This opinion is part of a group with 3 total opinions. Viewing opinion 1 of 3.

CARAFAS v. LaVALLEE, WARDEN

● Followed — Later opinions have followed this case. See citing opinions ↓
Filed: May 20, 1968 | Fortas, Harlan, Marshall, Stewart, Parker

391 U.S. 234 (1968)

CARAFAS
v.
LAVALLEE, WARDEN.

No. 71.

Supreme Court of United States.

Argued March 27, 1968.

Decided May 20, 1968.

CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT.

*235 James J. Cally argued the cause and filed briefs for petitioner.

Brenda Soloff, Assistant Attorney General of New York, argued the cause for respondent. With her on the brief were Louis J. Lefkowitz, Attorney General, Samuel A. Hirshowitz, First Assistant Attorney General, and Michael H. Rauch, Assistant Attorney General.

MR. JUSTICE FORTAS delivered the opinion of the Court.

This case has a lengthy procedural history. In 1960, petitioner was convicted of burglary and grand larceny in New York state court proceedings and was sentenced to concurrent terms of three to five years. On direct appeal (following Mapp v. Ohio, 367 U. S. 643 (1961)), petitioner claimed that illegally obtained evidence had been introduced against him at trial. The Appellate Division affirmed the conviction without opinion, People v. Carafas, 14 App. Div. 2d 886, 218 N. Y. S. 2d 536 (1961), as did the New York Court of Appeals, 11 N. Y. 2d 891, 182 N. E. 236 2d 413 (1962).[1] This Court denied a petition for a writ of certiorari. 372 U. S. 948 (1963).

Thereafter, complex proceedings took place in which petitioner sought in both federal and state courts to obtain relief by writ of habeas corpus, based on his claim that illegally seized evidence was used against him. 334 F. 2d 331 (1964); petition for writ of certiorari denied, 381 U. S. 951 (1965). On November 5, 1965, the United States District Court, as directed by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit (334 F. 2d 331 (1964)), heard petitioner's claim on the merits. It dismissed his petition on the ground that he had failed to show a violation of his Fourth Amendment rights. Petitioner appealed in circumstances hereinafter related. The Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit dismissed the appeal. On March 20, 1967, a petition for a writ of certiorari was filed here. We granted the petition, 389 U. S. 896 (1967), to consider whether, because of facts to which we later refer, the Court of Appeals' dismissal conformed to our holding in Nowakowski v. Maroney, 386 U. S. 542 (1967). But first we must consider the State's contention that this case is now moot because petitioner has been unconditionally released from custody.

Petitioner applied to the United States District Court for a writ of habeas corpus in June 1963. He was in custody at that time. On March 6, 1967, petitioner's sentence expired,[2] and he was discharged from the parole status in which he had been since October 4, 1964. We issued our writ of certiorari on October 16, 1967 (389 U. S. 896).

*237 The issue presented, then, is whether the expiration of petitioner's sentence, before his application was finally adjudicated and while it was awaiting appellate review, terminates federal jurisdiction with respect to the application. Respondent relies upon Parker v. Ellis, 362 U. S. 574 (1960), and unless this case is overruled, it stands as an insuperable barrier to our further consideration of petitioner's cause or to the grant of relief upon his petition for a writ of habeas corpus.

Parker v. Ellis held that when a prisoner was released from state prison after having served his full sentence, this Court could not proceed to adjudicate the merits of the claim for relief on his petition for habeas corpus which he had filed with the Federal District Court. This Court held that upon petitioner's unconditional release the case became "moot." Parker was announced in a per curiam decision.[3]

It is clear that petitioner's cause is not moot. In consequence of his conviction, he cannot engage in certain businesses;[4] he cannot serve as an official of a labor union for a specified period of time;[5] he cannot vote in any election held in New York State;[6] he cannot serve as a juror.[7] Because of these "disabilities or burdens [which] may flow from" petitioner's conviction, he has "a substantial stake in the judgment of conviction which survives the satisfaction of the sentence imposed on him." Fiswick v. United States, 329 U. S. 211, 222 (1946). On account of these "collateral consequences,"[8] the case is 238 not moot. Ginsberg v. New York, 390 U. S. 629, 633-634, n. 2 (1968); Fiswick v. United States, supra, at 222, n. 10; United States v. Morgan, 346 U. S. 502, 512-513 (1954).

The substantial issue, however, which is posed by Parker v. Ellis, is not mootness in the technical or constitutional sense, but whether the statute defining the habeas corpus jurisdiction of the federal judiciary in respect of persons in state custody is available here. In Parker v. Ellis, as in the present case, petitioner's application was filed in the Federal District Court when he was in state custody, and in both the petitioner was unconditionally released from state custody before his case could be heard in this Court. For the reasons which we here summarize and which are stated at length in the dissenting opinions in Parker v. Ellis, we conclude that under the statutory scheme, once the federal jurisdiction has attached in the District Court, it is not defeated by the release of the petitioner prior to completion of proceedings on such application.

The federal habeas corpus statute requires that the applicant must be "in custody" when the application for habeas corpus is filed. This is required not only by the repeated references in the statute,[9] but also by the history of the great writ.[10] Its province, shaped to guarantee the most fundamental of all rights,[11] is to provide an effective and speedy instrument by which judicial inquiry may be had into the legality of the detention of a person. See Peyton v. Rowe, ante, p. 54.[12]

*239 But the statute does not limit the relief that may be granted to discharge of the applicant from physical custody. Its mandate is broad with respect to the relief that may be granted. It provides that "[t]he court shall . . . dispose of the matter as law and justice require." 28 U. S. C. § 2243. The 1966 amendments to the habeas corpus statute seem specifically to contemplate the possibility of relief other than immediate release from physical custody. At one point, the new § 2244 (b) (1964 ed., Supp. II) speaks in terms of "release from custody or other remedy." See Peyton v. Rowe, supra; Walker v. Wainwright, 390 U. S. 335 (1968). Cf. Ex parte Hull, 312 U. S. 546 (1941).

