Name: Paul H. Melbostad v. Donald G Fisher et al :: Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco :: State Civil Lawsuit No. CGC-05-447978, Judge Ronald E. Quidachay presiding
Creator: Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco
Published: 2005-12-23
License: https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/
Keywords: court documents, legal case, docket, PACER, Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco

Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription.

117	Filed: 1/20/2009, Entered: 1/20/2009	Satisfaction of Judgment
	Satisfaction Of Judgment, Fully Satisfied, Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin As To Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

116	Filed: 11/18/2008, Entered: 11/18/2008
	Second Notice Of Stay Of State Court Proceedings Pursuant To Pltf's Filing Of Voluntary Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Petition Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

115	Filed: 11/18/2008, Entered: 11/18/2008
	Pos: Second Notice Of Stay Of State Court Proceedings Pursuant To Pltf's Filing Of Voluntary Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

114	Filed: 10/24/2008, Entered: 10/24/2008	Remittitur
	Remittitur Dismissed (a119514, Div. 4)
	Request

113	Filed: 8/5/2008, Entered: 8/5/2008	Order
	Order Certifying For Publication The Court's 7/23/08 Opinion A119514 #4
	Request

112	Filed: 11/14/2007, Entered: 11/14/2007	Order
	Order Directing The Parties To Address The Timeliness Of The Appeal In Their Appellate Briefing, Etal, A119514
	Request

111	Filed: 10/23/2007, Entered: 10/23/2007
	Certification Notice Issued
	Request

110	Filed: 10/23/2007, Entered: 10/23/2007
	Appeal Record Certified To The Court Of Appeal (8.124/2 Vols Rt)
	Request

109	Filed: 10/17/2007, Entered: 10/17/2007
	Stipulation Designating The Contents Of A Joint Appendix For Record On Appeal Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

108	Filed: 10/15/2007, Entered: 10/15/2007
	Proof Of Service Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

107	Filed: 10/10/2007, Entered: 10/10/2007
	1st Notice To Reporter To Prepare Transcript (m. Torreano)
	Request

106	Filed: 10/3/2007, Entered: 10/3/2007	Notice Of Election/designation Of The Record On Appeal; Amended
	Notice Of Election/designation Of The Record On Appeal; Amended Designation Of Clerk's And Reporter's Trancripts (8.124) Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

105	Filed: 10/2/2007, Entered: 10/2/2007
	Clerk's Ntc Of Filing Of Ntc Of Appeal
	Request

104	Filed: 9/28/2007, Entered: 9/28/2007	Request For Clerks/reporter Transcript
	Request For Clerk's/reporter's Transcript Filed
	Request

103	Filed: 9/28/2007, Entered: 9/28/2007	Notice Of Appeal/request For Transcript
	Notice Of Appeal/request For Transcript Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

102	Filed: 8/2/2007, Entered: 8/2/2007
	Notice Of Entry Of Judgment
	Request

101	Filed: 8/1/2007, Entered: 8/1/2007	Judgment For Defendant
	The Court Ordered The Following Judgment Entered: It Is Adjudged That Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public Take Nothing From Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin On The Complaint, Said Defendant To Have Judgment Thereon For $148,044.25 Costs, Total Judgment $148,044.25, See Scanned Document (no Copies Provided, No Sase)


100	Filed: 6/13/2007, Entered: 6/13/2007
	Mini-minutes For Jun-13-2007 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

99	Filed: 6/13/2007, Entered: 6/13/2007
	Pos: Notice Of Ruling Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin As To Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

98	Filed: 6/13/2007, Entered: 6/13/2007
	Notice Of Entry Of Order/notice Of Ruling Filed Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

97	Filed: 6/13/2007, Entered: 6/13/2007	Order
	Order Granting Motion For Attorneys Fees And Costs
	Request

96	Filed: 6/13/2007, Entered: 6/13/2007
	Law And Motion 302, Defendant Donald Fisher's Motion For Attorney's Fees And Costs. Argued And The Court Adopted And Modified Its Tentative Ruling: Granted. - The Decisions In Ketchum V. Moses (2001) 24 Cal.4th 1122, 1131; Rosenaur V. Superior Court (2001) 88 Cal.app.4th 260, 287 And Ramona Unified School District V. Tsiknas (2005) 135 Cal.app.4th 510, 523 Through 525 Establish Fisher's Right To Recover Attorneys' Fees And Costs. - Lodestar Is The Appropriate Method To Determine The Fees To Be Awarded (ketchum At 1139), Meaning A Calculation Of The Number Of Hours Reasonably Worked Multiplied By The Reasonable Hourly Rate. Flannery V. Prentice (2001) 26 Cal.4th 572, 584. There Is No Legal Or Factual Basis To Allocate The Fees And Costs Among The Prevailing Defendants. (ramona Unified School District Supra At 525) - Recoverable Fees Include Fees Incurred In Enforcing The Right To Mandatory Fees. (ketchum Supra At 1133-34) - Fees And Costs Awarded Of $148,044.25 To Account For Possible Duplication And Inefficiency. The Court Denied The Renewed Request For Discovery By Attorney Melbostad. The Court Granted The Request To Strike The Purported Fisher Declaration. Order Signed In Open Court. Judge: Patrick J. Mahoney, Reporter: Maria Torreano, Csr #8600
	Request

