United States et al v. Google LLC Document 166: Brief in Support, Attachment 2

Virginia Eastern District Court
Case No. 1:23-cv-00108-LMB-JFA
Filed April 28, 2023

Brief in Support to [165] MOTION for Entry of Order Regarding Coordination of Discovery filed by Google LLC. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A, # (2) Exhibit B, # (3) Exhibit C, # (4) Exhibit D)(Garrett, Tyler)

Back to United States et al v. Google LLC

No tags have been applied so far. Sign in to add some.

Previous: Document 165

Next: Document 167

Jump to Document 166 or Attachment 1 • 2 • 3 • 4

Formatted Text

Raw Text

Page 1 PageID#
Exhibit B

Page 2 PageID#

;=47

=,42#0477D><
#0477D,B
,/4>:9$?=00?
70C,9/=4,'

.=,42=0477D..=0477D7,B.:8

9/=0BB,7?><
=0>31407/>=@.63,@>0=4920="
$?=00? ( 7::=
(,>3492?:9
9/=0BB,7?1=0>31407/>.:8

@74,(::/><
,=:9%04?07-,@8><
&94?0/$?,?0>0;,=?809?:1@>?4.0
9?4?=@>?4A4>4:9
41?3$?=00? )$@4?0
(,>3492?:9
@74,%,=A0=(::/@>/:52:A
,=:9%04?07-,@8@>/:52:A

4>.:A0=D::=/49,?4:94>.@>>4:9
=,429/D@74,,9/,=:9
B=4?0:9-03,71:1?30"7,49?411>49
8/ ";09/49249?30$:@?30=94>?=4.?:1 0B):=6?30H.?4:9I
?:1@=?30=:@=.:9A0=>,?4:9>.:9.0=9492?30>.:;0:1;:?09?4,7.::=/49,?4:9-0?B009?3,?.?4:9
,9/?30,/?0.3.,>0;09/492,2,49>?::27049?30,>?0=94>?=4.?:1'4=2494,
.A ?30H'.?4:9I
(3470?30"7,49?411>-0740A0?3,?>:8070A07:1.::=/49,?4:94>,;;=:;=4,?0
49.7@/4921:=?30>3,=492:1/:.@809?>,9/?:307;=0/@.0?30-@=/09:9?34=/;,=?40>B03,A0
>429414.,9?.:9.0=9>,-:@??30/=,1?;=:;:>,7>D:@3,A0>3,=0/B4?3@>,>?30D=07,?0?:
/0;:>4?4:9>,9/-0740A0?3,?.0=?,49,>;0.?>:1?30;=:;:>,7>B:@7/>429414.,9?7D;=05@/4.0?30
"7,49?411>J=423?,9/,-474?D?:/0A07:;0A4/09.049.7@/492,>.:9?08;7,?0/-D?300C4>?492
>.30/@7049?30.?4:9,9/?300/0=,7#@70>
(0@9/0=>?,9/?3,?::270B477-08,6492,9,;;74.,?4:949?30.?4:9,9/?3,?
::270,9/:=?30'"7,49?411>30=049,1?0=H!IB477-08,6492,9,;;74.,?4:949?30
'.?4:9:9=4/,D;=47 (0,>6?3,?D:@;=:A4/0,.:;D:1?34>70??0=?:-:?3.:@=?>?:
;=:A4/0,9:A0=A40B:1?30"7,49?411>J;:>4?4:9(0,7>:;7,9?:=0<@0>?1=:8?30:@=?49
?30.?4:9GB30=0B0,=0;,=?40>G?3,?B0-0;0=84??0/?:=0>;:9/?:::270J>8:?4:9
B4?349:90B006:9,D
%30"7,49?411>=0.:294E0?3,??30=0,=0>@->?,9?4,7>4847,=4?40>-0?B009?30.7,48>
,>>0=?0/49?30'.?4:9,9/?30.?4:90A09B3470?30=0,=0>:80/4110=09.0>:?3
.,>0>1:.@>:9::270J>.:9/@.?49.:990.?4:9B4?3?30,/?0.3>?,.6,9/4?>48;,.?:9-:?3
:97490;@-74>30=>,9/,/A0=?4>0=>?3:@23?30=0,=0>:80/4110=09.0>49?30?30:=40>;@=>@0/-D
A,=4:@>;,=?40>/4110=09.0>-0?B009?30/,8,20>>:@23?49?30?B:,.?4:9>,9/49?30