In the present case, petitioner filed his application shortly after June 20, 1963, while he was in custody. He was not released from custody until March 6, 1967, two weeks before he filed his petition for certiorari here. During the intervening period his application was under consideration in various courts. Petitioner is entitled to consideration of his application for relief on its merits. He is suffering, and will continue to suffer, serious disabilities because of the law's complexities and not because of his fault, if his claim that he has been illegally convicted is meritorious. There is no need in the statute, the Constitution, or sound jurisprudence for denying to petitioner his ultimate day in court.

This case illustrates the validity of THE CHIEF JUSTICE'S criticism that the doctrine of Parker simply aggravates the hardships that may result from the "intolerable delay[s] in affording justice." Parker v. Ellis, supra, at 585 (dissenting opinion). The petitioner in this case was sentenced in 1960. He has been attempting to litigate 240 his constitutional claim ever since. His path has been long—partly because of the inevitable delays in our court processes and partly because of the requirement that he exhaust state remedies.[13] He should not be thwarted now and required to bear the consequences of assertedly unlawful conviction simply because the path has been so long that he has served his sentence.[14] The federal habeas corpus statute does not require this result, and Parker v. Ellis must be overruled.

We turn now to the substance of the question as to which we granted certiorari. Petitioner's first hearing on the merits in the Federal District Court was held on November 5, 1965.[15] The District Court dismissed the petition for habeas corpus, denying petitioner's claim that evidence used against him had been obtained by an illegal search and seizure. The District Court issued a 241 certificate of probable cause pursuant to 28 U. S. C. § 2253 and ordered that the notice of appeal be filed without prepayment of the prescribed fee. A notice of appeal was filed, and the petitioner applied in the Court of Appeals for an order allowing him to appeal in forma pauperis. 28 U. S. C. § 1915. The State opposed petitioner's application for leave to appeal in forma pauperis and moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that it was without merit. Petitioner filed a reply in July 1966 in which he opposed the State's motion to dismiss and in which he renewed his plea for leave to appeal in forma pauperis. On February 3, 1967, the Court of Appeals entered the following order: "Application for Leave to Proceed in Forma Pauperis. Application denied. Motion to dismiss appeal granted." Rehearing was thereafter denied. It is this action of the Court of Appeals that brings into issue our decision in Nowakowski v. Maroney, 386 U. S. 542 (April 10, 1967).

In Nowakowski, we held that "when a district judge grants . . . a certificate [of probable cause], the court of appeals must grant an appeal in forma pauperis (assuming the requisite showing of poverty), and proceed to a disposition of the appeal in accord with its ordinary procedure." At 543. Although Nowakowski was decided after the Court of Appeals dismissed petitioner's appeal, its holding applies to a habeas corpus proceeding which, like this one, was not concluded at the time Nowakowski was decided. Cf. Eskridge v. Washington Prison Board, 357 U. S. 214 (1958); see also Linkletter v. Walker, 381 U. S. 618, 628, n. 13 and 639, n. 20 (1965); Tehan v. Shott, 382 U. S. 406, 416 (1966).

Respondent argues that the denial of the motion to proceed in forma pauperis by the Court of Appeals in this case and the dismissal of the appeal were permissible because the Court had before it the entire District Court record and because respondent's motion to dismiss and 242 petitioner's reply contained some argument on the merits. Nothing in the order entered by the Court of Appeals, however, indicates that the appeal was duly considered on its merits as Nowakowski requires in cases where a certificate of probable cause has been granted. Although Nowakowski does not necessarily require that the Court of Appeals give the parties full opportunity to submit briefs and argument in an appeal which, despite the issuance of the certificate of probable cause, is frivolous, enough must appear to demonstrate the basis for the court's summary action. Anything less than this, as we held in Nowakowski, would negate the office of the certificate of probable cause. Indeed, it appears that since Nowakowski, the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has accorded this effect to that ruling. The State informs us that "it appears to be the policy of the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit that in cases where habeas corpus appeals have been dismissed, reargument will be granted and the appeal reinstated where the time to apply for certiorari had not expired prior to the decision in Nowakowski." Brief for respondent 22-23.

Accordingly, the judgment below is vacated and the case is remanded to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

It is so ordered.

MR. JUSTICE MARSHALL took no part in the consideration or decision of this case.

MR. JUSTICE HARLAN and MR. JUSTICE STEWART, concurring.

Although we joined the per curiam decision in Parker v. Ellis, 362 U. S. 574, we are now persuaded that what the Court there decided was wrong insofar as it held that even though a man be in custody when he initiates 243 a habeas corpus proceeding, the statutory power of the federal courts to proceed to a final adjudication of his claims depends upon his remaining in custody. Consequently we concur in the opinion and judgment of the Court.

MR. JUSTICE HARLAN also notes that his views upon the issue discussed in his separate concurring opinion in Parker, id., at 576, have not changed.