95	Filed: 6/8/2007, Entered: 6/8/2007
	Objection Ot Admission Into Evidence Of Purported Declaration Of Donald G. Fisher Attached To Supplemental Declaration Of James R. Sutton In Support Of Application For Attorneys Fees And Costs Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

94	Filed: 6/6/2007, Entered: 6/6/2007
	Reply To Oppositiion To Application For A Attorneys Fees And Costs By Donald G. Fisher; Proof Of Service Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

93	Filed: 6/6/2007, Entered: 6/6/2007
	Declaration Of (supplemental) James R. Sutton In Support Of Application For Attorneys Fees And Costs By Donald G. Fisher Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

92	Filed: 6/6/2007, Entered: 6/6/2007
	Supplemental Request For Judicila Notice By Donald G. Fisher Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

91	Filed: 6/4/2007, Entered: 6/4/2007
	Notice Of Entry Of Order/notice Of Ruling Filed Grantig Motion For Protective Order Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

90	Filed: 6/1/2007, Entered: 6/1/2007
	Declaration Of Anthony Saab In Opposition To Application Fo9r Attorneys Fees And Costs By Donald Fisher Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

89	Filed: 6/1/2007, Entered: 6/1/2007
	Memorandum Of P&a In Opposition To Application For Attorneys Fees And Costs By Donald Fisher Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

88	Filed: 6/1/2007, Entered: 6/1/2007
	Declaration Of Paul H. Melbostad In Opposition To Application For Attorney Fees And Costs By Donald Fisher Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

87	Filed: 5/25/2007, Entered: 5/25/2007	Order
	Order Granting Defendants' Motion For Protective Order
	Request

86	Filed: 5/23/2007, Entered: 5/23/2007
	Law And Motion 302, Defendants Donald Fisher, James Sutton, Kevin Heneghan's Motion In Support Of Application For Attorneys Fees Continued From May-31-2007 To Law And Motion At Jun-13-2007, 9:30 Am In Dept. 302, Per Agreement Of Parties.
	Request

85	Filed: 5/16/2007, Entered: 5/16/2007
	Mini-minutes For May-16-2007 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

84	Filed: 5/16/2007, Entered: 5/16/2007
	Law And Motion 302, Defendants Donald Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan's Re-notice Of Motion For Protective Order. Argued And The Court Adopts And Modifies Its Tentative Ruling. The Motion For Protective Order Is Granted Without Prejudice For The Plaintiff To Seek Further Discovery. Prevailing Party Is To Submit A Form Of Order Approved As To Form. Judge: Patrick J. Mahoney, Reporter: Maria Torreano, Csr #8600
	Request

83	Filed: 5/16/2007, Entered: 5/16/2007
	Law And Motion, 302, Defendants Donald Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan's Motion For Protective Order - Off Calendar. Duplicate Entry. Judge: Patrick J. Mahoney, Reporter: Maria Torreano, Csr #8600
	Request

82	Filed: 5/16/2007, Entered: 5/16/2007
	Mini-minutes For May-16-2007 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

81	Filed: 5/9/2007, Entered: 5/9/2007
	Re-notice Of Motion And Motion In Supporet Of Defts' Motion For Protective Order, Proof Of Service Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin Hearing Set For May-16-2007 At 09:30 Am In Dept 302
	Request

80	Filed: 5/9/2007, Entered: 5/9/2007
	Discovery 610, Defendant Donal Fisher's Motion For Protective Order Continued From May-09-2007 To Law And Motion At May-16-2007, 9:30 Am In Dept. 302. Both Commissioners Bruce Chan And Everett Hewlett Have Recused. Commissioner: Bruce E. Chan.
	Request

79	Filed: 5/9/2007, Entered: 5/9/2007
	Mini-minutes For May-09-2007 9:00 Am For Dept 610
	Request

78	Filed: 5/7/2007, Entered: 5/7/2007
	Objection To Admission Into Evidence Of Purported Declaration Of Donald G. Fisher In Support Of Df's Motion For Protective Order Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

77	Filed: 5/2/2007, Entered: 5/2/2007
	Reply To Opposition To Motion For Protective Order Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

76	Filed: 5/2/2007, Entered: 5/2/2007
	Proof Of Service Of Reply To Opposition To Motion For Protective Order, Request For Judicial Notice, Declarations Of Donald J. Fisher And James R. Sutton Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin Served May-02-2007, Personal Service On Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

