JUDGMENT of USCA vacating the order of March 3, 2022 and remanding for further proceedings as to [1049] Notice of Interlocutory Appeal filed by Accenture LLP (Attachments: # (1) USCA Opinion)(kos, Deputy Clerk)
Status Conference held on 7/11/2023 before Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher.(Court Reporter: Patricia Mitchell) Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG et al.(yks, Deputy Clerk)
ORDER denying without prejudice [1106] Defendants Partial Motion for Summary Judgment; granting [1120] Motion to Seal. Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 7/5/2023. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
LETTER ORDER scheduling an in-person status conference for July 11, 2023 at 11:30 a.m. Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 6/7/2023. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
RESPONSE re [1106] Sealed Document, DEFENDANTS REPLY MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING FINES filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 17)(Warren, Daniel)
Order on Motion for Extension of Time to File Response / Reply
ORDER granting [1123] MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE A REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MARRIOTTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT. Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 5/8/2023. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Motion for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply
MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE A REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MARRIOTTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Warren, Daniel)
RESPONSE in Opposition re (1105 in 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 72 in 8:19-cv-00654-SAG) MOTION to Seal DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF EXHIBITS FILED IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING FINES-- Plaintiff City of Chicagos Memorandum in Opposition to Defendants Second Motion for Summary Judgment [Dkts. 1106, 1107] filed by City of Chicago. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit List, # (2) Notice of Filing Under Seal, # (3) Exhibit 2, # (4) Exhibit 10, # (5) Exhibit 11, # (6) Exhibit 12, # (7) Exhibit 13, # (8) Exhibit 14, # (9) Exhibit 15, # (10) Exhibit 16, # (11) Exhibit 17, # (12) Exhibit 18)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 8:19-cv-00654-SAG(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
MOTION to Seal Plaintiff City of Chicagos Motion for Leave to File Portions of Its Opposition to Defendants Second Motion for Summary Judgment Under Seal by City of Chicago (Attachments: # (1) Proposed Order, # (2) Exhibit A)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 8:19-cv-00654-SAG(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
Order on Motion for Extension of Time to File Response / Reply
ORDER granting [1117], [75] MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply as to (1106 in 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 73 in 8:19-cv-00654-SAG) Sealed Document, Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time on Briefing Schedule on Marriotts Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 4/11/2023. Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 8:19-cv-00654-SAG(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Motion for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply
MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply as to (1106 in 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 73 in 8:19-cv-00654-SAG) Sealed Document, Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time on Briefing Schedule on Marriotts Motion for Summary Judgment by City of Chicago (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 8:19-cv-00654-SAG(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [1115] Consent MOTION to Seal Portions of the Special Master's March 6, 2023 Report & Recommendation (ECF [1104]). Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 4/10/2023. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Consent MOTION to Seal Portions of the Special Master's March 6, 2023 Report & Recommendation (ECF 1104) by Marriott International, Inc., Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT, # (2) Exhibit Exhibit 1 - Redacted Version of ECF 1104, # (3) Exhibit Exhibit 2 - Declaration)(Marinucci, Dante)
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [1105] MOTION to Seal DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF EXHIBITS FILED IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING FINES. Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 4/6/2023. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
RESPONSE re [1109] Objection to Report and Recommendations filed by Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Irma Lawrence, Paula OBrien, Roger Cullen, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Laura Gononian, Eric Fishon, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Michaela Bittner, Anne Marie Amarena. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A - March 8, 2022 Letter, # (2) Exhibit B - March 10, 2022 Letter)(Keller, Amy)
MOTION for Extension of Time UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Keteltas, Gilbert)
MOTION to Seal DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF EXHIBITS FILED IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING FINES by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 8:19-cv-00654-SAG(Warren, Daniel)
ORDER re [1102] STIPULATION STIPULATED PROPOSED ORDER REGARDING MOVING TO SEAL RELATED TO PARTIES DISPUTE REGARDING CCPA DISCOVERY filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC. Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 3/3/2023. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
STIPULATION STIPULATED PROPOSED ORDER REGARDING MOVING TO SEAL RELATED TO PARTIES DISPUTE REGARDING CCPA DISCOVERY by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Marinucci, Dante)
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [1100] Joint MOTION for Extension of Time by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC in case 8:19-md-02879-SAG. Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 2/21/2023. Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 8:19-cv-00654-SAG(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Joint MOTION for Extension of Time by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 8:19-cv-00654-SAG(Warren, Daniel)
PAPERLESS ORDER GRANTING ECF [1097] (the Marriott Defendants' request for leave to file their proposed summary judgment motion). The motion should be filed within three weeks of todays date. Plaintiff's opposition and Defendants' reply, if any, shall be due in accordance with the filing schedule set forth in Local Rule 105.2(a) (D. Md. 2021). Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 2/14/2023. Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG, 8:19-cv-00654-SAG(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
PAPERLESS ORDER accepting the [1089] Report and Recommendation of the Special Master denying Chicago's motion to transfer its case to the Northern District of Illinois. This Court notes Marriott's partial objection to the Special Masters Report and Recommendation, and understands that factual discovery on the merits has concluded but expert discovery on the merits has not. Signed by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher on 1/18/2023. (Gallagher, Stephanie) Modified on 1/20/2023 (kns, Deputy Clerk).
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
LETTER ORDER Overruling Marriott's objection and adopting Report and Recommendations re [1079] Report and Recommendations of Special Master regarding jurisdictional issues. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/23/2022. (heps, Deputy Clerk)
STATUS REPORT Joint Status Report by Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Irma Lawrence, Paula OBrien, Roger Cullen, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Laura Gononian, Eric Fishon, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Michaela Bittner, Anne Marie Amarena(Keller, Amy)
RESPONSE re [1081] Objection to Report and Recommendations filed by Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Irma Lawrence, Paula OBrien, Roger Cullen, David Viggiano, Eric Fishon, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Michaela Bittner, Anne Marie Amarena.(Keller, Amy)
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [1080] Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. The appearance of Benjamin Scott Thomassen on behalf of the City of Chicago is terminated. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/1/2022. (imws, Chambers)
Correspondence re: Reply in Support of Transfer of City of Chicago v. Marriott Int'l [Dkts. 1070, 1073] Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00654-PWG(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
Correspondence re: Marriott International, Inc. and Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, LLC position that the Court should not suggest to Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation that Government Track be remanded Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00654-PWG(Warren, Daniel)
PAPERLESS ORDER approving the joint proposed briefing schedule to resolve the Court's jurisdiction over CCPA-related discovery, ECF No. 1068; and granting Marriott's request to stay other discovery, ECF No. 1057, since Plaintiffs do not oppose the stay of all non-CCPA related discovery, see ECF Nos. 1060, 1064. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 9/20/2022. Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG et al.(imws, Chambers)
MARGINAL ORDER APPROVING [1066] NOTICE by City of Chicago Joint Submission of Proposed Briefing Schedule filed by City of Chicago. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 9/19/2022. (kb3s, Deputy Clerk)
ORDER denying [944] -SEALED- MOTION for Other Relief DEFENDANTS MOTION TO EXCLUDE DR. BAZELONS OPINIONS, denying [946] REDACTED DOCUMENT to [944] MOTION for Other Relief DEFENDANTS MOTION TO EXCLUDE DR. BAZELONS OPINIONS; granting in part and denying in part [943] -SEALED- Motion for Summary Judgment, granting in part and denying in part [945] REDACTED DOCUMENT to [943] MOTION for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 9/8/2022. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [942] Motion to Seal; granting [973] Motion to Seal; and granting [988] Motion to Seal. However, as indicated throughout these proceedings, including in the Consumer Track, the Court may include certain redacted information in its written opinions to the extent that information is necessary to include. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 9/8/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [1056] Correspondence. The Court ADOPTS the parties' proposed schedule for CCPA-related discovery. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 8/22/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
NOTICE by City of Chicago re [977] Redacted Document,,, [975] Response in Opposition to Motion,,, of Supplemental Authority (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A, # (2) Exhibit B)(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [1053] Correspondence. The Court ADOPTS the parties' jointly proposed briefing schedule regarding Defendants' letter motion to stay limited damages discovery. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 8/5/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
ORDER of USCA "Granting" motion to withdraw Erin Murphy from further representation on appeal as to [849] Notice of Appeal filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California. (slss, Deputy Clerk)
USCA Appeal Fees received from Kirkland & Ellis LLP $ 505 receipt number 835 re [1049] Notice of Interlocutory Appeal filed by Accenture LLP (kos, Deputy Clerk)
Filed: None, Entered: None
Correspondence
Correspondence from Jenner and Block LLP re: Payment of the Appeal Filing Fee, $505. (dm4s, Deputy Clerk)
NOTICE OF INTERLOCUTORY APPEAL as to [1015] Order on Motion to Certify Class by Accenture LLP. (Anderson, Devin) Modified on 7/25/2022 (kos, Deputy Clerk).
NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on 6-1-2022, before Judge Grimm. Court Reporter/Transcriber Linda Marshall, Telephone number 301-344-3229. Total number of pages filed: 22. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 7/22/2022. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 8/1/2022. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 9/29/2022.(lcm, Court Reporter)
(FILED IN ERROR) NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on 1-7-2021, before Judge Messitte. Court Reporter/Transcriber Linda Marshall, Telephone number 301-344-3229. Total number of pages filed: 94. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 7/19/2022. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 7/29/2022. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 9/26/2022.(lcm, Court Reporter) Modified on 6/28/2022 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
PAPERLESS ORDER re ECF No. [1040] Correspondence. The Court ADOPTS the parties' updated schedule regarding the CCPA-related issues. The Court STAYS the remaining steps in the Consumer Track, as outlined by the parties, until the Fourth Circuit resolves Defendants' Rule 23(f) petitions. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/21/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
Correspondence re: Discovery Concerning Valuation of Consumer PII Pursuant to Court's June 1, 2022 Order (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A, Proposed Discovery)(Keller, Amy)
ORDER Revoking (1037) Order Reassigning Litigation to Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher for coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings. Signed by Judge Karen K. Caldwell, Chair, Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, on 6/16/2022. Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-SAG et al.(kns, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 6/16/2022 (kns, Deputy Clerk).
[REVOKED - SEE [1138]] ORDER Reassigning Litigation to Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher for coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings. Signed by Judge Karen K. Caldwell, Chair, Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, on 6/14/2022. Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG et al.(jf3s, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 6/16/2022 (kns, Deputy Clerk).
(ELECTRONICALLY FILED IN ERROR)ORDER consolidating of USCA as to [849] Notice of Appeal filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California (jb5s, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 6/16/2022 (slss, Deputy Clerk).
Case Reassigned to Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher. Judge Paul W. Grimm no longer assigned to the case. (jf3s, Deputy Clerk)
1035
Filed: 6/10/2022, Entered: 6/10/2022
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER re [1034] Correspondence. The Court GRANTS the parties' joint request to extend the deadlines concerning Consumer Plaintiffs' discovery request related to Marriott's valuation of customers' Personally Identifiable Information ("PII"), Marriott's response thereto, and Plaintiffs' reply. The Court ADOPTS the parties' requested deadlines. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/10/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
PAPERLESS ORDER scheduling a status conference with counsel in the Consumer and Government Tracks for June 1, 2022 at 9:30am. The status conference will take place via Zoom. Counsel will be emailed a link to the Zoom meeting prior to the status conference. The status conference will concern scheduling in the Consumer and Government Tracks, as well as Consumer Plaintiffs' request for discovery related to Marriott's valuation of rewards customers' Personally Identifiable Information ("PII"). Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/23/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
(ELECTRONICALLY FILED IN ERROR)USCA Case Number 22-184 for [849] Notice of Appeal filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California. Case Manager - Richard H. Sewell (slss, Deputy Clerk) (Additional attachment(s) added on 5/20/2022: # (1) Corporate Disclosure Statement) (slss, Deputy Clerk). Modified on 5/23/2022 (slss, Deputy Clerk).
(ELECTRONICALLY FILED IN ERROR)USCA Case Number 22-181 for [849] Notice of Appeal filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California. Case Manager - Richard H. Sewell (dm4s, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 5/23/2022 (slss, Deputy Clerk).
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [911] Motion to Seal; granting [912] Motion to Seal; granting [933] Motion to Seal. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/9/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
LETTER ORDER that the parties have re-filed their class certification briefing on the public record with updated redactions and they have re-filed the relevant motions to seal; Granting [892], [900], [915], [962], [965], [983], [1020], and [1021] Motions to Seal; Denying as Moot [860], [864], [866], [886], and [904] Motions to Seal;. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/6/2022. (heps, Deputy Clerk)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [914] Motion to Exclude Expert Opinions of Kevin T. Poindexter. Pursuant to footnote 3 of the Class Certification Opinion, ECF No. 1014, the Motion is DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/6/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
1024
Filed: 5/6/2022, Entered: 5/6/2022
Order on Motion for Other Relief
PAPERLESS ORDER re [913] Motion to Exclude Expert Opinions of Tom Snyder. Pursuant to footnote 3 of the Class Certification Opinion, ECF No. 1014, the Motion is DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/6/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
NOTICE by Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Irma Lawrence, Paula OBrien, Roger Cullen, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Laura Gononian, Eric Fishon, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Michaela Bittner, Anne Marie Amarena of Filing Documents on the Public Record in Support of their Reply Brief in Support of their Corrected Motion for Class Certification (Attachments: # (1) Reply Memorandum in Support of Bellwether Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification, # (2) Exhibit C, Expert Class Certification Rebuttal Report of Jeffrey T. Prince, Ph.D., # (3) Exhibit D, Rebuttal Report of Sarah Butler, # (4) Exhibit E, Email re Marriott Rule 30(b)(6) Topics and Attachment of Revised Topics)(Keller, Amy)
MOTION to Seal Portions of Plaintiffs' Class Certification Briefs in Accordance with Report and Recommendations and Court Orders by Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Irma Lawrence, Paula OBrien, Roger Cullen, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Laura Gononian, Eric Fishon, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Michaela Bittner, Anne Marie Amarena (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Keller, Amy)
MOTION to Seal Motion to File Under Seal Portions of Their Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Marinucci, Dante)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
LETTER ORDER adopting Report and Recommendations re [1011] Report and Recommendations. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/4/2022. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment 1) (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
ORDER granting in part and denying in part [858] Motion to Certify Class, [859] Sealed Document, [863] Sealed Document, [865] Sealed Document. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/3/2022. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