Footnotes

1 The New York Court of Appeals amended its remittitur to reflect that it had passed on petitioner's constitutional claim. 11 N. Y. 2d 969, 183 N. E. 2d 697 (1962).
2 It appears that petitioner was on bail after conviction until this Court denied his earlier petition for a writ of certiorari. 372 U. S. 948 (March 18, 1963).
3 THE CHIEF JUSTICE and JUSTICES BLACK, DOUGLAS, and BRENNAN dissented.
4 E. g., New York Education Law §§ 6502, 6702; New York General Business Law § 74, subd. 2; New York Real Property Law § 440-a; New York Alcoholic Beverage Control Law § 126.
5 73 Stat. 536, 29 U. S. C. § 504.
6 New York Election Law § 152, subd. 2.
7 New York Judiciary Law §§ 596, 662.
8 Undoubtedly there are others. See generally Note, Civil Disabilities of Felons, 53 Va. L. Rev. 403 (1967).
9 See 28 U. S. C. §§ 2241, 2242, 2243, 2244, 2245, 2249, 2252, 2254.
10 See 9 W. Holdsworth, History of English Law 108-125 (1926).
11 E. g., Article 39 of the Magna Carta (see 9 W. Holdsworth, at 112-125). The federal habeas corpus statute grants jurisdiction to inquire into violations of the United States Constitution.
12 If there has been, or will be, an unconditional release from custody before inquiry can be made into the legality of detention, it has been held that there is no habeas corpus jurisdiction. See Parker v. Ellis, supra, at 582, n. 8 (WARREN. C. J., dissenting); Ex parte Baez, 177 U. S. 378 (1900); United States ex rel. Rivera v. Reeves, 246 F. Supp. 599 (D. C. S. D. N. Y. 1965); Burnett v. Gladden, 228 F. Supp. 527 (D. C. D. Ore. 1964).
13 Petitioner was convicted in 1960. He took his case through the state appellate process, and this Court denied a writ of certiorari in March 1963. 372 U. S. 948. In June 1963 petitioner began his quest for a writ of habeas corpus in the federal courts. The District Court denied the petition without prejudice, suggesting, in view of what the judge thought was the unsettled state of New York law, that petitioner reapply to the state courts. See 28 U. S. C. § 2254. Petitioner did so, and apparently at the same time appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. The state courts denied relief a second time. The United States Court of Appeals reversed the District Court and ordered a hearing on the merits. 334 F. 2d 331 (1964). This Court denied the State's petition for a writ of certiorari. 381 U. S. 951 (1965). The hearing ordered by the Court of Appeals was held by the District Court on November 5, 1965. The petition was dismissed on the merits on May 2, 1966. Petitioner's appeal to the Second Circuit was dismissed on February 3, 1967, and a petition for rehearing was denied on February 21, 1967. A petition for a writ of certiorari was filed here on March 20, 1967, and granted on October 16, 1967, 389 U. S. 896, about seven years after petitioner's conviction.
14 See Thomas v. Cunningham, 335 F. 2d 67 (C. A. 4th Cir. 1964).
15 See n. 13, supra.

How later opinions treat this case

AI-derived from opinions that cite this case. Each entry links to the citing opinion and shows the passages it was drawn from, with this case highlighted and the words the label rests on in darker type. Verify before relying on this in a filing.

... his challenge he would still have to finish serving his current sentence. The Court explained that the habeas corpus statute should be construed liberally because it is a remedial statute, and concluded that federal courts had the power "to fashion appropriate relief other than immediate release." 391 U.S. at 66, 88 S.Ct. at 1556. See also Andrews v. United States, 373 U.S. 334, 339, 83 S.Ct. 1236, 1239, 10 L.Ed.2d 383 (1963) (§ 2255 "can also be utilized to provide a more flexible remedy" than release from custody). Of particular relevance to the appeal now before us is the fact that Peyton v. Rowe expressly overruled ...

... . . . Even when void, its operation may be stayed by Habeas corpus only through the exercise of the authority of the court to remove the prisoner from custody. That authority cannot be exercised where the custody is lawful. 12293 U.S. at 139, 55 S.Ct. at 27. In yet a third unanimous decision, Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), the Court, expressly overruling Parker v. Ellis, 362 U.S. 574, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 963 (1960), held that a prisoner was entitled to challenge the validity of his conviction via habeas corpus notwithstanding the fact that he had been unconditionally released while his petition was ...

... behind this line of cases, quite plainly, is that merely to stand "convicted" is to be subjected to a great many "collateral consequences." See Benton v. Maryland, 395 U.S. 784, 790, 89 S.Ct. 2056, 23 L.Ed.2d 707 (1969); Sibron v. New York, 392 U.S. 40, 55, 88 S.Ct. 1889, 20 L.Ed.2d 917 (1968); Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 237-38, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968); Parker v. Ellis, 362 U.S. 574, 593-94, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 963 (1960) (Warren, C. J., dissenting). See also Wright v. United States, 519 F.2d 13, 19-20 (7th Cir.), Cert. denied, 423 U.S. 932, 96 S.Ct. 285, 46 L.Ed.2d 262 (1975); O'Clair v. United States, 470 F.2d 1199, 1203 (1st Cir. ...

... 54, 67, 88 S.Ct. 1549, 20 L.Ed.2d 426 (1968), the Court unanimously overruled Mc-Nally, which underlay Parker, and held that a prisoner serving consecutive sentences is “in custody” under any one of them for purposes of the habeas corpus jurisdiction section. Finally, in Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), the Supreme Court overruled Parker v. Ellis, supra. The Court held that “once the federal jurisdiction has attached” (emphasis added) in the district court, it is not defeated by the release of the prisoner prior to completion of proceedings on his habeas corpus application. 391 U.S. at 238, 88 S.Ct. at 1559. No Supreme Court decision, however, supports district court jurisdiction of Kamsler’s petition. He is not a prisoner, nor a parolee under the federal sentence he attacks, and he is free to go as he chooses so far as federal legal control over him is concerned. When he filed his petition he was ...

... right to be free from wrongful restraints upon their liberty.' Id. at 243, 83 S.Ct. at 377. See also Peyton v. Rowe, 391 U.S. 54, 88 S.Ct. 1549, 20 L.Ed.2d 426 (1968) (overruling the prematurity doctrine of McNally v. Hill, 293 U.S. 131, 55 S.Ct. 24, 79 L.Ed. 238 (1934)); Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968) (habeas corpus available although petitioner released from prison after writ is filed). 13In the instant case, the naval authorities claim jurisdiction over Hammond's person and the right to subject him to their orders and supervision. Indeed, it was necessary for the District Court to ...