75	Filed: 5/2/2007, Entered: 5/2/2007
	Request For Judicial Notice Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

74	Filed: 5/2/2007, Entered: 5/2/2007
	Declaration Of James R. Sutton In Support Of Motion For Protective Order Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

73	Filed: 5/2/2007, Entered: 5/2/2007
	Declaration Of Donald G. Fisher In Support Of Motion For Protective Order Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

72	Filed: 4/26/2007, Entered: 4/26/2007
	Declaration Of Paul H Melbostad In Oppos. To Mtn For Protective Order Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

71	Filed: 4/26/2007, Entered: 4/26/2007
	Memorandum Of Points And Authorities In Oppos. To Deft's Mtn For Protective Order Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

70	Filed: 4/26/2007, Entered: 4/26/2007
	Declaration Of Anthony Saab In Oppos. To Deft's Mtn For Protective Order Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

69	Filed: 4/19/2007, Entered: 4/19/2007
	Notice Of Unavailability Of Melbostad Paul H On May-04-2007 Through May-07-2007 ; May 25, 2007 Through May 29, 2907 And From July 2, 2007 Through July 6, 2007 Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

68	Filed: 4/19/2007, Entered: 4/19/2007
	Law And Motion 302, Ntc Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Application For Attys Fees Continued From Apr-26-2007 To Law And Motion At May-31-2007, 9:30 Am In Dept. 302 Per Request Of Moving Parties Donald Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan.
	Request

67	Filed: 4/16/2007, Entered: 4/16/2007
	Ntc Of Mtn And Mtn In Support Of Mtn For Protective Order, Proof Of Service, Points And Authorities, Declaration Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin Hearing Set For May-09-2007 At 09:00 Am In Dept 610
	Request

66	Filed: 4/9/2007, Entered: 4/9/2007
	Ex Parte Application For Order To Continue Hearing And Briefing Deadlines On Deft's Application For Atorneys Fees And Costs, Points And Authorities, Declaration Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

65	Filed: 4/2/2007, Entered: 4/2/2007
	Request For Judicial Notice Filed By Defts
	Request

64	Filed: 4/2/2007, Entered: 4/2/2007
	Ntc Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Application For Attys Fees, Proof Of Service, Points And Authorities, Declaration Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin Hearing Set For Apr-26-2007 At 09:30 Am In Dept 302
	Request

63	Filed: 10/13/2006, Entered: 10/13/2006
	Pos: Notice Of Stay Of State Court Proceedings Pursuant To Pltf's Filing Of Voluntary Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Petition Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

62	Filed: 10/13/2006, Entered: 10/13/2006
	Notice Of Stay Of Proceedings Regarding Bankruptcy
	Request

61	Filed: 10/11/2006, Entered: 10/11/2006	Order That Hearing Is Off Calendar
	Case Management Conference Of Oct-20-2006 Is Off Calendar, Complaint Stricken. Notice Sent By Court.
	Request

60	Filed: 9/27/2006, Entered: 9/27/2006
	Notice Of Entry Of Order/notice Of Ruling Filed Granting Defts Anti-slapp Motion To Strike; Pos; Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

59	Filed: 9/8/2006, Entered: 9/8/2006	Order
	Order Granting Defendants' Anti-slapp Motion To Strike.
	Request

58	Filed: 8/8/2006, Entered: 8/8/2006	Order Continuing Case Management Conference
	Case Management Conference Of Aug-18-2006 Continued To Oct-20-2006 At 9:00 Am In Dept. 212. Notice Sent By Court.
	Request

57	Filed: 6/26/2006, Entered: 6/26/2006	Order Continuing Case Management Conference
	Case Management Conference Of Jul-07-2006 Continued To Aug-18-2006 At 9:00 Am In Dept. 212. Notice Sent By Court.
	Request

56	Filed: 6/16/2006, Entered: 6/16/2006
	Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration, On Court's Own Motion, Granted.
	Request

55	Filed: 6/16/2006, Entered: 6/16/2006
	Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion To Recuse, On Court's Own Motion, Granted.
	Request

54	Filed: 6/16/2006, Entered: 6/16/2006	Order
	Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion For Reconsideration And Motion For Recusal.
	Request

53	Filed: 6/14/2006, Entered: 6/14/2006
	Case Management Statement Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public Jury Demanded, Estimated Time For Trial: 5.0 Days
	Request

52	Filed: 6/13/2006, Entered: 6/13/2006
	Law And Motion, 302, Rre-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration. Argued And The Court Took The Matter Under Submission. Parties To Submit Respective Orders. (302/req/pb) Beldon Yee # 2647
	Request

