Reality Check: Herbalife Nutrition Ltd.

Download Report (PDF)
Download Report (PDF)

By Christine Richard and Aaron Greenspan

Executive Summary

Herbalife Nutrition Ltd., a Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) nutritional supplement company, has a long and highly publicized history of being accused of operating as a pyramid scheme. Less well known is the extent to which its global reach has overlapped with money laundering and narcotrafficking channels.

Based on numerous interviews, Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, legal document searches, and internal Herbalife materials, this report presents a history of Herbalife’s intersection with money laundering and the illicit drug trade, both directly and indirectly through its distributors. For decades, rather than address its entanglement with money laundering in ways that would dissuade further criminal involvement, Herbalife has structured its business in such a way that it remains vulnerable. Examples include:

  • Allowing its products to be moved through the so-called “gray market,” where products in one country are illicitly transported across borders to another
  • Relying on poorly disclosed or undisclosed third parties to operate the Herbalife business in high-risk countries including Russia, Colombia, Panama and Mexico, creating blind spots throughout the company’s vast operational footprint
  • Allowing high-ranking distributors at the top of the pyramid to make decisions at Strategy and Planning Committee meetings that dictate the company’s global expansion plans, vendors, and policies, even though members have questionable histories and, in at least one case, a narcotics trafficking conviction
  • Building a complex business structure that permits the company and distributors to move money across international borders with little to no regulatory oversight

Herbalife’s business has been linked to at least two notorious drug cartels, as well as the global bank HSBC, known for terrorist and narcotics financing. The company’s extensive track record of compliance failures, in direct violation of multiple federal Anti-Money Laundering (AML) statutes, leaves open the door to those who would use Herbalife to move illicit goods and funds around the world.

Herbalife has carefully cultivated a public image as a purveyor of nutritional supplements that are designed to help its customers lose weight and stay fit. Thus far it has been successful in convincing the marketplace that it is a legitimate business, albeit one with a few deficiencies like any large company. Considerable evidence supports a different and darker view.

References on PlainSite

Space Sort Descending Date Filed Court Case Number Title Tags Space
3/9/2018 District Of Columbia District Court 1:18-cr-00053-KBJ-1 United States v. MH PILLARS LTD. Money TransmissionMulti-Level Marketing (MLM)

10/27/2017 District Of Columbia District Court 1:17-cr-00201-ABJ USA v. MANAFORT et al CyprusMueller Trump InvestigationPresident Donald J. TrumpRussiaSaint Vincent And The GrenadinesShell CompaniesUkraine

9/18/2017 Florida Southern District Court 1:17-cv-23429-MGC Lavigne v. HERBALIFE, LTD Herbalife

4/26/2017 District Of Columbia District Court 1:17-cv-00763-DLF CONFERENCE OF STATE BANK SUPERVISORS v. OFFICE OF THE COMPTROLLER OF THE CURRENC... BitcoinMobile PaymentsMoney Transmission

7/15/2016 California Central District Court 2:16-cv-05217-BRO-GJS Federal Trade Commission v. Herbalife International of America Inc Herbalife

2/27/2014 New York Eastern District Court 1:14-cr-00105-MKB USA v. Estrada-Tepal et al Herbalife

5/6/2013 California Northern District Court 5:13-cv-02054-EJD Think Computer Corporation v. Dwolla, Inc. et al BitcoinCryptocurrencyMobile PaymentsMoney TransmissionSilicon ValleyUnfair CompetitionVenture Capital

12/11/2012 New York Eastern District Court 1:12-cr-00763-AMD USA v. HSBC Bank USA, N.A. et al Dirty MoneyMexicoMoney LaunderingNarcotrafficking

3/24/2010 Texas Northern District Court 3:10-cr-00073-K USA v. Poveda-Ortega et al HerbalifeNarcotrafficking

11/20/2009 Superior Court of California, County of San Diego 37-2009-00102604-CU-DE-CTL Donald H. Lake v. California Department of Financial Institutions Money Transmission

6/6/2005 North Carolina Western District Court 1:05-cr-00209-MR-DLH USA v. Fernandez et al

4/5/2004 Idaho District Court 2:04-cv-00175-TLM Fallow, et al v. Herbalife Intl, Inc, et al

12/30/2003 Arizona District Court 2:03-cv-02612-SRB Fallow, et al v. Herbalife Intl Inc, et al

3/12/2003 Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles SC076324 Roosevelt Bates v. Philip J. Halvorson, Robert R. Venchiarutti et al

1/17/2003 Idaho Bankruptcy Court 03-06021-TLM Daniel Steven Fallow- Adversary Proceeding

2/1/1995 New York Eastern District Court 1:95-mj-00174-ASC USA v. 1-95-m-174-01, et al HerbalifeNarcotrafficking

4/17/1987 District Of Columbia District Court 1:87-cr-00165-NHJ USA v. HADDOW

5/29/1985 New Jersey District Court 85-cr-00185 USA v. Socrates Valencia HerbalifeNarcotrafficking

18 Rows Total

Have a tip?

E-Mail us at tips at plainsite.org

Or, read our other Reality Check reports.

Space
Issues Laws Cases Pro Articles Firms Entities
Issues Laws Cases Pro Articles Firms Entities
 
PlainSite
Sign Up
Need Password Help?