... was discharged from the Army on August 7, 1967, and was released from custody on November 8, 1967. We dismissed the appeal as being moot. 2 The Supreme Court granted certiorari, vacated our judgment and remanded the case to us for further consideration in light of Carafas v. LaVal *283 lee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed. 2d 554 (1968). 3 Carafas laid to rest any doubts concerning the meaning of the words “in custody” as used in 28 U.S.C.A. 2241. 4 There, as here, the petitioner was in custody when the application for habeas corpus was filed with the District Court but petitioner had been released before completion of the proceedings ...

... not moot. Ginsberg v. New York, 390 U.S. 629, 633-634, n. 2, [88 S.Ct. 1274, 1277, 20 L.Ed.2d 195] (1968); Fiswick v. United States, supra, [329 U.S.] at 222, n. 10, [67 S.Ct., at 230]; United States v. Morgan, 346 U.S. 502, 512-513, [74 S.Ct. 247, 253, 98 L.Ed. 248] (1954).” [Footnote omitted.] Carafas v. LaVallee, supra, at 237, 238, 88 S.Ct. at 1559. We entertain no doubt that the “collateral consequences” which may flow from appellants’ convictions and to which we alluded in our original opinion, i. e., that “in many states they will not be able to vote, sit on juries or run for public office,” bring this case squarely within the principles enunciated in Carafas. We therefore proceed to the merits. On January 17, 1964, ten months after he was required to do so, 5 Brown registered with his local board. Both Brown and his mother contended that they informed the clerk of the board that Brown was a conscientious objector. Several days after his registration ...

... initial question of whether the fact that McAliley is no longer in the Army’s custody renders the present appeal moot and unreviewable by this Court. Although the federal habeas corpus statute expressly requires that the petitioner be in custody, 28 U.S.C. § 2241(c), in Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U. S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), the United States Supreme Court has ruled that “once the federal jurisdiction has attached in the District Court, it is not defeated by the release of the petitioner prior to completion of proceedings on such application.” 391 U.S. 238, 88 S.Ct. 1560. In Carafas, the petitioner’s sentence under a state court conviction expired after the District Court had denied the petition for a writ of habeas corpus and after the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit had affirmed that denial but before the petitioner sought a writ of certiorari from the Supreme ...

... consequences,’ the case is not moot. Ginsberg v. New York, 390 U.S. 629, 633-34, n. 2 [88 S.Ct. 1274, 1277-1278, 20 L.Ed.2d 195] (1968); Fiswick v. United States, supra, at 222, n. 10 [67 S.Ct. at 230]; United States v. Morgan, 346 U.S. 502, 512-13 [74 S.Ct. 247, 253, 98 L.Ed. 248] (1954).” 391 U.S. at 237-38, 88 S.Ct. at 1559 (footnotes omitted). The Carafas Court further observed that release from custody is not the sole remedy available through a writ of habeas corpus; rather, the federal habeas corpus statute provides that the court shall “dispose of the matter as law and justice require.” 28 U.S.C. § 2243; see 391 U.S. at 239, 88 S.Ct. at 1560. That such “collateral consequences” may accompany and persist after a dishonorable discharge from the Armed Forces following court-martial convictions was clearly suggested by the Supreme Court in Brown v. Resor, 393 U. S. 10, 89 S.Ct. 51, 21 L.Ed.2d 23 (1968). There the petitioners had ...

... the Fifth Circuit dismissed their appeals as moot because the men had by then been released from the Army under dishonorable discharges. Brown v. Reaves, 388 F.2d 682 (5th Cir. 1968). The Supreme Court vacated the judgment of the Court of Appeals and remanded for further consideration in light of Carafas v. LaVallee, supra. Brown v. Resor, su *1246 pra, 393 U.S. at 10, 89 S.Ct. 51. On remand, the Court of Appeals found that the ease was not moot: “We entertain no doubt that the ‘collateral consequences’ which may flow from appellants’ convictions and to which we alluded in our original opinion, i. e., that ‘in many states they will not be able to vote, sit on juries or run for public office,’ bring this case squarely within the principles enunciated in Carafas.” Brown v. Re-sor, 407 F.2d 281, 283 (5th Cir. 1969). We believe that the rule set forth in Carafas and applied in Brown is fully applicable to the present case, notwithstanding the fact that those cases involved the “collateral consequences” flowing from actual convictions whereas McAliley simply received an undesirable discharge without any conviction. Although the disabilities which ...

... certificate reveals none of the circumstances surrounding his undesirable discharge, but merely states that he was discharged “for the good of the service.” We therefore find that MeAliley’s undesirable discharge carries with it serious “collateral consequences” which, under the Carafas case, require us to hold that his cause is not moot. II. Turning to the merits of the appeal, in his petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the District Court McAliley reviewed his local draft board’s denial of his request for conscientious objector status, the Alabama State Appeals Board’s ...

... a situation in which the party had an opportunity to brief and argue the merits of the underlying issues, nor do they suggest that the stay procedure of Rule 8 is somehow abrogated by the granting of a certificate of probable cause. We think that this case is controlled by Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), more than Garrison and Nowakowski. In Carafas, the Court, as in Nowakowski, reversed the Second Circuit’s denial of leave to proceed in forma pauperis. The Court discussed Nowakowski and its implications. The Court stated: Nothing in the order entered by the Court of Appeals, however, indicates that the appeal was duly considered on its ...

... not necessarily require that the Court of Appeals give the parties full opportunity to submit briefs and argument in an appeal which, despite the issuance of the certificate of probable cause, is frivolous, enough must appear to demonstrate the basis for the court’s summary action. Id. at 242, 88 S.Ct. at 1562. Our actions here fall under this language. Petitioner’s motion is directed solely to the merits. The parties have been also afforded an unlimited opportunity to make their contentions upon the underlying merits by briefs and oral argument. This opinion demonstrates the reasons for our decision. ...

