Law And Motion, 301, Plaintiff Rural Media Arts And Education
Project's Motion For Attorneys' Fees And Expenses. Argued; The Court
Adopted Its Tentative Ruling As Follows: Plaintiff Rural Media Arts
And Education Project's Motion For Attorneys' Fees And Expenses Is
Denied. Plaintiff Has Not Shown That A Significant Benefit Has Been
Conferred On A Large Class Of People. Prevailing Party Is To Prepare A
Form Of Order. Judge: Peter J. Busch, Reporter: Carol Karen, Csr #8189
Supplemental Declaration Of Amitai Schwartz In Support Of Motion For
Attorneys' Fees And Expenses Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Reply Memorandum Of Points And Authorities In Support Of Motion For
Attorneys' Fees And Expenses Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Opposition To Motion For Attoney Fees Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Request For Judicial Notice In Support Of Opposition To Motion For
Attorneys Fees Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Appendix Of Non Ca Authorities In Support Of Opposition To Motion For
Attorneys Fees Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Declaration Of Marian E Moe In Support Of Opposition To Motion For
Attorneys Fees Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Declaration Of Susan Hildreth In Support Of Opposition To Motion For
Attorney Fees Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Ntc And Mtn For Attys' Fees And Expenses, Proof Of Service, Points And
Authorities, Declaration, Separate Statement Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Hearing Set For Nov-03-2008 At 09:30 Am In Dept 301
Notice Of Time And Place Of Trial And Mandatory Settlement Conference
Notice Of Time And Place Of Trial, Court Trial Set For Nov-17-2008 At
9:30 Am In Dept. 206.
Notice Of Mandatory Settlement Conference On Nov-03-2008 At 3:30 Pm In
Department 303. Notice Sent By Court.
Notice Of Objection To Case Management Order Setting Trial And
Mandatory Settlement Conference Dates Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Notice Of Time And Place Of Trial And Mandatory Settlement Conference
Notice Of Mandatory Settlement Conference On Aug-28-2008 At 8:30 Am In
Department 502.
Notice Of Time And Place Of Trial, Court Trial Set For Sep-15-2008 At
9:30 Am In Dept. 206. Case Management Conference On Mar-21-2008 Is Off
Calendar. Notice Sent By Court.
Case Management Statement Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Estimated Time For Trial: 1.0 Days
Answer To 1st Amended Complaint Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Notice Of Entry Of Order/notice Of Ruling Filed Filed By Respondent
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Case Management Statement Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Estimated Time For Trial: 4.0 Hours
Law And Motion 301, Demurrer To 1st Amended Complaint. Argued And The
Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling As Follows -- Defendants Susan
Hildreth, Diane Matsuda, The California State Library, The California
Cultural And Historical Endowment's Demurrer To 1st Amended Complaint
Is Sustained Without Leave To Amend As To Causes Of Action 1-3 For
Failure To State A Cause Of Action. Overruled As To Cause Of Action 6.
Prevailing Party To Submit Form Of Order. Judge: Paul H. Alvarado,
Reporter: Lavena Ward, Csr # 7077
Law And Motion 301, Defendants Susan Hildreth, Diane Matsuda, The
California State Library, The California Cultural And Historical
Endowment's Demurrer To First Amended Complaint Is Continued To
12/17/07 On The Court's Own Motion. Judge: Paul H. Alvarado, Reporter:
Carol Karen Csr # 8189.
