GLOBE COTTON OIL MILLS, Petitioner, v. I. ZELLERBACH Et Al., Members of the Fish and Game Commission, Etc., Respondents

California Supreme Court, Case No. Docket No. S.F. 12323.
Filed: January 20, 1927

THE COURT.

Upon submission of the cause in open court the Chief Justice announced the decision of the court as follows:

The petitioner, owning and operating a fish reduction plant at Terminal Island, San Pedro Harbor, seeks a writ *Page 277 of mandate to compel the respondent Fish and Game Commission to set for hearing and to act on the application filed with the Commission by petitioner for a permit authorizing it to use in its plant the quantity of fish designated in the application, for the purposes therein specified. The Commission has refused to entertain jurisdiction of the application upon the ground that it is a nonjudicial body, and that to act as requested by the petitioner would be to exercise judicial functions. In assuming this position the respondent relies upon Van Camp Sea Food Co. v. Fish Game Com., 75 Cal.App. 764 [ 243 P. 702 ], in which it was held that a Commission like the Fish and Game Commission, which is one having a state-wide jurisdiction, as distinguished from a local board, cannot be invested with judicial functions, for the reason that, "except for local purposes," section 1 of article VI of the constitution confines all judicial power to certain specified courts.

This court is of the view, however, that, admitting that the Fish and Game Commission cannot be granted any power which constitutionally belongs exclusively to the judicial department of the state government, the granting of power to hold hearings and determine facts incidental to the regulation of fish and game, and to the granting of permits to take and use fish, is valid as an administrative or regulatory power, and in nowise transgresses upon the exclusive functions of the judicial department.

Let the writ of mandate issue as prayed for.

Font Options

A
A

Opinion Details

Court
California Supreme Court
Case Number
Docket No. S.F. 12323.
Filed Date
January 20, 1927
Format
HTML
Posture
APPLICATION for a Writ of Mandate to require the Fish and Game Commission to act upon an application for a permit. Writ granted. The facts are stated in the opinion of the court.

Additional Information

Attorneys
John L. Dyer and Warren H. Pillsbury for Petitioner., B. D. Marx Greene for Respondents.

Statistics

This opinion has been viewed 12 times.

Issues Laws Cases News Firms Entities Pro