... court on appeal in habeas corpus proceedings. Fay v. Noia, 372 U.S. 391, 83 S.Ct. 822, 9 L.Ed.2d 837 (1963). However, Murray’s is not the ordinary case. Rather it is the case of an appeal from a denial of habeas corpus to be decided after the petitioner has been released. In Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), the Supreme Court held that such proceedings are not necessarily moot. The issue of mootness turns in such cases upon the presence of the petitioner’s *468 continuing interest in the validity of the judgment of conviction which survives the satisfaction of the sentence imposed on him. “On account of these ‘collateral consequences’, the case is not moot.” Carafas, supra, at 237, 88 S.Ct. at 1559. The collateral consequences which arise when one is convicted of a felony are not here present, Murray has already suffered those consequences as a result of his 1953 conviction. However, as the court noted in Sibron v. New York, 392 U.S. 40, 55-57, 88 S.Ct. 1889, 20 L.Ed.2d 917 (1968), there is ...

... since Murray is no longer confined by authority of the 1959 conviction, we need not remand this ease to the district court for further proceedings. We do remand so that the district court may enter an order which takes such action under 28 U.S.C.A. § 2243, as “law and justice require.” Carafas v. LaVallee, supra. In this case such an order may take the form of expunging the record of conviction. We, however, do not decide this question, but remand to the district court for appropriate action. Accordingly, we affirm the denial of habeas corpus relief on defendant’s 1953 conviction. We reverse the denial of ha-beas corpus relief on his 1959 conviction and remand for appropriate procedure consistent herewith. The judgment below is affirmed in part, reversed in part and remanded for further proceedings. . In Carafas, supra, 88 S.Ct. 1559 at note 8, the Supreme Court noticed that there were undoubtedly other collateral consequences, and we therefore feel obliged to notice that under F.S.A. § 775.9 and § 775.10 Murray faces collateral consequences of his 1959 conviction in the form of enhanced sentences ...

... without more, to make a prima facie case on the point. The prior judgment duly entered precludes any subsequent assault- on- its merits.’’ . It is the nature of collateral consequences in the case of a multiple offender to be speculative. The Supreme Court in Sibron, 392 U.S. at 55, 88 S.Ct. at 1899, stated: “This case certainly meets that test for survival. Without pausing to canvass the possibilities in detail, we note that New York expressly provides by statute that Sibron’s conviction may be used to impeach his character should he choose to put it in issue at any future criminal ...

... developed record of testimony about contested historical facts, which reflects the ‘impact of actuality’ to a far greater degree than many controversies accepted for adjudication as a matter of course under the Federal Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2201.” Sibron, supra, at 57, 88 S.Ct. at 1900. We conclude that the standard of mootness in a criminal case is that it is moot only if it is shown that there is no possibility that any collateral legal consequences will be imposed on the basis of the challenged conviction. That is certainly not the case here. . “A person serving a ...

... custody and his prayer for the relief of release was therefore moot. Were Parker v. Ellis, 362 U.S. 574, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 963 (1960), still good law, we would be required to dismiss this appeal as moot. Parker v. Ellis, however, is not good law, having been overruled by Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968). Since Mizell was in state custody at the time he filed his application in the district court (November 29, 1976), federal jurisdiction "is not defeated by the release of the petitioner prior to completion of proceedings . . . ." Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. at 238, 88 S.Ct. at 1560. The basis for the Carafas holding is that: 30the statute does not limit the relief that may be granted to discharge of the applicant from physical custody. Its mandate is broad with respect to the relief that may be granted. It provides that "(t)he court shall . . . dispose of the matter as law and justice require." 28 U.S.C. § 2243. 31391 U.S. at 239, 88 S.Ct. at 1560. The Supreme Court then notes that amendments in 1966 to the habeas corpus statutes (for example, 28 U.S.C. § 2244(b)) "seem specifically to contemplate the possibility of relief other than immediate release from physical custody." 391 U.S. at 239, 88 S.Ct. at 1560. 32Mizell may wish to ask for such other relief. The conviction of September 10, 1971, may subject him to "disabilities or burdens" (Fiswick v. United States, 329 U.S. 211, 222, 67 S.Ct. 224, 91 L.Ed. 196 (1946)) and to "collateral consequences" (Ginsberg v. New York, 390 U.S. 629, 633-34 n. 2, ...

... since October 21, 1974. The relief petitioner had originally sought was a reduction in his then current sentence by crediting the time served under the allegedly unconstitutional prior conviction. The court reasoned that a grant of such relief was no longer possible, that Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), did not apply, and therefore, denied the writ. Two issues are presented by this appeal, the district court’s jurisdiction, and the possible mootness of the petition. The starting place for a consideration of both issues is Carafas v. La Vallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968). JURISDICTION In Carafas the Court held that in a habeas proceeding “once the federal jurisdiction has attached in the District Court, it is not defeated by the release of the petitioner prior to completion of proceedings on such application.” 391 U.S. at 238, 88 S.Ct. at 1560. Carafas was in custody at the time he filed his petition, and that was sufficient to establish jurisdiction in the district court. In the case before us, Harrison was also in custody when he filed his petition, but pursuant to a conviction subsequent to the one he attacks. We are therefore required to ...

... unlawful because the petition for federal habeas relief was filed after the sentence under attack was fully served. Harrison had begun his pursuit of post-conviction relief in state courts well before the sentence for the conviction under attack was fully served. As the Supreme Court observed in Carafas, “He should not be thwarted now and required to bear the *117 consequences of assertedly unlawful conviction simply because the path has been so long that he has served his sentence.” 391 U.S. at 240, 88 S.Ct. at 1561. Peyton v. Rowe held that “a prisoner serving consecutive sentences is ‘in custody’ under any one of them for purposes of § 2241(c)(3).” 391 U.S. at 67, 88 S.Ct. at 1556. Peyton was thus able to attack a conviction the sentence for which he had not yet begun to serve. Harrison’s situation is just the reverse, he seeks to attack a conviction the sentence for which has been fully served. In a technical sense Harrison was no longer serving consecutive sentences ...