ORDER granting in part and denying in part [894] SEALED Corrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's OpinionsCorrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions; granting in part and denying in part [895] REDACTED Corrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's OpinionsCorrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/3/2022. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on 04/20/2022, before Judge Paul Grimm. Court Reporter/Transcriber Marlene Kerr, Telephone number 3013443499. Total number of pages filed: 117. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 5/24/2022. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 6/3/2022. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 8/1/2022.(mmk, Court Reporter)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER adopting [1003] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. The Report and Recommendations were filed on the docket on April 11, 2022. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation[s], the Report and Recommendation[s] will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendations, ECF No. 1003, are adopted by the Court. The parties shall re-file relevant briefing (sealed and redacted) in accordance with the Report and Recommendations, as well as the Errata, ECF No. 1008, by Thursday, May 5, 2022. For any briefing that has changed as a result of the Report and Recommendations, the parties should file new motions to seal. The Court will consider these new motions and resolve the prior motions that pertain to the now-outdated briefing submitted before the parties and the Special Master resolved the confidentiality designation disputes. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 4/28/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
JUDGMENT of USCA (certified copy) "Affirming" the judgment of the District Court as to [849] Notice of Appeal filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California. (Attachments: # (1) Opinion)(slss, Deputy Clerk)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER adopting [997] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. The Report and Recommendations were filed on the docket on March 30, 2022. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation[s], the Report and Recommendation[s] will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendations, ECF No. 997, are adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 4/15/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
RESPONSE re [1000] Objection to Report and Recommendations, filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.(Keteltas, Gilbert)
NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on 04/04/2022, before Judge Paul Grimm. Court Reporter/Transcriber Marlene Kerr, Telephone number 3013443499. Total number of pages filed: 239. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 4/25/2022. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 5/5/2022. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 7/5/2022.(mmk, Court Reporter)
OBJECTION to [993] Report and Recommendations by Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Irma Lawrence, Paula OBrien, Roger Cullen, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Laura Gononian, Eric Fishon, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Michaela Bittner, Anne Marie Amarena. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 1)(Keller, Amy)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [998] Correspondence. The class certification hearing scheduled for April 20, 2022 will be in-person and conducted in Courtroom 4B of the Greenbelt Courthouse. It will begin at 9:30 a.m. (Please note the updated start time.) Plaintiffs will argue first and will be afforded 45 minutes to make arguments related to the materials submitted in support of class certification. Defendants will then have 45 minutes for their argument. Plaintiffs will be allotted 15 minutes for rebuttal. The Court may provide further details as needed as the date approaches. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 3/31/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 3/29/2022. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment 1, # (2) Attachment 2)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER adopting [992] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. The Report and Recommendations were filed on the docket on March 14, 2022. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation[s], the Report and Recommendation[s] will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendations, ECF No. 992, are adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 3/29/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
STATUS REPORT Joint Status Report by Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Irma Lawrence, Paula OBrien, Roger Cullen, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Laura Gononian, Eric Fishon, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Michaela Bittner, Anne Marie Amarena(Keller, Amy)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master: The introductory paragraph of the Report and Recommendation used two incorrect dates. The email referred to was dated March 15, 2022, not March 14, and the hearing referenced is scheduled for April 20, 2022, and not April 22. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 3/18/2022. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment 1, # (2) Attachment 2, # (3) Attachment 3, # (4) Attachment 4)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master: The Report and Recommendations inadvertently referred to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(c)(4). The rule to which the Report and Recommendations intended to refer is Rule 23(c)(4), and the document should be read that way. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 3/11/2022. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment 1, # (2) Attachment 2, # (3) Attachment 3)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
REDACTED DOCUMENT to [989] Sealed Document REPLY MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT [943] ON THE ISSUES OF HOME RULE, EXTRATERRITORIALITY, AND STANDING by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Notice of Filing Under Seal)(Warren, Daniel) Modified on 3/10/2022 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
PAPERLESS ORDER re [940] Letter Order. Ms. Sarah Butler and Dr. Olivier Toubia no longer need to attend the on-the-record proceeding with the experts scheduled for March 21, 2022. The proceeding will go forward with Dr. Jeffrey Prince and Dr. Catherine Tucker. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 2/22/2022. (rs9s, Chambers)
REDACTED DOCUMENT to [984] Sealed Document Supplemental Expert Report of Catherine Tucker, Ph.D. by Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC, Marriott International, Inc. (Attachments: # (1) Notice of Filing Supplemental Tucker Report, # (2) Notice of Filing Under Seal)(Warren, Daniel)
NOTICE by Eric Fishon, Robert Guzikowski, Michaela Bittner, Paula OBrien, Brent Long, Laura Gononian, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Roger Cullen, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Anne Marie Amarena Bellwether Class Certification Claims and Defenses Chart (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit Certificate of Service)(Keller, Amy)
PAPERLESS ORDER directing Plaintiffs in Consumer Track to add an additional column to the Joint Bellwether Class Certification Claims and Defenses Spreadsheet, ECF No. [958]. This additional column shall correspond with the "Affirmative Defenses and Defendants' Elements" column in the original submission and address whether Plaintiffs concede that the affirmative defenses cited by Defendants are applicable to the causes of actions for which Plaintiffs seek class certification. Plaintiffs correctly noted in their first footnote in ECF No. 958 that while Defendants submitted their information after having reviewed what Plaintiffs submitted, Plaintiffs did not have the opportunity to respond to Defendants' submissions. I agree that they should be afforded the opportunity to do so, provided it is done succinctly. Further, Plaintiffs may not cite more than three cases in support of any information they provide regarding a particular affirmative defense they wish to address. Plaintiffs shall file a revised Bellwether Class Certification Claims and Defenses Spreadsheet, with the information allowed in this Paperless Order as an additional column, by Friday, February 11, 2022. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/27/2022. (rs9, Chambers)
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [969] Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. The appearance of Ben Travis on behalf of Andrea Durkee and Nathan Esquerra is terminated. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/24/2022. (rs9, Chambers)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER adopting [954] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket on January 3, 2022. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 954, is adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/18/2022. (rs9, Chambers)
LETTER ORDER re [961] Sealed Document, [963] Redacted Document filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC, [964] Correspondence re: Testimony, Expert Report, and Rebuttal Report of Jeffrey Prince, Ph.D. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/18/2022. (ybs, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 1/18/2022 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
MOTION to Seal by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace(Keller, Amy)
REDACTED DOCUMENT to [961] Sealed Document by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit E, # (2) Notice of Filing Under Seal)(Warren, Daniel)
Order on Motion for Extension of Time to File Response / Reply
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [959] Motion for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/11/2022. (rs9, Chambers) Modified on 1/12/2022 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
Motion for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply
MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply as to [944] MOTION for Other Relief DEFENDANTS MOTION TO EXCLUDE DR. BAZELONS OPINIONS, [943] MOTION for Summary Judgment Unopposed by City of Chicago(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
PAPERLESS ORDER scheduling the class certification hearing in the Consumer Track for Wednesday, April 20, 2022, at 9:00 am in Courtroom 4B. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/7/2022. (rs9, Chambers)
956
Filed: 1/6/2022, Entered: 1/6/2022
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER clarifying that [952] Order on Motion for Extension of Time extended the deadline for the Claims Spreadsheet by seven days. Thus, the spreadsheet deadline is Friday, January 7, 2022. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/6/2022. (rs9, Chambers)
RESPONSE re [953] Order, Parties Joint Response to the Courts Order (ECF No. 953) filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.(Keteltas, Gilbert)
PAPERLESS ORDER scheduling the on-the-record proceeding with the experts in the Consumer Track for Monday, March 21, 2022, at 9:00 am in Courtroom 4B. Further, the Court directs the parties to jointly submit more dates when they are available for the class certification hearing. The Court has a jury trial the week of April 4. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/3/2022. (rs9, Chambers)
952
Filed: 12/29/2021, Entered: 12/29/2021
Order on motion for extension of time
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [951] Motion for Extension of Time. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 12/29/2021. (rs9, Chambers)
MOTION for Extension of Time JOINT MOTION FOR 7-DAY EXTENSION by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Keteltas, Gilbert)
RESPONSE re [947] Order Parties Joint Response to the Courts Letter Order (ECF No. 947) filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.(Keteltas, Gilbert)
NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on 11-30-2021, before Judge Grimm. Court Reporter/Transcriber Linda C Marshall, Telephone number 3013443229. Total number of pages filed: 58. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 1/10/2022. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 1/20/2022. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 3/21/2022.(lcm, Court Reporter)
NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on 3-5-2021, before Judge Grimm. Court Reporter/Transcriber Linda C Marshall, Telephone number 3013443229. Total number of pages filed: 50. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 1/10/2022. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 1/20/2022. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 3/21/2022.(lcm, Court Reporter)
STATUS REPORT JOINT STATUS REPORT OF THE CONSUMER TRACK PARTIES REGARDING THE NOVEMBER 30, 2021 STATUS CONFERENCE AND THE COURT'S LETTER ORDER (ECF NO. 940) by Marriott International, Inc.(Ghannoum, Lisa)
LETTER ORDER memorializing today's status conference. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/30/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment Dr. De Figueiredo CV) (rs9, Chambers)
REDACTED DOCUMENT to [936] Response in Opposition to Motion, by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A, # (2) Exhibit B)(Warren, Daniel)
-SEALED-RESPONSE in Opposition re [914] MOTION for Other Relief Motion to Exclude Expert Opinions of Kevin T. Poindexter filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A, # (2) Exhibit B)(Warren, Daniel)
REDACTED DOCUMENT to [934] Response in Opposition to Motion, [913] MOTION for Other Relief to Exclude Expert Opinions of Tom Snyder by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Warren, Daniel)
-SEALED-RESPONSE in Opposition re [913] MOTION for Other Relief to Exclude Expert Opinions of Tom Snyder filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A, # (2) Exhibit B)(Warren, Daniel)
PAPERLESS ORDER STAYING the prior paperless order, [931], issued on November 24, 2021. Counsel will receive further instructions regarding the letter response at the November 30 status conference. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/28/2021. (rs9, Chambers)
931
Filed: 11/24/2021, Entered: 11/24/2021
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER DIRECTING Plaintiffs in Consumer track to file a short letter response to [930] Correspondence by 3:00pm on Monday, November 29, 2021. The letter response, excluding attachments, should be no more than five pages. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/24/2021. (rs9, Chambers)
MOTION for Extension of Time AGREED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME ON BRIEFING SCHEDULE REGARDING MARRIOTTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Warren, Daniel)
PAPERLESS ORDER scheduling a status conference with counsel for Plaintiffs in the Consumer track and counsel for Defendants Marriott and Accenture for November 30, 2021 at 10:00am. The status conference will take place via Zoom. Counsel will be emailed a link to the Zoom meeting prior to the status conference. Counsel are advised that the Court will reschedule the Class Certification and Expert Challenges hearing currently scheduled for January 24, 2022 and January 25, 2022. The status conference will concern the Court's organizational approach to resolving the class certification motions and expert challenges. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/12/2021. (rs9, Chambers)
925
Filed: 11/8/2021, Entered: 11/8/2021
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER STAYING sine die the deadlines outlined in [881] re confidentiality designation challenges. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/8/2021. (rs9s, Chambers)
Memorandum re [914] MOTION for Other Relief Motion to Exclude Expert Opinions of Kevin T. Poindexter , RESPONSE in Support (Redacted, Publicly-Available Version) filed by Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace.(Ulwick, James)
RESPONSE in Opposition re [916] Response in Opposition to Motion,,, [895] Corrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions(Redacted, Publicly-Available Version) by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace. (Ulwick, James)
Memorandum re [913] MOTION for Other Relief to Exclude Expert Opinions of Tom Snyder (Redacted, Publicly-Available Version) filed by Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace.(Ulwick, James)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [918] correspondence. The Court acknowledges defense counsel's request for a status conference. Following a jury trial this week, the Court will schedule a status conference with the parties. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/1/2021. (rs9, Chambers)
-SEALED-RESPONSE in Opposition re [895] Corrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions, [894] Corrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions filed by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 1, Expert Class Certification Rebuttal Report of Jeffrey T. Prince, Ph.D., dated October 12, 2021, # (2) Exhibit 2, Excerpts from Dr. Jeffrey T. Prince's Deposition, # (3) Exhibit 3, Excerpts from Russell Vereb's Corporate Representative Deposition, # (4) Exhibit 4, Excerpts from Dr. Catherine Tucker's Deposition, # (5) Exhibit 5, Excerpts from Gregory J. Lattin's Corporate Representative Deposition)(Keller, Amy)
MOTION to Seal Plaintiffs' Response in Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Keller, Amy)
-SEALED- MOTION for Other Relief Motion to Exclude Expert Opinions of Kevin T. Poindexter by Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support, # (2) Exhibit 1, Declaration of Kevin T. Poindexter, # (3) Exhibit 2, Deposition Transcript of Kevin T. Poindexter)(Keller, Amy)
-SEALED- MOTION for Other Relief to Exclude Expert Opinions of Tom Snyder by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support, # (2) Exhibit 1, Expert Report of Tom Snyder, # (3) Exhibit 2, Deposition Transcript of Tom Snyder, # (4) Exhibit 3, Rebuttal Expert Report of Nicolas Christin, # (5) Exhibit 4, Letter from S. Petterson to T. Hogan and E. Long dated Sept. 29, 2021, # (6) Exhibit 5, Email from T. Hogan to S. Petterson dated Oct. 1, 2021, # (7) Exhibit 6, Email to T. Snyder dated May 26, 2021, # (8) Exhibit 7, Marriott Research Request 2018, # (9) Exhibit 8, Marriott Research Request 2021)(Keller, Amy)
MOTION to Seal by Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Keller, Amy)
MOTION to Seal by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Keller, Amy)
REPLY to Response to Motion re [858] Corrected MOTION to Certify Class by the Bellwether PlaintiffsRedacted, Publicly-Available Version filed by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace.(Keller, Amy)
PAPERLESS ORDER DIRECTING counsel in the consumer track to docket in this court the filings in the Northern District of Illinois related to a motion to quash filed in that district that relates to this litigation, so that Special Master Facciola may have these documents to prepare to work with counsel to address the issues raised. Counsel will docket the documents no later than close of business on Monday, October 18, 2021, unless otherwise directed by the Special Master. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 10/15/2021. (ats, Chambers)
(FILED IN ERROR) -SEALED - NOTICE of Filing Under Seal Exhibits A-E in Support of Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Class Certification by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace re [905] Sealed Document, (Keller, Amy) Modified on 10/13/2021 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
(FILED IN ERROR) -SEALED - NOTICE of Filing Under Seal Reply in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace re [905] Sealed Document, (Keller, Amy) Modified on 10/13/2021 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
Sealed Document (Attachments: # (1) Index of Exhibits, # (2) Exhibit A, Rebuttal Report of Nicolas Christin, # (3) Exhibit B, Excerpts from Promod Achary Deposition, # (4) Exhibit C, Rebuttal Report of Jeffrey Prince, Ph.D., # (5) Exhibit D, Rebuttal Report of Sarah Butler, # (6) Exhibit E, Communication and Notes from 30(b)(6) Negotiations)(Keller, Amy)
MOTION to Seal their unredacted Reply in Support of their Motion for Class Certification by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Keller, Amy)
REDACTED DOCUMENT to [896] MOTION for Leave to File (Motion for Leave to File Expert Rebuttal Reports) by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Warren, Daniel)
-SEALED-RESPONSE to Motion re [896] MOTION for Leave to File (Motion for Leave to File Expert Rebuttal Reports) filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.(Warren, Daniel)
NOTICE of Hearing: Class Certification and Expert Challenges hearing (Consumer Track)set for January 24, 2022 and January 25, 2022 at 09:00 AM in Courtroom 4B, 6500 Cherrywood Lane, Greenbelt, Maryland 20770, before Judge Paul W. Grimm. (ats, Chambers)
STATUS REPORT by Accenture LLP, Michaela Bittner, City of Chicago, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Marriott International, Inc., Marriott International, Inc., Paula OBrien, Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace(Ghannoum, Lisa) Modified on 9/23/2021 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
MOTION for Leave to File (Motion for Leave to File Expert Rebuttal Reports) by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A)(Ulwick, James)
Corrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support Defendants' Memorandum in Support of Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions, # (2) Exhibit Exhibit 1, # (3) Exhibit Exhibit 2, # (4) Exhibit Exhibit 3, # (5) Exhibit Exhibit 4, # (6) Exhibit Exhibit 5, # (7) Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order, # (8) Defendants' Notice of Filing Documents Under Seal)(Warren, Daniel)
-SEALED-Corrected MOTION for Other Relief Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support Defendants' Memorandum in Support of Motion to Exclude Dr. Prince's Opinions, # (2) Exhibit Exhibit 1, # (3) Exhibit Exhibit 2, # (4) Exhibit Exhibit 3, # (5) Exhibit Exhibit 4, # (6) Exhibit Exhibit 5, # (7) Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order)(Warren, Daniel)
MOTION for Leave to File Under Seal Portions of Defendants' Motion to Exclude Dr. Jeffrey Princes Opinions and Materials in Support by Marriott International, Inc. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment Proposed Order)(Warren, Daniel)
NOTICE by Tom Abogabal, Latoya Aguillard, Debra Anthony, Amanda Arnold, Nathan Royce Banks, Jamie Bannon, Cayla Campbell, Arhonda Carlisle, Luke Castle, Crystal Chambers, Patricia Daughtery, Richard Davis, Scott Dias, Eric Dubitsky, Michele Emanuele, Barbara Erickson, Scott Farkas, Nathan Finney(PWG 19-94), Nicholas Frazer, Julie Ganuelas, Paula Glass, Cynthia Griffith, Tanya Harris, Brian Herman, Ron Jones, David J. Kimmel, Irma Lawrence, Samuel Mangano, Lisa McGuire, Pamela Moore, Howard William Myones, Christina Olsen, Darren Perks, Frank Ragan, Lamarkis Robinson, Adam Sanderson, David Secrist, Nicole Theiss, Robert Trepper, Edgar Vaynshteyn, April Vrtis, Jennifer White, Matthew White, Dolly Wright, Jacqueline Zenon re [842] Order on Motion for Other Relief (Consumer Plaintiffs' Notice Regarding the Appointment of a Commission to Hear Testimony Under the Hague Evidence Convention (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A)(Ulwick, James)
ORDER granting in part and denying in part [833] Motion for Voluntary Dismissal; directing Clerk to terminate Plaintiffs Janel Sempre and Mary Ann Miller. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 8/31/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [878] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket on August 3, 2021. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 878, is adopted by the Court as follows. The parties will exchange challenges to the confidentiality designations made for materials filed in conjunction with the class certification briefing within 7 days of the filing of plaintiffs' reply in support of its motion for class certification. The parties shall then meet and confer on those materials within 7 days. The parties may bring any challenge to unresolved confidentiality designations within 14 days after that to Special Master Judge Facciola. With respect to the confidentiality designations made for deposition testimony and exhibits, but not used in the parties' class certification briefing, so long as the confidentiality designations were timely made, challenges may not be commenced until 14 days after the Court's receipt of all confidentiality challenges made after the briefing of class certification. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 8/20/2021.(pk3s, Chambers)
880
Filed: 8/20/2021, Entered: 8/20/2021
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [877] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket on August 3, 2021. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 877, is adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 8/20/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
879
Filed: 8/5/2021, Entered: 8/5/2021
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER re [816] Consumer Track Briefing Schedule. In the briefing schedule for class certification and expert reports in the Consumer Track, ECF 816, the deadline for Defendants to oppose class certification and for Defendants to serve reports for class certification experts is September 6, 2021. The Court will be closed on that day for the Labor Day holiday. Therefore, these deadlines will be amended to September 7, 2021. All other deadlines in the schedule remain the same. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 8/5/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [852] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket on July 12, 2021. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 852, is adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/29/2021.(pk3s, Chambers)
USCA Case Number 21-1802 for [849] Notice of Appeal filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California. Case Manager - Rickie Edwards (jj2, Deputy Clerk)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER re [870] Report and Recommendation. As I Ordered at the bottom of the Special Master's Report and Recommendation, ECF 870, when it was filed on the docket, the Report and Recommendation, ECF 870, is approved. The deadlines for the parties to object to the Special Master's previous Report and Recommendation, ECF 867, are stayed pending the Special Master's resolution of any motions for reconsideration of that Report and Recommendation. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/27/2021.(pk3s, Chambers)
REPLY to Response to Motion re [833] MOTION for Voluntary Dismissal filed by Mary Ann Miller, Janel Sempre. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 1, Declaration of Mary Ann Miller, # (2) Exhibit 2, Declaration of Janel Sempre)(Keller, Amy)
Status Report Submitted by Accenture LLP, Accenture PLC, Michaela Bittner, City of Chicago, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Marriott International, Inc., Paula OBrien, Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Keller, Amy)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re [867] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 7/22/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
PAPERLESS ORDER approving [861] Joint Proposed Briefing Schedule. The deadlines and page limits as proposed shall apply to Marriott's Motion for Summary Judgment relating to the Government Track. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/21/2021. (imws, Chambers)
transmission of notice of appeal and docket sheet to USCA
Transmission of Notice of Appeal and Docket Sheet to US Court of Appeals re [849] Notice of Appeal. IMPORTANT NOTICE: To access forms which you are required to file with the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit please go to http://www.ca4.uscourts.gov and click on Forms & Notices.(jj2, Deputy Clerk)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 7/20/2021. (heps, Deputy Clerk) (Additional attachment(s) added on 7/21/2021: # (1) Attachment, # (2) Attachment) (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
MOTION to Seal Correct Memorandum in Support of Their Corrected Motion for Class Certification by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order for Consumer Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to File Under Seal)(Ulwick, James)
MOTION to Seal Docket No. 863 - Consumer Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to File Under Seal Revised Exhibits to Class Certiication Motion by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order)(Ulwick, James)
Sealed Document (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit Book 2 of Exhibits pursuant to ECF 862, Tabs 7-11, # (2) Exhibit Book 3 of Exhibits pursuant to ECF 862, Tabs 12-14, # (3) Exhibit Book 4 of Exhibits pursuant to ECF 862, Tabs 15-17, # (4) Exhibit Book 5 of Exhibits pursuant to ECF 862,Tabs 18-24, # (5) Exhibit Book 6 of Exhibits pursuant to ECF 862, Tabs 25-49, # (6) Exhibit Book 7 of Exhibits pursuant to ECF 862, Tab 50)(Ulwick, James)
862
Filed: 7/13/2021, Entered: 7/13/2021
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER regarding exhibits. Consumer Plaintiffs motion for class certification was filed yesterday along with 50 exhibits totaling over 5,600 pages. See ECF Nos. 857, 858, 859. To facilitate my review of these lengthy exhibits, counsel for Consumer Plaintiffs will please highlight the relevant portions of the exhibits. To the extent possible, deposition transcripts should be filed in minuscript form, with four pages per sheet. Counsel for Consumer Plaintiffs should refile their exhibits on the docket and provide a paper copy in accordance with these instructions. These formatting instructions for exhibits and deposition transcripts apply to all future briefing in this MDL. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/13/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
MOTION to Seal Memorandum in Support of Bellwether Plaintiffs' Corrected Motion for Class Certification and Supporting Exhibits by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Keller, Amy)
Corrected MOTION to Certify Class by the Bellwether Plaintiffs by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support, # (2) Appendix Index of Exhibits, # (3) Exhibit Declaration of Class Counsel, # (4) Text of Proposed Order, # (5) Exhibit Proposed Trial Plan, Redacted, # (6) Exhibit Notice, Exhibits 4 through 50 Filed Under Seal)(Keller, Amy)
(FILED IN ERROR) MOTION to Certify Class by the Bellwether Plaintiffs by Anne Marie Amarena, Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Paula OBrien, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace (Attachments: # (1) Appendix of Exhibits, Redacted, # (2) Exhibit 1, Declaration of Class Counsel, # (3) Text of Proposed Order 2, Proposed Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion, # (4) Exhibit 3, Trial Plan, Redacted, # (5) Exhibit Notice of Exhibits 4-50 Filed Under Seal)(Keller, Amy) Modified on 7/13/2021 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
MOTION to Seal by Marriott International, Inc., Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order)(Ghannoum, Lisa)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 7/12/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment A, # (2) Attachment B)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
PAPERLESS ORDER APPROVING [850] Stipulation of Dismissal Without Prejudice and [848] Notice of Voluntary Dismissal. The CLERK is directed to terminate Plaintiffs Adam Ropp, Ricardo Zepeda, and Cina Nouri from this proceeding. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/12/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
NOTICE OF APPEAL as to [810] Order on Motion to Dismiss by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California. Filing fee $ 505, receipt number 0416-9370199.(Villegas, Carol)
PAPERLESS ORDER regarding the Consumer Track. Third-party 4Discovery has moved in the Northern District of Illinois to quash Marriott's notice of deposition and production of documents. Consumer Plaintiffs have also asked Special Master Judge Facciola to quash the notice of deposition on other grounds and the parties are briefing that issue before the Special Master. Consumer Plaintiffs and Marriott should complete that briefing before Special Master Judge Facciola. Judge Facciola's resolution of that dispute is stayed pending the resolution of 4Discovery's motion to quash in the Northern District of Illinois. If the subpoena is not quashed by the Northern District of Illinois or this Court, the deposition testimony and production of documents requested by the subpoena may be completed after the close of fact discovery on July 12, 2021. The deadlines for the class certification briefing will not be changed. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/7/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
846
Filed: 7/6/2021, Entered: 7/6/2021
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER memorializing today's telephone conference in the Government Track. The City of Chicago and Marriott should submit a proposed briefing schedule and page limits for summary judgment briefing on the issues identified in Marriott's pre-motion letter, ECF No. 825, by Tuesday, July 13, 2021. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/6/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
845
Filed: 7/6/2021, Entered: 7/6/2021
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [834] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket on June 29, 2021. On that day, I issued a Paperless Order, ECF No. 835, instructing the parties that any objections to the Report and Recommendation were due by July 2, 2021, and if no objection was filed by that date, the Report and Recommendation would be adopted by the Court. No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 834, is adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/6/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
844
Filed: 7/3/2021, Entered: 7/3/2021
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER re [843]. Marriott's response to Consumer Plaintiff's motion for voluntary dismissal, ECF 833, is due on July 12, 2021. Consumer Plaintiffs' reply is due on July 26, 2021. The page limits for the response and reply are 10 pages and 5 pages, respectively, excluding exhibits. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/3/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
ORDER granting [837] Motion for the Issuance of Revised Letters of Request. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 7/1/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment 1, # (2) Attachment 2) (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
MOTION to Seal Portions of Its Response to Marriotts Correspondence Regarding Summary Judgment by City of Chicago (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
MOTION for Other Relief (Motion for the Issuance of Revised Letters of Request) by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit, # (2) Exhibit, # (3) Exhibit, # (4) Exhibit, # (5) Memorandum in Support, # (6) Text of Proposed Order)(Ulwick, James)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [833] MOTION for VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL. Consumer Plaintiffs filed this motion without following my pre-motion procedures, ECF 334. I will accept the motion as filed, but in the future I may strike a motion that does not follow the pre-motion procedures. Under Fed. R. Civ. P. 41(a)(2), I may dismiss an action on a plaintiffs request on terms that I consider proper. Consumer Plaintiffs request that Bellwether Plaintiffs Janel Sempre and Mary Ann Miller be dismissed without prejudice, and indicate that Marriott believes that the dismissal should be with prejudice. I am inclined to grant the dismissal of these Bellwether Plaintiffs and the parties should brief the upcoming class certification motion accordingly. However, prior to determining the proper terms of dismissal, Marriott may file a response and Consumer Plaintiffs may reply. The response and reply should be 10 pages and 5 pages, respectively, excluding exhibits. The briefing on this issue will not affect the close of discovery or the class certification briefing deadlines. Consumer Plaintiffs and Marriott are directed to file a proposed briefing schedule for the response and reply by Friday, July 2, 2021. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/30/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [834] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. If Consumer Plaintiffs object to the Special Master's Report and Recommendation, they must file their objection by July 2, 2021. If no objection is filed by that date, the Report and Recommendation will be adopted by the Court. If Consumer Plaintiffs file an objection, Defendants may file a response by July 7, 2021. Any objection and response should be three pages or less, single-spaced, excluding exhibits. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/29/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Signed by Judge the Honorable John M. Facciola on 6/29/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk) (Additional attachment(s) added on 6/29/2021: # (1) Attachment, # (2) Attachment) (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [803] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation regarding the NDS database was filed on the docket on June 7, 2021. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 803, is adopted by the Court. The Special Master's previous Report and Recommendation regarding the NDS database, ECF No. 682, is also resolved as moot. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/23/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
LETTER ORDER scheduling a pre-motion telephone conference call on July 6, 2021 at 5:00 p.m. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/23/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Order on Motion for Extension of Time to File Response / Reply
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [829] Motion for Extension of Time to File Response as follows: Chicago is granted an extension of five days until June 30, 2021 to file its response to Marriott's pre-motion letter. I will hold a conference call with the parties in the Government track on July 6, 2021 at 5:00 pm to discuss the parties' submissions. A separate order with details will follow. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/23/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
Motion for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply
MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply as to [827] Order,, [825] Miscellaneous Correspondence Unopposed by City of Chicago(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [825] Marriott's letter regarding a proposed motion for summary judgment in the Government Track. The City of Chicago is directed to respond to Marriott's letter in a letter of three pages or less, single-spaced, excluding exhibits, by Friday, June 25, 2021. The response should address whether summary judgment briefing on the issues identified by Marriott should go forward at this time. I will schedule a conference with the parties to discuss their submissions. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/21/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [797] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket on June 2, 2021. The dispute resolution procedures regarding privilege log challenges, ECF No. 781, paragraph G.3.e provides, "If no party files an objection within six (6) calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court, and the Producing Party shall de-designate similar documents within ten (10) days of the dispute being lodged on the docket." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 797, is adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/17/2021.(pk3s, Chambers)
823
Filed: 6/17/2021, Entered: 6/17/2021
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [792] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket on May 25, 2021. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 792, is adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/17/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
ORDER granting [818] Motion for Issuance of Letters of Request; granting [819] Motion for Issuance of Letters of Request. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/17/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment A, # (2) Attachment B) (ybs, Deputy Clerk) (Additional attachment(s) added on 6/17/2021: # (3) Attachment A Sealed, # (4) Attachment B Sealed) (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
MOTION to Seal Motion for Issuance of Letters of Request (filed at ECF No. 819) by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips(PWG 18-3933), Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Ulwick, James)
-SEALED- MOTION for Other Relief (Motion for Issuance of Letters of Request) by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips(PWG 18-3933), Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support, # (2) Exhibit A, # (3) Exhibit B, # (4) Text of Proposed Order)(Ulwick, James)
MOTION for Other Relief REDACTED-PUBLIC VERSION (Motion for Issuance of Letters of Request) by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support, # (2) Exhibit A, # (3) Exhibit B, # (4) Text of Proposed Order)(Ulwick, James)
LETTER ORDER Regarding Consumer Track. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/14/2021. (heps, Deputy Clerk) (Additional attachment(s) added on 7/29/2021: # (1) Letter Order) (mg3s, Deputy Clerk).
ERRATUM Regarding [808] Report and Recommendation Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on. Signed by Judge Maryland Unassigned on 6/14/2021. (heps, Deputy Clerk)
ORDER granting [658] Motion to Dismiss; dismissing with prejudice Plaintiff's federal security claims (Counts IV, V and VI) and dismissing without prejudice Plaintiff's Delaware State law claims (Count I, II, and III) as to [624] Plaintiff's Verified Shareholder Derivative Second Amended Consolidated Complaint; directing the Clerk to close civil action no 19-cv-830-PWG. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/11/2021. (jf3s, Deputy Clerk)
