Vote Up
Vote Down

Medical Professionals Frequently Restrict Patient Data, Even To Patients Themselves

1,819 Views / Posted by Aaron Greenspan

Share with Reddit Share with Reddit

I was once waiting on crucial test results, and a nurse refused to tell them to me over the phone even though they were my results. She insisted that HIPAA prohibited her from disclosing them over the phone, and that I would have to come to the hospital to see them--even though I was too sick to get there, which is why I needed the results. It was absolutely infuriating.

Doctors, nurses and hospitals have totally overcompensated to meet the law's requirements to the point where patients are being harmed.
Supporters: Aaron Greenspan, Jonathan Wallis, Lisa Matulevicz
Opponents: None
Section This issue has not been linked to a statute yet.
Court Cases This issue has not been linked to any court cases yet.
News This issue has not been linked to any news articles yet.
Companies and Organizations This issue has not been linked to any companies or organizations yet.
    Alex Hendler

    Alex Hendler / January 19, 2012 at 2:50 AM EST

    Please note that the following is not legal advice and should not be taken as such; it is my personal opinion and may not be applicable to your particular situation. If you need to obtain legal advice on this matter, seek the counsel of a qualified attorney who has agreed to represent you.
    The privacy-related portions of the statute and related rules are relatively straightforward (see compared to other health care statutes and regulations, but the penalties are so great that health care providers and their staff are (rightfully) scared to improperly divulge information. In many cases, they will refuse to disclose information over the phone and will only do so in person or by fax or letter.

    As an individual, a health care provider is generally required to disclose to you all of the medical information about yourself that you request, but the provider must take certain precautions to ensure that you are that individual or risk serious penalties under 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6.

    The problem is therefore not necessarily with the privacy law itself: The problem more likely lies with the advice (or lack thereof) that health care providers get or implement regarding how to apply it. One contributing factor is that health care providers are so squeezed for resources from all sides that they cannot afford to obtain or implement decent advice about how to comply with the law.

    There are, as I see it, multiple facets to this particular problem:

    1) The law is not clearly understood by those it most directly affects, even though the law is relatively straightforward on privacy issues;
    2) The affected people or entities are unable or unwilling to dedicate the human or financial resources necessary to achieve an adequate working understanding of the law for all people responsible for complying with it; and
    3) As a result, they tend be extraordinarily cautious to avoid potentially crippling civil and criminal penalties.

    Sign in to post a comment.
    Solutions Add Add a Solution
    Vote Up
    Vote Down
    Solution Simplify HIPAA.
    The law is clearly so confusing that even highly-educated medical professionals can't interpret it properly. If the Sherman Antitrust Act could be a few clauses and still effective, why can't laws be written the same way today?
    Issues Laws Cases Pro Articles Firms Entities
    Issues Laws Cases Pro Articles Firms Entities
    Sign Up
    Need Password Help?