51	Filed: 6/13/2006, Entered: 6/13/2006
	Law And Motion, 302, Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion To Recuse. Argued And The Court Took The Matter Under Submission. Parties To Submit Respective Orders. (302/req/pb) Beldon Yee # 2647
	Request

50	Filed: 6/13/2006, Entered: 6/13/2006
	Mini-minutes For Jun-13-2006 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

49	Filed: 6/13/2006, Entered: 6/13/2006
	Mini-minutes For Jun-13-2006 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

48	Filed: 6/12/2006, Entered: 6/12/2006
	Declaration Of Paul H. Melvbostad For Rehearing Of Motion For Reconsideration Of Order Granting Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Motion To Disqualify Jordanna Thigpen From Participation In This Matter Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

47	Filed: 6/9/2006, Entered: 6/9/2006
	Notice Of Unavailability Of Melbostad Paul H On Jun-29-2006 Through Jul-05-2006 And 8/1 To 8/4/06 Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

46	Filed: 6/1/2006, Entered: 6/1/2006
	Added To Calendar For Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration, On Court's Own Motion Hearing Set For Jun-13-2006 At 09:30 Am In Dept 302
	Request

45	Filed: 6/1/2006, Entered: 6/1/2006
	Added To Calendar For Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion To Recuse, On Court's Own Motion Hearing Set For Jun-13-2006 At 09:30 Am In Dept 302
	Request

44	Filed: 5/31/2006, Entered: 5/31/2006
	Law And Motion 302, Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration Of Order Granting Special Motion To Strike Complaint An Request For Attorney's Fees By Defendants. Argued And The Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling - Motion For Reconsideration Is Denied. Prevailing Party To Prepare Order. Judge: Ronald E. Quidachay. Reporter: Beldon Yee, Csr #2647
	Request

43	Filed: 5/31/2006, Entered: 5/31/2006
	Law And Motion 302, Plaintiff Paul Melbostad Motion For Order That Jordana Thigpen Be Recused From Participation In Court's Consideration Of Any Matters In This Action. Argued And The Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling - Denied. Ms. Thigpen Was Not The Research Counsel Who Prepared Bench Memo Re Underlying Motion. Prevailing Party To Prepare Order. Judge: Ronald E. Quidachay. Reporter: Beldon Yee, Csr #2647
	Request

42	Filed: 5/31/2006, Entered: 5/31/2006
	Mini-minutes For May-31-2006 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

41	Filed: 5/31/2006, Entered: 5/31/2006
	Mini-minutes For May-31-2006 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

40	Filed: 5/23/2006, Entered: 5/23/2006
	Reply Re Motion For Reconsideration Of Order Granting Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys Fees By Defts Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

39	Filed: 5/23/2006, Entered: 5/23/2006
	Reply Re Motion For Order That Jordanna Thigpen Be Recused From Participation In Court's Consideration Of Any Matters In This Action Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

38	Filed: 5/23/2006, Entered: 5/23/2006
	Declaration Of Paul H. Melbostad In Support Of Replied Regarding Motion For Reconsideration Of Order Granting Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Motion To Disqualify Jordanna Thigpen From Participation In This Matter Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

37	Filed: 5/19/2006, Entered: 5/19/2006	Order Continuing Case Management Conference
	Case Management Conference Of May-26-2006 Continued To Jul-07-2006 At 9:00 Am In Dept. 212,. Notice Sent By Court.
	Request

36	Filed: 5/17/2006, Entered: 5/17/2006
	Pos On Oppos. To Mtn For Reconsideration; Oppos To Mtn To Recuse Jordanna Thigpen; Dec.'s Of James R. Sutton And Ion B. Meyn And Req. For Judicial Ntc Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

35	Filed: 5/17/2006, Entered: 5/17/2006
	Req. For Judicial Ntc Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

34	Filed: 5/17/2006, Entered: 5/17/2006
	Declaration Of James R. Sutton In Support Of Oppos. To Mtn For Reconsideration Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

33	Filed: 5/17/2006, Entered: 5/17/2006
	Declaration Of Ion B. Meyn In Support Of Oppos. To Mtn For Reconsideration Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

32	Filed: 5/17/2006, Entered: 5/17/2006
	Opposition To Mtn To Recuse Jordanna Thigpen Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

31	Filed: 5/17/2006, Entered: 5/17/2006
	Opposition To Mtn For Reconsideration Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

30	Filed: 5/11/2006, Entered: 5/11/2006
	Case Management Statement Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public Jury Demanded, Estimated Time For Trial: 5.0 Days
	Request

29	Filed: 5/1/2006, Entered: 5/1/2006
	Mtn For Reconsideration Of Order Granting Special Mtn To Strike Complt & Req For Atty's Fees By Defts; Req For Judicial Ntc, Proof Of Service, Points And Authorities, Declaration Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public Hearing Set For May-31-2006 At 09:30 Am In Dept 302
	Request