ORDER granting [647] Motion to Dismiss; dismissing with prejudice [609] Plaintiff's Third Amended Complaint; directing the Clerk to close civil action no. 19-cv-368-PWG. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/11/2021. (jf3s, Deputy Clerk)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 6/11/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
REDACTED DOCUMENT to [799] Response,,,,,, [Public Version] Letter Brief in Response to ECF No. 796 by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 1, # (2) Exhibit 2, # (3) Exhibit 3, # (4) Exhibit 4, # (5) Exhibit 5, # (6) Exhibit 6)(Ulwick, James)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re NDS Database. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 6/7/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment A, # (2) Attachment B, # (3) Attachment C)(ybs, Deputy Clerk) (Additional attachment(s) added on 6/7/2021: # (4) Attachment C Updated) (ybs, Deputy Clerk). (Additional attachment(s) added on 6/7/2021: # (7) Attachment B-1, # (8) Attachment B-2) (ybs, Deputy Clerk). (Additional attachment(s) added on 6/8/2021: # (9) Attachment B-3) (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
MOTION to Seal ECF No. 799- Plaintiffs' Letter Brief in Response to ECF No. 796 by Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Ulwick, James)
(FILED IN ERROR) REDACTED DOCUMENT to [799] Response,,,,,, [Public Version] Letter Brief in Response to ECF No. 796 by Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 1, # (2) Exhibit 2, # (3) Exhibit 3, # (4) Exhibit 4, # (5) Exhibit 5, # (6) Exhibit 6)(Ulwick, James) Modified on 6/8/2021 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
-SEALED-RESPONSE re [796] Order,,, Letter Brief in Response filed by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 1, # (2) Exhibit 2, # (3) Exhibit 3, # (4) Exhibit 4, # (5) Exhibit 5, # (6) Exhibit 6)(Ulwick, James)
PAPERLESS ORDER re [795] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Unless the parties reach a prior agreement, the Consumer Plaintiffs are directed to file a response to the Special Master's Report and Recommendation by Friday, June 4, 2021. Accenture should file a response by Wednesday, June 9, 2021. The responses should be three pages or less, single-spaced, excluding exhibits. It seems unlikely to me that the information from the Indian depositions will be critical to the issues for class certification. Based on that understanding, I will consider an extension of the discovery deadline for the limited purpose of conducting the Indian depositions, without moving the class certification briefing deadline or other discovery deadlines, provided that no party is disadvantaged when merits issues are addressed in any subsequent summary judgment briefing. The parties should address this in their responses. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 6/1/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [787] Report and Recommendations of Special Master Judge Facciola Regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket under seal and transmitted to the parties on May 10, 2021. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 787, is adopted by the Court. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 5/25/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney by Amanda Arnold, Edward Baker, Brad Barringer, Kiana Belcher, Kevin Berry, Susan Beverley, Douglas Blake, Michael Blicher, Carol Blood, Robert Bluestone, Tanesha Boradgiak, Michael Bunker, Brenda Burr, Yvette Butler, Shelia Canipe, Deana Cannon, Catherine Carlberg, Ruthanne Carpenter, Cheryl Castor, Michael Castor, Crystal Chambers, Kathleen Christensen, Prudence Concert-White, Curtis Cummings, Mary Ellen Davey, Christopher Davies, Dorothy Davis, Karen Davis, Kenneth Davis, Graves De Armond, Cynthia Deese, May Desrochers, Scott Dias, Sami Difuntorum, Jonathan Dodart, Julie Duchsherer, Mark Duffey, Gretchen Ehle, Vance Edward Eichelberger, Carla Engle, Barbara Erickson, Michelle Featherstone, Ronald Michael Feschak, Nathan Finney, Janice Frazier-Scott, Lisa Frederickson, Michael Freeland, Lisa Fritz, Marlon Gaines, Steve Gajewski, Laurene Gallway, Eric Gault, Betsy Gentry, Scott Gideon, John Gilliland, Jon Goldberg, Angela Gresh, Latausha Griffin, Jernard Griggs, Edward Hanley, Charles Hanson, Sheila Harrison, Danielle Hayes, Phyllis Hecker, Amber Helton, Jeri Holt-Minter, Virginia Howell, Donna Hughes, Patricia Huizar, Tamika Jackson, Kyle Jaski, Monica Johnson, Nikole Jordan, Mary Jo Jurey, Robert Kaiser, Lucy Karl, Jeffrey Kemp, Linda Kite, Joan Knudson, Sarah Korwan, Ronald Kotz, Ellen Kowitt, Maretta Leitka, Rik Lewis, Beverly Louk, Anthony Malfi, Patrice Matthews, Olivia May, Susan Mcintosh, David Melendez, Holger Meyer, Debra Michaud, Jack Milam, Judy Mills, Chalise Morris, Chris Morris, David Moyer, Susan Mullins, Dorothy Odie, Jeffrey Oelhafen, Christina Olsen, Carol Ostapchuk, Steven Owens, Asim Padh, Justin Palmer, Darrel Parris, Janlisa Parris, Curtis Payne, Lawrence Perlmutter, Jeninne Pitts, Christopher Pratt, Burnease Ragin, Jeffrey Rahn, Michael Raimondi, Karen Rambat, Michael Rapp, Kumar Rashad, Beverly Ricks, Selma Rodriguez, Ruth Patricia Rosados, Andrew Rose, Joel Rosson, Mark Rotondi, Deidrinelle Rouse, Karen Russell, Rick Sabath, Bruce Sanders, Anne Santo, Anne Savarese, Vincent Savarese, Sonja Scott, David Secrist, Shawn Seeley, Tonekia Showell, Tamika Simmonds, John Simmons, Edward Siperstein, Lee Slagle, Dale Smith, Shane Somerville, Angela Sonnier, David Sparks, Kent Spence, Jody Stephens, Rhonda Stevens, Theresa Sykes, Debra Talley, Peter Tapling, Joe Taylor, Gordon Thomas, Joseph Throneberry, Beverly Tookey, Ricardo Vaquer, Edgar Vaynshteyn, Vickie Vetter, Felicia Wallace, John Waller, Kevin Walls, Jean Waskiewicz, Curtis Weaver, Ira Weintraub, Janet Wender, Marjorie Wheeler, Doreen Whelan, Debra Whiddon, Melissa White, Charles Williams, Gerald Williams, Linda Winsey, Stacey Wollman, Dennis Wooldridge, Maria Wooten, Ronzella Wright-Loftly, Jason Young, Julie Young, Melissa Yurkanin, Shaun YurtkuranAssociated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG et al.(Lai, Erica)
-SEALED-REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re the Consumer Track. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 5/10/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Plaintiffs' Submission - Glasgow Declaration, # (2) Plaintiffs' Ex A, # (3) Plaintiffs' Ex B, # (4) Plaintiffs' Ex C, # (5) Plaintiffs' Ex D, # (6) Plaintiffs' Ex E, # (7) Plaintiffs' Ex F, # (8) Defendants' Submission Vereb Declaration, # (9) Defendants Ex 1, # (10) Defendants Ex 2)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
PAPERLESS ORDER APPROVING [782] Status Report filed by Marriott International, Inc. regarding the NDS database. Marriott and the Consumer Plaintiffs are directed to file a joint status report upon completion of the final production from the NDS database. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 4/30/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
STIPULATED Protocol and ORDER for the Logging of Privileged Electronically Stored Information. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 4/23/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
STIPULATION Joint Stipulation with Defendants and Bellwether Plaintiffs by Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Mary Ann Miller, Paula OBrien, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace(Keller, Amy)
LETTER ORDER memorializing the hearing on March 24, 2021 in the Consumer and Government Tracks. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 3/31/2021. (jf3s, Deputy Clerk)
-SEALED-ORDER by the Special Master regarding objections to Marriott's interrogatory responses in the Consumer Track.. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 3/29/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on March 24, 2021, before Judge Paul W. Grimm. Court Reporter/Transcriber Rebecca Stonestreet, Telephone number 301-344-3912. Total number of pages filed: 78. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 4/19/2021. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 4/29/2021. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 6/28/2021.(rs6, Court Reporter)
PAPERLESS ORDER APPROVING [762] Stipulation of Dismissal by Plaintiff Bank of Louisiana and Defendant Marriott International, Inc. Case number 18-cv-3833-PWG is dismissed with prejudice with each party to bear its own fees and costs. The CLERK is directed to CLOSE case number 18-cv-3833-PWG. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 3/23/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
763
Filed: 3/22/2021, Entered: 3/22/2021
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER re [759] Status Report.The Court has scheduled a Zoom hearing for this Wednesday, March 24, 2021 at 2:00 pm with counsel for Marriott and the Consumer Plaintiffs regarding the Special Master's Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 752. During this hearing, the Court will also discuss the parties' Status Report, ECF No. 759. Therefore counsel for the City of Chicago should also attend this hearing. Counsel will be emailed a link to the Zoom meeting prior to the hearing. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 3/22/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
STIPULATION of Dismissal WITH PREJUDICE PURSUANT TO FED. R. CIV. P. 41(A)(1)(A)(II) by Marriott International, Inc., Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLCAssociated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:18-cv-03833-PWG(Keteltas, Gilbert)
RESPONSE re [757] Objection to Report and Recommendations, filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.(Warren, Daniel)
OBJECTION to [752] Report and Recommendations by Michaela Bittner, Roger Cullen, Eric Fishon, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, Robert Guzikowski, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Irma Lawrence, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Mary Ann Miller, Paula OBrien, Susan Raab, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace. (Attachments: # (1) Certificate of Filing)(Keller, Amy)
PAPERLESS ORDER scheduling a Zoom hearing with counsel for Marriott and the Consumer Plaintiffs regarding [752] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of the Special Master and the parties' forthcoming letter briefing on Wednesday, March 24, 2021 at 2:00 pm. Counsel will be emailed a link to the Zoom meeting prior to the hearing. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 3/17/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on 3-5-2021, before Judge Grimm. Court Reporter/Transcriber Linda Marshall, Telephone number 301-344-3229. Total number of pages filed: 50. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 4/6/2021. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 4/16/2021. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 6/14/2021.(lcm, Court Reporter)
PAPERLESS ORDER re briefing schedule for objection to [752] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master regarding the inspection of Consumer Plaintiffs' devices. If Marriott objects to the Special Master's Report and Recommendation, it should file a letter by close of business on March 17, 2021. Consumer Plaintiffs should submit a letter response by close of business on March 19, 2021. The letters should be 3 pages or less, single-spaced, excluding exhibits. The letters should include any legal authority for whether the Court should consider the alleged value of the Plaintiffs' PII on an objective and/or subjective basis. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 3/15/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master regarding inspection of Plaintiffs' devices in the Consumer Track. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 3/15/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 1, # (2) Exhibit 2)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
-SEALED- Order by the Special Master regarding discovery and damage model objection in the Consumer Track. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 3/5/2021(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
PAPERLESS ORDER memorializing today's status conference. Marriott, Accenture, and the Plaintiffs in the Consumer, Financial Institution, and Government tracks will submit a joint status report by March 19, 2021 that includes a revised proposed briefing schedule on class certification, expert reports, and expert challenges in the Consumer and Financial Institution tracks, and next steps in the Government track. This schedule should also include any proposed adjustments to the current discovery schedule. In addition, the parties should submit a proposal regarding when and how they will provide the Court information regarding the identity of their experts, their area of expertise, and what standards they will be applying. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 3/5/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
LETTER ORDER approving with modifications Special Master Judge Facciola's Order [739] regarding Marriott's proposed deposition of the City of Chicago's counsel in the Government Track. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 2/26/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 2/26/2021 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
Correspondence re: City of Chicago's Request for Leave to File Reply to Marriott's Opposition to the City's Objection to Special Master's Report and Recommendation (Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
RESPONSE re (735 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 97 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG) Notice (Other),, . Response to Defendants' Notice of Supplemental Authority filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00368-PWG(Villegas, Carol)
STATUS REPORT JOINT STATUS REPORT REGARDING NDS REHYDRATION by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Keteltas, Gilbert)
PAPERLESS ORDER scheduling a status conference with counsel for the Plaintiffs in the Consumer, Financial Institution and Government tracks and counsel for Defendants Marriott and Accenture for March 5, 2021 at 11:30 am. The status conference will take place via Zoom. Counsel will be emailed a link to the Zoom meeting prior to the status conference. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 2/25/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
742
Filed: 2/25/2021, Entered: 2/25/2021
Order on Motion to withdraw as attorney
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [737] Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. The appearance of Iman Boundaoui on behalf of the City of Chicago is terminated. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 2/25/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
Correspondence re: City of Chicago's Objection to Special Master's February 22, 2021 Order (ECF No. 739) (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A, # (2) Exhibit B, # (3) Exhibit C)(Rapp, Eve-Lynn)
ORDER by the Special Master regarding deposition objection in the Government track. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 2/22/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
ORDER by the Special Master regarding deposition objections in the Financial Institution track. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 2/22/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
NOTICE by Arne M. Sorenson, Bao Giang Val Bauduin, Mary K. Bush, Frederick A. Henderson, Bruce Hoffmeister, Lawrence W. Kellner, Aylwin B. Lewis, Marriott International, Inc., George Munoz, Kathleen Kelly Oberg re (92 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG, 690 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG) Reply to Response to Motion, (90 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG, 669 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG) Response in Opposition to Motion, (647 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 88 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG) MOTION to Dismiss the Third Amended Class Action ComplaintNotice of Supplemental Authority (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00368-PWG(Mendro, Jason)
PAPERLESS ORDER GRANTING [732] Defendants' motion to seal portions of their status report [731] and APPROVING the status report. Defendants have shown good cause to seal sensitive information regarding data security and alternatives to sealing would not provide sufficient protection. Marriott and the Consumer Plaintiffs are directed to file the next status report regarding the NDS database jointly on or before February 25, 2021. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 2/5/2021. (pk3s, Chambers)
MOTION to Seal Defendants' Motion for Leave to File Portions of Their Status Report Regarding NDS Rehydration Under Seal by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Keteltas, Gilbert)
-SEALED- STATUS REPORT Marriotts Status Report Regarding NDS Rehydration by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Keteltas, Gilbert)
STATUS REPORT Marriotts Status Report Regarding NDS Rehydration by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Keteltas, Gilbert)
STIPULATION Regarding Marriott's Searching for Information in NDS Database and Consumer Plaintiffs' Responses to Discovery Requests by IN RE: MARRIOTT INTERNATIONAL, INC.,(Keller, Amy)
NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings held on 1-14-2021, before Judge Grimm. Court Reporter/Transcriber Linda C Marshall, Telephone number 3013443229. Total number of pages filed: 64. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained from the Court Reporter or through PACER. Redaction Request due 2/16/2021. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 2/26/2021. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 4/26/2021.(lcm, Court Reporter)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
LETTER ORDER adopting with modifications (704) Report and Recommendations of Special Master regarding paragraph 11 and Protective Order against subpoenas. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/22/2021. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
Paperless Order ADOPTING [718] Report and Recommendation Regarding the Consumer Track by Special Master Judge Facciola. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket under seal and transmitted to the parties on January 5, 2020. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 718, is adopted by the Court. Marriott may claw back the PX83 spreadsheet referenced therein. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/22/2021.(pk3s, Chambers)
REPLY to Response to Motion re (699 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 94 in 8:18-cv-03833-PWG) MOTION to Dismiss BANK OF LOUISIANAS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR LACK OF STANDING filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:18-cv-03833-PWG(Keteltas, Gilbert)
RESPONSE re [715] Objection to Report and Recommendations,,,, [714] Objection to Report and Recommendations,,,, filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.(Warren, Daniel)
RESPONSE re [713] Objection to Report and Recommendations filed by Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran.(Keller, Amy)
PAPERLESS ORDER ADOPTING [707] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master Judge Facciola Regarding the Consumer Track. This Report and Recommendation was filed on the docket under seal and transmitted to the parties on December 21, 2020. The stipulated dispute resolution procedures, ECF No. 580, paragraph 5 provides, "If no party files an objection within 14 calendar days of the filing of the Report and Recommendation, the Report and Recommendation will be deemed adopted by the Court." No party has filed an objection, and the time to do so has passed. Therefore, the Report and Recommendation, ECF No. 707, is adopted by the Court. Marriott may claw back Exhibits 2 and 3, but not Exhibit 7, referenced therein. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 1/12/2020. (pk3s, Chambers)
RESPONSE in Opposition re [699] MOTION to Dismiss BANK OF LOUISIANAS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR LACK OF STANDING filed by Bank of Louisiana.(Silverman, Steven)
-SEALED-REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master regarding the Consumer Track. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 1/5/2021. (Attachments: # (1) Plaintiffs' Submission and Exhibits, # (2) Defendants' Response, # (3) Defendants' Exhibit A, # (4) Defendants' Exhibit B, # (5) Defendants' Exhibit C, # (6) Defendants' Exhibit D)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