Page 3 PageID#
.?4:9>:80:1?30,.?4:9>,=0:9-03,71:1;@?,?4A0.7,>>0>B3470?30=0,=09:.7,>>0>49?30
'.?4:9
"=:.0/@=,77D?30?B:.?4:9>,=049<@4?0/4110=09?;:>?@=0>:=0C,8;7049?30'
,.?4:9B0@9/0=>?,9/?3,?1,.?/4>.:A0=D4>>.30/@70/?:.7:>0:9$0;?08-0= 0C;0=?
/4>.:A0=D4>?:-0.:9.7@/0/-D,9@,=D ,9/,149,7;=0?=4,7.:910=09.0>.30/@70/1:=
,9@,=D 9.:9?=,>??30.?4:93,>,1,.?/4>.:A0=D.@?:11:9@90 G
94908:9?3>7,?0=?3,949?30'.?4:9G,9/0C;0=?/4>.:A0=D?3=:@230.08-0=
1:77:B0/-D.7,>>.0=?414.,?4:98:?4:9>B34.3B477-0-=4010/-D84/?:7,?0,=.3
@=?30=/4>.:A0=D:10?,,>,;,=?D4>,?70,>?7,=207D>?,D0/49,9D.,>049B34.30?,4>
9,80/,>,;,=?D,9/?30=04>,?70,>?:90.:9>:74/,?0/.,>0-D;7,49?41191:=89.1:=B34.3
/4>.:A0=D4>>?,D0/;09/4921@=?30=:=/0=:1?30:@=?,9/?30;,=?40>J-=401492:9?304>>@,9.0:1
,.:9?49@0/>?,D$0A0=,78:?4:9>?:/4>84>>.7,48>:=;:=?4:9>:1.7,48>49?30A,=4:@>
.,>0>,7>:=08,49;09/492?30:@?.:80:1B34.38:?4:9>.:@7/48;,.??30>.:;0,9/9,?@=0:1
/4>.:A0=D
4A09?30>@->?,9?4A0>4847,=4?40>4?8,60>9,?@=,7>09>0?:.::=/49,?0?30;=:/@.?4:9:1
/:.@809?>49.7@/492?:09>@=0?3,?,77;,=?40>49-:?3,.?4:9>?4807D=0.04A0/:.@809?>:-?,490/
4904?30=,.?4:9(0-0740A0?30;,=?40>49-:?3.?4:9>B477-0,-70?:,2=00@;:9?30>3,=492:1
/:.@809?/4>.:A0=DB30?30=;=:/@.0/-D,;,=?D:=-D?34=/;,=?40>(3470?30=0,=0
/4110=09.0>-0?B009?30;=:?0.?4A0:=/0=>490,.3.,>0B0-0740A0?3,??34>/4110=09.04>
;=48,=47D,94>>@0-,>0/:9?34=/;,=?D0C;0.?,?4:9>B34.3.,9-0,//=0>>0/-D/4>.7:>492?:
?34=/;,=?40>?3,??304=/:.@809?>B477-0;=:A4/0/?:?30;,=?40>49-:?3,.?4:9>B30=0?30DB:@7/
-0>@-50.??:?30/4110=09?;=:?0.?4A0:=/0=>(3470B00C;0.??3,?>:80?34=/;,=?40>8,D/0>4=0
/4110=09?;=:?0.?4:9>?3,9,=0.,770/1:=-D?30=0>;0.?4A0;=:?0.?4A0:=/0=>?3:>0.,9-0=0>:7A0/
B4?3?30?34=/;,=?40>7?0=9,?4A07D?30?34=/;,=?40>.:@7/070.?-0?B009?30?B:;=:?0.?4A0
:=/0=>1:=?303,9/7492:1?304=.:914/09?4,7491:=8,?4:9
%30>3,=492:1/:.@809?>49,.::=/49,?0/1,>34:9>3:@7/09>@=0?3,?,77;,=?40>-09014?
1=:8?30?34=/;,=?D;=:/@.?4:9>,=049A:7A0/49902:?4,?492?30>.:;0:1?34=/;,=?D;=:/@.?4:9>
?30D.,=0,-:@?,9/>3:@7/307;=0>:7A0?30@91:=?@9,?0/07,D>?30"7,49?411>3,A0
09.:@9?0=0/,>?:::270J>;=:/@.?4:9:1/:.@809?>::2703,>/07,D0/8:=0?3,9,
8:9?349;=:A4/492,>48;70.:;D:1?30/:.@809?>::270;=0A4:@>7D;=:/@.0/?:!
-@?B4?3307/1=:8?30"7,49?411>B34.34>>@04>;09/49249?30.?4:9B4?3,70??0=
8:?4:9?:.:8;07G6? 49 460B4>0B3470::2703,>>:80?480>34237423?0/
?3,?!3,>,7=0,/D092,20/49:A0= /0;:>4?4:9>,>;,=?:14?>;=0>@4?49A0>?42,?4:9::270
3,>9:?;=:A4/0/,9D:1?3:>0?=,9>.=4;?>:97D>:80:1B34.3=07,?0/4=0.?7D?:,/?0.34>>@0>?:
?30"7,49?411>1@=?30=;@??492@>,?,/4>,/A,9?,20?3,?.:@7/-0>:7A0/-D?30>3,=492:1
/:.@809?>::2703,>,7=0,/D=0.04A0/!J>09?4=049A0>?42,?4A0147049.7@/492/:.@809?>
;=:/@.0/-D?34=/;,=?40>?:B34.3"7,49?411>/:9:?3,A0,..0>>460B4>0::2703,>
=0.04A0/H84774:9>:1*?34=/;,=?D+/:.@809?>I.:770.?0/-D?30$?,?0"7,49?411>/@=492?304=
49A0>?42,?4:9%=,? .A %0C,D
"=4A,?0;7,49?411>3,A0>0099:90:1?3:>0/:.@809?>
(4?3=0>;0.??:/0;:>4?4:9>:1?34=/;,=?40>B0,7>:-0740A0?3,?.::=/49,?4:9B30=0
;:>>4-70B477307;=0/@.0?30-@=/09:98,9D?34=/;,=?40>1:=?30;=:/@.?4:9:1/:.@809?>,9/
1:=;=:/@.492B4?90>>0>1:=/0;:>4?4:9%:,.340A0?34>2:,7:1.::=/49,?4921:=?34=/;,=?D