28	Filed: 5/1/2006, Entered: 5/1/2006
	Mtn For Order That Jordana Thigpen Be Recused From Participation In Ct's Consideration Of Any Matters In This Action, Proof Of Service, Points And Authorities Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public Hearing Set For May-31-2006 At 09:30 Am In Dept 302
	Request

27	Filed: 4/20/2006, Entered: 4/20/2006
	Notice Of Entry Of Order/notice Of Ruling Filed Granting Special Mtn To Strike Complaint And Req. For Attorney's Fee Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

26	Filed: 4/18/2006, Entered: 4/18/2006
	Defendants Donald Fisher, Et Al Motion To Strike All Prayers For Monetary Damages And / Or Penalties In Complaint Granted.
	Request

25	Filed: 4/18/2006, Entered: 4/18/2006
	Defendants James R. Sutton, Kevin Heneghan And Donald Fisher's Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees, Granted.
	Request

24	Filed: 4/18/2006, Entered: 4/18/2006	Order
	Order Granting Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees By Defendants


23	Filed: 4/5/2006, Entered: 4/5/2006
	Summons On Complaint, Proof Of Service Only, Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public Served Dec-28-2005, Personal Service On Defendant Fisher, Donald G
	Request

22	Filed: 4/5/2006, Entered: 4/5/2006
	Summons On Complaint, Proof Of Service Only, Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public Served Dec-24-2005, Personal Service On Defendant Sutton, James R.
	Request

21	Filed: 4/5/2006, Entered: 4/5/2006
	Summons On Complaint, Proof Of Service Only, Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public Served Dec-28-2005, Personal Service On Defendant Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

20	Filed: 4/5/2006, Entered: 4/5/2006
	Pos Of Ntc Of Unavailability Filed By Pltf
	Request

19	Filed: 2/17/2006, Entered: 2/17/2006
	Mini-minutes For Feb-17-2006 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

18	Filed: 2/17/2006, Entered: 2/17/2006
	Mini-minutes For Feb-17-2006 9:30 Am For Dept 302
	Request

Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription.

17	Filed: 2/17/2006, Entered: 2/17/2006
	Law And Motion, 302, Defendants Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Heneghan's Motion To Strike All Prayers For Monetary Damages And/or Penalties In Complaint. Argued And The Court Took The Matter Under Submission. After Further Review, The Court May Ask Counsel To Submit Proposed Order(s). (302/req/jt) Judge: Ronald E. Quidachay, Reporter: Beldon Yee, Csr #2647
	Request

16	Filed: 2/17/2006, Entered: 2/17/2006
	Law And Motion, 302, Defendants Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Heneghan's Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees. Argued And The Court Took The Matter Under Submission. After Further Review, The Court May Ask Counsel To Submit Proposed Order(s). (302/req/jt) Judge: Ronald E. Quidachay, Reporter: Beldon Yee, Csr #2647
	Request

15	Filed: 2/9/2006, Entered: 2/9/2006
	Pos Of Reply To Oppositon Of Special Motion To Strike Complaint; Supplemental Request For Jusdical Notice; Supplemental Seclaration Of James R. Sutton; Reply To Opposition To Motion To Strike Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

14	Filed: 2/9/2006, Entered: 2/9/2006
	Supplemental Request For Judicial Notice By Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Heneghan Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

13	Filed: 2/9/2006, Entered: 2/9/2006
	Declaration (supplemental) Of James R. Sutton In Support Of Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees By Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Heneghan Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

12	Filed: 2/9/2006, Entered: 2/9/2006
	Reply To Opposition To Motion To Strike All Prayers For Monetary Damages And/or Penalties In Complaint By Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Henegan Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

11	Filed: 2/9/2006, Entered: 2/9/2006
	Reply To Opposition To Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees By Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Heneghan Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin
	Request

10	Filed: 2/3/2006, Entered: 2/3/2006
	Opposition To Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees By Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Heneghan Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

9	Filed: 2/3/2006, Entered: 2/3/2006
	Declaration Of Paul H. Melbostad In Opposition To Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys Fees Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

8	Filed: 2/3/2006, Entered: 2/3/2006
	Request For Judicial Notice Of Admissions Binding On Defendants In Previously Filed Declarations Of Thomas Hsieh, Jr. Offered In Opposition To Defendants Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys Fees Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

7	Filed: 2/3/2006, Entered: 2/3/2006
	Opposition To Motion To Strike All Prayers For Monetary Damages And/or Penalties In Complaint By Defendants Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

6	Filed: 1/23/2006, Entered: 1/23/2006
	Notice Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Motion To Strike All Prayers For Monetary Damages And / Or Penalties In Complaint, Request For Judicial Notice, Proof Of Service, Points And Authorities Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin Hearing Set For Feb-17-2006 At 09:30 Am In Dept 302
	Request

