Solution :: Create a tax system that links taxes paid to government services accrued, both directly and indirectly. Perform a study by a non-partisan group of economists to establish this relationship.

Create a tax system that links taxes paid to government services accrued, both directly and indirectly. Perform a study by a non-partisan group of economists to establish this relationship.

543 Views / Posted by William Hughes

No tags have been applied so far. Sign in to add some.

Economic benefit (various types of income) is a decent surrogate for figuring out the benefits someone enjoys from government activity, but it's prone to obfuscation by the people who desire to avoid taxes.

A better solution - and one that is in principle achievable - is to see how every dollar spent by the US government (and perhaps later even state governments) benefits each taxpayer. This wouldn't require a 1-for-1 match, but it would certainly be reasonable to do within income percentile groupings (5%, 10%, whatever).

So if the government spends $1 T to maintain a $10 T GDP and guarantee the safety of $100 T in wealth (tens make head math easier), then a person who makes $1 B (1/10,000th of the economy) should pay $100 M in taxes (1/10,000th of the operating budget).

Alternatively we could figure out how much work the government does that protects property and how much protects income-generation and further subdivide tax burden that way.

It would probably be good to set some minimum threshold for these taxes, but it is also the case that poverty-abatement programs benefit those who aren't poor, so those sorts of programs could also be handled this way.

Supporter: William Hughes

Opponents: None

This issue has not been linked to a statute yet.

This issue has not been linked to any court cases yet.

This issue has not been linked to any news articles yet.

This issue has not been linked to any companies or organizations yet.

No comments have been added yet. Sign in to post a comment.

Problems

Add a Problem

13		The federal tax code is unnecessarily complicated and highly inequitable.
		The tax code's immense complexity makes it possible for the richest Americans to pay less in taxes than everyone else, thanks to expensive accountants who are in point-blank terms, tax evasion specialists. Meanwhile, average Americans, who cannot afford to set up questionably legal off-shore tax shelters, Swiss bank accounts, and industry-specific loopholes for their employers, have to struggle with a byzantine labyrinth of complex forms and procedures which are not even necessary in the first place, because the IRS can actually calculate your taxes for you.


Issues	Laws	Cases	Pro	Articles	Firms	Entities