Page 4 PageID#
/4>.:A0=D3:B0A0=?30"7,49?411>B:@7/900/?:-0,>>@=0/:1,1,4=:;;:=?@94?D?:-:?3
/0?0=8490B30?30=?:.=:>>9:?4.0,?34=/;,=?DB4?90>>>:@23??:-0/0;:>0/49?30'
.?4:9,9/41>:;=:;0=7D;=0;,=0?:0C,8490>@.3,B4?90>>
%:/:>:?30;,=?40>B477900/?:,2=00?:;=:.0/@=0>?:,77:B?30"7,49?411>?:
=0.04A0.:;40>:1/:.@809?>;=:/@.0/-D?30?34=/;,=?40>B30?30=49::270J>,9/!J>
;:>>0>>4:91=:849A0>?42,?4:9>:=/4>.:A0=D,9/;,=?D/:.@809?>49.7@/492::270J>
/:.@809?>=07,?492?:>@.3?34=/;,=?D1?30"7,49?411>,=0;=:A4/0/>@.3/:.@809?>,9/
,=0;=0>09?,?4:9:1?30>@->?,9?4,7.:8;70?4:9:1?30;=:/@.?4:9?:@>:1>@.3/:.@809?>?309?30
"7,49?411>.:@7/-049,;:>4?4:9?:5:4949?30/0;:>4?4:9>:1?34=/;,=?DB4?90>>0> /,D>
,1?0=>@.30C.3,920,9/=0;=0>09?,?4:9,9/-0,-70?:49/4.,?0B30?30=B0.=:>>9:?4.0>@.3
/0;:>4?4:91:=?30.?4:9B4?349 /,D>,1?0=>@.30C.3,920,9/=0;=0>09?,?4:9
(4?3=0>;0.??:::270/0;:>4?4:9>3:B0A0=B0>00>429414.,9?;=05@/4.0?:?30
"7,49?411>>3:@7/?30/=,1?;=:;:>0//4>.:A0=D.::=/49,?4:9;=:.0/@=0>-0,/:;?0/%34>,=4>0>
-0.,@>0:1,A0=D?=@9.,?0/;0=4:/.:8809>@=,?0B4?3?30/4>.:A0=D.@?:1149?30'
.?4:9/@=492B34.3>429414.,9?/0;:>4?4:9>:1::270B4?90>>0>B:@7/:..@=-@?B4?3:@?
,77:B492?30"7,49?411>,1,4=:;;:=?@94?D?:/0A07:;?30;,=?D,9/?34=/;,=?D/4>.:A0=D?3,?
B0900/?:;,=?4.4;,?080,94921@77D,9/,;;=:;=4,?07D49>@.3,/0;:>4?4:9:=0A09.3::>0
B30?30=?:;,=?4.4;,?049>@.3/0;:>4?4:9
%34>.:9.0=94>1,=1=:83D;:?30?4.,7,9/49>?0,/,7=0,/D0C,.0=-,?0/-D::270J>
/4>.:A0=D/07,D>49?30.?4:9B30=01:=0C,8;70,>9:?0/,-:A0::2703,>=01@>0/1:=
8:=0?3,9,8:9?3?:;=:A4/0?30"7,49?411>B4?3,84==:=.:;D:14?>;=:/@.?4:9:1
/:.@809?>,7=0,/D;=:A4/0/?:!49?30'.?4:9B4?39:=0,>:9,-700C;7,9,?4:91:=?30
/07,D24A09B03,A0>48;7D=0<@0>?0/,90C,.?.:;D460B4>0::2703,>>,?1:=B006>:9?30
"7,49?411>J;=:;:>0/>0,=.3?0=8>,9/.@>?:/4,974>?>B34.3>3:B>?3,?::2704>9:?D0?