5	Filed: 1/23/2006, Entered: 1/23/2006
	Notice Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees, Proof Of Service, Points And Authorities, Declaration Filed By Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin Hearing Set For Feb-17-2006 At 09:30 Am In Dept 302
	Request

4	Filed: 12/27/2005, Entered: 12/27/2005
	Peremptory Challenge Of The Honorable Curtis E.a. Karnow Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

3	Filed: 12/27/2005, Entered: 12/27/2005
	Notice Of Unavailability Of Melbostad Paul H On Jan-09-2006 Through Jan-20-2006 Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public
	Request

2	Filed: 12/23/2005, Entered: 12/23/2005	Notice To Plaintiff
	Notice To Plaintiff
	Request

1	Filed: 12/23/2005, Entered: 12/23/2005	Complaint
	Other Non Exempt Complaints, Complaint Filed By Plaintiff Melbostad, Paul H. A Voter On Behalf Of Public As To Defendant Fisher, Donald G Sutton, James R. Heneghan, Kevin Does 1 To 50, Inclusive Summons Issued, Judicial Council Civil Case Cover Sheet Filed Case Management Conference Scheduled For May-26-2006 Proof Of Service Due On Feb-21-2006 Case Management Statement Due On May-11-2006

	Date: 6/13/2007, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
	Ntc Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Application For Attys Fees Off Calendar Jun-13-2007 Text Ruling Tentative Ruling: Set For Hearing On Wednesday, June 13, 2007, Line 3. Defendants Donald Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan's Motion In Support Of Application For Attorney's Fees Is Granted. - The Decisions In Ketchum V. Moses (2001) 24 Cal.4th 1122, 1131; Rosenaur V. Superior Court (2001) 88 Cal.app.4th 260, 287 And Ramona Unified School District V. Tsiknas (2005) 135 Cal.app.4th 510, 523 Through 525 Establish Fisher's Right To Recover Attorneys' Fees And Costs. - Lodestar Is The Appropriate Method To Determine The Fees To Be Awarded (ketchum At 1139), Meaning A Calculation Of The Number Of Hours Reasonably Worked Multiplied By The Reasonable Hourly Rate. Flannery V. Prentice (2001) 26 Cal.4th 572, 584. There Is No Legal Or Factual Basis To Allocate The Fees And Costs Among The Prevailing Defendants. (ramona Unified School District Supra At 525) - Recoverable Fees Include Fees Incurred In Enforcing The Right To Mandatory Fees. (ketchum Supra At 1133-34) - Fees And Costs Awarded Of $148,044.25 To Account For Possible Duplication And Inefficiency. =(302/pjm/kd) Mini Minutes: Defendant Donald Fisher's Motion For Attorney's Fees And Costs. Appearances: Paul H. Melbostad, Esquire (goldstein, Gellman, Melbostad, Gibson & Harris, Llp, 415.673.5600) Appearing For Plaintiff In Pro Per As Voter On Behalf Of Public. James R. Sutton, Esquire And Gabe Camarillo, Esquire (the Sutton Law Firm, 415.732.7700) Appearing For Defendant Donald Fisher. Ruling: Argued And The Court Adopted And Modified Its Tentative Ruling: Granted. - The Decisions In Ketchum V. Moses (2001) 24 Cal.4th 1122, 1131; Rosenaur V. Superior Court (2001) 88 Cal.app.4th 260, 287 And Ramona Unified School District V. Tsiknas (2005) 135 Cal.app.4th 510, 523 Through 525 Establish Fisher's Right To Recover Attorneys' Fees And Costs. - Lodestar Is The Appropriate Method To Determine The Fees To Be Awarded (ketchum At 1139), Meaning A Calculation Of The Number Of Hours Reasonably Worked Multiplied By The Reasonable Hourly Rate. Flannery V. Prentice (2001) 26 Cal.4th 572, 584. There Is No Legal Or Factual Basis To Allocate The Fees And Costs Among The Prevailing Defendants. (ramona Unified School District Supra At 525) - Recoverable Fees Include Fees Incurred In Enforcing The Right To Mandatory Fees. (ketchum Supra At 1133-34) - Fees And Costs Awarded Of $148,044.25 To Account For Possible Duplication And Inefficiency. The Court Denied The Renewed Request For Discovery By Attorney Melbostad. The Court Granted The Request To Strike The Purported Fisher Declaration. Order Signed In Open Court. Judge: Patrick J. Mahoney, Reporter: Maria Torreano, Csr 8600 (302/pjm/kd)

	Date: 5/31/2007, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
	Ntc Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Application For Attys Fees Off Calendar May-23-2007 Continued To Jun-13-07 At 09:30 A.m. In Dept 302