RESPONSE re (711 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 94 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG) Notice (Other),, / Response to Defendants' Notice of Supplemental Authority filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California.Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00368-PWG(Villegas, Carol)
OBJECTION to [704] Report and Recommendations by Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran. (Keller, Amy)
OBJECTION to [704] Report and Recommendations by Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran. (Keller, Amy)
ORDER: REVISED STIPULATED DEPOSITION PROTOCOL. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 12/28/2020. (Attachments: # (1) Deposition Protocol Redline)(kns, Deputy Clerk)
NOTICE by Arne M. Sorenson, Bao Giang Val Bauduin, Mary K. Bush, Frederick A. Henderson, Bruce Hoffmeister, Lawrence W. Kellner, Aylwin B. Lewis, Marriott International, Inc., George Munoz, Kathleen Kelly Oberg re (92 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG, 690 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG) Reply to Response to Motion, (90 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG, 669 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG) Response in Opposition to Motion, (647 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 88 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG) MOTION to Dismiss the Third Amended Class Action ComplaintNotice of Supplemental Authority (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00368-PWG(Mendro, Jason)
REPLY to Response to Motion re (49 in 8:19-cv-00830-PWG, 40 in 8:19-cv-00812-PWG, 658 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG) MOTION to Dismiss the Verified Shareholder Derivative Second Amended Consolidated Complaint filed by Mary K. Bush, Bruce W. Duncan, Deborah M. Harrison, Frederick A. Henderson, Eric Hippeau, Lawrence W. Kellner, Debra L. Lee, Aylwin B. Lewis, Marriott International Inc, J.W. Marriott, Jr., George Munoz, Steven S Reinemund, Susan C. Schwab, Arne M. Sorenson, Bao Giang Val Bauduin, Deborah Marriott Harrison, Frederick A. Henderson, Eric Hippeau, Bruce Hoffmeister, Lawrence W. Kellner, Aylwin B. Lewis, Marriott International, Inc., J.W. Marriott Jr., Kathleen Kelly Oberg, Arne M. Sorenson.Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00812-PWG, 8:19-cv-00830-PWG(Mendro, Jason)
-SEALED-REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 12/18/2020. (Attachments: # (1) Attachment, # (2) Attachment)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
PAPERLESS ORDER scheduling a status conference with counsel for the Plaintiffs in the Consumer, Financial Institution, Government, Securities, and Derivative tracks and counsel for Defendants Marriott and Accenture for January 14, 2021 at 12:00 pm. The status conference will take place via Zoom. Counsel will be emailed a link to the Zoom meeting prior to the status conference. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 12/17/2020. (pk3s, Chambers)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master regarding paragraph 11 and Protective Order against subpoenas. Signed by Judge John M. Facciola on 12/2/2020. (Attachments: # (1) SEALED Marriot Letter and Exhibits re Redactions, # (2) Plaintiff Letter Brief re Protective Order, # (3) Plaintiffs Exhibits in Support of Motion for Protective Order, # (4) Plaintiff Response to Motion to Amend Protective Order, # (5) Marriott Opposition to Motion for Protective Order, # (6) Accenture Letter to SM)(ybs, Deputy Clerk) Modified on 12/15/2020 (ybs, Deputy Clerk). Modified on 12/30/2020 (kns, Deputy Clerk).
LETTER ORDER adopting in part and modifying in part [663] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master filed by City of Chicago. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 12/8/2020. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
MOTION to Dismiss BANK OF LOUISIANAS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR LACK OF STANDING by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support, # (2) Exhibit A)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:18-cv-03833-PWG(Warren, Daniel)
Correspondence re: City of Chicago's Request for Leave to file Reply to Marriotts Opposition to the Citys Objection to the Special Masters Report and Recommendation (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A)(Richman, Benjamin)
RESPONSE re [685] Miscellaneous Correspondence, [672] Order on Motion to Dismiss,,, [688] Order,, [CORRECTED FILING] Response To Accenture's Request To Reconsider The Courts October 27, 2020 filed by Annemarie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran.(Ulwick, James)
(FILED IN ERROR) RESPONSE re [685] Miscellaneous Correspondence, [672] Order on Motion to Dismiss,,, [688] Order,, Consumer Plaintiffs' Response To Accentures Request To Reconsider The Courts October 27, 2020 filed by Tom Abogabal, Latoya Aguillard, Scott Aigen, Stacey K. Allen, Edmund Alves, Anne Marie Amarena, Annemarie Amarena, Melissa Ames, Debra Anthony, Amanda Arnold, Lisa Axelrod, Aline Baca, Edward Baker, Robert Baker, Bank of Louisiana, Nathan Royce Banks, Jamie Bannon, Robert Barbour, Raymond J. Barkley, Joanne Barrett, Brad Barringer, Dena Barron, Ann Bascom, Dana Bass, Paulette Beale, Kiana Belcher, Harry Bell, Shaun Belland, Terrie Bennett, Kimberly Bentley, Adam Benwitz, Diane Bernard, David Bernstein, Catherine Berrahou, Kevin Berry, Michael Betit, Susan Beverley(PWG 19-94), Michaela Bittner, Darrell Black, Juliet Black, Winnie Blackwell, Douglas Blake, Michael Blicher, Carol Blood, Steven Bloom, Robert Bluestone, Heidi Bodian, Bridget Bodie-Papino, Michelle Bonifacio, Tanesha Boradgiak, Teresa Borman, Adam Borst, Candace Boston, Cory Bovair, Ronald Bowers, Travis Bowlby, Celia Bowman, Connie Bowman, Katesha Box, Miriam Boyd, William Boyd, William Boyd(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 19-1091), Julia Boykin, Tracy Bradford, Tracy Bradford Lockaby, Anitra Bradley, Brian Braid, Marvin Braun, Lawrence Brenner, Byron Brewer, Barbara Brooks, Dorothy Brooks, Adrianne Brown, LaToya Brown, David Bruemmer, Terrance D. Bulger, Michael Bunker, Brenda Burr, Yvette Butler, Cheryl Butler-Adams, Kylie Byron, Kathrina Cajigal, Cole Callahan, Valerie Campanella, Alisha Campbell, Cayla Campbell, Claudia Canedo, Chastity Canfall, Shelia Canipe, Deana Cannon, Salvatore Caponigro, Elizabeth Capper, Catherine Carlberg, Arhonda Carlisle, Ruthanne Carpenter, Yvette Caruthers, Louann Cashill, Luke Castle, Cheryl Castor, Michael Castor, Mark Catuogno, Jacquelyn Cauble, Chris Cervantes(PWG 18-3933), Chris Cervantes(On behalf of Himself and All Others Similarly PWG 18-3835), Penn Chabrow, Crystal Chambers, Michael Charron, Amy Chen, Kevin Cheng, Raphael Chieke, Cindy Chism, Nycole Chisum, Kathleen Christensen, Davin Christiansen, Michael C. Christner, Ryan Ciavarra, City of Chicago, Edward Claffy, John Coakley, Rob Colletti, Brady Collins, David Collins, Elizabeth Collins, Kevin Collins, Prudence Concert-White, Rita Connuck, Scott Coogan, Carol Cook, James Cook, Meghan Cook, Sherri Cook, Kristie Cooley, Laura Coombs, Cassandra Cooper, Eric Cooper, William Copeland, Kathryn Costa, John H. Cottrell, Sheila Coughlin, Jeri Covington, Kelly Cox, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Matthew Crabtree, Ivette Crawford, Bret Crockett, Roger Cullen, Curtis Cummings, Elizabeth Cunningham, Ebony Currie, Leslie Dallner, Betty Dampier, Davidez Dampier, Barbara Dane, Patricia Daughtery, Mary Ellen Davey, Christopher Davies, Dorothy Davis, Julie Davis, Karen Davis, Kenneth Davis, Kimberly R. Davis, Nikki Davis, Randall Davis, Richard Davis, Shanti Davis, Graves De Armond, Sean DeMarco, Cynthia Deese, Austin Delaney, Denee Delnay, Gerald Deloss, Jenn Demarco, Sherry Denny, Dennis Desalvo, Benjamin Desantis, May Desrochers, Parth Detroja, Jobe Anthony Diagne, Scott Dias, Mark Diefenbach, Sami Difuntorum, Gary Dittemore, Jonathan Dodart, Tammy Doles, Robert Dorfman, Lisa Dotson, Nathlie Dowdell, Perkins Drake, Lula Draper, Eric Dubitsky, Julie Duchsherer, Tommy Dudley, Alexander Duff, Mark Duffey, India Dugat, Nitya Bodhi Durant, Andrea Durkee, Stephanie Dyer, Allison Eells, Gretchen Ehle, Vance Edward Eichelberger, Todd Joseph Elliot, Brad Ellish, Michele Emanuele, Carla Engle, Barbara Erickson, Jeffrey Erlbaum, Destiny Esper, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, Julie Evans, Romel Fajardo, Jeremiah Fanyui, Scott Farkas, James Marshall Farmer, David Fasolino, Annette Fears, Michelle Featherstone, Ronald Michael Feschak, Nathan Finney(PWG 19-94), Jerome Fisher, Arnold Fishon, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Jill Fleisher, Sara Flesch, Amber Flor, Sharay Floyd, Donna Fontaine, Jeral Forger, Adam Fornal, Shaelyn Forrest, William Forrester, Michael J. Fox, Nicholas Frazer, Janice Frazier-Scott, Lisa Frederickson, Arlona Fredrickson, Michael Freeland, Philip S. Friedman, Philip Friedman, Lisa Fritz, Lisa Gadsby, Cindy Gaines, Marlon Gaines, Torri A. Gaines, Steve Gajewski, Christopher Galasso, Pablo Gallegos, Kathy Gallivan, Laurene Gallway, Mike Galvin, Robert Gamburg, Julie Ganuelas, Fae Garden, Mark Gardner, Kerry Gates, Eric Gault, Natalene Gauna, Betsy Gentry, Mitchell Gerson, Kim Gibbs, Scott Gideon, John Gilliland, John Gilmour, Maxine Glass, Paula Glass, Robert Glass, Jon Goldberg, Barry Golin, Kimberly Gomez, Laura Gononian, Billy Goodman, Jesse Gore, Erik Goudie, Brian Grady, Africa Green, Lonja Green, Angela Gresh, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Latausha Griffin, Cynthia Griffith, Jernard Griggs, Dale Grimes, Alyssa Groski, Samir Gupta, Robert Guzikowski, Gertie Haese, Anna L. Haley, Raven Hall, Trish Hamilton Cobourn, Edward Hanley, Laurie Hansen, Charles Hanson, Zakaria Haque, James Hardin, John Hariaczyi, Chris Harris, Lillian Harris, Tanya Harris, Sheila Harrison, Basimah Hasan, Philip Haskett, Timothy Hawkins, Danielle Hayes, Robeson Heard, Phyllis Hecker, Amber Helton, Lisa Henderson, Samantha Hendricks, Norbert Hennrich, Brian Herman, Jose Herrera, Luis Herrera, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Andrew Hickner, Thomas Hickner, Tobias Hinsch, Donna Hiteshew, Robin Hollingsworth, Paul Holloway, Jeri Holt-Minter, Mary Hopson, Tenise Houston, Sara Howe, Virginia Howell, Kirk Huddles, Talitha Huddleston, Donna Hughes, Patricia Huizar, Gennell Hunter, Mary Hunter, Cynthia Husebo, Dustin Iagulli, Chasity Jackson, Christina Jackson, Tameka Jackson, Tamika Jackson, Robert Jamerson, Steven Jamison, Aaron Janik, Kyle Jaski, Michael Jennings, David Johnson, David Johnson, III, Lisa Johnson, Marlo Johnson, Monica Johnson, Cleary Johs, Ron Jones, Shakimberly Jones, Matt Jordan, Nikole Jordan, Shana Jordan, Teisha Jordan, Robert Josephberg, Mary Jo Jurey, Robert Kaiser, Camara Karamatic, Peter Karkazis, Lucy Karl, Robert Keil, Jeffrey Kemp, Raymond Kerkvliet, Marybeth Kern, Matthew Kiesel, Helen Kim, David J. Kimmel, Dianne King, Nicole King, Linda Kite, Pegi Klaess, Mark Kleiman, Joan Knudson, Kenton Kolstad, Robert Korn, Sarah Korwan, Ronald Kotz, Deborah Koulpasis, Ellen Kowitt, Garry Kravit, Morris Kris, Stanley Kubinski, Shantonu Kundu, Julius Kuperberg, Yong Woo Stephano Kwon, Tina Lapene, Anthony Latore, Bob Lavine, Doris Lavine, Robin Lawler, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Krystal Lear, Greg Leeb, Maretta Leitka, Donna Level, Jonathan Levy, Deborah Lewandowski, Courtney Lewis, Jahmelia Lewis, Rik Lewis, Tishaunda Lewis, Valerie Lewis, Violet Limen, Charles Lindsey, Agnieszka Lizewska, Jay Lockaby, Ashley Logan, Brent Long, Melanie Lopez, Beverly Louk, Shayla Lowry, Juan Lozano, Kathryn Lucas, Savannah Louise Lyon, Elizabeth Lyons, Tiffany Maberry, Monica Celeste Madolora, Rita Mair, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Charity Maldonado, Anthony Malfi, Suzanne Mallon, Samuel Mangano, Deann Mankell, Yisroel Mann, Mike Manno, Bryan Mantei, Pauline Marco, Denitrice Marks, Karen Markus-Handis, Andrea Marshall, Abdjul Martin, Anthony Martin, Leslie Martin, Mark Mason, Maria Masucci, Patrice Matthews, Mark Maxey, Elizabeth Maxwell, Olivia May, Brent McArthur, John McCoy, Anastasia McGee, Dennis McGrath, Lisa McGuire, Gwendolyn McNeal, Susan Mcintosh, Eric Mcpherson, Deborah Meade, Cindy Medeiros, David Melendez, Michael Mendez, Chloe Merjil, Collin Messer, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Holger Meyer, Leon Meyer, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Daniel Meyerson, Debra Michaud, Ted Michelakos, Jack Milam, Cariss Milano, Kim Miller, Mary Ann Miller, Shane Miller, Judy Mills, Eric Mitchell, Nancy Molesworth, Vickie Mondane, Gabrielle Moore, Jason Moore, Jeremiah Moore, John P. Moore, Pamela Moore, Tanika Moore, Oscar Moreno, Chalise Morris, Chris Morris, Kris Morris, Andrew J. Mortensen, John Moy, David Moyer, William Muckelroy II, Albert Muick, Susan Mullins, Jose Munoz, Gwendolyn Murai, Bryan E. Murphy, Maggie Murphy, Ron Musto, Heidi Myers, Howard William Myones, Amelia Naccarto-Coleman, Maria Naclerio, Jonathan Nateghi-Asli, Victoria Neikirk, Sarah Newcomb, Joel Nice, Seraphin Nicholson, Dianna Nolan, Clarice Notley, Cina Nouri, Paula OBrien, Luther B Oakes, Dorothy Odie, Jeffrey Oelhafen, Monica Ogawa, Gerard Ohara, Sherita Olive-Miller, Christina Olsen, Sandra Ortner, Carol Ostapchuk, Anita Overton-Smith, Steven Owens, Asim Padh, Alicia Page, Nikki Page, Rebecca Pageau, Derrick Palmer, Justin Palmer, Kevin Parker, Darrel Parris, Janlisa Parris, Michael Anthony Partland, Douglas Patton, Daniel Paul, Curtis Payne, Dallas Perkins, Shanisha Perkins, Darren Perks, Lawrence Perlmutter, Patrice Perrier, Kenneth Peterson, Yaroslava Petraitis, Terri Pettiford, Michelle Pfannenstiel, Sean Phillips, Sean Phillips(PWG 18-3933), Michael Piana, Cherly Pilon, Jeninne Pitts, Patrick Plank, Michelle Plotsker, Michael Podesta, Juli Poloway, Emily Poltrack, Alice Poole, Brandon Post, George Pouliot, Walter Powell, Christopher Pratt, Andrea Preston, Kashanna Price, Tammy Pry, Benjamin Quinn, Linda Quinones, Susan Goldfine Raab, Susan Raab, David Rado, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Frank Ragan, Burnease Ragin, Jeffrey Rahn, Michael Raimondi, Karen Rambat, Giorgio Ramirez, Lisa Ramirez, Lupe Ramos, Thomas J. Rapak, Michael Rapp, Kumar Rashad, Nicole Regne, Robert G Reynolds, Beverly Ricks, Donna Riggins, Steve Risinger, Marvin Roberson, Dominique Robertson, Lamarkis Robinson, Nick Robinson, Betty Robinson-Harris, Lanny Rodgers, Robert Rodriguez, Selma Rodriguez, Kevin S. Rogers, Joseph Rollins, Kathleen Romeo, Adam Ropp, Ruth Patricia Rosados, Elizabeth Rosch, Andrew Rose, Joel Rosson, Mark Rotondi, Deidrinelle Rouse, Stacey Rowland, Paul Rozzo, Michael Rubin, Steven Ruga, Joshua Ruhlman, Niesha Rush, Brittany Rushing, Karen Russell, Matthew Russo, Stacy Ryan, Richard Ryans, Rick Sabath, Bruce Sanders, Adam Sanderson, Anne Santo, Luis Santos, Anne Savarese, Vincent Savarese, Adam Savett, Stephen Sawyer, Ethan Schaffer, Sara Schauer, Justin J. Schmid, Holly Schmidt, Dean Schrickel, James Schultz, Edward Schwartz, Joely Sciascia, Sonja Scott, John Scribner, Annie Seberson, David Secrist, Shawn Seeley, Janel Sempre, Terry Senn, Alaa Shaaban, Eilene Shaffer, Hiren Shah, Sharon Shank, Kerri Shapiro, Brian Sharnick, Julie Shippy, Tonekia Showell, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Jose Siandre, Sean Silver, Tamika Simmonds, John Simmons, Lenord Simmons, Aryeh Simon, Sassya Simon, Janet Simonitsch, Illya Singh, Edward Siperstein, Justin Sisbarro, Kirk Skinner, Lee Slagle, Lori Smallwood, Dale Smith, Doug Smith, W. Gregory Smith, Brittany Cliff Snyman, Julissa Solano, Shane Somerville, Angela Sonnier, Steven Spagnolo, Michael Spain, David Sparks(PWG 19-94), David Sparks(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3703), Kent Spence, Donald Springer, James Sprowl, Jeanine St. Hill, Thomas Stabile, Shelli Stapp, Jody Stephens, Rhonda Stevens, Bahasha Stigall, Tammy Stiller, Daniel Stinson, Karen Stivaletta, Debra Stolte, Sarah Stone, Simon Sum, Samantha Summers, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Craig Swanson, Jennifer Sykes, Theresa Sykes, Yanina Szenkman, Debra Talley, Peter Tapling(PWG 19-94), Peter Tapling(PWG 18-3703), Ben Taylor, Bonnie Taylor, Chris Taylor, Gerald Taylor, Joe Taylor, Melissa Taylor, Alan Teitleman, Kenneth Tew, Nicole Theiss, Carla Theriot, Gordon Thomas, Kia Thomas, Roy Thompson, Michael Thomson, Joseph Throneberry, Matthew Tidd, Pete Tittl, Joseph Tobin, Teresa Tobin, Kent Toft, Valerie Tolliver, Danny Tolver, Beverly Tookey, Matthew Tragarz, Josiah Trager, Michael Traugott, Lori Trent, Robert Trepper, Ryan Truskowski, John Turgon-Schramm, Martin Turnauer, Hope Turner, Edward Twine, Stella Ureno, Mackenzie Van Dam, Thomas Lee Van Doren, Paul Vannoy, Bari Vapnek, Ricardo Vaquer, Audrey Varner, Leo Varshavsky, Lauren Vasiliadis, Edgar Vaynshteyn, Martha Cebrian Vega, Vickie Vetter, David Viggiano, Anne Vitasek, Alan Voll, April Vrtis, Nicholas Walker, Bryan Wallace, Felicia Wallace, Tamara Wallace, John Waller, Kevin Walls, John Walsh, Ronald Walters, James Walton, Andrew Walts, Zhaochuan Wang, Jean Waskiewicz, Curtis Weaver, Ashley Webster, Marc Weinberg, Debra Weinstein, Ira Weintraub, Janet Wender, Marjorie Wheeler, Doreen Whelan, Debra Whiddon, Clara White, Jennifer White, Matthew White, Melissa White, Randolph White, Octavia Wilkerson, Charles Williams, Earline Williams, Eddie Williams, Gerald Williams, Richard Williams, Terella Williams, Keith Williams, William Winkelstein, Linda Winsey, Sheila Wolff, Stacey Wollman, Kelley Womack, Dennis Wooldridge, Maria Wooten, Chris Wright, Dolly Wright, Ronzella Wright-Loftly, Fugong Wu, Linda Wu, Debra Yokoyama, Brittany Young, Glenn Young, Jason Young, Julie Young, Melissa Yurkanin, Shaun Yurtkuran, Jacqueline Zenon, Ricardo Zepeda.(Ulwick, James) Modified on 12/10/2020 (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
RESPONSE re [680] Objection to Report and Recommendations filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.(Warren, Daniel)
REPLY to Response to Motion re (647 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 88 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG) MOTION to Dismiss the Third Amended Class Action Complaint filed by Arne M. Sorenson, Bao Giang Val Bauduin, Mary K. Bush, Frederick A. Henderson, Bruce Hoffmeister, Lawrence W. Kellner, Aylwin B. Lewis, Marriott International, Inc., George Munoz, Kathleen Kelly Oberg. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit C)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00368-PWG(Mendro, Jason)
RESPONSE in Opposition re (49 in 8:19-cv-00830-PWG, 658 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG) MOTION to Dismiss the Verified Shareholder Derivative Second Amended Consolidated Complaint filed by John P. Moore. (Attachments: # (1) Affidavit Declaration of Gregory M, Egleston, # (2) Exhibit, # (3) Declaration of John P. Moore, # (4) Text of Proposed Order)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00830-PWG(O Connell, Andrew)
PAPERLESS ORDER accepting [685] correspondence as a motion for reconsideration of the Court's October 27, 2020 Order (ECF No. 672) denying Accenture's motion to dismiss, for purposes of certifying certain questions to the Maryland Court of Appeals and the Connecticut Supreme Court. Consumer Plaintiffs are directed to respond by letter of 3-5 pages single-spaced on or before November 24, 2020, and Accenture Defendants may reply by letter of commensurate length on or before December 8, 2020. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/12/2020. (imws, Chambers)
687
Filed: 11/12/2020, Entered: 11/12/2020
Order
PAPERLESS ORDER APPROVING [686] Notice of Voluntary Dismissal of One of the Plaintiffs Without Prejudice. All claims brought by Plaintiff Edmund Alves in this action against all defendants are dismissed without prejudice, with each party to bear its own costs, unless otherwise agreed. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/12/2020. Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00812-PWG, 8:19-cv-00830-PWG(imws, Chambers)
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [683] Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to the City's Objections to Special Master's October 14, 2020 Report and Recommendation. Marriott's response is due on or before December 2, 2020. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/9/2020. (imws, Chambers)
MOTION for Extension of Time to Respond to the City's Objections to Special Master's October 14, 2020 Report and Recommendation by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Warren, Daniel)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re NDS database. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 11/3/2020. (Attachments: # (1) Cover Letter, # (2) Parties' Submissions, # (3) Envelope)(ybs, Deputy Clerk) (Additional attachment(s) added on 11/23/2020: # (5) Corrected Parties' Submissions) (ybs, Deputy Clerk).