Reply To Opposition To Demurrer To Rmaep's First Amended Complaint
Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Opposition To Defts Demurrer To The First, Second, Third, And Sixth
Causes Of Action In The First Amended Complaint Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Demurrer To 1st Amended Complaint, Proof Of Service, Points And
Authorities, Declaration Ntc Of Hearing On Demrrer And Demurrer;
Request For Judicial Ntc Filed By Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Hearing Set For Dec-12-2007 At 09:30 Am In Dept 301
1st Amended Complaint Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
As To Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Does 1-10, Inclusive
Summons On Complaint, Proof Of Service Only, Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Served Aug-30-2007, Personal Service On Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Summons On Complaint, Proof Of Service Only, Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Served Aug-30-2007, Personal Service On Defendant
The California State Library
Summons On Complaint, Proof Of Service Only, Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Served Aug-27-2007, Personal Service On Defendant
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Summons On Complaint, Proof Of Service Only, Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
Served Aug-27-2007, Personal Service On Defendant
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Declaratory Relief, Complaint Filed By Plaintiff
Rural Media Arts And Education Project, A Not For Profit
Corporation
As To Defendant
Hildreth, Susan In Her Official Capacity As Librarian Of The
State Of California
Matsuda, Diane In Her Official Capacity As Executive Officer Of
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
The California State Library
The California Cultural And Historical Endowment
Does 1-10, Inclusive
Summons Issued, Judicial Council Civil Case Cover Sheet Filed
Case Management Conference Scheduled For Jan-25-2008
Proof Of Service Due On Oct-22-2007
Case Management Statement Due On Jan-10-2008
Master Calendar Court
Off Calendar Oct-31-2008 Vacated
Date: 11/3/2008, Time: 15:30:00, Status: None
Mandatory Settlement Conference
Off Calendar Oct-31-2008 Off Calendar
Date: 11/3/2008, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
Ntc And Mtn For Attys' Fees And Expenses
Off Calendar Nov-03-2008 Denied
Mini Minutes:
Appearances- Atty. Amitai Schwartz, Tel. No. (510) 597-1775 Appearing For The Plaintiff And Moving Party;
Atty. Marian E. Moe, Deputy Attorney General, Tel. No. (916) 322-5460 Appearing For The Defendant.
Ruling - A R G U E D; The Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling As Follows:
Plaintiff Rural Media Arts And Education Project's Motion For Attorneys' Fees And Expenses Is Denied.
Plaintiff Has Not Shown That A Significant Benefit Has Been Conferred On A Large Class Of People.
Prevailing Party Is To Prepare A Form Of Order.
Judge:
Peter J. Busch,
Reporter:
Carol Karen, Csr #8189
=(301/pjb/ay)
Date: 9/15/2008, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
Master Calendar Court
Off Calendar Mar-24-2008 Set For Trial On Nov-17-08 At 09:30 A.m. In Dept 206; Settlement Conference On Nov-03-08 At 03:30 P.m. In Dept 303
Date: 8/28/2008, Time: 08:30:00, Status: None
Mandatory Settlement Conference
Off Calendar Mar-24-2008 Off Calendar
Date: 3/21/2008, Time: 09:00:00, Status: None
Case Management Conference
Off Calendar Mar-10-2008 Set For Trial On Sep-15-08 At 09:30 A.m. In Dept 206; Settlement Conference On Aug-28-08 At 08:30 A.m. In Dept 502
Date: 1/25/2008, Time: 09:00:00, Status: None
Case Management Conference
Off Calendar Jan-17-2008 Continued To Mar-21-08 At 09:00 A.m. In Dept 212
Date: 12/17/2007, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
Demurrer To 1st
Amended Complaint
Off Calendar Dec-17-2007 Sustained
Mini Minutes: Appearances:
Marian Moe, Esq., Deputy Attorney General, 916-322-5460 For Defendants And Moving Parties
Susan Hildreth, Diane Matsuda, The California State Library
Lisa Sitkin, Esq. Of Law Office Of Amitai Schwartz, 510-597-0957 For Plaintiff And Opposing Party
Rural Media Arts And Education Project
Ruling:
Argued And The Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling As Follows --
Defendant Susan Hildreth, Diane Matsuda, The California State Library, The California Cultural And Historical Endowment's Demurrer To 1st
Amended Complaint Is Sustained Without Leave To Amend To Causes Of Action 1-3 For Failure To State A Cause Of Action.
Overruled As To Cause Of Action 6.
Prevailing Party To Submit Form Of Order. Judge:
Paul H. Alvarado,
Reporter: Lavena Ward, Csr # 7077
(301/pha/lb)
Date: 12/12/2007, Time: 09:30:00, Status: None
Demurrer To 1st
Amended Complaint
Off Calendar Dec-12-2007 Continued To Dec-17-07 At 09:30 A.m. In Dept 301
Mini Minutes: No Appearances On This Matter.
The Court Adopted Its Tentative Ruling As Follows:
Defendant Susan Hildreth, Diane Matsuda, The California State Library, The California Cultural And Historical Endowment's Demurrer To 1st
Amended Complaint Is Continued To 12/17/07 On The Court's Own Motion.
Judge:
Paul H. Alvarado,
Reporter: Carol Karen Csr # 8189.
(301/pha/lb)
August 21, 2007 - Payment W1007821F010 to 
Update
Alerts
Jump