... was still in custody at the time of consideration, and had substantial time to serve. That reasoning would also distinguish Lyons v. Brierley, DiRienzo, and the recidivist cases. However, the district court failed to make the distinction between the issue of jurisdiction and the issue of mootness. Carafas is unambiguously clear that “once federal jurisdiction has attached in the District Court, it is not defeated by the release of the petitioner prior to completion of proceedings on such application.” 391 U.S. at 238, 88 S.Ct. at 1560. The basis for jurisdiction cannot affect that principle. Whether the petitioner attacks the conviction under which he is currently confined, or attacks an earlier conviction whose effect is to prolong his current but unrelated confinement, if his petition was filed while he was confined, so that ...

... habeas petition was discharge of the prisoner or admission to bail, once a habeas petitioner was released, his petition became moot. Parker v. Ellis, 362 U.S. 574, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 963 (1960); McNally v. Hill, 293 U.S. 131, 55 S.Ct. 24, 79 L.Ed. 238 (1934). Parker v. Ellis was overruled by Carafas v. LaVallee, where the court observed that the statute does not limit the relief that may be granted to discharge of the applicant from physical custody. Its mandate is broad with respect to the relief that may be granted. It provides that “[t]he court shall . . . dispose of the matter as law and justice require.” 28 U.S.C. § 2243. 391 U.S. at 239, 88 S.Ct. at 1560. Carafas not only broadened beyond release from custody the relief available by means of habeas, it also recognized that habeas is appropriate to remedy the collateral consequences of a conviction. 391 U.S. at 237-38, 88 S.Ct. 1556. See also Note, Civil Disabilities of Felons, 53 Va.L.Rev. 403 (1967); Note,. The Collateral Consequences of a Criminal Conviction, 23 Vand. L.Rev. 929 (1970). The cases cited by respondent, the State of Indiana, are all beside the point, since they stand only for the proposition that collateral ...

Followed — (1978)

... restrained his freedom, and that this was enough to keep him in the "custody" of the members of the Parole Board, in this instance Virginia, within the meaning of the habeas corpus statute. In Jones, as here, the accused had been in prison when the petition was filed. 40In Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), the petitioner was in prison when the petition was filed. His sentence expired while the petition was pending and he was unconditionally released. The Court overruled its prior decision in Parker v. Ellis, 362 U.S. 574, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 963 (1960), and held that the release did not ...

... of conviction and the sentence are vacated. . The government makes mention of the fact that Hupert was released during the pendency of this appeal, having served his full sentence, and that his appeal is, therefore, mooted. We find no merit to this contention in light of Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968) ; Jones v. Cunningham, 371 U.S. 236, 83 S.Ct. 373, 9 L.Ed.2d 285 (1963) ; Application of Kiser, 419 F.2d 1134, n. 1 (8th Cir. 1969). . Brady v. United States, 397 U.S. 742, 90 S.Ct. 1463, 25 L.Ed.2d 747 (1970) ; McMann v. Richardson, 397 U.S. 759, 90 S.Ct. 1441, 25 L.Ed.2d 763 (1970) ; ...

... be given his day in federal court on the merits of his habeas contentions. He was still serving his state sentence at the time he filed that petition, so he is entitled to have it adjudicated on its merits. The case is not moot even though the sentence has been served. Carafas v. La Vallee, 1968, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554. Therefore, we vacate the order appealed from and remand the case to the district court for adjudication of the merits of McDaniel’s habeas corpus petition. Vacated and remanded.

... more substantial question is whether the District Court’s civil contempt order has rendered this case moot. Re *936 cent decisions of the Supreme Court emphasize that the mootness doctrine should no longer be mechanically applied in habeas corpus cases. See Carafas v. La Vallee, 1968, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (expressly overruling Parker v. Ellis, 1960, 362 U.S. 574, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 963), where the Court rejected the contention that the petitioner’s claim was mooted by his unconditional release from custody after he had filed his petition in the District Court. In Sibron v. New York, 1968, ...

... for ‘minor’ offenses which carry only short sentences.12 We do not believe that the Constitution contemplates that people deprived of constitutional rights at this level should be left utterly remediless and defenseless against repetitions of unconstitutional conduct.” 392 U.S. at 52-53, 88 S.Ct. at 1897. (footnote omitted.) See also Ginsberg v. New York, 1968, 390 U.S. 629, 633 n. 3, 88 S.Ct. 1274, 20 L.Ed.2d 195. Bacon’s case presents the type of low visibility incursion by government upon personal liberty referred to in Sibron. Had she not refused to answer questions before the grand jury, ...

... and Davis establish the proposition that an “arrest” —a “seizure” of the person — within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment does not coincide with “a trip to the station house and prosecution for crime — ‘arrests’ in traditional terminology.” Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. at 16, 88 S.Ct. at 1877. Under those eases and the Fourth Amendment, the essential element is the physical restraint placed upon the person, not the purpose behind the restraint. Such an arrest as we have here, when based on a showing of less than probable cause, has no history of judicial or public acceptance. ...

... be imprisoned under the unattaeked concurrent sentence. The Supreme Court specifically overruled the progenitors of this rule, Parker v. Ellis, 362 U.S. 574, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 963; McNally v. Hill, 293 U.S. 131, 55 S.Ct. 24, 79 L.Ed. 238, during the most recent term. Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554; Peyton v. Rowe, 391 U.S. 54, 88 S.Ct. 1549, 20 L.Ed.2d 426; Walker v. Wainwright, 390 U.S. 335, 88 S.Ct. 962, 19 L.Ed.2d 1215. As a result of the Court’s departure from the former standard, “a prisoner serving consecutive sentences is ‘in custody’ under any one of them for purposes of Section 2241 (c) (3).” Peyton v. Rowe, supra. And due to the disabilities attendant upon conviction, a movant who has served his sentence may pursue a habeas corpus petition initiated while still in custody. Carafas v. LaVallee, supra. This court has applied these principles in a Section 2255 case involving consecutive sentences and found no basis for distinguishing between habeas corpus and Section 2255 motions. Crow v. United States, 10 Cir., 397 F.2d 284. We are unable to conceive any compelling reason, ...