	Date: 5/16/2007, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
	Ntc Of Mtn And Mtn In Support Of Mtn For Protective Order Off Calendar May-16-2007 Off Calendar Tentative Ruling: Set For Hearing On Wednesday, May 16, 2007, Line 6. Defendants Donald Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan's Motion For Protective Order Is Off Calendar. Duplicate Entry. =(302/pjm) Mini Minutes: Defendants Donald Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan's Motion For Protective Order. No Appearances On This Matter. Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling: Off Calendar. Duplicate Entry. (302/pjm) Judge: Patrick J. Mahoney, Reporter: Maria Torreano, Csr #8600 Re-notice Of Motion And Motion In Supporet Of Defts' Motion For Protective Order Off Calendar May-16-2007 Text Ruling Tentative Ruling: Set For Hearing On Wednesday, May 16, 2007, Line 6. Defendants Donald Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan's Re-notice Of Motion For Protective Order Is Granted For The Reasons Set Forth In Defendant's Proposed Order With One Additional Observation. The Actual Time Recorded Is Relevant To But Not Determinative Of A Reasonable Fee Award. At This Point, Plaintiff Has Failed To Demonstrate That A Deposition On This Subject Is Necessary To Address The Merits Of The Fee Motion. =(302/pjm/kd) Mini Minutes: Defendants Donald Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan's Re-notice Of Motion For Protective Order. Appearances: Paul H. Melbostad, Esquire (goldstein, Gellman, Melbostad, Gibson & Harris, Llp, 415.673.5600) Appearing For Plaintiff. James R. Sutton, Esquire And Gabe Camarillo, Esquire (the Sutton Law Firm, 415.732.7700) Appearing For Defendants. Argued And The Court Adopts And Modifies Its Tentative Ruling. The Motion For Protective Order Is Granted Without Prejudice For The Plaintiff To Seek Further Discovery. Prevailing Party Is To Submit A Form Of Order Approved It As To Form. (302/pjm/kd) Judge: Patrick J. Mahoney, Reporter: Maria Torreano, Csr #8600

	Date: 5/9/2007, Time: 09:00:00, Status: None
	Ntc Of Mtn And Mtn In Support Of Mtn For Protective Order Off Calendar May-09-2007 Continued To May-16-07 At 09:30 A.m. In Dept 302 Tentative Ruling: Matter On Calendar For Wednesday, May 9, 2007. Defendant Donald Fisher's Motion For A Protective Order Is Granted. The Request For Monetary Sanctions Is Denied. = (bec/610) Mini Minutes: Appearances: Gabe Camarillo, Esq., For Defendant And Moving Party: Donal Fisher, James Sutton And Kevin Heneghan Paul H. Melbostad, J.d. M.b.a. Plaintiff And Opposing Party In Propria Persona After Hearing, Tentative Ruling Is Vacated And Defendant Donald Fisher's Motion For A Protective Order Is Transferred To Department 302. Both Commissioners Bruce Chan And Everett Hewlett Have Recused. The Motion Is Continued To May 16, 2007 At 9:30 A.m. In Dept. 302. Commissioner: Bruce E. Chan.

	Date: 4/26/2007, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
	Ntc Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Application For Attys Fees Off Calendar Apr-19-2007 Continued To May-31-07 At 09:30 A.m. In Dept 302

	Date: 10/20/2006, Time: 09:00:00, Status: None
	Case Management Conference Off Calendar Oct-11-2006 Off Calendar

	Date: 8/18/2006, Time: 09:00:00, Status: None
	Case Management Conference Off Calendar Aug-08-2006 Continued To Oct-20-06 At 09:00 A.m. In Dept 212

	Date: 7/7/2006, Time: 09:00:00, Status: None
	Case Management Conference Off Calendar Jun-26-2006 Continued To Aug-18-06 At 09:00 A.m. In Dept 212

	Date: 6/13/2006, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
	Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration, On Court's Own Motion Off Calendar Jun-16-2006 Granted Per Written Order Tentative Ruling: Set For Hearing On June 13, 2006 Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration, On Court's Own Motion, Hearing Is Required. =(302/req/pb) Mini Minutes: Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration Appearances: Paul H. Melbostad, Esq. 415/ 673-5600( Plaintiff In Pro Per)-mp Ion Meyn, Esq. 415/ 732-7700 For Defendant-op James R. Sutton,esq. 415/ 73-7701 For Defendant-op Ruling; Argued And The Court Took The Matter Under Submission. Parties To Submit Respective Orders. =(302/req/pb) Beldon Yee # 2647 Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion To Recuse, On Court's Own Motion Off Calendar Jun-16-2006 Granted Per Written Order Tentative Ruling: Set For Hearing On June 13, 2006 Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion To Recuse, On Court's Own Motion, Hearing Is Required. =(302/req/pb) Mini Minutes: Re-hearing On Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion To Recuse Appearances: Paul H. Melbostad, Esq. 415/ 673-5600( Plaintiff In Pro Per)-mp Ion Meyn, Esq. 415/ 732-7700 For Defendant-op James R. Sutton,esq. 415/ 73-7701 For Defendant-op Ruling; Argued And The Court Took The Matter Under Submission. Parties To Submit Respective Orders. =(302/req/pb) Beldon Yee # 2647