0A09>@->?,9?4,77D.:770.?492/:.@809?>,94>>@0B34.3419:?;=:8;?7D=0>:7A0/?30
"7,49?411>,9?4.4;,?0,7>:3,A492?:-=492?:?30:@=?1:==0>:7@?4:9
4A09::270J>;:>4?4:9:9.::=/49,?4:9?3,??30"7,49?411>B:@7/9:?-0;0=84??0/
,->09?2::/.,@>07,?0=?:/0;:>0,B4?90>>B3:B,>/0;:>0/49?30'.?4:9B0/:9:?
-0740A04?4>,80=0.:49.4/09.0?3,?::2703,A492@9>@..0>>1@77D>:@23??:=08:A0?30'
.?4:91=:84?>H=:.60?/:.60?I7:.,?4:94>9:B,??08;?492?:@>0?301,>?0=>.30/@70?30=0?:
>@;;=0>>0A4/09.0,9/2,49,9@91,4=,9/@9,9?4.4;,?0/-09014?,2,49>??30"7,49?411>
::2704>0>>09?4,77D>006492?:=0<@4=0,H@>0:=7:>0I,;;=:,.31:=60D/0;:>4?4:9>:1::270
B4?90>>0>/@=492?3090C?10B8:9?3>?30 B4?90>>0>B3:8!B477.3::>0?:/0;:>0
B3470>48@7?,90:@>7D,9/B4?3:@?2::/=0,>:9>@->?,9?4,77D>7:B492?30;=:/@.?4:9:1?30A0=D
/:.@809?>,9//,?,?30"7,49?411>900/?:-0,-70?:092,2049>@.3/0;:>4?4:9>
9/00/?34>,??08;?-D::270?:?,60,/A,9?,20:1!J>=423?@9/0= &$
F 29:??:3,A04?>,9?4?=@>?,.?4:9?=,9>10==0/,>;,=?:1,9B:@7/-0.:9?=,=D?:?30
;@=;:>0:1?3,?>?,?@?:=D;=:A4>4:9:92=0>>=0.:294E0/?3,?600;492!J>.,>0>>0;,=,?01=:8
=07,?0/>H8,D:..,>4:9,77D-@=/09/0109/,9?>-0.,@>0?30D8,D3,A0?:,9>B0=>4847,=
<@0>?4:9>;:>0/-D-:?3?30:A0=9809?,9/-D;=4A,?0;,=?40>I08!;'.?4:9
6?,?<@:?4927024>7,?4A034>?:=D:1F 2?B:@7/;=05@/4.0?30"7,49?411>41
?30DB0=0?:-0=0<@4=0/?:;=:.00/:9?30>,80?4801=,80,>!J>>0;,=,?0,.?4:9/0>;4?0,

Page 5 PageID#
>0;,=,?07D:=/0=0/>.30/@70,7=0,/D0>?,-74>30/49?30.?4:9B34.3>.30/@70/:0>9:?
=0<@4=0?30"7,49?411>?:?,60,9D/0;:>4?4:9>:1::270,?,9D;,=?4.@7,=?48070?,7:90
;=4:=?:3,A492,1,4=:;;:=?@94?D?:09>@=0?3,?::2703,>;=:/@.0/?30B=4??09/4>.:A0=D
90.0>>,=D?:1,4=7D.:9/@.?>@.3/0;:>4?4:9>

$49.0=07D
>"3474;:=:7:2:>

"3474;:=:7:2:>
:;DA4,08,47?::@9>0749?30.?4:9


Issues	Laws	Cases	Pro	Articles	Firms	Entities