... by our own precedent as well as the unanimous precedent of our sister circuits. 13The Supreme Court has made it clear that the "in custody" determination is made at the time the habeas petition is filed. Spencer v. Kemna, 523 U.S. 1, 7, 118 S.Ct. 978, 140 L.Ed.2d 43 (1998); Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 237-38, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968). Moreover, this court has previously held that this rule applies to petitioners who have been deported in the same way it applies to any other habeas petitioner no longer in custody. In Max-George v. Reno, 205 F.3d 194 (5th Cir.2000), rev'd on other grounds, 533 U.S. 945, 121 S.Ct. 2585, ...

... McCurry, 449 U.S. 90, 98 n. 12, 101 S.Ct. 411, 66 L.Ed.2d 308 (1980) (noting that the "unique purpose of habeas corpus" is "to release the applicant for the writ from unlawful confinement"). Habeas relief, however, is not confined to this form alone; over the years, its mandate has become broader. Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 239, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968). See also Preiser v. Rodriguez, 411 U.S. 475, 487, 93 S.Ct. 1827, 36 L.Ed.2d 439 (1973) (stating that "habeas corpus relief is not limited to immediate release from illegal custody"). Where an individual is no longer in custody (but was at the time he filed the action), the Court has ...

... Court applies a rule of federal law to the parties before it, that rule is the controlling interpretation of federal law and must be given full retroactive effect in all cases still open on direct review...."Harper v. Va. Dep't of Taxation, 509 U.S. 86, 97, 113 S.Ct. 2510, 125 L.Ed.2d 74 (1993). Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 239, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968).

... under attack had expired prior to the filing of the petition. The District Court dismissed the petition on this ground on April 22, 1968, citing Parker v. Ellis, 1960, 362 U.S. 574, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 968. On May 20, 1968, the Supreme Court rendered its opinion in Carafas v. LaVallee, 1968, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554. The District Court then reconsidered its order of April 22, 1968 and again denied relief. The court was of the view that Carafas overruled only that part of Parker v. Ellis which had held that subsequent release, i. e., after having filed the petition for the writ while in custody, mooted the petition. Since there was no petition here until after the expiration of the sentence under attack, the court held that Carafas had no effect on its earlier order. The sole issue on this appeal is the question of jurisdiction under the circumstances. Appellant is in custody in Florida under another sentence and was at the time the petition in question was filed. It *1239 appears that he had been convicted and sentenced on ...

... claim that his Hills-borough sentence would date back to its original imposition in the event the Dade County sentence is set aside. He urges that he would be entitled to full credit on the Hillsborough sentence for time served on the Dade sentence with the result of immediate release. The Carafas case speaks directly to two situations. The first is the prisoner who files his petition while in custody on one charge and whose term of imprisonment expires and who is released before the petition is finally adjudicated. Car-afas holds that such a petition does not become moot merely because the person is no longer in custody if he was in custody when the petition was filed. The second situation is the prisoner whose term of imprisonment expires and who is released before he ever files a habeas petition. Carafas expressly states: “The federal habeas corpus statute requires that the applicant must be ‘in custody’ when the application for habeas corpus is filed * * *”. The instant ease presents a situation somewhat different in that the petition was filed while the petitioner was “in custody” ...

... petition for habeas corpus must be vacated and remanded. The question of mootness in a habeas corpus situation turns on the substantiality of any "collateral consequences" that may have befallen the appellant during the time in which his or her appeal was pending. See Carafas v. LaVallee, 1968, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554. While Carafas involved a convicted felon, we conclude that the rationale of Argersinger requires that Carafas apply to a situation in which a jail term was levied and served and fines were assessed and paid: 4"We must conclude, therefore, that the problems associated with misdemeanor and petty offenses often require the presence of counsel to insure the accused a fair trial. . . . We need not consider ...

... Neither can we find any collateral consequences that arise here from a fully-served sentence for inability to pay a fine. Wade's misdemeanor conviction has not caused her to lose the right to vote, to hold public office to join a union, or to engage in a particular business, as was the case in Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968). No. 27,953 is accordingly dismissed for mootness." 433 F.2d at 70. 16Both these cases were decided after the Supreme Court decided Carafas v. LaVallee. 17The facts of this traffic case were that while he was a "jail trusty" Matthews was twice arrested for driving without a license and for making an improper start (running a stop sign). He pleaded guilty to the charges, but without counsel. This is now the case before us for habeas ...

... license and forced to pay several fines for various traffic violations, was not entitled to bring a petition for habeas corpus. However, the rationale of that decision was simply that appellant was not "in custody" at the time of the filing, and that the "collateral consequences" analysis of Carafas v. LaVallee, supra, did not create the requisite "custody" to maintain appellant's habeas corpus petition. In the instant case Matthews was indisputably "in custody" at the time his petition was filed

... in the Staton Correctional Center, Elmore, Alabama. Thus, the statutory scheme has been complied with and Malloy's unconditional release from custody while his appeal of the district court's first dismissal was pending does not defeat the jurisdiction previously established. Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968). We focus our concern, therefore, on the question of mootness.1 5Although he has served the sentence and has been unconditionally released from custody, Malloy contends that the forgery conviction now challenged constitutes a consequence to him in the form of a blemish upon his record. ...