NOTICE by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California re (90 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG, 669 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG) Response in Opposition to Motion, /Notice of Supplemental Authority (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00368-PWG(Villegas, Carol)
PAPERLESS ORDER APPROVING [676] Stipulation of Voluntary Dismissal Without Prejudice. All claims brought by Plaintiff Richard Ryan in this action against all defendants are dismissed without prejudice, with each party to bear its own costs, unless otherwise agreed. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 11/3/2020. (imws, Chambers)
ORDER granting in part and denying in part [464] Motion to Dismiss; granting in part and denying in part [465] Motion to Dismiss; directing Defendant Accenture to file its Answer to Second Amended Complaint on or before November 23, 2020. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 10/26/2020. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Motion for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply
MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply as to [663] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re [294] Amended Complaint filed by City of Chicago Unopposed by City of Chicago (Attachments: # (1) Text of Proposed Order)(Richman, Benjamin)
RESPONSE in Opposition re (647 in 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 88 in 8:19-cv-00368-PWG) MOTION to Dismiss the Third Amended Class Action Complaint filed by Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California.Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00368-PWG(Villegas, Carol)
Clarification re [649] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re credit card numbers. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 10/17/2020 (Attachments: # (1) Cover Letter, # (2) Envelope)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Order on Report and Recommendations - Special Master
LETTER ORDER adopting [649] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re credit card numbers. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 10/21/2020. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
Correspondence re: Request for an Order Adopting Special Master Facciola's Report and Recommendation Entered on September 14, 2020 (ECF No. 664) (Keller, Amy)
Correspondence re: Marriott International, Inc. and Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, LLC respectfully request that the Court enter an Order adopting Special Master Facciolas Report and Recommendation entered on September 14, 2020 (R&R) [ECF No. 649] (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A)(Ghannoum, Lisa)
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master. Signed by Judge John M. Facciola on 10/9/2020. (Attachments: # (1) Letter pursuant to Stipulated Order regarding Discovery Dispute Protocol, # (2) Plaintiff City of Chicago's Responses and Objections to Defendant's First Set of Request for Production of Documents, # (3) Plaintiff City of Chicago's Responses and Objections to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories, # (4) Plaintiff City of Chicago's Responses and Objections to Defendant's Second Set of Interrogatories, # (5) Plaintiff City of Chicago response to September 1, 2020 discovery dispute letter)(ybs, Deputy Clerk)
LETTER ORDER re [630] Consumer Plaintiffs' Letter Brief re: CrowdStrike Investigation dated 7/17/2020; [631] Consumer Plaintiffs' Letter Brief re: CrowdStrike Investigation dated 8/27/2020; [632] Marriotts' Letter Brief re: CrowdStrike Investigation dated 8/14/2020; [633] Marriott's Letter Brief re: CrowdStrike Investigation dated 8/27/2020 ; [634] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re CrowdStrike Investigation. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 8/28/2020; [35] SUPPLEMENT to [634] REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Special Master re CrowdStrike Investigation. Signed by the Honorable John M. Facciola on 8/29/2020; [650] Objection to Report and Recommendations filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC; [651] Objection to Report and Recommendations; [652] Objection to Report and Recommendations,. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 10/13/2020. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
LETTER ORDER re [464] MOTION to Dismiss Consumer Plaintiffs' Second Amended Consolidated Complaint filed by Accenture PLC, Accenture LLP. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 10/13/2020. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
LETTER ORDER re [606] Response filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC, [618] Response, filed by Bank of Louisiana, [590] Miscellaneous Correspondence. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 10/13/2020. (ybs, Deputy Clerk)
MOTION to Dismiss the Verified Shareholder Derivative Second Amended Consolidated Complaint by Mary K. Bush, Bruce W. Duncan, Deborah M. Harrison, Frederick A. Henderson, Eric Hippeau, Lawrence W. Kellner, Debra L. Lee, Aylwin B. Lewis, Marriott International Inc, J.W. Marriott, Jr., George Munoz, Steven S Reinemund, Susan C. Schwab, Arne M. Sorenson, Bao Giang Val Bauduin, Deborah Marriott Harrison, Frederick A. Henderson, Eric Hippeau, Bruce Hoffmeister, Lawrence W. Kellner, Aylwin B. Lewis, Marriott International, Inc., J.W. Marriott Jr., Kathleen Kelly Oberg, Arne M. Sorenson (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support, # (2) Exhibit A, # (3) Exhibit B, # (4) Exhibit C, # (5) Exhibit D, # (6) Exhibit E, # (7) Text of Proposed Order)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00812-PWG, 8:19-cv-00830-PWG(Mendro, Jason)
RESPONSE re [652] Objection to Report and Recommendations,,,,, filed by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC.(Keteltas, Gilbert)
OBJECTION to [649] Report and Recommendations by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran. (Keller, Amy)
RESPONSE in Support re [628] Miscellaneous Correspondence, Marriott Reply letter by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC. (Keteltas, Gilbert)
OBJECTION to [634] Report and Recommendations by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Chris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran. (Keller, Amy)
OBJECTION to [634] Report and Recommendations by Anne Marie Amarena, Harry Bell, Michaela Bittner, Douglas Blake, Teresa Borman, Travis Bowlby, William Boyd, Salvatore Caponigro, Michael Charron, Kathleen Christensen, Sheila Coughlin, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Roger Cullen, Leslie Dallner, Gary Dittemore, Eric Dubitsky, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, James Marshall Farmer, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Amber Flor, Barry Golin, Laura Gononian, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Gertie Haese, Charles Hanson, Timothy Hawkins, Lisa Henderson, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Steven Jamison, Cleary Johs, Mary Jo Jurey, Nicole King, Joan Knudson, Shantonu Kundu, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Brent Long, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Denitrice Marks, Brent McArthur, Anastasia McGee, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Mary Ann Miller, Kris Morris, William Muckelroy II, Susan Mullins, Paula OBrien, Sherita Olive-Miller, Dallas Perkins, Sean Phillips, Michael Piana, Jeninne Pitts, Michael Podesta, Susan Raab, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Robert G Reynolds, Adam Ropp, Richard Ryans, Janel Sempre, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Alan Teitleman, Josiah Trager, Hope Turner, David Viggiano, Bryan Wallace, Marc Weinberg, Keith Williams, Linda Wu, Shaun Yurtkuran. (Keller, Amy)
RESPONSE re [628] Miscellaneous Correspondence, Opposition to Motion for Sanctions filed by Bank of Louisiana. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit Exhibit 1, # (2) Exhibit Exhibit 2, # (3) Exhibit Exhibit 3)(Sinclair, William)
MOTION to Dismiss the Third Amended Class Action Complaint by Arne M. Sorenson, Bao Giang Val Bauduin, Mary K. Bush, Frederick A. Henderson, Bruce Hoffmeister, Lawrence W. Kellner, Aylwin B. Lewis, Marriott International, Inc., George Munoz, Kathleen Kelly Oberg (Attachments: # (1) Memorandum in Support, # (2) Exhibit A, # (3) Exhibit B, # (4) Appendix, # (5) Text of Proposed Order)Associated Cases: 8:19-md-02879-PWG, 8:19-cv-00368-PWG(Mendro, Jason)
NOTICE by Tom Abogabal, Latoya Aguillard, Scott Aigen, Stacey K. Allen, Edmund Alves, Anne Marie Amarena, Annemarie Amarena, Melissa Ames, Debra Anthony, Amanda Arnold, Lisa Axelrod, Aline Baca, Edward Baker, Robert Baker, Bank of Louisiana, Nathan Royce Banks, Jamie Bannon, Robert Barbour, Raymond J. Barkley, Joanne Barrett, Brad Barringer, Dena Barron, Ann Bascom, Dana Bass, Paulette Beale, Kiana Belcher, Harry Bell, Shaun Belland, Terrie Bennett, Kimberly Bentley, Adam Benwitz, Diane Bernard, David Bernstein, Catherine Berrahou, Kevin Berry, Michael Betit, Susan Beverley(PWG 19-94), Michaela Bittner, Darrell Black, Juliet Black, Winnie Blackwell, Douglas Blake, Michael Blicher, Carol Blood, Steven Bloom, Robert Bluestone, Heidi Bodian, Bridget Bodie-Papino, Michelle Bonifacio, Tanesha Boradgiak, Teresa Borman, Adam Borst, Candace Boston, Cory Bovair, Ronald Bowers, Travis Bowlby, Celia Bowman, Connie Bowman, Katesha Box, Miriam Boyd, William Boyd, William Boyd(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 19-1091), Julia Boykin, Tracy Bradford, Tracy Bradford Lockaby, Anitra Bradley, Brian Braid, Marvin Braun, Lawrence Brenner, Byron Brewer, Barbara Brooks, Dorothy Brooks, Adrianne Brown, LaToya Brown, David Bruemmer, Terrance D. Bulger, Michael Bunker, Brenda Burr, Yvette Butler, Cheryl Butler-Adams, Kylie Byron, Kathrina Cajigal, Cole Callahan, Valerie Campanella, Alisha Campbell, Cayla Campbell, Claudia Canedo, Chastity Canfall, Shelia Canipe, Deana Cannon, Salvatore Caponigro, Elizabeth Capper, Catherine Carlberg, Arhonda Carlisle, Ruthanne Carpenter, Yvette Caruthers, Louann Cashill, Luke Castle, Cheryl Castor, Michael Castor, Mark Catuogno, Jacquelyn Cauble, Chris Cervantes(PWG 18-3933), Chris Cervantes(On behalf of Himself and All Others Similarly PWG 18-3835), Penn Chabrow, Crystal Chambers, Michael Charron, Amy Chen, Kevin Cheng, Raphael Chieke, Cindy Chism, Nycole Chisum, Kathleen Christensen, Davin Christiansen, Michael C. Christner, Ryan Ciavarra, City of Chicago, Edward Claffy, John Coakley, Rob Colletti, Brady Collins, David Collins, Elizabeth Collins, Kevin Collins, Prudence Concert-White, Rita Connuck, Scott Coogan, Carol Cook, James Cook, Meghan Cook, Sherri Cook, Kristie Cooley, Laura Coombs, Cassandra Cooper, Eric Cooper, William Copeland, Kathryn Costa, John H. Cottrell, Sheila Coughlin, Jeri Covington, Kelly Cox, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Matthew Crabtree, Ivette Crawford, Bret Crockett, Roger Cullen, Curtis Cummings, Elizabeth Cunningham, Ebony Currie, Leslie Dallner, Betty Dampier, Davidez Dampier, Barbara Dane, Patricia Daughtery, Mary Ellen Davey, Christopher Davies, Dorothy Davis, Julie Davis, Karen Davis, Kenneth Davis, Kimberly R. Davis, Nikki Davis, Randall Davis, Richard Davis, Shanti Davis, Graves De Armond, Sean DeMarco, Cynthia Deese, Austin Delaney, Denee Delnay, Gerald Deloss, Jenn Demarco, Sherry Denny, Dennis Desalvo, Benjamin Desantis, May Desrochers, Parth Detroja, Jobe Anthony Diagne, Scott Dias, Mark Diefenbach, Sami Difuntorum, Gary Dittemore, Jonathan Dodart, Tammy Doles, Robert Dorfman, Lisa Dotson, Nathlie Dowdell, Perkins Drake, Lula Draper, Eric Dubitsky, Julie Duchsherer, Tommy Dudley, Alexander Duff, Mark Duffey, India Dugat, Nitya Bodhi Durant, Andrea Durkee, Stephanie Dyer, Allison Eells, Gretchen Ehle, Vance Edward Eichelberger, Todd Joseph Elliot, Brad Ellish, Michele Emanuele, Carla Engle, Barbara Erickson, Jeffrey Erlbaum, Destiny Esper, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, Julie Evans, John M. Facciola, Romel Fajardo, Jeremiah Fanyui, Scott Farkas, James Marshall Farmer, David Fasolino, Annette Fears, Michelle Featherstone, Ronald Michael Feschak, Nathan Finney(PWG 19-94), Jerome Fisher, Arnold Fishon, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Jill Fleisher, Sara Flesch, Amber Flor, Sharay Floyd, Donna Fontaine, Jeral Forger, Adam Fornal, Shaelyn Forrest, William Forrester, Michael J. Fox, Nicholas Frazer, Janice Frazier-Scott, Lisa Frederickson, Arlona Fredrickson, Michael Freeland, Philip S. Friedman, Philip Friedman, Lisa Fritz, Lisa Gadsby, Cindy Gaines, Marlon Gaines, Torri A. Gaines, Steve Gajewski, Christopher Galasso, Pablo Gallegos, Kathy Gallivan, Laurene Gallway, Mike Galvin, Robert Gamburg, Julie Ganuelas, Fae Garden, Mark Gardner, Kerry Gates, Eric Gault, Natalene Gauna, Betsy Gentry, Mitchell Gerson, Kim Gibbs, Scott Gideon, John Gilliland, John Gilmour, Maxine Glass, Paula Glass, Robert Glass, Jon Goldberg, Barry Golin, Kimberly Gomez, Laura Gononian, Billy Goodman, Jesse Gore, Erik Goudie, Brian Grady, Africa Green, Lonja Green, Angela Gresh, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Latausha Griffin, Cynthia Griffith, Jernard Griggs, Dale Grimes, Alyssa Groski, Samir Gupta, Robert Guzikowski, Gertie Haese, Anna L. Haley, Raven Hall, Trish Hamilton Cobourn, Edward Hanley, Laurie Hansen, Charles Hanson, Zakaria Haque, James Hardin, John Hariaczyi, Chris Harris, Lillian Harris, Tanya Harris, Sheila Harrison, Basimah Hasan, Philip Haskett, Timothy Hawkins, Danielle Hayes, Robeson Heard, Phyllis Hecker, Amber Helton, Lisa Henderson, Samantha Hendricks, Norbert Hennrich, Brian Herman, Jose Herrera, Luis Herrera, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Andrew Hickner, Thomas Hickner, Tobias Hinsch, Donna Hiteshew, Robin Hollingsworth, Paul Holloway, Jeri Holt-Minter, Mary Hopson, Tenise Houston, Sara Howe, Virginia Howell, Kirk Huddles, Talitha Huddleston, Donna Hughes, Patricia Huizar, Gennell Hunter, Mary Hunter, Cynthia Husebo, Dustin Iagulli, Chasity Jackson, Christina Jackson, Tameka Jackson, Tamika Jackson, Robert Jamerson, Steven Jamison, Aaron Janik, Kyle Jaski, Michael Jennings, David Johnson, David Johnson, III, Lisa Johnson, Marlo Johnson, Monica Johnson, Cleary Johs, Ron Jones, Shakimberly Jones, Matt Jordan, Nikole Jordan, Shana Jordan, Teisha Jordan, Robert Josephberg, Mary Jo Jurey, Robert Kaiser, Camara Karamatic, Peter Karkazis, Lucy Karl, Robert Keil, Jeffrey Kemp, Raymond Kerkvliet, Marybeth Kern, Matthew Kiesel, Helen Kim, David J. Kimmel, Dianne King, Nicole King, Linda Kite, Pegi Klaess, Mark Kleiman, Joan Knudson, Kenton Kolstad, Robert Korn, Sarah Korwan, Ronald Kotz, Deborah Koulpasis, Ellen Kowitt, Garry Kravit, Morris Kris, Stanley Kubinski, Shantonu Kundu, Julius Kuperberg, Yong Woo Stephano Kwon, Tina Lapene, Anthony Latore, Bob Lavine, Doris Lavine, Robin Lawler, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Krystal Lear, Greg Leeb, Maretta Leitka, Donna Level, Jonathan Levy, Deborah Lewandowski, Courtney Lewis, Jahmelia Lewis, Rik Lewis, Tishaunda Lewis, Valerie Lewis, Violet Limen, Charles Lindsey, Agnieszka Lizewska, Jay Lockaby, Ashley Logan, Brent Long, Melanie Lopez, Beverly Louk, Shayla Lowry, Juan Lozano, Kathryn Lucas, Savannah Louise Lyon, Elizabeth Lyons, Tiffany Maberry, Monica Celeste Madolora, Rita Mair, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Charity Maldonado, Anthony Malfi, Suzanne Mallon, Samuel Mangano, Deann Mankell, Yisroel Mann, Mike Manno, Bryan Mantei, Pauline Marco, Denitrice Marks, Karen Markus-Handis, Andrea Marshall, Abdjul Martin, Anthony Martin, Leslie Martin, Mark Mason, Maria Masucci, Patrice Matthews, Mark Maxey, Elizabeth Maxwell, Olivia May, Brent McArthur, John McCoy, Anastasia McGee, Dennis McGrath, Lisa McGuire, Gwendolyn McNeal, Susan Mcintosh, Eric Mcpherson, Deborah Meade, Cindy Medeiros, David Melendez, Michael Mendez, Chloe Merjil, Collin Messer, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Holger Meyer, Leon Meyer, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Daniel Meyerson, Debra Michaud, Ted Michelakos, Jack Milam, Cariss Milano, Kim Miller, Mary Ann Miller, Peter Miller, Shane Miller, Judy Mills, Eric Mitchell, Nancy Molesworth, Vickie Mondane, Gabrielle Moore, Jason Moore, Jeremiah Moore, John P. Moore, Pamela Moore, Tanika Moore, Oscar Moreno, Chalise