Certified Mail) as to defts. NUTONE, INC., and SCOVILL, INC. on 8/6/92; Answer due on 8/26/92 for defts. SCOVILL, INC., for NUTONE, INC. (lc)


19	Filed: 8/17/1992, Entered: 8/21/1992	Crossclaim
	CROSSCLAIM by deft. SCOVILL, INC. against deft. NUTONE, INC. (lc)


19	Filed: 8/17/1992, Entered: 8/21/1992	Answer to Amended Complaint
	ANSWER TO AMENDED COMPLAINT; jury demand and COUNTERCLAIM by deft. SCOVILL, INC. against plaintiffs CHERYL ANN GRAHAM and RAYMOND HAGAN. (lc)


--	Filed: 7/31/1992, Entered: 7/31/1992	Summons Issued
	SUMMONS(ES) on Amended Complaint issued for defts. SCOVILL, INC., and NUTONE, INC. ( 35 Days) (Mailed to Counsel) (lc)


18	Filed: 7/29/1992, Entered: 7/31/1992	Amended Complaint
	AMENDED COMPLAINT by plaintiffs, CHERYL ANN GRAHAM, RAYMOND HAGAN, 6400 PLEASURE AVENUE , (Answer due 8/8/92 for SCOVILL, INC.) amending [1-1] complaint against NUTONE, INC. (lc)


--	Filed: 7/28/1992, Entered: 7/28/1992	Scheduling Conference
	Scheduling conference held before Magistrate Joel B. Rosen on 7/13/92. (lc)


17	Filed: 7/22/1992, Entered: 7/28/1992	Order
	ORDER dismissing defendant Markel Products, without prejudice and permiting plaintiff to file a Second Amended Complaint naming Nutone, Inc. as a defendant in this case. ( signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen ) (lc)


16	Filed: 7/20/1992, Entered: 7/27/1992	Answer to Amended Complaint
	ANSWER OF DEFENDANT SCOVILL, INC. TO AMENDED COMPLAINT, SEPARATE DEFENSES, JURY DEMAND AND COUNTERCLAIM against plaintiffs CHERYL ANN GRAHAM and RAYMOND HAGAN. (lc)


13	Filed: 7/17/1992, Entered: 7/17/1992, Terminated: 5/17/1994	Answer to Amended Complaint
	ANSWER to AMENDED COMPLAINT with jury demand and COUNTERCLAIM by deft. SCOVILL, INC. against pltfs. RAYMOND HAGAN and CHERYL ANN GRAHAM. (mgr)


15	Filed: 7/16/1992, Entered: 7/21/1992	Miscellaneous Document
	TRACK ONE ORDER OF DESIGNATION signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen FILED (lc)


14	Filed: 7/16/1992, Entered: 7/21/1992	Scheduling Order
	SCHEDULING ORDER setting Discovery cutoff 1/29/93 ; Pretrial order to be submitted on or before 9:45 4/26/93 ; (signed by Chief Judge John F. Gerry) (lc)


12	Filed: 7/6/1992, Entered: 7/7/1992	Summons Returned Executed
	RETURN OF SERVICE of Summons and Complaint executed (by Certified Mail) as to defendant SCOVILL, INC. on 6/8/92. Answer due on 6/28/92 for SCOVILL, INC. (lc)


11	Filed: 7/6/1992, Entered: 7/7/1992	Summons Returned Executed
	RETURN OF SERVICE of Summons and Complaint, executed (by Certified Mail) as to deft. MARKEL PRODUCTS on 6/5/92. Answer due on 6/25/92 for MARKEL PRODUCTS. (lc)


10	Filed: 6/26/1992, Entered: 7/1/1992	Affidavit
	AFFIDAVIT of Service Re: [9-1] Answer. (lc)


9	Filed: 6/26/1992, Entered: 7/1/1992	Answer
	ANSWER to Complaint; jury demand and COUNTERCLAIM by deft. MARKEL PRODUCTS against plaintiffs CHERYL ANN GRAHAM, RAYMOND HAGAN and 6400 PLEASURE AVENUE (lc)


--	Filed: 6/26/1992, Entered: 7/1/1992	Crossclaim
	CROSSCLAIM by deft. MARKEL PRODUCTS against deft. SCOVILL, INC. (This is part of pleading #9) (lc) Modified on 07/01/1992


--	Filed: 6/2/1992, Entered: 6/2/1992	Summons Issued
	SUMMONS(ES) on Amended Complaint issued for deft. SCOVILL, INC. ( 35 Days) (Mailed to Counsel) (lc)


8	Filed: 5/29/1992, Entered: 6/2/1992	Amended Complaint
	AMENDED COMPLAINT, amending [1-1] complaint against SCOVILL, INC. (lc)


7	Filed: 5/29/1992, Entered: 6/2/1992	Stipulation
	STIPULATION AND ORDER TO AMEND COMPLAINT. (lc)


6	Filed: 3/23/1992, Entered: 3/23/1992	Order
	ORDER, set scheduling conference for 11:15 5/6/92 ( signed by Magistrate Joel B. Rosen ) (lc)


5	Filed: 3/20/1992, Entered: 3/23/1992	Affidavit
	AFFIDAVIT of Service Re: [4-1] answer. (lc)


4	Filed: 3/20/1992, Entered: 3/23/1992	Answer
	ANSWER to Complaint; jury demand and COUNTERCLAIM by defendant MARKEL PRODUCTS against plaintiffs CHERYL ANN GRAHAM, RAYMOND HAGAN, 6400 PLEASURE AVENUE . (lc)


3	Filed: 2/25/1992, Entered: 2/27/1992	Acknowledgment of Service
	ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE of Summons and Complaint Served by Certified Mail as to defendant MARKEL PRODUCTS on 2/10/92; Answer due on 3/1/92 for MARKEL PRODUCTS. (lc)


2	Filed: 1/31/1992, Entered: 1/31/1992	Case Assigned/Reassigned
	NOTICE of Allocation and Assignment filed. Magistrate Joel B. Rosen (femp)


--	Filed: 1/31/1992, Entered: 1/31/1992	Summons Issued
	SUMMONS(ES) issued for MARKEL PRODUCTS ( 35 Days) (Mailed to Counsel) (femp)


1	Filed: 1/30/1992, Entered: 1/31/1992	Complaint
	COMPLAINT filed;; jury demand FILING FEE $ 120.00 RECEIPT # 148939 (femp)