... of any possibility that collateral consequences may adhere to the conviction under attack. The state counters this argument by asserting that no collateral consequences were cited because none were perceived. 6Concerned primarily with the in custody jurisdictional issue, the Supreme Court in Carafas held that in a habeas corpus proceeding, "once the federal jurisdiction has attached in the District Court, it is not defeated by the release of the petitioner prior to completion of proceedings on such application." 391 U.S. at 238, 88 S.Ct. at 1560. The Court did, however, preliminarily address the question of mootness and its effect on the power of the federal courts to grant relief. In declaring the case not moot, the Court discussed the consequences still burdening Carafas as a result of his conviction. "In consequence of his conviction, he cannot engage in certain businesses; he cannot serve as an official of a labor union for a specified period of time; he cannot vote in any election held in New York State; he cannot serve as a juror." 391 U.S. at 237, 88 S.Ct. at 1559 (footnotes omitted). These civil penalties furnished Carafas with "a substantial stake in the judgment of conviction which survives the satisfaction of the sentence imposed on him" and, as such, prevented the case from becoming moot. 391 U.S. at 237, 88 S.Ct. at 1559, quoting Fiswick v. United States, 329 U.S. 211, 222, 67 S.Ct. 224, 230, 91 L.Ed. 196 (1946). 7According to Malloy, the blemish on one's record caused by a conviction is enough of a collateral consequence to prevent a habeas corpus petition from becoming moot where the petitioner is no longer ...

... to the extreme, this argument would call for treatment on the merits even in those instances where the petitioner was still allowed to vote or engage in certain professions, or where the conviction could not be used for enhancement purposes. Such a rule would require us to read the language of Carafas mentioned above as merely surplusage or dicta. We refuse to do so. If the Supreme Court desired to hold that a conviction in and of itself constituted a collateral consequence, the circumstances in Carafas presented an ample opportunity for expressing such a rule. Because it did not, however, we refuse to sanction a rule that would effectively abrogate the meaning and purpose underlying the requirement of proving collateral consequences. 8Inasmuch as his multiple offender status has already ...

... incarcerated. Disregarding the appellant's multiple offender status, the Court stated the test to be that "a criminal case is moot only if it is shown that there is no possibility that any collateral legal consequences will be imposed on the basis of the challenged conviction." 392 U.S. at 57, 88 S.Ct. at 1900. 9The types of civil liberties to which Carafas refers are similarly applicable in Alabama. Thus, Malloy cannot vote, Ala.Const. art. VIII § 182; he cannot serve as a juror, Ala.Code Ann. § 12-16-60(a)(4); he cannot serve as an official of a labor union, 29 U.S.C.A. § 504; he cannot obtain a license in various professions, see, e.g., ...

... his sentence had not expired at the time he filed his original petition. Relying upon Maleng, Thompson contends that he meets the "in custody" requirement so long as he was in custody when he filed his original petition. We disagree. Maleng merely restated the holding in Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 238, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 1559, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), in which the Court held that a petitioner who was in custody pursuant to a conviction when he filed his petition satisfied the "in custody" requirement even though he was released prior to completion of the litigation. In Escobedo v. Estelle, 655 F.2d 613 (5th Cir. Unit A Sept.1981) (per curiam), we declined to extend the Carafas holding to a scenario similar to Thompson's. Escobedo had challenged a 1970 conviction used to enhance his 1977 conviction, for which he was incarcerated when he filed his petition. While the case was pending, Escobedo's sentence expired. We held that Escobedo no longer met the "in custody' ...

... related to the conviction he attacks; this is so despite the fact that he was in custody pursuant to the positively and demonstrably related conviction at the time he filed his petition. Id. at 616-17. We conclude that Maleng did not disturb this holding. Maleng, again, only restated the rule of Carafas, which we distinguished in Escobedo. The Maleng holding does nothing more than establish that a habeas petitioner meets the "in custody" requirement where he challenges a conviction used to enhance another co nviction for which he is currently in custody. In this circuit, we first recognized this principle in Sinclair v. Blackburn, 599 F.2d 673, 676 (5th Cir.1979), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 1023, 100 S.Ct. 684, 62 L.Ed.2d 656 (1980). In Escobedo, we concluded that the rules in Carafas and Sinclair could not be combined. 655 F.2d at 616. Because Maleng does not affect our Escobedo holding, we conclude that the district court properly dismissed Thompson's petition. We need not decide whether Thompson's case became moot when his 1978 sentence expired. We observe only that the collateral consequences saving the petitioner's claim in Carafas from mootness do not seem to be implicated where, as here, the petitioner has been convicted of multiple felonies. Also, we express no opinion as to whether the present petition deprives the district court of jurisdiction in a parallel petition Thompson filed to attack his 1978 conviction. We ...

... Attorney asserts that Marshall had been released from custody on June 21, 1972, his sentence having been completed on that date. Inasmuch as this section 2255 proceeding was instituted at a time when Marshall was in custody, it was not mooted by his subsequent release. See Carafas v. LaVallee, 391 U.S. 234, 88 S.Ct. 1556, 20 L.Ed.2d 554 (1968), overruling Parker v. Ellis, 362 U.S. 574, 80 S.Ct. 909, 4 L.Ed.2d 963 (1960). While Carafas was a habeas corpus proceeding, we believe the rule of that case applies in section 2255 proceedings. The constitutionality of section 2255 which supplants, with certain exceptions, habeas corpus challenges to federal convictions, has been upheld on the theory that it is the full equivalent of ...

Font Options

A
A

Opinion Details

Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Case Number
71
Filed Date
May 20, 1968
Format
HTML
Judges
Fortas, Harlan, Marshall, Stewart, Parker
Related Opinions
Opinion 1
Opinion 2 (Mr. Justice Fortas)
Opinion 3 (Mr. Justice Harlan)

Additional Information

Attorneys
James J. Cally argued the cause and filed briefs for petitioner., Brenda Soloff, Assistant Attorney General of New York, argued the cause for respondent. With her on the brief were Louis J. Lefkowitz, Attorney General, Samuel A. Hirshowitz, First Assistant Attorney General, and Michael H. Rauch, Assistant Attorney General.

Statistics

This opinion has been viewed 69 times.

Issues Laws Cases News Firms Entities Pro