Morris, Chris Morris, Kris Morris, Andrew J. Mortensen, John Moy, David Moyer, William Muckelroy II, Albert Muick, Susan Mullins, Jose Munoz, Gwendolyn Murai, Bryan E. Murphy, Maggie Murphy, Ron Musto, Heidi Myers, Howard William Myones, Amelia Naccarto-Coleman, Maria Naclerio, Jonathan Nateghi-Asli, Victoria Neikirk, Sarah Newcomb, Joel Nice, Seraphin Nicholson, Dianna Nolan, Clarice Notley, Cina Nouri, Paula OBrien, Luther B Oakes, Dorothy Odie, Jeffrey Oelhafen, Monica Ogawa, Gerard Ohara, Sherita Olive-Miller, Christina Olsen, Sandra Ortner, Carol Ostapchuk, Anita Overton-Smith, Steven Owens, Asim Padh, Alicia Page, Nikki Page, Rebecca Pageau, Derrick Palmer, Justin Palmer, Kevin Parker, Darrel Parris, Janlisa Parris, Michael Anthony Partland, Douglas Patton, Daniel Paul, Curtis Payne, Dallas Perkins, Shanisha Perkins, Darren Perks, Lawrence Perlmutter, Patrice Perrier, Kenneth Peterson, Yaroslava Petraitis, Terri Pettiford, Michelle Pfannenstiel, Sean Phillips, Sean Phillips(PWG 18-3933), Michael Piana, Cherly Pilon, Jeninne Pitts, Patrick Plank, Michelle Plotsker, Michael Podesta, Juli Poloway, Emily Poltrack, Alice Poole, Brandon Post, George Pouliot, Walter Powell, Christopher Pratt, Andrea Preston, Kashanna Price, Tammy Pry, Benjamin Quinn, Linda Quinones, Susan Goldfine Raab, Susan Raab, David Rado, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Frank Ragan, Burnease Ragin, Jeffrey Rahn, Michael Raimondi, Karen Rambat, Giorgio Ramirez, Lisa Ramirez, Lupe Ramos, Thomas J. Rapak, Michael Rapp, Kumar Rashad, Nicole Regne, Robert G Reynolds, Beverly Ricks, Donna Riggins, Steve Risinger, Marvin Roberson, Dominique Robertson, Lamarkis Robinson, Nick Robinson, Betty Robinson-Harris, Lanny Rodgers, Robert Rodriguez, Selma Rodriguez, Kevin S. Rogers, Joseph Rollins, Kathleen Romeo, Adam Ropp, Ruth Patricia Rosados, Elizabeth Rosch, Andrew Rose, Joel Rosson, Mark Rotondi, Deidrinelle Rouse, Stacey Rowland, Paul Rozzo, Michael Rubin, Steven Ruga, Joshua Ruhlman, Niesha Rush, Brittany Rushing, Karen Russell, Matthew Russo, Stacy Ryan, Richard Ryans, Rick Sabath, Bruce Sanders, Adam Sanderson, Anne Santo, Luis Santos, Anne Savarese, Vincent Savarese, Adam Savett, Stephen Sawyer, Ethan Schaffer, Sara Schauer, Justin J. Schmid, Holly Schmidt, Dean Schrickel, James Schultz, Edward Schwartz, Joely Sciascia, Sonja Scott, John Scribner, Annie Seberson, David Secrist, Shawn Seeley, Janel Sempre, Terry Senn, Alaa Shaaban, Eilene Shaffer, Hiren Shah, Sharon Shank, Kerri Shapiro, Brian Sharnick, Julie Shippy, Tonekia Showell, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Jose Siandre, Sean Silver, Tamika Simmonds, John Simmons, Lenord Simmons, Aryeh Simon, Sassya Simon, Janet Simonitsch, Illya Singh, Edward Siperstein, Justin Sisbarro, Kirk Skinner, Lee Slagle, Lori Smallwood, Dale Smith, Doug Smith, W. Gregory Smith, Brittany Cliff Snyman, Julissa Solano, Shane Somerville, Angela Sonnier, Steven Spagnolo, Michael Spain, David Sparks(PWG 19-94), David Sparks(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3703), Kent Spence, Donald Springer, James Sprowl, Jeanine St. Hill, Thomas Stabile, Shelli Stapp, Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC, Jody Stephens, Rhonda Stevens, Bahasha Stigall, Tammy Stiller, Daniel Stinson, Karen Stivaletta, Debra Stolte, Sarah Stone, Simon Sum, Samantha Summers, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Craig Swanson, Jennifer Sykes, Theresa Sykes, Yanina Szenkman, Debra Talley, Peter Tapling(PWG 19-94), Peter Tapling(PWG 18-3703), Ben Taylor, Bonnie Taylor, Chris Taylor, Gerald Taylor, Joe Taylor, Melissa Taylor, Alan Teitleman, Kenneth Tew, Nicole Theiss, Carla Theriot, Gordon Thomas, Kia Thomas, Roy Thompson, Michael Thomson, Joseph Throneberry, Matthew Tidd, Pete Tittl, Joseph Tobin, Teresa Tobin, Kent Toft, Valerie Tolliver, Danny Tolver, Beverly Tookey, Matthew Tragarz, Josiah Trager, Michael Traugott, Lori Trent, Robert Trepper, Ryan Truskowski, John Turgon-Schramm, Martin Turnauer, Hope Turner, Edward Twine, Stella Ureno, Mackenzie Van Dam, Thomas Lee Van Doren, Paul Vannoy, Bari Vapnek, Ricardo Vaquer, Audrey Varner, Leo Varshavsky, Lauren Vasiliadis, Edgar Vaynshteyn, Martha Cebrian Vega, Vickie Vetter, David Viggiano, Anne Vitasek, Alan Voll, April Vrtis, Nicholas Walker, Bryan Wallace, Felicia Wallace, Tamara Wallace, John Waller, Kevin Walls, John Walsh, Ronald Walters, James Walton, Andrew Walts, Zhaochuan Wang, Jean Waskiewicz, Curtis Weaver, Ashley Webster, Marc Weinberg, Debra Weinstein, Ira Weintraub, Janet Wender, Marjorie Wheeler, Doreen Whelan, Debra Whiddon, Clara White, Jennifer White, Matthew White, Melissa White, Randolph White, Octavia Wilkerson, Charles Williams, Earline Williams, Eddie Williams, Gerald Williams, Richard Williams, Terella Williams, Keith Williams, William Winkelstein, Linda Winsey, Sheila Wolff, Stacey Wollman, Kelley Womack, Dennis Wooldridge, Maria Wooten, Chris Wright, Dolly Wright, Ronzella Wright-Loftly, Fugong Wu, Linda Wu, Debra Yokoyama, Brittany Young, Glenn Young, Jason Young, Julie Young, Melissa Yurkanin, Shaun Yurtkuran, Jacqueline Zenon, Ricardo Zepeda re [630] Miscellaneous Correspondence Notice of Filing Document in Public Record - Ex. K to Consumer Plaintiffs' 7/17/2020 Letter Brief (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit K)(Ulwick, James)
-SEALED-Supplemental MOTION to Seal Exhibit B to Consumer Plaintiffs' July 17, 2020 Letter Brief (ECF No. 630) by Tom Abogabal, Latoya Aguillard, Scott Aigen, Stacey K. Allen, Edmund Alves, Anne Marie Amarena, Annemarie Amarena, Melissa Ames, Debra Anthony, Amanda Arnold, Lisa Axelrod, Aline Baca, Edward Baker, Robert Baker, Bank of Louisiana, Bank of Louisiana, Nathan Royce Banks, Jamie Bannon, Robert Barbour, Raymond J. Barkley, Joanne Barrett, Brad Barringer, Dena Barron, Ann Bascom, Dana Bass, Paulette Beale, Kiana Belcher, Harry Bell, Shaun Belland, Terrie Bennett, Kimberly Bentley, Adam Benwitz, Diane Bernard, David Bernstein, Catherine Berrahou, Kevin Berry, Michael Betit, Susan Beverley(PWG 19-94), Michaela Bittner, Darrell Black, Juliet Black, Winnie Blackwell, Douglas Blake, Michael Blicher, Carol Blood, Steven Bloom, Robert Bluestone, Heidi Bodian, Bridget Bodie-Papino, Michelle Bonifacio, Tanesha Boradgiak, Teresa Borman, Adam Borst, Candace Boston, Cory Bovair, Ronald Bowers, Travis Bowlby, Celia Bowman, Connie Bowman, Katesha Box, Miriam Boyd, William Boyd, William Boyd(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 19-1091), Julia Boykin, Tracy Bradford, Tracy Bradford Lockaby, Anitra Bradley, Brian Braid, Marvin Braun, Lawrence Brenner, Byron Brewer, Barbara Brooks, Dorothy Brooks, Adrianne Brown, LaToya Brown, David Bruemmer, Terrance D. Bulger, Michael Bunker, Brenda Burr, Mary K. Bush, Yvette Butler, Cheryl Butler-Adams, Kylie Byron, Kathrina Cajigal, Cole Callahan, Valerie Campanella, Alisha Campbell, Cayla Campbell, Claudia Canedo, Chastity Canfall, Shelia Canipe, Deana Cannon, Salvatore Caponigro, Elizabeth Capper, Catherine Carlberg, Arhonda Carlisle, Ruthanne Carpenter, Yvette Caruthers, Louann Cashill, Luke Castle, Cheryl Castor, Michael Castor, Mark Catuogno, Jacquelyn Cauble, Chris Cervantes(PWG 18-3933), Chris Cervantes(On behalf of Himself and All Others Similarly PWG 18-3835), Penn Chabrow, Crystal Chambers, Michael Charron, Amy Chen, Kevin Cheng, Raphael Chieke, Cindy Chism, Nycole Chisum, Kathleen Christensen, Davin Christiansen, Michael C. Christner, Ryan Ciavarra, City of Chicago, Edward Claffy, John Coakley, Rob Colletti, Brady Collins, David Collins, Elizabeth Collins, Kevin Collins, Prudence Concert-White, Rita Connuck, Scott Coogan, Carol Cook, James Cook, Meghan Cook, Sherri Cook, Kristie Cooley, Laura Coombs, Cassandra Cooper, Eric Cooper, William Copeland, Kathryn Costa, John H. Cottrell, Sheila Coughlin, Jeri Covington, Kelly Cox, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Matthew Crabtree, Ivette Crawford, Bret Crockett, Roger Cullen, Curtis Cummings, Elizabeth Cunningham, Ebony Currie, Leslie Dallner, Betty Dampier, Davidez Dampier, Barbara Dane, Patricia Daughtery, Mary Ellen Davey, Christopher Davies, Dorothy Davis, Julie Davis, Karen Davis, Kenneth Davis, Kimberly R. Davis, Nikki Davis, Randall Davis, Richard Davis, Shanti Davis, Graves De Armond, Sean DeMarco, Cynthia Deese, Austin Delaney, Denee Delnay, Gerald Deloss, Jenn Demarco, Sherry Denny, Dennis Desalvo, Benjamin Desantis, May Desrochers, Parth Detroja, Jobe Anthony Diagne, Scott Dias, Mark Diefenbach, Sami Difuntorum, Gary Dittemore, Jonathan Dodart, Tammy Doles, Robert Dorfman, Lisa Dotson, Nathlie Dowdell, Perkins Drake, Lula Draper, Eric Dubitsky, Julie Duchsherer, Tommy Dudley, Alexander Duff, Mark Duffey, India Dugat, Nitya Bodhi Durant, Andrea Durkee, Stephanie Dyer, Allison Eells, Gretchen Ehle, Vance Edward Eichelberger, Todd Joseph Elliot, Brad Ellish, Michele Emanuele, Carla Engle, Barbara Erickson, Jeffrey Erlbaum, Destiny Esper, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, Julie Evans, Romel Fajardo, Jeremiah Fanyui, Scott Farkas, James Marshall Farmer, David Fasolino, Annette Fears, Michelle Featherstone, Ronald Michael Feschak, Nathan Finney(PWG 19-94), Jerome Fisher, Arnold Fishon, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Jill Fleisher, Sara Flesch, Amber Flor, Sharay Floyd, Donna Fontaine, Jeral Forger, Adam Fornal, Shaelyn Forrest, William Forrester, Michael J. Fox, Nicholas Frazer, Janice Frazier-Scott, Lisa Frederickson, Arlona Fredrickson, Michael Freeland, Philip S. Friedman, Philip Friedman, Lisa Fritz, Lisa Gadsby, Cindy Gaines, Marlon Gaines, Torri A. Gaines, Steve Gajewski, Christopher Galasso, Pablo Gallegos, Kathy Gallivan, Laurene Gallway, Mike Galvin, Robert Gamburg, Julie Ganuelas, Fae Garden, Mark Gardner, Kerry Gates, Eric Gault, Natalene Gauna, Betsy Gentry, Mitchell Gerson, Kim Gibbs, Scott Gideon, John Gilliland, John Gilmour, Maxine Glass, Paula Glass, Robert Glass, Jon Goldberg, Barry Golin, Kimberly Gomez, Laura Gononian, Billy Goodman, Jesse Gore, Erik Goudie, Brian Grady, Africa Green, Lonja Green, Angela Gresh, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Latausha Griffin, Cynthia Griffith, Jernard Griggs, Dale Grimes, Alyssa Groski, Samir Gupta, Robert Guzikowski, Gertie Haese, Anna L. Haley, Raven Hall, Trish Hamilton Cobourn, Edward Hanley, Laurie Hansen, Charles Hanson, Zakaria Haque, James Hardin, John Hariaczyi, Chris Harris, Lillian Harris, Tanya Harris, Sheila Harrison, Basimah Hasan, Philip Haskett, Timothy Hawkins, Danielle Hayes, Robeson Heard, Phyllis Hecker, Amber Helton, Lisa Henderson, Samantha Hendricks, Norbert Hennrich, Brian Herman, Jose Herrera, Luis Herrera, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Andrew Hickner, Thomas Hickner, Tobias Hinsch, Eric Hippeau, Donna Hiteshew, Robin Hollingsworth, Paul Holloway, Jeri Holt-Minter, Mary Hopson, Tenise Houston, Sara Howe, Virginia Howell, Kirk Huddles, Talitha Huddleston, Donna Hughes, Patricia Huizar, Gennell Hunter, Mary Hunter, Cynthia Husebo, Dustin Iagulli, Chasity Jackson, Christina Jackson, Tameka Jackson, Tamika Jackson, Robert Jamerson, Steven Jamison, Aaron Janik, Kyle Jaski, Michael Jennings, David Johnson, David Johnson, III, Lisa Johnson, Marlo Johnson, Monica Johnson, Cleary Johs, Ron Jones, Shakimberly Jones, Matt Jordan, Nikole Jordan, Shana Jordan, Teisha Jordan, Robert Josephberg, Mary Jo Jurey, Robert Kaiser, Camara Karamatic, Peter Karkazis, Lucy Karl, Robert Keil, Jeffrey Kemp, Raymond Kerkvliet, Marybeth Kern, Matthew Kiesel, Helen Kim, David J. Kimmel, Dianne King, Nicole King, Linda Kite, Pegi Klaess, Mark Kleiman, Joan Knudson, Kenton Kolstad, Robert Korn, Sarah Korwan, Ronald Kotz, Deborah Koulpasis, Ellen Kowitt, Garry Kravit, Morris Kris, Stanley Kubinski, Shantonu Kundu, Julius Kuperberg, Yong Woo Stephano Kwon, Tina Lapene, Anthony Latore, Bob Lavine, Doris Lavine, Robin Lawler, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Krystal Lear, Greg Leeb, Maretta Leitka, Donna Level, Jonathan Levy, Deborah Lewandowski, Courtney Lewis, Jahmelia Lewis, Rik Lewis, Tishaunda Lewis, Valerie Lewis, Violet Limen, Charles Lindsey, Agnieszka Lizewska, Jay Lockaby, Ashley Logan, Brent Long, Melanie Lopez, Beverly Louk, Shayla Lowry, Juan Lozano, Kathryn Lucas, Savannah Louise Lyon, Elizabeth Lyons, Tiffany Maberry, Monica Celeste Madolora, Rita Mair, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Charity Maldonado, Anthony Malfi, Suzanne Mallon, Samuel Mangano, Deann Mankell, Yisroel Mann, Mike Manno, Bryan Mantei, Pauline Marco, Denitrice Marks, Karen Markus-Handis, Andrea Marshall, Abdjul Martin, Anthony Martin, Leslie Martin, Mark Mason, Maria Masucci, Patrice Matthews, Mark Maxey, Elizabeth Maxwell, Olivia May, Brent McArthur, John McCoy, Anastasia McGee, Dennis McGrath, Lisa McGuire, Gwendolyn McNeal, Susan Mcintosh, Eric Mcpherson, Deborah Meade, Cindy Medeiros, David Melendez, Michael Mendez, Chloe Merjil, Collin Messer, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Holger Meyer, Leon Meyer, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Daniel Meyerson, Debra Michaud, Ted Michelakos, Jack Milam, Cariss Milano, Kim Miller, Mary Ann Miller, Shane Miller, Judy Mills, Eric Mitchell, Nancy Molesworth, Vickie Mondane, Gabrielle Moore, Jason Moore, Jeremiah Moore, John P. Moore, Pamela Moore, Tanika Moore, Oscar Moreno, Chalise Morris, Chris Morris, Kris Morris, Andrew J. Mortensen, John Moy, David Moyer, William Muckelroy II, Albert Muick, Susan Mullins, Jose Munoz, Gwendolyn Murai, Bryan E. Murphy, Maggie Murphy, Ron Musto, Heidi Myers, Howard William Myones, Amelia Naccarto-Coleman, Maria Naclerio, Jonathan Nateghi-Asli, Victoria Neikirk, Sarah Newcomb, Joel Nice, Seraphin Nicholson, Dianna Nolan, Clarice Notley, Cina Nouri, Paula OBrien, Luther B Oakes, Dorothy Odie, Jeffrey Oelhafen, Monica Ogawa, Gerard Ohara, Sherita Olive-Miller, Christina Olsen, Sandra Ortner, Carol Ostapchuk, Anita Overton-Smith, Steven Owens, Asim Padh, Alicia Page, Nikki Page, Rebecca Pageau, Derrick Palmer, Justin Palmer, Kevin Parker, Darrel Parris, Janlisa Parris, Michael Anthony Partland, Douglas Patton, Daniel Paul, Curtis Payne, Dallas Perkins, Shanisha Perkins, Darren Perks, Lawrence Perlmutter, Patrice Perrier, Kenneth Peterson, Yaroslava Petraitis, Terri Pettiford, Michelle Pfannenstiel, Sean Phillips, Sean Phillips(PWG 18-3933), Michael Piana, Cherly Pilon, Jeninne Pitts, Patrick Plank, Michelle Plotsker, Michael Podesta, Juli Poloway, Emily Poltrack, Alice Poole, Brandon Post, George Pouliot, Walter Powell, Christopher Pratt, Andrea Preston, Kashanna Price, Tammy Pry, Benjamin Quinn, Linda Quinones, Susan Goldfine Raab, Susan Raab, David Rado, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Frank Ragan, Burnease Ragin, Jeffrey Rahn, Michael Raimondi, Karen Rambat, Giorgio Ramirez, Lisa Ramirez, Lupe Ramos, Thomas J. Rapak, Michael Rapp, Kumar Rashad, Nicole Regne, Robert G Reynolds, Beverly Ricks, Donna Riggins, Steve Risinger, Marvin Roberson, Dominique Robertson, Lamarkis Robinson, Nick Robinson, Betty Robinson-Harris, Lanny Rodgers, Robert Rodriguez, Selma Rodriguez, Kevin S. Rogers, Joseph Rollins, Kathleen Romeo, Adam Ropp, Ruth Patricia Rosados, Elizabeth Rosch, Andrew Rose, Joel Rosson, Mark Rotondi, Deidrinelle Rouse, Stacey Rowland, Paul Rozzo, Michael Rubin, Steven Ruga, Joshua Ruhlman, Niesha Rush, Brittany Rushing, Karen Russell, Matthew Russo, Stacy Ryan, Richard Ryans, Rick Sabath, Bruce Sanders, Adam Sanderson, Anne Santo, Luis Santos, Anne Savarese, Vincent Savarese, Adam Savett, Stephen Sawyer, Ethan Schaffer, Sara Schauer, Justin J. Schmid, Holly Schmidt, Dean Schrickel, James Schultz, Edward Schwartz, Joely Sciascia, Sonja Scott, John Scribner, Annie Seberson, David Secrist, Shawn Seeley, Janel Sempre, Terry Senn, Alaa Shaaban, Eilene Shaffer, Hiren Shah, Sharon Shank, Kerri Shapiro, Brian Sharnick, Julie Shippy, Tonekia Showell, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Jose Siandre, Sean Silver, Tamika Simmonds, John Simmons, Lenord Simmons, Aryeh Simon, Sassya Simon, Janet Simonitsch, Illya Singh, Edward Siperstein, Justin Sisbarro, Kirk Skinner, Lee Slagle, Lori Smallwood, Dale Smith, Doug Smith, W. Gregory Smith, Brittany Cliff Snyman, Julissa Solano, Shane Somerville, Angela Sonnier, Steven Spagnolo, Michael Spain, David Sparks(PWG 19-94), David Sparks(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3703), Kent Spence, Donald Springer, James Sprowl, Jeanine St. Hill, Thomas Stabile, Shelli Stapp, Jody Stephens, Rhonda Stevens, Bahasha Stigall, Tammy Stiller, Daniel Stinson, Karen Stivaletta, Debra Stolte, Sarah Stone, Simon Sum, Samantha Summers, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Craig Swanson, Jennifer Sykes, Theresa Sykes, Yanina Szenkman, Debra Talley, Peter Tapling(PWG 19-94), Peter Tapling(PWG 18-3703), Ben Taylor, Bonnie Taylor, Chris Taylor, Gerald Taylor, Joe Taylor, Melissa Taylor, Alan Teitleman, Kenneth Tew, Nicole Theiss, Carla Theriot, Gordon Thomas, Kia Thomas, Roy Thompson, Michael Thomson, Joseph Throneberry, Matthew Tidd, Pete Tittl, Joseph Tobin, Teresa Tobin, Kent Toft, Valerie Tolliver, Danny Tolver, Beverly Tookey, Matthew Tragarz, Josiah Trager, Michael Traugott, Lori Trent, Robert Trepper, Ryan Truskowski, John Turgon-Schramm, Martin Turnauer, Hope Turner, Edward Twine, Stella Ureno, Mackenzie Van Dam, Thomas Lee Van Doren, Paul Vannoy, Bari Vapnek, Ricardo Vaquer, Audrey Varner, Leo Varshavsky, Lauren Vasiliadis, Edgar Vaynshteyn, Martha Cebrian Vega, Vickie Vetter, David Viggiano, Anne Vitasek, Alan Voll, April Vrtis, Nicholas Walker, Bryan Wallace, Felicia Wallace, Tamara Wallace, John Waller, Kevin Walls, John Walsh, Ronald Walters, James Walton, Andrew Walts, Zhaochuan Wang, Jean Waskiewicz, Curtis Weaver, Ashley Webster, Marc Weinberg, Debra Weinstein, Ira Weintraub, Janet Wender, Marjorie Wheeler, Doreen Whelan, Debra Whiddon, Clara White, Jennifer White, Matthew White, Melissa White, Randolph White, Octavia Wilkerson, Charles Williams, Earline Williams, Eddie Williams, Gerald Williams, Richard Williams, Terella Williams, Keith Williams, William Winkelstein, Linda Winsey, Sheila Wolff, Stacey Wollman, Kelley Womack, Dennis Wooldridge, Maria Wooten, Chris Wright, Dolly Wright, Ronzella Wright-Loftly, Fugong Wu, Linda Wu, Debra Yokoyama, Brittany Young, Glenn Young, Jason Young, Julie Young, Melissa Yurkanin, Shaun Yurtkuran, Jacqueline Zenon, Ricardo Zepeda (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit B)(Ulwick, James)