	Date: 5/31/2006, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
	Mtn For Reconsideration Of Order Granting Special Mtn To Strike Complt & Req For Atty's Fees By Defts; Req For Judicial Ntc Off Calendar May-31-2006 Text Ruling Tentative Ruling: Set For Hearing On May 31, 2006 Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration Is Denied. =(302/req/pb) Mini Minutes: Plaintiff Paul Melbostad's Motion For Reconsideration Of Order Granting Special Motion To Strike Complaint An Request For Attorney's Fees By Defendants, Request For Judicial Notice Appearances:paul H. Melbostad, Esq. 415/673-5600 For Plaintiff-mp James R. Sutton, Esq. 415/732-7700 For Defendant-op Ion Meyn, Esq. 415/732-7700 For Defendant-op Ruling; Argued And The Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling Motion For Reconsideration Is Denied. Prevailing Party To Prepare Order. =(302/req/pb)beldon Yee # 2647 Mtn For Order That Jordana Thigpen Be Recused From Participation In Ct's Consideration Of Any Matters In This Action Off Calendar May-31-2006 Text Ruling Tentative Ruling: Set For Hearing On May 31, 2006 Plaintiff Paul Melbostad Motion For Order That Jordana Thigpen Be Recused From Participation In Court's Consideration Of Any Matters In This Action Is Denied. Ms. Thigpen Was Not The Research Counsel Who Prepared Bench Memo Re Underlying Motion. =(302/req/pb) Mini Minutes: Plaintiff Paul Melbostad Motion For Order That Jordana Thigpen Be Recused From Participation In Court's Consideration Of Any Matters In This Action Appearances:paul H. Melbostad, Esq. 415/673-5600 For Plaintiff-mp James R. Sutton, Esq. 415/732-7700 For Defendant-op Ion Meyn, Esq. 415/732-7700 For Defendant-op Ruling; Argued And The Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling Denied. Ms. Thigpen Was Not The Research Counsel Who Prepared Bench Memo Re Underlying Motion. Prevailing Party To Prepare Order. =(302/req/pb) Beldon Yee # 2647

	Date: 5/26/2006, Time: 09:00:00, Status: None
	Case Management Conference Off Calendar May-19-2006 Continued To Jul-07-06 At 09:00 A.m. In Dept 212

	Date: 2/17/2006, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
	Notice Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Motion To Strike All Prayers For Monetary Damages And / Or Penalties In Complaint, Request For Judicial Notice Off Calendar Apr-18-2006 Granted Per Written Order Tentative Ruling: Hearing Required. (302/req/jt) Mini Minutes: Defendants Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Heneghan's Motion To Strike All Prayers For Monetary Damages And/or Penalties In Complaint. Appearance: Paul H. Melbostad, Esq. Of Goldstein, Gellman, Melbostad, Gibson & Harris, Llp 673-5600, "a Voter, On Behalf Of The Public, In Pro Per" & Opposing Party; James R. Sutton, Esq. & Ion B. Meyn, Esq. Of The Sutton Law Firm 732-7700 For Defts & Moving Parties. Ruling: Argued And The Court Took The Matter Under Submission. After Further Review, The Court May Ask Counsel To Submit Proposed Order(s). (302/req/jt) Judge: Ronald E. Quidachay, Reporter: Beldon Yee, Csr #2647 Notice Of Motion And Motion In Support Of Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees Off Calendar Apr-18-2006 Granted Per Written Order Tentative Ruling: Hearing Required. (302/req/jt) Mini Minutes: Defendants Donald G. Fisher, James R. Sutton, And Kevin R. Heneghan's Special Motion To Strike Complaint And Request For Attorneys' Fees. Appearance: Paul H. Melbostad, Esq. Of Goldstein, Gellman, Melbostad, Gibson & Harris, Llp 673-5600, "a Voter, On Behalf Of The Public, In Pro Per" & Opposing Party; James R. Sutton, Esq. & Ion B. Meyn, Esq. Of The Sutton Law Firm 732-7700 For Defts & Moving Parties. Ruling: Argued And The Court Took The Matter Under Submission. After Further Review, The Court May Ask Counsel To Submit Proposed Order(s). (302/req/jt) Judge: Ronald E. Quidachay, Reporter: Beldon Yee, Csr #2647