-SEALED - NOTICE of Filing Under Seal Exhibits to Defendants' Motion for Leave to File Under Seal and In Camera Certain Exhibits to Defendants' Discovery Letters by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC re [641] MOTION to Seal Defendants' Motion for Leave to File Under Seal and In Camera Certain Exhibits to Defendants' Discovery Letters (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit Ex. D to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (2) Exhibit Ex. E to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (3) Exhibit Ex. F to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (4) Exhibit Ex. G to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (5) Exhibit Ex. H to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (6) Exhibit Ex. I to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (7) Exhibit Ex. J to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (8) Exhibit Ex. J.1 to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (9) Exhibit Ex. K to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (10) Exhibit Ex. K.1 to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (11) Exhibit Ex. L to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (12) Exhibit Ex. M to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera), # (13) Exhibit Ex. N to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter (in camera))(Ghannoum, Lisa)
MOTION to Seal Defendants' Motion for Leave to File Under Seal and In Camera Certain Exhibits to Defendants' Discovery Letters by Marriott International, Inc., Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, LLC(Ghannoum, Lisa)
NOTICE by Marriott International, Inc. re [632] Miscellaneous Correspondence Notice of Filing Document in Public Record (Attachments: # (1) Attachment Ex. B to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter, # (2) Attachment Ex. C to Marriott's August 14, 2020 Letter)(Ghannoum, Lisa)
PAPERLESS ORDER granting [636] Motion to Seal Certain Exhibits to ECF Nos. [630] and [631]. Signed by Judge Paul W. Grimm on 9/3/2020. (kns, Deputy Clerk)
-SEALED- MOTION to Seal Certain Exhibits to ECF Nos. 630 and 631 by Tom Abogabal, Latoya Aguillard, Scott Aigen, Stacey K. Allen, Edmund Alves, Anne Marie Amarena, Annemarie Amarena, Melissa Ames, Debra Anthony, Amanda Arnold, Lisa Axelrod, Aline Baca, Edward Baker, Robert Baker, Bank of Louisiana, Bank of Louisiana, Nathan Royce Banks, Jamie Bannon, Robert Barbour, Raymond J. Barkley, Joanne Barrett, Brad Barringer, Dena Barron, Ann Bascom, Dana Bass, Bao Giang Val Bauduin, Paulette Beale, Kiana Belcher, Harry Bell, Shaun Belland, Terrie Bennett, Kimberly Bentley, Adam Benwitz, Diane Bernard, David Bernstein, Catherine Berrahou, Kevin Berry, Michael Betit, Susan Beverley(PWG 19-94), Michaela Bittner, Darrell Black, Juliet Black, Winnie Blackwell, Douglas Blake, Michael Blicher, Carol Blood, Steven Bloom, Robert Bluestone, Heidi Bodian, Bridget Bodie-Papino, Michelle Bonifacio, Tanesha Boradgiak, Teresa Borman, Adam Borst, Candace Boston, Cory Bovair, Ronald Bowers, Travis Bowlby, Celia Bowman, Connie Bowman, Katesha Box, Miriam Boyd, William Boyd, William Boyd(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 19-1091), Julia Boykin, Tracy Bradford, Tracy Bradford Lockaby, Anitra Bradley, Brian Braid, Marvin Braun, Lawrence Brenner, Byron Brewer, Barbara Brooks, Dorothy Brooks, Adrianne Brown, LaToya Brown, David Bruemmer, Terrance D. Bulger, Michael Bunker, Brenda Burr, Yvette Butler, Cheryl Butler-Adams, Kylie Byron, Kathrina Cajigal, Cole Callahan, Valerie Campanella, Alisha Campbell, Cayla Campbell, Claudia Canedo, Chastity Canfall, Shelia Canipe, Deana Cannon, Salvatore Caponigro, Elizabeth Capper, Catherine Carlberg, Arhonda Carlisle, Ruthanne Carpenter, Yvette Caruthers, Louann Cashill, Luke Castle, Cheryl Castor, Michael Castor, Mark Catuogno, Jacquelyn Cauble, Chris Cervantes(PWG 18-3933), Chris Cervantes(On behalf of Himself and All Others Similarly PWG 18-3835), Penn Chabrow, Crystal Chambers, Michael Charron, Amy Chen, Kevin Cheng, Raphael Chieke, Cindy Chism, Nycole Chisum, Kathleen Christensen, Davin Christiansen, Michael C. Christner, Ryan Ciavarra, City of Chicago, Edward Claffy, John Coakley, Rob Colletti, Brady Collins, David Collins, Elizabeth Collins, Kevin Collins, Prudence Concert-White, Rita Connuck, Scott Coogan, Carol Cook, James Cook, Meghan Cook, Sherri Cook, Kristie Cooley, Laura Coombs, Cassandra Cooper, Eric Cooper, William Copeland, Kathryn Costa, John H. Cottrell, Sheila Coughlin, Jeri Covington, Kelly Cox, Matthew Crabtree(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3779), Matthew Crabtree, Ivette Crawford, Bret Crockett, Roger Cullen, Curtis Cummings, Elizabeth Cunningham, Ebony Currie, Leslie Dallner, Betty Dampier, Davidez Dampier, Barbara Dane, Patricia Daughtery, Mary Ellen Davey, Christopher Davies, Dorothy Davis, Julie Davis, Karen Davis, Kenneth Davis, Kimberly R. Davis, Nikki Davis, Randall Davis, Richard Davis, Shanti Davis, Graves De Armond, Sean DeMarco, Cynthia Deese, Austin Delaney, Denee Delnay, Gerald Deloss, Jenn Demarco, Sherry Denny, Dennis Desalvo, Benjamin Desantis, May Desrochers, Parth Detroja, Jobe Anthony Diagne, Scott Dias, Mark Diefenbach, Sami Difuntorum, Gary Dittemore, Jonathan Dodart, Tammy Doles, Robert Dorfman, Lisa Dotson, Nathlie Dowdell, Perkins Drake, Lula Draper, Eric Dubitsky, Julie Duchsherer, Tommy Dudley, Alexander Duff, Mark Duffey, India Dugat, Nitya Bodhi Durant, Andrea Durkee, Stephanie Dyer, Allison Eells, Gretchen Ehle, Vance Edward Eichelberger, Todd Joseph Elliot, Brad Ellish, Michele Emanuele, Carla Engle, Barbara Erickson, Jeffrey Erlbaum, Destiny Esper, Nathan Esquerra, Thomas Evankovich, Julie Evans, Romel Fajardo, Jeremiah Fanyui, Scott Farkas, James Marshall Farmer, David Fasolino, Annette Fears, Michelle Featherstone, Ronald Michael Feschak, Nathan Finney(PWG 19-94), Jerome Fisher, Arnold Fishon, Eric Fishon, Bruce Fitzgerald, Jill Fleisher, Sara Flesch, Amber Flor, Sharay Floyd, Donna Fontaine, Jeral Forger, Adam Fornal, Shaelyn Forrest, William Forrester, Michael J. Fox, Nicholas Frazer, Janice Frazier-Scott, Lisa Frederickson, Arlona Fredrickson, Michael Freeland, Philip S. Friedman, Philip Friedman, Lisa Fritz, Lisa Gadsby, Cindy Gaines, Marlon Gaines, Torri A. Gaines, Steve Gajewski, Christopher Galasso, Pablo Gallegos, Kathy Gallivan, Laurene Gallway, Mike Galvin, Robert Gamburg, Julie Ganuelas, Fae Garden, Mark Gardner, Kerry Gates, Eric Gault, Natalene Gauna, Betsy Gentry, Mitchell Gerson, Kim Gibbs, Scott Gideon, John Gilliland, John Gilmour, Maxine Glass, Paula Glass, Robert Glass, Jon Goldberg, Barry Golin, Kimberly Gomez, Laura Gononian, Billy Goodman, Jesse Gore, Erik Goudie, Brian Grady, Africa Green, Lonja Green, Angela Gresh, John Stephen Griesenbeck, Latausha Griffin, Cynthia Griffith, Jernard Griggs, Dale Grimes, Alyssa Groski, Samir Gupta, Robert Guzikowski, Gertie Haese, Anna L. Haley, Raven Hall, Trish Hamilton Cobourn, Edward Hanley, Laurie Hansen, Charles Hanson, Zakaria Haque, James Hardin, John Hariaczyi, Chris Harris, Lillian Harris, Tanya Harris, Sheila Harrison, Basimah Hasan, Philip Haskett, Timothy Hawkins, Danielle Hayes, Robeson Heard, Phyllis Hecker, Amber Helton, Lisa Henderson, Samantha Hendricks, Norbert Hennrich, Brian Herman, Jose Herrera, Luis Herrera, Kathleen Frakes Hevener, Andrew Hickner, Thomas Hickner, Tobias Hinsch, Donna Hiteshew, Robin Hollingsworth, Paul Holloway, Jeri Holt-Minter, Mary Hopson, Tenise Houston, Sara Howe, Virginia Howell, Kirk Huddles, Talitha Huddleston, Donna Hughes, Patricia Huizar, Gennell Hunter, Mary Hunter, Cynthia Husebo, Dustin Iagulli, Chasity Jackson, Christina Jackson, Tameka Jackson, Tamika Jackson, Robert Jamerson, Steven Jamison, Aaron Janik, Kyle Jaski, Michael Jennings, David Johnson, David Johnson, III, Lisa Johnson, Marlo Johnson, Monica Johnson, Cleary Johs, Ron Jones, Shakimberly Jones, Matt Jordan, Nikole Jordan, Shana Jordan, Teisha Jordan, Robert Josephberg, Mary Jo Jurey, Robert Kaiser, Camara Karamatic, Peter Karkazis, Lucy Karl, Robert Keil, Jeffrey Kemp, Raymond Kerkvliet, Marybeth Kern, Matthew Kiesel, Helen Kim, David J. Kimmel, Dianne King, Nicole King, Linda Kite, Pegi Klaess, Mark Kleiman, Joan Knudson, Kenton Kolstad, Robert Korn, Sarah Korwan, Ronald Kotz, Deborah Koulpasis, Ellen Kowitt, Garry Kravit, Morris Kris, Stanley Kubinski, Shantonu Kundu, Julius Kuperberg, Yong Woo Stephano Kwon, Tina Lapene, Anthony Latore, Bob Lavine, Doris Lavine, Robin Lawler, Irma Lawrence, Fredric Lazarus, Krystal Lear, Greg Leeb, Maretta Leitka, Donna Level, Jonathan Levy, Deborah Lewandowski, Courtney Lewis, Jahmelia Lewis, Rik Lewis, Tishaunda Lewis, Valerie Lewis, Violet Limen, Charles Lindsey, Agnieszka Lizewska, Jay Lockaby, Ashley Logan, Brent Long, Melanie Lopez, Beverly Louk, Shayla Lowry, Juan Lozano, Kathryn Lucas, Savannah Louise Lyon, Elizabeth Lyons, Tiffany Maberry, Monica Celeste Madolora, Rita Mair, Maria Maisto, Peter Maldini, Charity Maldonado, Anthony Malfi, Suzanne Mallon, Samuel Mangano, Deann Mankell, Yisroel Mann, Mike Manno, Bryan Mantei, Pauline Marco, Denitrice Marks, Karen Markus-Handis, Andrea Marshall, Abdjul Martin, Anthony Martin, Leslie Martin, Mark Mason, Maria Masucci, Patrice Matthews, Mark Maxey, Elizabeth Maxwell, Olivia May, Brent McArthur, John McCoy, Anastasia McGee, Dennis McGrath, Lisa McGuire, Gwendolyn McNeal, Susan Mcintosh, Eric Mcpherson, Deborah Meade, Cindy Medeiros, David Melendez, Michael Mendez, Chloe Merjil, Collin Messer, Laura Messier, Gary Meter, Holger Meyer, Leon Meyer, Cheryl Pilon Meyer, Daniel Meyerson, Debra Michaud, Ted Michelakos, Jack Milam, Cariss Milano, Kim Miller, Mary Ann Miller, Shane Miller, Judy Mills, Eric Mitchell, Nancy Molesworth, Vickie Mondane, Gabrielle Moore, Jason Moore, Jeremiah Moore, John P. Moore, Pamela Moore, Tanika Moore, Oscar Moreno, Chalise Morris, Chris Morris, Kris Morris, Andrew J. Mortensen, John Moy, David Moyer, William Muckelroy II, Albert Muick, Susan Mullins, Jose Munoz, Gwendolyn Murai, Bryan E. Murphy, Maggie Murphy, Ron Musto, Heidi Myers, Howard William Myones, Amelia Naccarto-Coleman, Maria Naclerio, Jonathan Nateghi-Asli, Victoria Neikirk, Sarah Newcomb, Joel Nice, Seraphin Nicholson, Dianna Nolan, Clarice Notley, Cina Nouri, Paula OBrien, Luther B Oakes, Dorothy Odie, Jeffrey Oelhafen, Monica Ogawa, Gerard Ohara, Sherita Olive-Miller, Christina Olsen, Sandra Ortner, Carol Ostapchuk, Anita Overton-Smith, Steven Owens, Asim Padh, Alicia Page, Nikki Page, Rebecca Pageau, Derrick Palmer, Justin Palmer, Kevin Parker, Darrel Parris, Janlisa Parris, Michael Anthony Partland, Douglas Patton, Daniel Paul, Curtis Payne, Dallas Perkins, Shanisha Perkins, Darren Perks, Lawrence Perlmutter, Patrice Perrier, Kenneth Peterson, Yaroslava Petraitis, Terri Pettiford, Michelle Pfannenstiel, Sean Phillips, Sean Phillips(PWG 18-3933), Michael Piana, Cherly Pilon, Jeninne Pitts, Patrick Plank, Michelle Plotsker, Michael Podesta, Juli Poloway, Emily Poltrack, Alice Poole, Brandon Post, George Pouliot, Walter Powell, Christopher Pratt, Andrea Preston, Kashanna Price, Tammy Pry, Benjamin Quinn, Linda Quinones, Susan Goldfine Raab, Susan Raab, David Rado, Frank Ragan(PWG 18-3933), Frank Ragan, Burnease Ragin, Jeffrey Rahn, Michael Raimondi, Karen Rambat, Giorgio Ramirez, Lisa Ramirez, Lupe Ramos, Thomas J. Rapak, Michael Rapp, Kumar Rashad, Nicole Regne, Robert G Reynolds, Beverly Ricks, Donna Riggins, Steve Risinger, Marvin Roberson, Dominique Robertson, Lamarkis Robinson, Nick Robinson, Betty Robinson-Harris, Lanny Rodgers, Robert Rodriguez, Selma Rodriguez, Kevin S. Rogers, Joseph Rollins, Kathleen Romeo, Adam Ropp, Ruth Patricia Rosados, Elizabeth Rosch, Andrew Rose, Joel Rosson, Mark Rotondi, Deidrinelle Rouse, Stacey Rowland, Paul Rozzo, Michael Rubin, Steven Ruga, Joshua Ruhlman, Niesha Rush, Brittany Rushing, Karen Russell, Matthew Russo, Stacy Ryan, Richard Ryans, Rick Sabath, Bruce Sanders, Adam Sanderson, Anne Santo, Luis Santos, Anne Savarese, Vincent Savarese, Adam Savett, Stephen Sawyer, Ethan Schaffer, Sara Schauer, Justin J. Schmid, Holly Schmidt, Dean Schrickel, James Schultz, Edward Schwartz, Joely Sciascia, Sonja Scott, John Scribner, Annie Seberson, David Secrist, Shawn Seeley, Janel Sempre, Terry Senn, Alaa Shaaban, Eilene Shaffer, Hiren Shah, Sharon Shank, Kerri Shapiro, Brian Sharnick, Julie Shippy, Tonekia Showell, Svetlana Shtofmakher, Jose Siandre, Sean Silver, Tamika Simmonds, John Simmons, Lenord Simmons, Aryeh Simon, Sassya Simon, Janet Simonitsch, Illya Singh, Edward Siperstein, Justin Sisbarro, Kirk Skinner, Lee Slagle, Lori Smallwood, Dale Smith, Doug Smith, W. Gregory Smith, Brittany Cliff Snyman, Julissa Solano, Shane Somerville, Angela Sonnier, Steven Spagnolo, Michael Spain, David Sparks(PWG 19-94), David Sparks(individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated PWG 18-3703), Kent Spence, Donald Springer, James Sprowl, Jeanine St. Hill, Thomas Stabile, Shelli Stapp, Jody Stephens, Rhonda Stevens, Bahasha Stigall, Tammy Stiller, Daniel Stinson, Karen Stivaletta, Debra Stolte, Sarah Stone, Simon Sum, Samantha Summers, Mary Ann Sundius-Rose, Craig Swanson, Jennifer Sykes, Theresa Sykes, Yanina Szenkman, Debra Talley, Peter Tapling(PWG 19-94), Peter Tapling(PWG 18-3703), Ben Taylor, Bonnie Taylor, Chris Taylor, Gerald Taylor, Joe Taylor, Melissa Taylor, Alan Teitleman, Kenneth Tew, Nicole Theiss, Carla Theriot, Gordon Thomas, Kia Thomas, Roy Thompson, Michael Thomson, Joseph Throneberry, Matthew Tidd, Pete Tittl, Joseph Tobin, Teresa Tobin, Kent Toft, Valerie Tolliver, Danny Tolver, Beverly Tookey, Matthew Tragarz, Josiah Trager, Michael Traugott, Lori Trent, Robert Trepper, Ryan Truskowski, John Turgon-Schramm, Martin Turnauer, Hope Turner, Edward Twine, Stella Ureno, Mackenzie Van Dam, Thomas Lee Van Doren, Paul Vannoy, Bari Vapnek, Ricardo Vaquer, Audrey Varner, Leo Varshavsky, Lauren Vasiliadis, Edgar Vaynshteyn, Martha Cebrian Vega, Vickie Vetter, David Viggiano, Anne Vitasek, Alan Voll, April Vrtis, Nicholas Walker, Bryan Wallace, Felicia Wallace, Tamara Wallace, John Waller, Kevin Walls, John Walsh, Ronald Walters, James Walton, Andrew Walts, Zhaochuan Wang, Jean Waskiewicz, Curtis Weaver, Ashley Webster, Marc Weinberg, Debra Weinstein, Ira Weintraub, Janet Wender, Marjorie Wheel
Update
Alerts
Jump
1106